Approximate Decoherence of Histories and 't Hooft's Deterministic Quantum Theory

This paper explores the possibility that an exactly decoherent set of histories may be constructed from an approximately decoherent set by small distortions of the operators characterizing the histories. In particular, for the case of histories of positions and momenta, this is achieved by doubling the set of operators and then finding, amongst this enlarged set, new position and momentum operators which commute, so decohere exactly, and which are ``close'' to the original operators. The enlarged, exactly decoherent, theory has the same classical dynamics as the original one, and coincides with the so-called deterministic quantum theories of the type recently studied by 't Hooft. These results suggest that the comparison of standard and deterministic quantum theories may provide an alternative method of characterizing emergent classicality. A side-product is the surprising result that histories of momenta in the quantum Brownian motion model (for the free particle in the high-temperature limit) are exactly decoherent.Comment: 41 pages, plain Te

Decoherence of Hydrodynamic Histories: A Simple Spin Model

In the context of the decoherent histories approach to the quantum mechanics of closed systems, Gell-Mann and Hartle have argued that the variables typically characterizing the quasiclassical domain of a large complex system are the integrals over small volumes of locally conserved densities -- hydrodynamic variables. The aim of this paper is to exhibit some simple models in which approximate decoherence arises as a result of local conservation. We derive a formula which shows the explicit connection between local conservation and approximate decoherence. We then consider a class of models consisting of a large number of weakly interacting components, in which the projections onto local densities may be decomposed into projections onto one of two alternatives of the individual components. The main example we consider is a one-dimensional chain of locally coupled spins, and the projections are onto the total spin in a subsection of the chain. We compute the decoherence functional for histories of local densities, in the limit when the number of components is very large. We find that decoherence requires two things: the smearing volumes must be sufficiently large to ensure approximate conservation, and the local densities must be partitioned into sufficiently large ranges to ensure protection against quantum fluctuations.Comment: Standard TeX, 36 pages + 3 figures (postscript) Revised abstract and introduction. To appear in Physical Review

Classical Dynamics of the Quantum Harmonic Chain

The origin of classical predictability is investigated for the one dimensional harmonic chain considered as a closed quantum mechanical system. By comparing the properties of a family of coarse-grained descriptions of the chain, we conclude that local coarse-grainings in this family are more useful for prediction than nonlocal ones. A quantum mechanical system exhibits classical behavior when the probability is high for histories having the correlations in time implied by classical deterministic laws. But approximate classical determinism holds only for certain coarse-grainings and then only if the initial state of the system is suitably restricted. Coarse-grainings by the values of the hydrodynamic variables (integrals over suitable volumes of densities of approximately conserved quantities) define the histories usually used in classical physics. But what distinguishes this coarse-graining from others? This paper approaches this question by analyzing a family of coarse-grainings for the linear harmonic chain. At one extreme in the family the chain is divided into local groups of $N$ atoms. At the other extreme the $N$ atoms are distributed nonlocally over the whole chain. Each coarse-graining follows the average (center of mass) positions of the groups and ignores the ``internal'' coordinates within each group, these constituting a different environment for each coarse-graining. We conclude that noise, decoherence, and computational complexity favor locality over nonlocality for deterministic predictability.Comment: 38 pages RevTeX 3.0 + 4 figures (postscript). Numerous minor corrections. Submitted to Physical Review

An Information-Theoretic Measure of Uncertainty due to Quantum and Thermal Fluctuations

We study an information-theoretic measure of uncertainty for quantum systems. It is the Shannon information $I$ of the phase space probability distribution \la z | \rho | z \ra , where |z \ra are coherent states, and $\rho$ is the density matrix. The uncertainty principle is expressed in this measure as $I \ge 1$. For a harmonic oscillator in a thermal state, $I$ coincides with von Neumann entropy, - \Tr(\rho \ln \rho), in the high-temperature regime, but unlike entropy, it is non-zero at zero temperature. It therefore supplies a non-trivial measure of uncertainty due to both quantum and thermal fluctuations. We study $I$ as a function of time for a class of non-equilibrium quantum systems consisting of a distinguished system coupled to a heat bath. We derive an evolution equation for $I$. For the harmonic oscillator, in the Fokker-Planck regime, we show that $I$ increases monotonically. For more general Hamiltonians, $I$ settles down to monotonic increase in the long run, but may suffer an initial decrease for certain initial states that undergo ``reassembly'' (the opposite of quantum spreading). Our main result is to prove, for linear systems, that $I$ at each moment of time has a lower bound $I_t^{min}$, over all possible initial states. This bound is a generalization of the uncertainty principle to include thermal fluctuations in non-equilibrium systems, and represents the least amount of uncertainty the system must suffer after evolution in the presence of an environment for time $t$.Comment: 36 pages (revised uncorrupted version), Report IC 92-93/2

Quantum-Mechanical Histories and the Uncertainty Principle. II. Fluctuations About Classical Predictability

This paper is concerned with two questions in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics: the emergence of approximate classical predictability, and the fluctuations about it necessitated by the uncertainty principle. We consider histories characterized by position samplings at $n$ moments of time. We use this to construct a probability distribution on the value of (discrete approximations to) the field equations, $F = m \ddot x + V'(x)$, at $n-2$ times. We find that it is peaked around $F=0$; thus classical correlations are exhibited. We show that the width of the peak $\Delta F$ is largely independent of the initial state and the uncertainty principle takes the form $2 \sigma^2 \ (\Delta F)^2 \ge { \hbar^2 / t^2 }$, where $\sigma$ is the width of the position samplings, and $t$ is the timescale between projections. We determine the modifications to this result when the system is coupled to a thermal environment. We show that the thermal fluctuations become comparable with the quantum fluctuations under the same conditions that decoherence effects come into play. We also study an alternative measure of classical correlations, namely the conditional probability of finding a sequence of position samplings, given that particular initial phase space data have occurred. We use these results to address the issue of the formal interpretation of the probabilities for sequences of position samplings in the decoherent histories approach to quantum mechanics. The decoherence of the histories is also briefly discussed.Comment: 40 pages (plain Tex), Imperial College Preprin

Effective Theories of Coupled Classical and Quantum Variables from Decoherent Histories: A New Approach to the Backreaction Problem

We use the decoherent histories approach to quantum theory to derive the form of an effective theory describing the coupling of classical and quantum variables. The derivation is carried out for a system consisting of a large particle coupled to a small particle with the important additional feature that the large particle is also coupled to a thermal environment producing the decoherence necessary for classicality. The effective theory is obtained by tracing out both the environment and the small particle variables. It consists of a formula for the probabilities of a set of histories of the large particle, and depends on the dynamics and initial quantum state of the small particle. It has the form of an almost classical particle coupled to a stochastic variable whose probabilities are determined by a formula very similar to that given by quantum measurement theory for continuous measurements of the small particle's position. The effective theory gives intuitively sensible answers when the small particle is in a superposition of localized states.Comment: 27 pages, plain Te

Effective Theories of Coupled Classical and Quantum Variables

We address the issue of coupling variables which are essentially classical to variables that are quantum. Two approaches are discussed. In the first (based on collaborative work with L.Di\'osi), continuous quantum measurement theory is used to construct a phenomenological description of the interaction of a quasiclassical variable $X$ with a quantum variable $x$, where the quasiclassical nature of $X$ is assumed to have come about as a result of decoherence. The state of the quantum subsystem evolves according to the stochastic non-linear Schr\"odinger equation of a continuously measured system, and the classical system couples to a stochastic c-number \x (t) representing the imprecisely measured value of $x$. The theory gives intuitively sensible results even when the quantum system starts out in a superposition of well-separated localized states. The second approach involves a derivation of an effective theory from the underlying quantum theory of the combined quasiclassical--quantum system, and uses the decoherent histories approach to quantum theory.Comment: 25 pages, plain Tex. To appear in proceedings of the conference Open Systems and Measurement in Relativistic Quantum Theory, Naples, April 3-4, 1998, edited by H.P.Breuer and F.Petruccion

The Feynman propagator for spin foam quantum gravity

We link the notion causality with the orientation of the 2-complex on which spin foam models are based. We show that all current spin foam models are orientation-independent, pointing out the mathematical structure behind this independence. Using the technology of evolution kernels for quantum fields/particles on Lie groups/homogeneous spaces, we construct a generalised version of spin foam models, introducing an extra proper time variable and prove that different ranges of integration for this variable lead to different classes of spin foam models: the usual ones, interpreted as the quantum gravity analogue of the Hadamard function of QFT or as a covariant definition of the inner product between quantum gravity states; and a new class of causal models, corresponding to the quantum gravity analogue of the Feynman propagator in QFT, non-trivial function of the orientation data, and implying a notion of ''timeless ordering''.Comment: RevTex, 5 pages, no figures; v2-3:minor typos correcte

The Origin of Time Asymmetry

It is argued that the observed Thermodynamic Arrow of Time must arise from the boundary conditions of the universe. We analyse the consequences of the no boundary proposal, the only reasonably complete set of boundary conditions that has been put forward. We study perturbations of a Friedmann model containing a massive scalar field but our results should be independent of the details of the matter content. We find that gravitational wave perturbations have an amplitude that remains in the linear regime at all times and is roughly time symmetric about the time of maximum expansion. Thus gravitational wave perturbations do not give rise to an Arrow of Time. However density perturbations behave very differently. They are small at one end of the universe's history, but grow larger and become non linear as the universe gets larger. Contrary to an earlier claim, the density perturbations do not get small again at the other end of the universe's history. They therefore give rise to a Thermodynamic Arrow of Time that points in a constant direction while the universe expands and contracts again. The Arrow of Time does not reverse at the point of maximum expansion. One has to appeal to the Weak Anthropic Principle to explain why we observe the Thermodynamic Arrow to agree with the Cosmological Arrow, the direction of time in which the universe is expanding.Comment: 41 pages, DAMTP R92/2