2 research outputs found
Sherman Minton: Restraint Against a Tide of Activism
Sherman Minton was not a great U.S. Supreme Court Justice, but he was far better than the image that scholars have created for him would indicate. Although there are exceptions, scholars generally consider Minton to have been an ineffective Justice who was put on the bench only because he was a crony of President Harry Truman. Indeed, the scholars who periodically provide a list of the greatest and worst Justices inevitably relegate Minton to the worst category. For example, Bernard Schwartz, who classified Minton as one of the ten worst Justices, said Minton was below mediocrity as a Justice. His opinions, relatively few for his tenure, are less than third- rate, characterized by their cavalier approach to complicated issues.
This Article attempts to provide a fairer and more informed assessment of Minton\u27s tenure as a Supreme Court Justice. It first will explore the shortcomings of judicial ranking schemes and then illustrate how the biases in these schemes have resulted in an unfair Professor of Political Science at Indiana University Southeast
Chief Justice Fred M. Vinson of Kentucky: A Political Biography
Fred M. Vinson, the thirteenth Chief Justice of the United States, started his political career as a small-town Kentucky lawyer and rose to positions of power in all three branches of federal government. Born in Louisa, Kentucky, Vinson earned undergraduate and law degrees from Centre College in Danville. He served 12 years in the U.S. House of Representatives, where he achieved acclaim as a tax and fiscal expert. President Roosevelt appointed him to the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia and later named him to key executive-branch positions. President Truman appointed him Secretary of the Treasury and then Chief Justice. The Vinson court was embroiled in critical issues affecting racial discrimination and individual rights during the cold war. Chief Justice Fred M. Vinson of Kentucky: A Political Biography offers a wealth of insight into one of the most significant and highly regarded political figures to emerge from Kentucky.
James E. St. Clair is associate professor of journalism at Indiana University Southeast.
Linda C. Gugin is professor of political science at Indiana University Southeast.
At long last we have a first-rate biography of Fred Vinson that accounts for his significance in a thorough and readable fashion. Students of the U.S. Supreme Court, World War II, and American and Kentucky politics will profit from this book. —Robert M. Ireland
This book conveys his life and times effectively. —Appalachian Heritage
Presents a memorable portrait of an admirable in unappreciated statesman. —Appellate Practice Journal
Provides a sympathetic, easily read portrait of a small-town lawyer who rose to the top levels of all three branches of federal government. —Centrepiece
This readable biography of an eminent Kentuckian corrects this oversight to a significant degree and provides the basis for re-examining Vinson’s reputation. . . . An engaging narrative. —David J. Bodenhamer
Frederick Moore Vinson (1890-1953) was the thirteenth chief justice of the United States (1946-1953), and, until now, the only one of that number without a full biography. —H-New Reviews
A highly readable, balanced biography. . . . A useful addition to all libraries. —Journal of American History
Their excellent biography is dedicated largely to showing the Vinson ‘was so much more’ than just head of the American judiciary from 1946 to 1953, for his pubic career prior to that had spanned a quarter-century and was among the most distinguished of his time. . . . A superb and much-needed contribution to political and judicial history. —Journal of Southern History
The first in-depth analysis of Fred M. Vinson, Kentucky’s only chief justice of the United States. —Kentucky Monthly
Provides a basis for reevaluating Vinson’s reputation as a failure on the Supreme Court. . . . This is a ‘must read’ for anyone who hopes to understand the Vinson court. —Law and Politics Book Review
Meticulously assimilates—for the first time in a single source—an erudite yet accessible comparative analysis examining Vinson’s largely overlooked but pioneering roles in developing modern governmental functions. —Leo
St. Clair and Gugin provide a sympathetic, easily read portrait of a successful and devoted public servant. Even half a century after his death, Vinson remains a model worthy of emulation. —Lexington Herald-Leader
Opens a path for others to tread as the varied career of the most famous Kentuckian you’ve never heard of increasingly comes to light. —Louisville Courier-Journalhttps://uknowledge.uky.edu/upk_law/1005/thumbnail.jp