Neutrino masses from SUSY breaking in radiative seesaw models

Radiatively generated neutrino masses ($m_\nu$) are proportional to supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking, as a result of the SUSY non-renormalisation theorem. In this work, we investigate the space of SUSY radiative seesaw models with regard to their dependence on SUSY breaking (\require{cancel}\cancel{\text{SUSY}}). In addition to contributions from sources of $\cancel{\text{SUSY}}$ that are involved in electroweak symmetry breaking ($\cancel{\text{SUSY}}_\text{EWSB}$ contributions), and which are manifest from $\langle F^\dagger_H \rangle = \mu \langle \bar H \rangle \neq 0$ and $\langle D \rangle = g \sum_H \langle H^\dagger \otimes_H H \rangle \neq 0$, radiatively generated $m_\nu$ can also receive contributions from $\cancel{\text{SUSY}}$ sources that are unrelated to EWSB ($\cancel{\text{SUSY}}_\text{EWS}$ contributions). We point out that recent literature overlooks pure-$\cancel{\text{SUSY}}_\text{EWSB}$ contributions ($\propto \mu / M$) that can arise at the same order of perturbation theory as the leading order contribution from $\cancel{\text{SUSY}}_\text{EWS}$. We show that there exist realistic radiative seesaw models in which the leading order contribution to $m_\nu$ is proportional to $\cancel{\text{SUSY}}_\text{EWS}$. To our knowledge no model with such a feature exists in the literature. We give a complete description of the simplest model-topologies and their leading dependence on $\cancel{\text{SUSY}}$. We show that in one-loop realisations $L L H H$ operators are suppressed by at least $\mu \, m_\text{soft} / M^3$ or $m_\text{soft}^2 / M^3$. We construct a model example based on a one-loop type-II seesaw. An interesting aspect of these models lies in the fact that the scale of soft-$\cancel{\text{SUSY}}$ effects generating the leading order $m_\nu$ can be quite small without conflicting with lower limits on the mass of new particles.Comment: Accepted for publication in European Physical Journal C; 23 pages + appendices; references updated; minor revisions; extended conclusion