Mud crab susceptibility to disease from white spot syndrome virus is species-dependent

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Based on a report for one species (<it>Scylla serrata</it>), it is widely believed that mud crabs are relatively resistant to disease caused by white spot syndrome virus (WSSV). We tested this hypothesis by determining the degree of susceptibility in two species of mud crabs, <it>Scylla olivacea </it>and <it>Scylla paramamosain</it>, both of which were identified by mitochondrial 16 S ribosomal gene analysis. We compared single-dose and serial-dose WSSV challenges on <it>S. olivacea </it>and <it>S. paramamosain</it>.</p> <p>Findings</p> <p>In a preliminary test using <it>S. olivacea </it>alone, a dose of 1 × 10⁶WSSV copies/g gave 100% mortality within 7 days. In a subsequent test, 17 <it>S. olivacea </it>and 13 <it>S. paramamosain </it>were divided into test and control groups for challenge with WSSV at 5 incremental, biweekly doses starting from 1 × 10⁴and ending at 5 × 10⁶copies/g. For 11 <it>S. olivacea </it>challenged, 3 specimens died at doses between 1 × 10⁵and 5 × 10⁵copies/g and none died for 2 weeks after the subsequent dose (1 × 10⁶copies/g) that was lethal within 7 days in the preliminary test. However, after the final challenge on day 56 (5 × 10⁶copies/g), the remaining 7 of 11 <it>S. olivacea </it>(63.64%) died within 2 weeks. There was no mortality in the buffer-injected control crabs. For 9 <it>S. paramamosain </it>challenged in the same way, 5 (55.56%) died after challenge doses between 1 × 10⁴and 5 × 10⁵copies/g, and none died for 2 weeks after the challenge dose of 1 × 10⁶copies/g. After the final challenge (5 × 10⁶copies/g) on day 56, no <it>S. paramamosain </it>died during 2 weeks after the challenge, and 2 of 9 WSSV-infected <it>S. paramamosain </it>(22.22%) remained alive together with the control crabs until the end of the test on day 106. Viral loads in these survivors were low when compared to those in the moribund crabs.</p> <p>Conclusions</p> <p><it>S. olivacea </it>and <it>S. paramamosain </it>show wide variation in response to challenge with WSSV. <it>S. olivacea </it>and <it>S. paramamosain </it>are susceptible to white spot disease, and <it>S. olivacea </it>is more susceptible than <it>S. paramamosain</it>. Based on our single-challenge and serial challenge results, and on previous published work showing that <it>S. serrata </it>is relatively unaffected by WSSV infection, we propose that susceptibility to white spot disease in the genus <it>Scylla </it>is species-dependent and may also be dose-history dependent. In practical terms for shrimp farmers, it means that <it>S. olivacea </it>and <it>S. paramamosain </it>may pose less threat as WSSV carriers than <it>S. serrata</it>. For crab farmers, our results suggest that rearing of <it>S. serrata </it>would be a better choice than <it>S. paramamosain </it>or <it>S. olivacea </it>in terms of avoiding losses from seasonal outbreaks of white spot disease.</p