The Relationship between Subjective and Objective Parameters in CT Phantom Image Evaluation

Objective: To evaluate whether there is a relationship between subjective parameters determined by a reviewer (spatial resolution, low contrast resolution, and artifacts) and objective parameters (the CT number of water, noise, and image uniformity) in CT phantom image evaluations. Materials and Methods: We reviewed the CT results of phantom image evaluations conducted by Korean Institute for Accreditation of Medical Image (KIAMI) from May 2007 to June 2007. We compared the objective parameters against the pass or fail groups for the subjective parameters. We also evaluated whether there is a relationship between the artifact types and the other subjective parameters. Results: The mean noise value was significantly higher in the fail groups for the subjective parameters compared to the pass groups (p = 0.006). Specifically, noise and low contrast resolution were found to have a statistically significant positive correlation (r = 0. 183, p < 0.001). In the fail group for low contrast resolution, the failure due to artifacts was significantly higher than the pass group (p < 0.001). In contrast, no statistically significant differences were found for the mean CT number of water, noise, or image uniformity based on the types of artifacts. Conclusion: Subjective CT image parameters evaluated by a reviewer correlate with objectively measured parameters, especially noise. Therefore, a stricter noise standard might be able to improve the subjective parameters results, such as low contrast resolution.Park HJ, 2008, KOREAN J RADIOL, V9, P354, DOI 10.3348/kjr.2008.9.4.354IM TH, 2007, 1 KIAMI, P1*KIAMI DEP ED, 2006, WORKSH EX QUAL ASS P, P141*FLUK CORP, 2005, NUCL ASS 76 410 4130*KIAMI DEP ED, 2005, WORKSH EX QUAL ASS P, P13McCollough CH, 2004, MED PHYS, V31, P2423, DOI 10.1118/1.1769632MCCOLLOUGH CM, 2000, CATEGORICAL COURSE D, P189WIL R, 1998, CT IMAGE QUALITYEUCLID S, 1994, COMPUT TOMOGR, P174BETHESDA MD, 1988, 99 NCRPJUDY PF, 1977, 1 AAPM*ACR, CT ACCR PROGR REQ