Long-term health benefits and costs of measurement of carotid intima-media thickness in prevention of coronary heart disease

OBJECTIVE: Recently, it was demonstrated that information on carotid intima-media thickness (CIMT) and plaque may improve coronary heart disease (CHD) risk prediction through reclassification of some individuals to the correct risk category using the Framingham risk score. Our objective was to assess the currently unknown cost-effectiveness of CIMT measurements in primary prevention. METHODS: A hypothetical cohort of men and women aged 50-59 years and at intermediate or high CHD risk based on data from the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study was simulated using a Markov model. Myocardial infarction (MI) events were used as a proxy for CHD. The effectiveness of pharmaceutical treatment was varied in the analysis. Sensitivity analysis was performed to obtain robust results. RESULTS: CIMT-based reclassification induced a 1% lower absolute risk of MI and 0.01-0.02 increase in quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) for men, and a 1-3% lower risk, and 0.03-0.05 increase in QALYs for women, over a period of 20-30 years. Corresponding costs were an additional $100 per man, and a cost-saving of$200-300 per woman. Over a 10-year period CIMT measurements were cost-effective with a probability of 66% (men), and 94% (women). Over a 30-year period, CIMT measurements had acceptable cost-effectiveness for men and women. CONCLUSION: Performing CIMT measurements in asymptomatic men and women aged 50-59 years results in additional, but small, health benefits. It takes time for these health benefits to outweigh the initial CIMT measurement costs. Our results support CIMT measurements for cardiovascular risk stratification, in particular for women, when focusing on long-term health

Addressing persistent evidence gaps in cardiovascular sex differences research – the potential of clinical care data

Women have historically been underrepresented in cardiovascular clinical trials, resulting in a lack of sex-specific data. This is especially problematic in two situations, namely those where diseases manifest differently in women and men and those where biological differences between the sexes might affect the efficacy and/or safety of medication. There is therefore a pressing need for datasets with proper representation of women to address questions related to these situations. Clinical care data could fit this bill nicely because of their unique broad scope across both patient groups and clinical measures. This perspective piece presents the potential of clinical care data in sex differences research and discusses current challenges clinical care data-based research faces. It also suggests strategies to reduce the effect of these limitations, and explores whether clinical care data alone will be sufficient to close evidence gaps or whether a more comprehensive approach is needed

Sex-specific Mendelian randomisation to assess the causality of sex differences in the effects of risk factors and treatment: spotlight on hypertension

Hypertension is a key modifiable risk factor for cardiovascular disease. Several observational studies have found a stronger association of blood pressure and cardiovascular disease risk in women compared to men. Since observational studies can be affected by sex-specific residual confounding and reverse causation, it remains unclear whether these differences reflect actual differential effects. Other study designs are needed to uncover the causality of sex differences in the strength of risk factor and treatment effects. Mendelian randomisation (MR) uses genetic variants as instrumental variables to provide evidence about putative causal relations between risk factors and outcomes. By exploiting the random allocation of genes at gamete forming, MR is unaffected by confounding and results in more reliable causal effect estimates. In this review, we discuss why and how sex-specific MR and cis-MR could be used to study sex differences in risk factor and drug target effects. Sex-specific MR can be helpful to strengthen causal inferences in the field of sex differences, where it is often challenging to distinguish nature from nurture. The challenge of sex-specific (drug target) MR lays in leveraging robust genetic instruments from sex-specific GWAS studies which are not commonly available. Knowledge on sex-specific causal effects of hypertension, or other risk factors, could improve clinical practice and health policies by tailoring interventions based on personalised risk. Drug target MR can help to determine the anticipated on-target effects of a drug compound and to identify targets to pursue in drug developmen

Sex-dependent gene co-expression in the human body

Many pathophysiological mechanisms in human health and disease are dependent on sex. Systems biology approaches are successfully used to decipher human disease etiology, yet the effect of sex on gene network biology is mostly unknown. To address this, we used RNA-sequencing data of over 700 individuals spanning 24 tissues from the Genotype-Tissue Expression project to generate a whole-body gene co-expression map and quantified the sex differences per tissue. We found that of the 13,787 genes analyzed in 24 tissues, 29.5% of the gene co-expression is influenced by sex. For example, skeletal muscle was predominantly enriched with genes co-expressed stronger in males, whereas thyroid primarily contained genes co-expressed stronger in females. This was accompanied by consistent sex differences in pathway enrichment, including hypoxia, epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition, and inflammation over the human body. Furthermore, multi-organ analyses revealed consistent sex-dependent gene co-expression over numerous tissues which was accompanied by enrichment of transcription factor binding motifs in the promoters of these genes. Finally, we show that many sex-biased genes are associated with sex-biased diseases, such as autoimmunity and cancer, and more often the target of FDA-approved drugs than non-sexbiased genes. Our study suggests that sex affects biological gene networks by differences in gene co-expression and that attention to the effect of sex on biological responses to medical drugs is warranted

Addressing persistent evidence gaps in cardiovascular sex differences research – the potential of clinical care data

Women have historically been underrepresented in cardiovascular clinical trials, resulting in a lack of sex-specific data. This is especially problematic in two situations, namely those where diseases manifest differently in women and men and those where biological differences between the sexes might affect the efficacy and/or safety of medication. There is therefore a pressing need for datasets with proper representation of women to address questions related to these situations. Clinical care data could fit this bill nicely because of their unique broad scope across both patient groups and clinical measures. This perspective piece presents the potential of clinical care data in sex differences research and discusses current challenges clinical care data-based research faces. It also suggests strategies to reduce the effect of these limitations, and explores whether clinical care data alone will be sufficient to close evidence gaps or whether a more comprehensive approach is needed

Cardiorenal disease connection during post-menopause: The protective role of estrogen in uremic toxins induced microvascular dysfunction

Female gender, post-menopause, chronic kidney disease (CKD) and (CKD linked) microvascular disease are important risk factors for developing heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF). Enhancing our understanding of the interrelation between these risk factors could greatly benefit the identification of new drug targets for future therapy. This review discusses the evidence for the protective role of estradiol (E2) in CKD-associated microvascular disease and related HFpEF. Elevated circulating levels of uremic toxins (UTs) during CKD may act in synergy with hormonal changes during post-menopause and could lead to coronary microvascular endothelial dysfunction in HFpEF. To elucidate the molecular mechanism involved, published transcriptome datasets of indoxyl sulfate (IS), high inorganic phosphate (HP) or E2 treated human derived endothelial cells from the NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus database were analyzed. In total, 36 genes overlapped in both IS- and HP-activated gene sets, 188 genes were increased by UTs (HP and/or IS) and decreased by E2, and 572 genes were decreased by UTs and increased by E2. Based on a comprehensive in silico analysis and literature studies of collected gene sets, we conclude that CKD-accumulated UTs could negatively impact renal and cardiac endothelial homeostasis by triggering extensive inflammatory responses and initiating dysregulation of angiogenesis. E2 may protect (myo)endothelium by inhibiting UTs-induced inflammation and ameliorating UTs-related uremic bleeding and thrombotic diathesis via restored coagulation capacity and hemostasis in injured vessels

Sex differences in the genetic and molecular mechanisms of coronary artery disease

Sex differences in coronary artery disease (CAD) presentation, risk factors and prognosis have been widely studied. Similarly, studies on atherosclerosis have shown prominent sex differences in plaque biology. Our understanding of the underlying genetic and molecular mechanisms that drive these differences remains fragmented and largely understudied. Through reviewing genetic and epigenetic studies, we identified more than 40 sex-differential candidate genes (13 within known CAD loci) that may explain, at least in part, sex differences in vascular remodeling, lipid metabolism and endothelial dysfunction. Studies with transcriptomic and single-cell RNA sequencing data from atherosclerotic plaques highlight potential sex differences in smooth muscle cell and endothelial cell biology. Especially, phenotypic switching of smooth muscle cells seems to play a crucial role in female atherosclerosis. This matches the known sex differences in atherosclerotic phenotypes, with men being more prone to lipid-rich plaques, while women are more likely to develop fibrous plaques with endothelial dysfunction. To unravel the complex mechanisms that drive sex differences in CAD, increased statistical power and adjustments to study designs and analysis strategies are required. This entails increasing inclusion rates of women, performing well-defined sex-stratified analyses and the integration of multi-omics data

Sex-specific Mendelian randomisation to assess the causality of sex differences in the effects of risk factors and treatment: spotlight on hypertension

Hypertension is a key modifiable risk factor for cardiovascular disease. Several observational studies have found a stronger association of blood pressure and cardiovascular disease risk in women compared to men. Since observational studies can be affected by sex-specific residual confounding and reverse causation, it remains unclear whether these differences reflect actual differential effects. Other study designs are needed to uncover the causality of sex differences in the strength of risk factor and treatment effects. Mendelian randomisation (MR) uses genetic variants as instrumental variables to provide evidence about putative causal relations between risk factors and outcomes. By exploiting the random allocation of genes at gamete forming, MR is unaffected by confounding and results in more reliable causal effect estimates. In this review, we discuss why and how sex-specific MR and cis-MR could be used to study sex differences in risk factor and drug target effects. Sex-specific MR can be helpful to strengthen causal inferences in the field of sex differences, where it is often challenging to distinguish nature from nurture. The challenge of sex-specific (drug target) MR lays in leveraging robust genetic instruments from sex-specific GWAS studies which are not commonly available. Knowledge on sex-specific causal effects of hypertension, or other risk factors, could improve clinical practice and health policies by tailoring interventions based on personalised risk. Drug target MR can help to determine the anticipated on-target effects of a drug compound and to identify targets to pursue in drug development

Heart Size Corrected Electrical Dyssynchrony and Its Impact on Sex-specific Response to Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy

Background - Women are less likely to receive cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT), yet, they are more responsive to the therapy and respond at shorter QRS duration. The present study hypothesized that a relatively larger left ventricular (LV) electrical dyssynchrony in smaller hearts contributes to the better CRT response in women. For this the vectorcardiography-derived QRS area is used, since it allows for a more detailed quantification of electrical dyssynchrony compared to conventional electrocardiographic markers. Methods - Data from a multicenter registry of 725 CRT patients (median follow-up: 4.2 years [IQR: 2.7-6.1]) were analyzed. Baseline electrical dyssynchrony was evaluated using the QRS area, and the corrected QRS area for heart size using the LV end-diastolic volume (QRSarea/LVEDV). Impact of the QRSarea/LVEDV-ratio on the association between sex and LV reverse remodeling (end-systolic volume change: ΔLVESV) and sex and the composite outcome of all-cause mortality, LV assist device implantation or heart transplantation was assessed. Results - At baseline, women (n=228) displayed larger electrical dyssynchrony than men (QRS area: 132±55μVs vs 123±58μVs, p=0.043) which was, even more pronounced for the QRSarea/LVEDV-ratio (0.76±0.46μVs/ml vs 0.57±0.34μVs/ml, p<0.001). After multivariable analyses female sex was associated with ΔLVESV (β 0.12, p=0.003) and a lower occurrence the composite outcome (HR 0.59 (0.42-0.85), p=0.004). A part of the female advantage regarding reverse remodeling was attributed to the larger QRSarea/LVEDV-ratio in women (25-fold change in Beta from 0.12 to 0.09). The larger QRSarea/LVEDV-ratio did not contribute to the better survival observed in women. In both volumetric responders and non-responders, female sex remained strongly associated with a lower risk of the composite outcome (adjusted HR 0.59 (0.36-0.97), p=0.036 and 0.55 (0.33-0.90), p=0.018, respectively). Conclusions - Greater electrical dyssynchrony in smaller hearts contributes in part to more reverse remodeling observed in women after CRT, but this does not explain their better long-term outcomes