48 research outputs found
Mantle Pb paradoxes : the sulfide solution
Author Posting. Š Springer, 2006. This is the author's version of the work. It is posted here by permission of Springer for personal use, not for redistribution. The definitive version was published in Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology 152 (2006): 295-308, doi:10.1007/s00410-006-0108-1.There is growing evidence that the budget of Pb in mantle peridotites is largely
contained in sulfide, and that Pb partitions strongly into sulfide relative to silicate melt. In
addition, there is evidence to suggest that diffusion rates of Pb in sulfide (solid or melt)
are very fast. Given the possibility that sulfide melt âwetsâ sub-solidus mantle silicates,
and has very low viscosity, the implications for Pb behavior during mantle melting are
profound. There is only sparse experimental data relating to Pb partitioning between
sulfide and silicate, and no data on Pb diffusion rates in sulfides. A full understanding of
Pb behavior in sulfide may hold the key to several long-standing and important Pb
paradoxes and enigmas. The classical Pb isotope paradox arises from the fact that all
known mantle reservoirs lie to the right of the Geochron, with no consensus as to the
identity of the âbalancingâ reservoir. We propose that long-term segregation of sulfide
(containing Pb) to the core may resolve this paradox. Another Pb paradox arises from the fact that the Ce/Pb ratio of both OIB and MORB
is greater than bulk earth, and constant at a value of 25. The constancy of this âcanonical
ratioâ implies similar partition coefficients for Ce and Pb during magmatic processes
(Hofmann et al. 1986), whereas most experimental studies show that Pb is more
incompatible in silicates than Ce. Retention of Pb in residual mantle sulfide during
melting has the potential to bring the bulk partitioning of Ce into equality with Pb if the
sulfide melt/silicate melt partition coefficient for Pb has a value of ~ 14. Modeling shows
that the Ce/Pb (or Nd/Pb) of such melts will still accurately reflect that of the source, thus
enforcing the paradox that OIB and MORB mantles have markedly higher Ce/Pb (and
Nd/Pb) than the bulk silicate earth. This implies large deficiencies of Pb in the mantle
sources for these basalts. Sulfide may play other important roles during magmagenesis:
1). advective/diffusive sulfide networks may form potent metasomatic agents (in both
introducing and obliterating Pb isotopic heterogeneities in the mantle); 2). silicate melt
networks may easily exchange Pb with ambient mantle sulfides (by diffusion or
assimilation), thus âsamplingâ Pb in isotopically heterogeneous mantle domains
differently from the silicate-controlled isotope tracer systems (Sr, Nd, Hf), with an
apparent âde-couplingâ of these systems.Our intemperance
should not be blamed on the support we gratefully acknowledge from NSF: EAR-
0125917 to SRH and OCE-0118198 to GAG
Mantle Eclogite And Carbonate As Sources Of Sodic Carbonatites And Alkalic Magmas
Peer Reviewedhttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/62794/1/302700a0.pd
Carbon-fluid equilibria and the oxidation state of the upper mantle
IT has been proposed that the oxidation state of the Earth's upper mantle is buffered by C-O fluids in equilibrium with elemental carbon1,2. A large body of data on the oxygen fugacities (fo2) recorded by mantle rocks and their derivative melts now allows us to test this proposal. By comparing the measured fo2 values with those calculated for carbon-CO2-CO-carbonate equilibria along appropriate mantle geotherms, we find the data to be wholly consistent with this hypothesis. Moreover, the calculated variation of fo2 with temperature and pressure accounts for much of the observed correlation between the oxidation state of mantle samples and their tectonic provenance3,4. The apparent buffering of mantle fo2 requires modest quantities of mantle carbon and fluid, which do not exceed independently estimated values. The proposal is not compromised if parts of the mantle are fluid-undersaturated, or if the C-O fluid phase is diluted by other volatiles