EFFECTIVENESS OF BASALT FIBRE-REINFORCED CEMENTITIOUS SYSTEMS IN CONFINING MASONRY MEMBERS: AN EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION

The use of composites based on fibre-reinforced polymers (FRPs) to strengthen masonry columns has become a common practice in the last decades. FRPs, however, exhibit some shortcomings when applied to masonry substrates, due to the organic nature of their matrix. For this reason, increasing attention is paid today to composites based on fibre-reinforced cementitious matrices (FRCMs), in which the polymeric matrix is replaced with an inorganic matrix (such as cementitious mortars). Cementitious matrices guarantee higher breathability and compatibility with the substrate, less sensitivity to debonding at the interfaces, and higher resistance to fire and high temperatures. Moreover, due to the increasing demand for new materials not only mechanically efficient but also sustainable, composites reinforced with basalt fibres are becoming very appealing for strengthening masonry structures. Several works have been devoted to the application of composites to confine masonry, but only a few are about basalt fibres. Additionally, the small number of studies currently available on the confinement of masonry by means of FRCMs are mainly focused on the efficiency of this system in enhancing the mechanical performance of strengthened members. In fact, few indications are available on the modelling of the compressive behaviour of FRCM-confined masonry and few equations have been formulated to predict structural strength. Last but not least, comparisons on the performance of BFRP and BFRCM systems are still missing in the literature, a necessary step to quantify the effectiveness of cement-based composites in improving the performance of masonry columns. The aim of this study is the comparative evaluation of the effectiveness of BFRP and BFRCM systems in increasing the load carrying capacity and the ductility of confined masonry columns. Two are the main objectives: to assess the performance of basalt textile as a new material for strengthening applications; and to understand whether composites made with cementitious matrices and reinforced with basalt fibres are a valid alternative to FRPs for strengthening masonry columns

Effectiveness of Flax-TRM composites under traction

The scientific research in the field of masonry structures is increasingly welcoming the adoption of innovative and sustainable rehabilitation techniques aimed at the safeguarding of the Built Cultural Heritage. Textile Reinforced Matrix (TRM) composites are the most widely investigated strengthening systems for ancient masonry structures, thanks to their high compatibility level with the material substrates in terms of fire resistance, chemical/physical aspects, reversibility property, little impact on dimensions, stiffness and weight. Nevertheless, in the last years, the growing concern on sustainability increased the interest in products with low environmental impact, for promoting circular economy approaches in the design of the structural interventions. In particular, efforts have been done to replace the most common composites with materials less harmful to the environment, such as natural fibres, for developing compatible and sustainable rehabilitation techniques for masonry structures. This paper presents the preliminary results of experimental tests conducted by the authors on specimens of TRM composites made with natural, vegetable, flax-fibre grids and natural hydraulic lime mortar. The mechanical characterization tests aimed at detecting the tensile behaviour of the natural TRM system compared to the results available in the literature on different vegetable-fibre composites and TRMs made with natural basalt fibres. The experimental tests highlighted the promising mechanical effectiveness of natural TRM systems under traction and offered a hint to further research aimed at improving their mechanical strength and stiffness

Effectiveness of Flax-TRM composites under traction

The scientific research in the field of masonry structures is increasingly welcoming the adoption of innovative and sustainable rehabilitation techniques aimed at the safeguarding of the Built Cultural Heritage. Textile Reinforced Matrix (TRM) composites are the most widely investigated strengthening systems for ancient masonry structures, thanks to their high compatibility level with the material substrates in terms of fire resistance, chemical/physical aspects, reversibility property, little impact on dimensions, stiffness and weight. Nevertheless, in the last years, the growing concern on sustainability increased the interest in products with low environmental impact, for promoting circular economy approaches in the design of the structural interventions. In particular, efforts have been done to replace the most common composites with materials less harmful to the environment, such as natural fibres, for developing compatible and sustainable rehabilitation techniques for masonry structures. This paper presents the preliminary results of experimental tests conducted by the authors on specimens of TRM composites made with natural, vegetable, flax-fibre grids and natural hydraulic lime mortar. The mechanical characterization tests aimed at detecting the tensile behaviour of the natural TRM system compared to the results available in the literature on different vegetable-fibre composites and TRMs made with natural basalt fibres. The experimental tests highlighted the promising mechanical effectiveness of natural TRM systems under traction and offered a hint to further research aimed at improving their mechanical strength and stiffness

Experimental investigation on basalt grid cementitious mortar strips in tension

Fibre reinforced cementitious matrix (FRCM) composite materials are currently receiving great attention for strengthening reinforced concrete and masonry structures, especially when specific preservation criteria need to be fulfilled. FRCM composites can be a convenient alternative to fibre-reinforced polymers (FRP) for their better resistance to high temperature and compatibility with stone and masonry structures. In this work an experimental study for the tensile characterization of basalt reinforced cementitious matrix (BRCM) strips is presented. Strips with one, two or three layers of grid were tested in tension to study the effect of reinforcement ratio on the tensile stress-strain response of the composite strips. The basalt grid and matrix (cementitious mortar) were also tested in order to compare the mechanical properties of the constituent materials to the response of the composite. Strength, stiffness, failure modes and response stages of the composite strips are discussed in the paper

Shake‑table testing of a stone masonry building aggregate: overview of blind prediction study

City centres of Europe are often composed of unreinforced masonry structural aggregates, whose seismic response is challenging to predict. To advance the state of the art on the seismic response of these aggregates, the Adjacent Interacting Masonry Structures (AIMS) subproject from Horizon 2020 project Seismology and Earthquake Engineering Research Infrastructure Alliance for Europe (SERA) provides shake-table test data of a two-unit, double-leaf stone masonry aggregate subjected to two horizontal components of dynamic excitation. A blind prediction was organized with participants from academia and industry to test modelling approaches and assumptions and to learn about the extent of uncertainty in modelling for such masonry aggregates. The participants were provided with the full set of material and geometrical data, construction details and original seismic input and asked to predict prior to the test the expected seismic response in terms of damage mechanisms, base-shear forces, and roof displacements. The modelling approaches used differ significantly in the level of detail and the modelling assumptions. This paper provides an overview of the adopted modelling approaches and their subsequent predictions. It further discusses the range of assumptions made when modelling masonry walls, floors and connections, and aims at discovering how the common solutions regarding modelling masonry in general, and masonry aggregates in particular, affect the results. The results are evaluated both in terms of damage mechanisms, base shear forces, displacements and interface openings in both directions, and then compared with the experimental results. The modelling approaches featuring Discrete Element Method (DEM) led to the best predictions in terms of displacements, while a submission using rigid block limit analysis led to the best prediction in terms of damage mechanisms. Large coefficients of variation of predicted displacements and general underestimation of displacements in comparison with experimental results, except for DEM models, highlight the need for further consensus building on suitable modelling assumptions for such masonry aggregates

Effect of FRP Wraps on the Compressive Behaviour of Slender Masonry Columns

In the last decade, Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP) wrapping technique has become a common method to retrofit masonry piers or columns with poor structural performances. The passive confinement effect induced by the external wrap allows increasing the compressive strength and ductility of the member. Several studies highlighted as the efficacy of this technique is affected by several key parameters, including the shape of the transverse cross section, stress intensification at the strength corner of sharp sections, amount and mechanical properties of adopted composite. Despite this technique has been widely studied from both theoretical and experimental point of view, most of studies focused on short columns and little information is available on the influence of second order effects on its structural efficacy. This paper presents a simplified method able to assess the effect of FRP confinement on slender columns. A preliminary evaluation of the constitutive law in compression of FRP confined masonry is made and the best-fitting model is adopted to model masonry in compression. Sectional analysis is performed by including the tensile strength of masonry and considerations are made on the increase of ultimate moment and curvature. Finally, the effect of column slenderness is considered using a simple numerical procedure, making it possible to calculate the allowable slenderness ratios as a function of the maximum drift, taking into account both strength and stability

CRITERI E TECNICHE DI VALUTAZIONE E RIDUZIONE DELLA VULNERABILITÀ SISMICA DEL CENTRO STORICO

Una valutazione della vulnerabilità sismica, sia attraverso approcci fenomenologici che attraverso più accurati modelli meccanici non può prescindere dalla conoscenza (il più possibile accurata) di tali caratteristiche del costruito, che può essere acquisita spesso soltanto attraverso campagne di rilievo e di indagini sul costruito. In questo contesto, vengono inizialmente descritte le caratteristiche salienti del centro storico di Modica, per poi passare in rassegna i metodi di valutazione della vulnerabilità sismica a scala territoriale; infine verranno presentate alcune tecniche di mitigazione della vulnerabilità sismica, e presidi antisismici da mettere in atto per evitare che trasformazioni del costruito richieste per una più idonea fruizione del bene possano risultare nocive alla sicurezza sismic

Modelling of FRP and FRCM-confined masonry columns: critical review for design and intervention strategies

This paper presents a critical review of the most established analytical models for the prediction of the compressive strength of FRP and FRCM-confined masonry columns. In particular, two types of fibres are analysed, i.e. glass and basalt. A wide dataset available in the literature is used for the application of the analytical models and for the development of parametric analyses useful for the critical comparison of FRP vs. FRCM confinement technique and glass vs. basalt fibres to be adopted as reinforcement of masonry substrate. The effects of stiffness and strength of the reinforcement, the number of reinforcing layers, the compressive strength of masonry and the cross-section shape are investigate

Compressive behaviour of eccentrically loaded slender masonry columns confined by FRP

Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP) confinement represents an effective tool for retrofitting masonry piers or columns enhancing their structural performance. This technique has been widely studied in the literature mainly with reference to short columns, while no extensive information is available on the influence of second order effects on its efficacy in case of slender members. Within this framework, the presented study concerns a simplified method able to assess the effects of FRP confinement on the compressive behaviour of slender masonry columns. A proper constitutive law of FRP confined masonry in compression is adopted for performing a sectional analysis, in which also considerations are made on the increase of ultimate moment and curvature depending on the role of some key parameters. The effect of column slenderness is evaluated using a simple analytical iterative procedure, making it possible to calculate the allowable slenderness ratios as function of the maximum drift, taking into account both strength and stability. The effect of slenderness on eccentrically loaded columns is finally examined through a finite element model used for validating the results of the proposed analytical procedure, allowing also to draw safety domains useful for design/verification purposes. It is shown as the column's slenderness affects the efficiency of confinement, being the latter negligible for values of normalized length greater than 20