Chloroplast DNA rearrangements in Campanulaceae: phylogenetic utility of highly rearranged genomes

BACKGROUND: The Campanulaceae (the "hare bell" or "bellflower" family) is a derived angiosperm family comprised of about 600 species treated in 35 to 55 genera. Taxonomic treatments vary widely and little phylogenetic work has been done in the family. Gene order in the chloroplast genome usually varies little among vascular plants. However, chloroplast genomes of Campanulaceae represent an exception and phylogenetic analyses solely based on chloroplast rearrangement characters support a reasonably well-resolved tree. RESULTS: Chloroplast DNA physical maps were constructed for eighteen representatives of the family. So many gene order changes have occurred among the genomes that characterizing individual mutational events was not always possible. Therefore, we examined different, novel scoring methods to prepare data matrices for cladistic analysis. These approaches yielded largely congruent results but varied in amounts of resolution and homoplasy. The strongly supported nodes were common to all gene order analyses as well as to parallel analyses based on ITS and rbcL sequence data. The results suggest some interesting and unexpected intrafamilial relationships. For example fifteen of the taxa form a derived clade; whereas the remaining three taxa – Platycodon, Codonopsis, and Cyananthus – form the basal clade. This major subdivision of the family corresponds to the distribution of pollen morphology characteristics but is not compatible with previous taxonomic treatments. CONCLUSIONS: Our use of gene order data in the Campanulaceae provides the most highly resolved phylogeny as yet developed for a plant family using only cpDNA rearrangements. The gene order data showed markedly less homoplasy than sequence data for the same taxa but did not resolve quite as many nodes. The rearrangement characters, though relatively few in number, support robust and meaningful phylogenetic hypotheses and provide new insights into evolutionary relationships within the Campanulaceae

Implications of the Plastid Genome Sequence of Typha (Typhaceae, Poales) for Understanding Genome Evolution in Poaceae

Plastid genomes of the grasses (Poaceae) are unusual in their organization and rates of sequence evolution. There has been a recent surge in the availability of grass plastid genome sequences, but a comprehensive comparative analysis of genome evolution has not been performed that includes any related families in the Poales. We report on the plastid genome of Typha latifolia, the first non-grass Poales sequenced to date, and we present comparisons of genome organization and sequence evolution within Poales. Our results confirm that grass plastid genomes exhibit acceleration in both genomic rearrangements and nucleotide substitutions. Poaceae have multiple structural rearrangements, including three inversions, three genes losses (accD, ycf1, ycf2), intron losses in two genes (clpP, rpoC1), and expansion of the inverted repeat (IR) into both large and small single-copy regions. These rearrangements are restricted to the Poaceae, and IR expansion into the small single-copy region correlates with the phylogeny of the family. Comparisons of 73 protein-coding genes for 47 angiosperms including nine Poaceae genera confirm that the branch leading to Poaceae has significantly accelerated rates of change relative to other monocots and angiosperms. Furthermore, rates of sequence evolution within grasses are lower, indicating a deceleration during diversification of the family. Overall there is a strong correlation between accelerated rates of genomic rearrangements and nucleotide substitutions in Poaceae, a phenomenon that has been noted recently throughout angiosperms. The cause of the correlation is unknown, but faulty DNA repair has been suggested in other systems including bacterial and animal mitochondrial genomes

Abstract

The breakpoint phylogeny is an optimization problem proposed by Blanchette et al. for reconstructing evolutionary trees from gene order data. These same authors developed and implemented BPAnalysis [4], a heuristic method (based upon solving many instances of the Travelling Salesman Problem) for estimating the breakpoint phylogeny. We present a new heuristic for estimating the breakpoint phylogeny which, although not polynomial-time, is much faster in practice thanBPAnalysis. We use this heuristic to conduct a phylogenetic analysis of the flowering plant family Campanulaceae. We also present and discuss the results of experimentation on this real dataset with three methods: our new method, BPAnalysis, and the neighbor-joining method [21], using breakpoint distances, inversion distances, and inversion plus transposition distances

Abstract

The breakpoint phylogeny is an optimization problem proposed by Blanchette et al. for reconstructing evolutionary trees from gene order data. These same authors also developed and implemented BPAnalysis [3], a heuristic method (based upon solving many instances of the travelling salesman problem) for estimating the breakpoint phylogeny. We present a new heuristic for this purpose; although not polynomial-time, our heuristic is much faster in practice than BPAnalysis. We present and discuss the results of experimentation on synthetic datasets and on the flowering plant family Campanulaceae with three methods: our new method, BPAnalysis, and the neighbor-joining method [25] using several distance estimation techniques. Our preliminary results indicate that, on datasets with slow evolutionary rates and large numbers of genes in comparison with the number of taxa (genomes), all methods recover quite accurate reconstructions of the true evolutionary history (althoughBPAnalysis is too slow to be practical), but that on datasets where the rate of evolution is high relative to the number of genes, the accuracy of all three methods is poor

Abstract

The breakpoint phylogeny is an optimization problem proposed by Blanchette et al. for reconstructing evolutionary trees from gene order data. These same authors also developed and implemented BPAnalysis [3], a heuristic method (based upon solving many instances of the travelling salesman problem) for estimating the breakpoint phylogeny. We present a new heuristic for this purpose; although not polynomial-time, our heuristic is much faster in practice than BPAnalysis. We present and discuss the results of experimentation on synthetic datasets and on the flowering plant family Campanulaceae with three methods: our new method, BPAnalysis, and the neighbor-joining method [25] using several distance estimation techniques. Our preliminary results indicate that, on datasets with slow evolutionary rates and large numbers of genes in comparison with the number of taxa (genomes), all methods recover quite accurate reconstructions of the true evolutionary history (althoughBPAnalysis is too slow to be practical), but that on datasets where the rate of evolution is high relative to the number of genes, the accuracy of all three methods is poor

An Empirical Comparison of Phylogenetic Methods on Chloroplast Gene Order Data in Campanulaceae

The first heuristic for reconstructing phylogenetic trees from gene order data was introduced by Blanchette et al.. It sought to reconstruct the breakpoint phylogeny and was applied to a variety of datasets. We present a new heuristic for estimating the breakpoint phylogeny which, although not polynomial-time, is much faster in practice than BPAnalysis. We use this heuristic to conduct a phylogenetic analysis of chloroplast genomes in the flowering plant family Campanulaceae. We also present and discuss the results of experimentation on this real dataset with three methods: our new method, BPAnalysis, and the neighbor-joining method, using breakpoint distances, inversion distances, and inversion plus transposition distances.