Detection of Recent HIV-1 Infection Using a New Limiting-Antigen Avidity Assay: Potential for HIV-1 Incidence Estimates and Avidity Maturation Studies

Background: Accurate and reliable laboratory methods are needed for estimation of HIV-1 incidence to identify the highrisk populations and target and monitor prevention efforts. We previously described a single-well limiting-antigen avidity enzyme immunoassay (LAg-Avidity EIA) to detect recent HIV-1 infection. Methods: We describe here further optimization and characterization of LAg-Avidity EIA, comparing it to the BED assay and a two-well avidity-index (AI) EIA. Specimen sets included longitudinal sera (n = 393), collected from 89 seroconverting individuals from 4 cohorts representing 4 HIV-1 subtypes, and sera from AIDS patients (n = 488) with or without TB coinfections from 3 different cohorts. Ninety seven HIV-1 positive specimens were purchased commercially. The BED assay, LAg-Avidity EIA, AI-EIA and HIV serology were performed, as needed. Results: Monitoring quality control specimens indicated high reproducibility of the LAg-Avidity EIA with coefficient of variation of,10 % in the dynamic range. The LAg-Avidity EIA has an overall mean duration of recency (v) of 141 days (95% CI 119–160) at normalized optical density (ODn) cutoff of 1.0, with similar v in different HIV-1 subtypes and populations (132 to 143 days). Antibody avidity kinetics were similar among individuals and subtypes by both the LAg-Avidity EIA and AI-EIA compared to the HIV-IgG levels measured by the BED assay. The false recent rate among individuals with AIDS was 0.2% with the LAg-Avidity EIA, compared to 2.9 % with the BED assay. Western blot profiles of specimens with increasing avidit

Assessment of BED HIV-1 Incidence Assay in Seroconverter Cohorts: Effect of Individuals with Long-Term Infection and Importance of Stable Incidence

BACKGROUND: Performance of the BED assay in estimating HIV-1 incidence has previously been evaluated by using longitudinal specimens from persons with incident HIV infections, but questions remain about its accuracy. We sought to assess its performance in three longitudinal cohorts from Thailand where HIV-1 CRF01_AE and subtype B' dominate the epidemic. DESIGN: BED testing was conducted in two longitudinal cohorts with only incident infections (a military conscript cohort and an injection drug user cohort) and in one longitudinal cohort (an HIV-1 vaccine efficacy trial cohort) that also included long-term infections. METHODS: Incidence estimates were generated conventionally (based on the number of annual serocoversions) and by using BED test results in the three cohorts. Adjusted incidence was calculated where appropriate. RESULTS: For each longitudinal cohort the BED incidence estimates and the conventional incidence estimates were similar when only newly infected persons were tested, whether infected with CRF01_AE or subtype B'. When the analysis included persons with long-term infections (to mimic a true cross-sectional cohort), BED incidence estimates were higher, although not significantly, than the conventional incidence estimates. After adjustment, the BED incidence estimates were closer to the conventional incidence estimates. When the conventional incidence varied over time, as in the early phase of the injection drug user cohort, the difference between the two estimates increased, but not significantly. CONCLUSIONS: Evaluation of the performance of incidence assays requires the inclusion of a substantial number of cohort-derived specimens from individuals with long-term HIV infection and, ideally, the use of cohorts in which incidence remained stable. Appropriate adjustments of the BED incidence estimates generate estimates similar to those generated conventionally

HIV testing in developing countries: What is required?

HIV diagnostic and follow up testing are usually done in laboratory settings. However, in developing countries there is a need to decentralize testing as the majority of the population lives in rural settings. In developing countries stringent quality assurance (QA) practices, which include appropriate training, development of standard operating procedures, maintenance of operator proficiency, routine use of quality control (QC) specimens, standardized data management, equipment calibration and maintenance, and biohazard safety with proper disinfection/disposal procedures are not routinely followed to ensure reliability of results and a safe work environment. The introduction of point-of-care testing technologies involving the use of non-laboratorians in routine testing has further increased the complexity of QA. Therefore, a careful approach towards improvement of laboratories that encourages best practices, coupled with incentives, and review of government policies in point-of-care testing is needed to improve quality of testing as decentralization takes place. Development of a functional laboratory tiered network that facilitates communication, referral, training and problem solving could further enhance confidence in laboratory testing. There is also a need for special considerations in implementing a step-wise approach towards quality improvement, strengthening of the supply chain management, human capacity development, infrastructure upgrade, and strong public private partnerships to ensure long term sustainability of these efforts

A Comprehensive Evaluation of the Proficiency Testing Program for the HIV-1 BED Incidence Assay▿

The HIV-1 BED incidence assay was developed at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and since 2005 has been available as a commercial kit for use in HIV-1 incidence surveillance. A BED-specific proficiency testing (PT) program was initiated in 2006 that included a panel of eight coded specimens (six unique and two duplicates) to participating laboratories. The number of participating laboratories increased from 12 to 38 from 2006 to 2009. Overall, 96.1% of the laboratories reported results, and 95.4% of those reporting achieved a 100% score. The observed mean normalized optical density (OD-n) values of all participants correlated well with the expected OD-n values for all specimens (R2 = 0.98) used for seven PT rounds. BED testing demonstrated high reproducibility among all laboratories, with an agreement of 99.3% (574/578) between initial and confirmatory classification and regression statistics of R2 = 0.96, slope = 1.022, and intercept = 0.0066. Reproducibility among duplicate specimens was very high during each PT round, with mean deviation of 1.8%. Analysis of controls and calibrator specimen for all 343 runs showed a coefficient of variation of ca. 20% for raw ODs in the dynamic range, which was reduced to <10% when the OD was normalized (OD-n). Most laboratories that failed the PT assessment had transcriptional errors, kit reagent problems, or specimen handling errors. Thus, the BED-specific PT program enabled us to track performance of different laboratories conducting the BED assay while identifying areas for improvements. This program will also serve as a template for future PT programs for new incidence assays as they become available

Modification of Rapid Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) Antibody Assay Protocols for Detecting Recent HIV Seroconversion

Assay protocols of three rapid human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) assays, OraQuick-1/2, SeroStrip-1/2, and Determine-1/2, were modified to detect recent HIV seroconversion using a higher dilution of serum specimens. Optimal predilution of specimens resulted in negative test results during early periods of seroconversion (about 6 months), when antibody levels were low. A total of 269 seropositive specimens from routine HIV type 1 testing and from commercial sources (low-titer and seroconversion panels) were tested, and results were recorded as negative (score = 0) or positive using intensity scores from 0.5 (weak positive) to 4 (strongly positive). The same specimens were previously tested by a less sensitive (LS) enzyme immunoassay (EIA), Abbott 3A11-LS, and were classified as recent or long-term infections based on the standardized optical density (SOD) cutoff of 0.75. Overall concordance of >94% was observed between 3A11-LS and modified rapid tests (RT-LSs) for detecting and distinguishing recent HIV seroconversion from long-term HIV infection (kappa statistics = 0.894 to 0.901). Moreover, intensity scores on RT-LSs correlated well with median 3A11-LS SOD values (R(2) > 0.98). Our results indicate that rapid HIV tests can be modified to detect recent seroconversion with results comparable to those from less sensitive EIA

Performance Characteristics of the Immunoglobulin G-Capture BED-Enzyme Immunoassay, an Assay To Detect Recent Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Seroconversion

Recently, we developed an immunoglobulin G (IgG)-capture BED-enzyme immunoassay (BED-CEIA) to identify recent human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 (HIV-1) seroconversion for use in incidence estimates. We have established an algorithm for its use; developed quality control reagents to monitor the assay; and evaluated its performance for interrun, intrarun, and operator variability. Analysis of 144 individual plates, which involved multiple plate lots and several operators over more than a year, indicated that the coefficients of variation (CVs) were between 10 and 15% for raw optical density (OD) values in the dynamic range between 0.5 and 2.0 OD units; the CVs decreased to 5 to 10% when the OD was normalized (OD-n; OD-n = specimen OD/calibrator OD). The intrarun CVs were generally in the range of 5 to 10% for specimens with ODs <0.5 and less than 5% for specimens with ODs >0.5. The level of concordance between multiple plate lots (n = 6) and multiple operators (n = 7) was quite high (R(2) > 0.9). Comparison of the results of the initial and the confirmatory tests with specimens with OD-n values ≤1.5 demonstrated a high degree of correlation (R(2) = 0.92); 566 (92%) of 615 of specimens tested in the two modes retained the same classification (recent or long-term infection). The values for those specimens with changed classifications (n = 49) were close to the cutoff (OD-n = 1.0), as expected. The twofold difference in the HIV IgG contents between the controls and the calibrator reagents was exploited to monitor individual plate runs by using a control plot, which was incorporated into the spreadsheet for data entry and run monitoring. This information provides baseline data for the successful transfer of BED-CEIA to other laboratories and the use of BED-CEIA for the detection of recent HIV seroconversion and the calculation of incidence estimates worldwide

Performance evaluation of the Asante Rapid Recency Assay for verification of HIV diagnosis and detection of recent HIV-1 infections: Implications for epidemic control.

We previously described development of a rapid test for recent infection (RTRI) that can diagnose HIV infection and detect HIV-1 recent infections in a single device. This technology was transferred to a commercial partner as Asante Rapid Recency Assay (ARRA). We evaluated performance of the ARRA kits in the laboratory using a well-characterized panel of specimens. The plasma specimen panel (N = 1500) included HIV-1 (N = 570), HIV-2 (N = 10), and HIV-negatives (N = 920) representing multiple subtypes and geographic locations. Reference diagnostic data were generated using the Bio-Rad HIV-1-2-O EIA/Western blot algorithm with further serotyping performed using the Multispot HIV-1/2 assay. The LAg-Avidity EIA was used to generate reference data on recent and long-term infection for HIV-1 positive specimens at a normalized optical density (ODn) cutoff of 2.0 corresponding to a mean duration of about 6 months. All specimens were tested with ARRA according to the manufacturer's recommendations. Test strips were also read for line intensities using a reader and results were correlated with visual interpretation. ARRA's positive verification line (PVL) correctly classified 575 of 580 HIV-positive and 910 of 920 negative specimens resulting in a sensitivity of 99.1% (95% CI: 98.0-99.6) and specificity of 98.9% (95% CI: 98.1-99.4), respectively. The reader-based classification was similar for PVL with sensitivity of 99.3% (576/580) and specificity of 98.8% (909/920). ARRA's long-term line (LTL) classified 109 of 565 HIV-1 specimens as recent and 456 as long-term compared to 98 as recent and 467 as long-term (LT) by LAg-Avidity EIA (cutoff ODn = 2.0), suggesting a mean duration of recent infection (MDRI) close to 6 months. Agreement of ARRA with LAg recent cases was 81.6% (80/98) and LT cases was 93.8% (438/467), with an overall agreement of 91.7% (kappa = 0.72). The reader (cutoff 2.9) classified 109/566 specimens as recent infections compared to 99 by the LAg-Avidity EIA for recency agreement of 81.8% (81/99), LT agreement of 9% (439/467) with overall agreement of 91.9% (kappa = 0.72). The agreement between visual interpretation and strip reader was 99.9% (95% CI: 99.6-99.9) for the PVL and 98.1% (95% CI: 96.6-98.9) for the LTL. ARRA performed well with HIV diagnostic sensitivity >99% and specificity >98%. Its ability to identify recent infections is comparable to the LA-Avidity EIA corresponding to an MDRI of about 6 months. This point-of-care assay has implications for real-time surveillance of new infections among newly diagnosed individuals for targeted prevention and interrupting ongoing transmission thus accelerating epidemic control