EXPLORING NOVEL BIOACTIVE BONE REPAIR STRATEGIES

Alternative bone repair strategies are frequently sought after in orthopaedic surgery to address the growing need for improved morbidity and healing rates. This thesis sought to initiate and validate such an alternative, harnessing the flexible nature of a biomaterial substrate and the unique potential of glycosaminoglycan sugars. A novel, biodegradable biomaterial polymer, PHBV, has previously been identified to have the potential to mimic the characteristics of bone necessary for tissue repair and in this study, it was hypothesized that PHBV would be able to support bone formation. When tested in vitro, PHBV was found to support osteoblast cell attachment, proliferation and differentiation, despite its rougher, more hydrophobic surface characteristics compared to tissue culture plastic (TCP). However, unlike the progression of cells on TCP, PHBV caused a developmental delay at each stage of osteogenesis, suggesting a sub-optimal cell-substrate interaction. The expression profiles of genes involved in the maintenance of the extracellular matrix were monitored to investigate this phenomenon further. The results suggested that cells cultured on PHBV appeared to preference 7 against a collagen-based ECM and, instead, trigger an increase in the expression of other factors, such as osteopontin, presumably to modify the biomaterial microenvironment to optimise continued growth and differentiation. This finding led to the next hypothesis that functionalisation of PHBV with suitable compounds could optimise and enhance the osteogenic development at the implant site by facilitating the desired and appropriate cell-substrate interactions. Non-protein factors are often preferred for functionalisation to material scaffolds over proteins, as they are relatively robust and can survive many of the processes used in the manufacture of biomaterials. Glycosaminoglycan (GAG) sugars were appropriate candidates for this purpose, as they are not only abundantly expressed in bone, but more importantly, they are capable of binding and facilitating the activity of growth factors. Furthermore, they are resistant to several environmental influences including changes in pH, heat and desiccation. To identify a GAG that could be integrated with PHBV or any other biomaterial substrate, GAGs were extracted from phenotypically-distinct stages of MG-63 osteosarcoma cells. These GAGs were identified to display gross structural differences, as well as differences in the enzymes synthesising them, between immature and mature osteoblastic cells, with the increased production of a larger GAG species observed as the cells differentiated. Unexpectedly, however, when these GAGs were subsequently dosed back into the media of growing MG-63 cells, their bioactivity did not match the stage at which they had been harvested: all GAG species were able to influence cell survival and growth to varying degrees but were not capable of affecting cell differentiation. However, if these same GAGs were exposed to cells by first being attached to the growth substrate, they induced varying degrees of aggregation in human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs), with more mature GAGs producing the most profound effects. Interestingly, a similar phenomenon was not observed when MG-63 cells where cultured in a similar manner. A direct correlation between the GAGs expressed by osteoblasts and the specific cellular processes they functionally influence has yet to be identified. While the experiments presented here demonstrate an effect of GAGs in osteoblastic cell survival, a role for GAGs in the progression of bone formation was not revealed. Loss-of-function studies were therefore necessary to determine the role of GAGs in bone, but this was hampered by the limited availability of procedures that allow the alteration of GAGs and the subsequent detection of these effects. Therefore, a tool to screen the efficacy of a loss of GAG function was developed. TAT-EGFP, a purpose-designed fluorescent GAG-binding peptide, was able to confirm that treatment with sodium chlorate was an effective 8 strategy to hinder GAG expression in MG-63 cells with minimal cytotoxicity to the cells. Following more extensive studies with chlorate treatment, it was found that a recoverable disruption to both proliferation and mineralisation could be induced in MG-63 cells. This suggested a role for GAGs in osteogenesis. A series of experiments then carried out following gene expression microarray analysis indicated that GAG de-sulfation by chlorate gives rise to an S-phase block in the cell cycle and a disruption to the actin cytoskeleton, which appeared to be associated with a change in the activity of cell-surface proteoglycans, most likely syndecan 4. It was also found that cells up-regulated plasma membrane ALP activity and cholesterol synthesis, presumably in an attempt to recover from a chlorate-induced loss in GAG function. Cholesterol is known to be important in establishing connections between membrane elements and the actin cytoskeleton, and its up-regulation here may reflect dysfunctions in these units and a dysfunction in syndecan 4 activity. With further confirmation, this would suggest that syndecan 4 plays a pivotal role in maintaining osteogenesis, in at least MG-63 cells, and that sulfated GAGs function principally to facilitate this role. The effective use of GAGs in bone repair strategies will require further understanding of GAG/syndecan 4/osteogenesis relationship

Osteoblasts up-regulate the expression of extracellular proteases following attachment to Poly(β-hydroxybutyrate-co-β-hydroxyvalerate)

MC3T3-E1 cells demonstrate a lag in osteogenic development when seeded onto Poly(β-hydroxybutyrate-co-β-hydroxyvalerate) (PHBV), a biomaterial with substantial potential for bone tissue repair. To determine if this was due to the priority of extracellular matrix (ECM) remodelling over other developmental processes, gene expression levels of proteins involved in the production, maintenance and turnover of the ECM were compared between cells grown on PHBV and tissue culture plastic (TCP) 24 h after seeding. When grown on PHBV, MC3T3-E1 cells up-regulated proteins such as the matrix metalloproteinases and down-regulated the expression of proteins such as collagens that are involved in cell–substrate interactions, but in later-stage processes. The results also suggest that proteins such as fibronectin and aggrecan, and particularly osteopontin, may be more suitable candidates for PHBV functionalization for optimal MC3T3-E1 cell growth than proteins like osteonectin, periostin, vitronectin or collagen. This study confirms the importance of understanding the specific response of therapeutically-relevant cells, such as human stem cells, to candidate biomaterial surfaces in order to achieve optimal regenerative therapies

A novel use of TAT-EGFP to validate techniques to alter osteosarcoma cell surface glycosaminoglycan expression

Several methods to alter cell surface glycosaminoglycan (GAG) expression have previously been described, including treatments with chlorate to reduce the addition of charged sulfate groups, xyloside compounds to displace GAGs from their core proteins, and GAG lyases, such as heparinase and chondroitinase, to release GAG fragments from the cell layer. While these methods are useful in identifying cellular mechanisms which are dependent on GAGs, they must be stringently validated to assess results in the appropriate context. To determine the most useful technique for the evaluation of GAG function in osteogenesis, MG-63 osteosarcoma cells were systematically treated with these agents and evaluated for changes in cell surface GAGs using a TAT-EGFP fusion protein. TAT, a protein transduction domain from the HIV-1 virus, requires cell surface GAGs to traverse cell membranes. The EGFP component provides a method to assess protein entry into cells in both qualitative and quantitative tests. Here, TAT-EGFP transduction analysis confirmed radiochemical and physiological data that chlorate effectively disrupts GAG expression. TAT-EGFP entry into cells was also inhibited by the exogenous application of commercial heparin and GAGs extracted from MG-63 cells as well as by the pre-treatment of cells with chondroitinase ABC. However, neither heparinase III treatment nor the addition of exogenous chondroitin-6-sulfate affected TAT-EGFP entry into cells. In addition, xyloside-beta-D-naphthol and xyloside-beta-D-cis/trans-decahydro-2-naphthol treatment could not induce significant phenotypic change in these cells, and the unaffected TAT-EGFP transduction confirmed that this was due to an inability to efficiently prime GAG synthesis. The use of TAT-EGFP is thus a useful technique to specifically evaluate cell surface GAG expression in a simple, quantifiable manner, and avoids the complications involved with conventional radiochemical assays or analytical chromatography