Contesting Mad versus Bad: The Evolution of Forensic Mental Health Services and Law at Toronto

We analyze relevant aspects in the history of forensic mental health services in the Toronto area, which offers a well-documented historical record for contextualizing current public debates and controversies. Spanning the late 18th century to the present, we trace the development of common and statute law, and service responses in the forensic and criminal justice systems, through the evolution of asylums to latter-day psychiatric facilities and services. Addressing themes of evolving interfaces between the practices of law and mental health care reveals that the balance, as enacted in law and interpreted by the courts, has generally favoured legal interpretations of mental illness, despite psychiatry’s steadily increasing claim to superior insights and evidence on what constitutes mental illness in juridical contexts. The experience of forensic psychiatry over this 200-year period points to relevant implications for continued refinement of legal, court and clinical provisions for this service, and directions for future research