When to Welcome Greeks Bearing Gifts - Aristotle and the Rules of Evidence

Simpson and Selden's article explores the intersection of classical philosophy and modern evidentiary rules under Texas law. The authors analyze how Aristotle's principles of logic and rhetoric can inform the application and interpretation of evidence in legal proceedings. They discuss the importance of balancing fairness and reliability in evidentiary decisions while addressing the challenges posed by subjective interpretations. The article emphasizes the need for courts to adopt a reasoned approach that aligns with both legal precedent and philosophical underpinnings. Ultimately, it provides a thoughtful perspective on how ancient wisdom can enhance the administration of justice in contemporary legal systems