Weighted universal image compression

We describe a general coding strategy leading to a family of universal image compression systems designed to give good performance in applications where the statistics of the source to be compressed are not available at design time or vary over time or space. The basic approach considered uses a two-stage structure in which the single source code of traditional image compression systems is replaced with a family of codes designed to cover a large class of possible sources. To illustrate this approach, we consider the optimal design and use of two-stage codes containing collections of vector quantizers (weighted universal vector quantization), bit allocations for JPEG-style coding (weighted universal bit allocation), and transform codes (weighted universal transform coding). Further, we demonstrate the benefits to be gained from the inclusion of perceptual distortion measures and optimal parsing. The strategy yields two-stage codes that significantly outperform their single-stage predecessors. On a sequence of medical images, weighted universal vector quantization outperforms entropy coded vector quantization by over 9 dB. On the same data sequence, weighted universal bit allocation outperforms a JPEG-style code by over 2.5 dB. On a collection of mixed test and image data, weighted universal transform coding outperforms a single, data-optimized transform code (which gives performance almost identical to that of JPEG) by over 6 dB

Zerotree design for image compression: toward weighted universal zerotree coding

We consider the problem of optimal, data-dependent zerotree design for use in weighted universal zerotree codes for image compression. A weighted universal zerotree code (WUZC) is a data compression system that replaces the single, data-independent zerotree of Said and Pearlman (see IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology, vol.6, no.3, p.243-50, 1996) with an optimal collection of zerotrees for good image coding performance across a wide variety of possible sources. We describe the weighted universal zerotree encoding and design algorithms but focus primarily on the problem of optimal, data-dependent zerotree design. We demonstrate the performance of the proposed algorithm by comparing, at a variety of target rates, the performance of a Said-Pearlman style code using the standard zerotree to the performance of the same code using a zerotree designed with our algorithm. The comparison is made without entropy coding. The proposed zerotree design algorithm achieves, on a collection of combined text and gray-scale images, up to 4 dB performance improvement over a Said-Pearlman zerotree

Weighted universal transform coding: universal image compression with the Karhunen-Loève transform

We introduce a two-stage universal transform code for image compression. The code combines Karhunen-Loève transform coding with weighted universal bit allocation (WUBA) in a two-stage algorithm analogous to the algorithm for weighted universal vector quantization (WUVQ). The encoder uses a collection of transform/bit allocation pairs rather than a single transform/bit allocation pair (as in JPEG) or a single transform with a variety of bit allocations (as in WUBA). We describe both an encoding algorithm for achieving optimal compression using a collection of transform/bit allocation pairs and a technique for designing locally optimal collections of transform/bit allocation pairs. We demonstrate the performance using the mean squared error distortion measure. On a sequence of combined text and gray scale images, the algorithm achieves up to a 2 dB improvement over a JPEG style coder using the discrete cosine transform (DCT) and an optimal collection of bit allocations, up to a 3 dB improvement over a JPEG style coder using the DCT and a single (optimal) bit allocation, up to 6 dB over an entropy constrained WUVQ with first- and second-stage vector dimensions equal to 16 and 4 respectively, and up to a 10 dB improvement over an entropy constrained vector quantizer (ECVQ) with a vector dimension of 4

A vector quantization approach to universal noiseless coding and quantization

A two-stage code is a block code in which each block of data is coded in two stages: the first stage codes the identity of a block code among a collection of codes, and the second stage codes the data using the identified code. The collection of codes may be noiseless codes, fixed-rate quantizers, or variable-rate quantizers. We take a vector quantization approach to two-stage coding, in which the first stage code can be regarded as a vector quantizer that “quantizes” the input data of length n to one of a fixed collection of block codes. We apply the generalized Lloyd algorithm to the first-stage quantizer, using induced measures of rate and distortion, to design locally optimal two-stage codes. On a source of medical images, two-stage variable-rate vector quantizers designed in this way outperform standard (one-stage) fixed-rate vector quantizers by over 9 dB. The tail of the operational distortion-rate function of the first-stage quantizer determines the optimal rate of convergence of the redundancy of a universal sequence of two-stage codes. We show that there exist two-stage universal noiseless codes, fixed-rate quantizers, and variable-rate quantizers whose per-letter rate and distortion redundancies converge to zero as (k/2)n -1 log n, when the universe of sources has finite dimension k. This extends the achievability part of Rissanen's theorem from universal noiseless codes to universal quantizers. Further, we show that the redundancies converge as O(n-1) when the universe of sources is countable, and as O(n-1+ϵ) when the universe of sources is infinite-dimensional, under appropriate conditions

Optimal modeling for complex system design

The article begins with a brief introduction to the theory describing optimal data compression systems and their performance. A brief outline is then given of a representative algorithm that employs these lessons for optimal data compression system design. The implications of rate-distortion theory for practical data compression system design is then described, followed by a description of the tensions between theoretical optimality and system practicality and a discussion of common tools used in current algorithms to resolve these tensions. Next, the generalization of rate-distortion principles to the design of optimal collections of models is presented. The discussion focuses initially on data compression systems, but later widens to describe how rate-distortion theory principles generalize to model design for a wide variety of modeling applications. The article ends with a discussion of the performance benefits to be achieved using the multiple-model design algorithms

Conditional weighted universal source codes: second order statistics in universal coding

We consider the use of second order statistics in two-stage universal source coding. Examples of two-stage universal codes include the weighted universal vector quantization (WUVQ), weighted universal bit allocation (WUBA), and weighted universal transform coding (WUTC) algorithms. The second order statistics are incorporated in two-stage universal source codes in a manner analogous to the method by which second order statistics are incorporated in entropy constrained vector quantization (ECVQ) to yield conditional ECVQ (CECVQ). In this paper, we describe an optimal two-stage conditional entropy constrained universal source code along with its associated optimal design algorithm and a fast (but nonoptimal) variation of the original code. The design technique and coding algorithm here presented result in a new family of conditional entropy constrained universal codes including but not limited to the conditional entropy constrained WUVQ (CWUVQ), the conditional entropy constrained WUBA (CWUBA), and the conditional entropy constrained WUTC (CWUTC). The fast variation of the conditional entropy constrained universal codes allows the designer to trade off performance gains against storage and delay costs. We demonstrate the performance of the proposed codes on a collection of medical brain scans. On the given data set, the CWUVQ achieves up to 7.5 dB performance improvement over variable-rate WUVQ and up to 12 dB performance improvement over ECVQ. On the same data set, the fast variation of the CWUVQ achieves identical performance to that achieved by the original code at all but the lowest rates (less than 0.125 bits per pixel)

On the rate-distortion performance and computational efficiency of the Karhunen-Loeve transform for lossy data compression

We examine the rate-distortion performance and computational complexity of linear transforms for lossy data compression. The goal is to better understand the performance/complexity tradeoffs associated with using the Karhunen-Loeve transform (KLT) and its fast approximations. Since the optimal transform for transform coding is unknown in general, we investigate the performance penalties associated with using the KLT by examining cases where the KLT fails, developing a new transform that corrects the KLT's failures in those examples, and then empirically testing the performance difference between this new transform and the KLT. Experiments demonstrate that while the worst KLT can yield transform coding performance at least 3 dB worse than that of alternative block transforms, the performance penalty associated with using the KLT on real data sets seems to be significantly smaller, giving at most 0.5 dB difference in our experiments. The KLT and its fast variations studied here range in complexity requirements from O(n^2) to O(n log n) in coding vectors of dimension n. We empirically investigate the rate-distortion performance tradeoffs associated with traversing this range of options. For example, an algorithm with complexity O(n^3/2) and memory O(n) gives 0.4 dB performance loss relative to the full KLT in our image compression experiment

MDL Denoising Revisited

We refine and extend an earlier MDL denoising criterion for wavelet-based denoising. We start by showing that the denoising problem can be reformulated as a clustering problem, where the goal is to obtain separate clusters for informative and non-informative wavelet coefficients, respectively. This suggests two refinements, adding a code-length for the model index, and extending the model in order to account for subband-dependent coefficient distributions. A third refinement is derivation of soft thresholding inspired by predictive universal coding with weighted mixtures. We propose a practical method incorporating all three refinements, which is shown to achieve good performance and robustness in denoising both artificial and natural signals.Comment: Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, June 200