Action Recognition in Videos: from Motion Capture Labs to the Web

This paper presents a survey of human action recognition approaches based on visual data recorded from a single video camera. We propose an organizing framework which puts in evidence the evolution of the area, with techniques moving from heavily constrained motion capture scenarios towards more challenging, realistic, "in the wild" videos. The proposed organization is based on the representation used as input for the recognition task, emphasizing the hypothesis assumed and thus, the constraints imposed on the type of video that each technique is able to address. Expliciting the hypothesis and constraints makes the framework particularly useful to select a method, given an application. Another advantage of the proposed organization is that it allows categorizing newest approaches seamlessly with traditional ones, while providing an insightful perspective of the evolution of the action recognition task up to now. That perspective is the basis for the discussion in the end of the paper, where we also present the main open issues in the area.Comment: Preprint submitted to CVIU, survey paper, 46 pages, 2 figures, 4 table

Action Recognition Using Particle Flow Fields

In recent years, research in human action recognition has advanced on multiple fronts to address various types of actions including simple, isolated actions in staged data (e.g., KTH dataset), complex actions (e.g., Hollywood dataset), and naturally occurring actions in surveillance videos (e.g, VIRAT dataset). Several techniques including those based on gradient, flow, and interest-points, have been developed for their recognition. Most perform very well in standard action recognition datasets, but fail to produce similar results in more complex, large-scale datasets. Action recognition on large categories of unconstrained videos taken from the web is a very challenging problem compared to datasets like KTH (six actions), IXMAS (thirteen actions), and Weizmann (ten actions). Challenges such as camera motion, different viewpoints, huge interclass variations, cluttered background, occlusions, bad illumination conditions, and poor quality of web videos cause the majority of the state-of-the-art action recognition approaches to fail. An increasing number of categories and the inclusion of actions with high confusion also increase the difficulty of the problem. The approach taken to solve this action recognition problem depends primarily on the dataset and the possibility of detecting and tracking the object of interest. In this dissertation, a new method for video representation is proposed and three new approaches to perform action recognition in different scenarios using varying prerequisites are presented. The prerequisites have decreasing levels of difficulty to obtain: 1) Scenario requires human detection and trackiii ing to perform action recognition; 2) Scenario requires background and foreground separation to perform action recognition; and 3) No pre-processing is required for action recognition. First, we propose a new video representation using optical flow and particle advection. The proposed “Particle Flow Field” (PFF) representation has been used to generate motion descriptors and tested in a Bag of Video Words (BoVW) framework on the KTH dataset. We show that particle flow fields has better performance than other low-level video representations, such as 2D-Gradients, 3D-Gradients and optical flow. Second, we analyze the performance of the state-of-the-art technique based on the histogram of oriented 3D-Gradients in spatio temporal volumes, where human detection and tracking are required. We use the proposed particle flow field and show superior results compared to the histogram of oriented 3D-Gradients in spatio temporal volumes. The proposed method, when used for human action recognition, just needs human detection and does not necessarily require human tracking and figure centric bounding boxes. It has been tested on KTH (six actions), Weizmann (ten actions), and IXMAS (thirteen actions, 4 different views) action recognition datasets. Third, we propose using the scene context information obtained from moving and stationary pixels in the key frames, in conjunction with motion descriptors obtained using Bag of Words framework, to solve the action recognition problem on a large (50 actions) dataset with videos from the web. We perform a combination of early and late fusion on multiple features to handle the huge number of categories. We demonstrate that scene context is a very important feature for performing action recognition on huge datasets. iv The proposed method needs separation of moving and stationary pixels, and does not require any kind of video stabilization, person detection, or tracking and pruning of features. Our approach obtains good performance on a huge number of action categories. It has been tested on the UCF50 dataset with 50 action categories, which is an extension of the UCF YouTube Action (UCF11) Dataset containing 11 action categories. We also tested our approach on the KTH and HMDB51 datasets for comparison. Finally, we focus on solving practice problems in representing actions by bag of spatio temporal features (i.e. cuboids), which has proven valuable for action recognition in recent literature. We observed that the visual vocabulary based (bag of video words) method suffers from many drawbacks in practice, such as: (i) It requires an intensive training stage to obtain good performance; (ii) it is sensitive to the vocabulary size; (iii) it is unable to cope with incremental recognition problems; (iv) it is unable to recognize simultaneous multiple actions; (v) it is unable to perform recognition frame by frame. In order to overcome these drawbacks, we propose a framework to index large scale motion features using Sphere/Rectangle-tree (SR-tree) for incremental action detection and recognition. The recognition comprises of the following two steps: 1) recognizing the local features by non-parametric nearest neighbor (NN), and 2) using a simple voting strategy to label the action. It can also provide localization of the action. Since it does not require feature quantization it can efficiently grow the feature-tree by adding features from new training actions or categories. Our method provides an effective way for practical incremental action recognition. Furthermore, it can handle large scale datasets because the SR-tree is a disk-based v data structure. We tested our approach on two publicly available datasets, the KTH dataset and the IXMAS multi-view dataset, and achieved promising results

A robust and efficient video representation for action recognition

This paper introduces a state-of-the-art video representation and applies it to efficient action recognition and detection. We first propose to improve the popular dense trajectory features by explicit camera motion estimation. More specifically, we extract feature point matches between frames using SURF descriptors and dense optical flow. The matches are used to estimate a homography with RANSAC. To improve the robustness of homography estimation, a human detector is employed to remove outlier matches from the human body as human motion is not constrained by the camera. Trajectories consistent with the homography are considered as due to camera motion, and thus removed. We also use the homography to cancel out camera motion from the optical flow. This results in significant improvement on motion-based HOF and MBH descriptors. We further explore the recent Fisher vector as an alternative feature encoding approach to the standard bag-of-words histogram, and consider different ways to include spatial layout information in these encodings. We present a large and varied set of evaluations, considering (i) classification of short basic actions on six datasets, (ii) localization of such actions in feature-length movies, and (iii) large-scale recognition of complex events. We find that our improved trajectory features significantly outperform previous dense trajectories, and that Fisher vectors are superior to bag-of-words encodings for video recognition tasks. In all three tasks, we show substantial improvements over the state-of-the-art results

Log-Euclidean Bag of Words for Human Action Recognition

Representing videos by densely extracted local space-time features has recently become a popular approach for analysing actions. In this paper, we tackle the problem of categorising human actions by devising Bag of Words (BoW) models based on covariance matrices of spatio-temporal features, with the features formed from histograms of optical flow. Since covariance matrices form a special type of Riemannian manifold, the space of Symmetric Positive Definite (SPD) matrices, non-Euclidean geometry should be taken into account while discriminating between covariance matrices. To this end, we propose to embed SPD manifolds to Euclidean spaces via a diffeomorphism and extend the BoW approach to its Riemannian version. The proposed BoW approach takes into account the manifold geometry of SPD matrices during the generation of the codebook and histograms. Experiments on challenging human action datasets show that the proposed method obtains notable improvements in discrimination accuracy, in comparison to several state-of-the-art methods