Stereoscopic Omnidirectional Image Quality Assessment Based on Predictive Coding Theory

Objective quality assessment of stereoscopic omnidirectional images is a challenging problem since it is influenced by multiple aspects such as projection deformation, field of view (FoV) range, binocular vision, visual comfort, etc. Existing studies show that classic 2D or 3D image quality assessment (IQA) metrics are not able to perform well for stereoscopic omnidirectional images. However, very few research works have focused on evaluating the perceptual visual quality of omnidirectional images, especially for stereoscopic omnidirectional images. In this paper, based on the predictive coding theory of the human vision system (HVS), we propose a stereoscopic omnidirectional image quality evaluator (SOIQE) to cope with the characteristics of 3D 360-degree images. Two modules are involved in SOIQE: predictive coding theory based binocular rivalry module and multi-view fusion module. In the binocular rivalry module, we introduce predictive coding theory to simulate the competition between high-level patterns and calculate the similarity and rivalry dominance to obtain the quality scores of viewport images. Moreover, we develop the multi-view fusion module to aggregate the quality scores of viewport images with the help of both content weight and location weight. The proposed SOIQE is a parametric model without necessary of regression learning, which ensures its interpretability and generalization performance. Experimental results on our published stereoscopic omnidirectional image quality assessment database (SOLID) demonstrate that our proposed SOIQE method outperforms state-of-the-art metrics. Furthermore, we also verify the effectiveness of each proposed module on both public stereoscopic image datasets and panoramic image datasets

A blind stereoscopic image quality evaluator with segmented stacked autoencoders considering the whole visual perception route

Most of the current blind stereoscopic image quality assessment (SIQA) algorithms cannot show reliable accuracy. One reason is that they do not have the deep architectures and the other reason is that they are designed on the relatively weak biological basis, compared with findings on human visual system (HVS). In this paper, we propose a Deep Edge and COlor Signal INtegrity Evaluator (DECOSINE) based on the whole visual perception route from eyes to the frontal lobe, and especially focus on edge and color signal processing in retinal ganglion cells (RGC) and lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN). Furthermore, to model the complex and deep structure of the visual cortex, Segmented Stacked Auto-encoder (S-SAE) is used, which has not utilized for SIQA before. The utilization of the S-SAE complements weakness of deep learning-based SIQA metrics that require a very long training time. Experiments are conducted on popular SIQA databases, and the superiority of DECOSINE in terms of prediction accuracy and monotonicity is proved. The experimental results show that our model about the whole visual perception route and utilization of S-SAE are effective for SIQA

A no-reference optical flow-based quality evaluator for stereoscopic videos in curvelet domain

Most of the existing 3D video quality assessment (3D-VQA/SVQA) methods only consider spatial information by directly using an image quality evaluation method. In addition, a few take the motion information of adjacent frames into consideration. In practice, one may assume that a single data-view is unlikely to be sufficient for effectively learning the video quality. Therefore, integration of multi-view information is both valuable and necessary. In this paper, we propose an effective multi-view feature learning metric for blind stereoscopic video quality assessment (BSVQA), which jointly focuses on spatial information, temporal information and inter-frame spatio-temporal information. In our study, a set of local binary patterns (LBP) statistical features extracted from a computed frame curvelet representation are used as spatial and spatio-temporal description, and the local flow statistical features based on the estimation of optical flow are used to describe the temporal distortion. Subsequently, a support vector regression (SVR) is utilized to map the feature vectors of each single view to subjective quality scores. Finally, the scores of multiple views are pooled into the final score according to their contribution rate. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed metric significantly outperforms the existing metrics and can achieve higher consistency with subjective quality assessment

Sparse representation based stereoscopic image quality assessment accounting for perceptual cognitive process

In this paper, we propose a sparse representation based Reduced-Reference Image Quality Assessment (RR-IQA) index for stereoscopic images from the following two perspectives: 1) Human visual system (HVS) always tries to infer the meaningful information and reduces uncertainty from the visual stimuli, and the entropy of primitive (EoP) can well describe this visual cognitive progress when perceiving natural images. 2) Ocular dominance (also known as binocularity) which represents the interaction between two eyes is quantified by the sparse representation coefficients. Inspired by previous research, the perception and understanding of an image is considered as an active inference process determined by the level of “surprise”, which can be described by EoP. Therefore, the primitives learnt from natural images can be utilized to evaluate the visual information by computing entropy. Meanwhile, considering the binocularity in stereo image quality assessment, a feasible way is proposed to characterize this binocular process according to the sparse representation coefficients of each view. Experimental results on LIVE 3D image databases and MCL database further demonstrate that the proposed algorithm achieves high consistency with subjective evaluation

Perceptual Quality-of-Experience of Stereoscopic 3D Images and Videos

With the fast development of 3D acquisition, communication, processing and display technologies, automatic quality assessment of 3D images and videos has become ever important. Nevertheless, recent progress on 3D image quality assessment (IQA) and video quality assessment (VQA) remains limited. The purpose of this research is to investigate various aspects of human visual quality-of-experience (QoE) when viewing stereoscopic 3D images/videos and to develop objective quality assessment models that automatically predict visual QoE of 3D images/videos. Firstly, we create a new subjective 3D-IQA database that has two features that are lacking in the literature, i.e., the inclusion of both 2D and 3D images, and the inclusion of mixed distortion types. We observe strong distortion type dependent bias when using the direct average of 2D image quality to predict 3D image quality. We propose a binocular rivalry inspired multi-scale model to predict the quality of stereoscopic images and the results show that the proposed model eliminates the prediction bias, leading to significantly improved quality predictions. Second, we carry out two subjective studies on depth perception of stereoscopic 3D images. The first one follows a traditional framework where subjects are asked to rate depth quality directly on distorted stereopairs. The second one uses a novel approach, where the stimuli are synthesized independent of the background image content and the subjects are asked to identify depth changes and label the polarities of depth. Our analysis shows that the second approach is much more effective at singling out the contributions of stereo cues in depth perception. We initialize the notion of depth perception difficulty index (DPDI) and propose a novel computational model for DPDI prediction. The results show that the proposed model leads to highly promising DPDI prediction performance. Thirdly, we carry out subjective 3D-VQA experiments on two databases that contain various asymmetrically compressed stereoscopic 3D videos. We then compare different mixed-distortions asymmetric stereoscopic video coding schemes with symmetric coding methods and verify their potential coding gains. We propose a model to account for the prediction bias from using direct averaging of 2D video quality to predict 3D video quality. The results show that the proposed model leads to significantly improved quality predictions and can help us predict the coding gain of mixed-distortions asymmetric video compression. Fourthly, we investigate the problem of objective quality assessment of Multi-view-plus-depth (MVD) images, with a main focus on the pre- depth-image-based-rendering (pre-DIBR) case. We find that existing IQA methods are difficult to be employed as a guiding criterion in the optimization of MVD video coding and transmission systems when applied post-DIBR. We propose a novel pre-DIBR method based on information content weighting of both texture and depth images, which demonstrates competitive performance against state-of-the-art IQA models applied post-DIBR

Towards Top-Down Stereoscopic Image Quality Assessment via Stereo Attention

Stereoscopic image quality assessment (SIQA) plays a crucial role in evaluating and improving the visual experience of 3D content. Existing binocular properties and attention-based methods for SIQA have achieved promising performance. However, these bottom-up approaches are inadequate in exploiting the inherent characteristics of the human visual system (HVS). This paper presents a novel network for SIQA via stereo attention, employing a top-down perspective to guide the quality assessment process. Our proposed method realizes the guidance from high-level binocular signals down to low-level monocular signals, while the binocular and monocular information can be calibrated progressively throughout the processing pipeline. We design a generalized Stereo AttenTion (SAT) block to implement the top-down philosophy in stereo perception. This block utilizes the fusion-generated attention map as a high-level binocular modulator, influencing the representation of two low-level monocular features. Additionally, we introduce an Energy Coefficient (EC) to account for recent findings indicating that binocular responses in the primate primary visual cortex are less than the sum of monocular responses. The adaptive EC can tune the magnitude of binocular response flexibly, thus enhancing the formation of robust binocular features within our framework. To extract the most discriminative quality information from the summation and subtraction of the two branches of monocular features, we utilize a dual-pooling strategy that applies min-pooling and max-pooling operations to the respective branches. Experimental results highlight the superiority of our top-down method in simulating the property of visual perception and advancing the state-of-the-art in the SIQA field. The code of this work is available at https://github.com/Fanning-Zhang/SATNet.Comment: 13 pages, 4 figure

Quality index for stereoscopic images by jointly evaluating cyclopean amplitude and cyclopean phase

With widespread applications of three-dimensional (3-D) technology, measuring quality of experience for 3-D multimedia content plays an increasingly important role. In this paper, we propose a full reference stereo image quality assessment (SIQA) framework which focuses on the innovation of binocular visual properties and applications of low-level features. On one hand, based on the fact that human visual system understands an image mainly according to its low-level features, local phase and local amplitude extracted from phase congruency measurement are employed as primary features. Considering the less prominent performance of amplitude in IQA, visual saliency is applied into the modification on amplitude. On the other hand, by fully considering binocular rivalry phenomena, we create the cyclopean amplitude map and cyclopean phase map. With this method, both image features and binocular visual properties are mutually combined with each other. Meanwhile, a novel binocular modulation function in spatial domain is also adopted into the overall quality prediction of amplitude and phase. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the proposed framework achieves higher consistency with subjective tests than relevant SIQA metrics

Visual Comfort Assessment for Stereoscopic Image Retargeting

In recent years, visual comfort assessment (VCA) for 3D/stereoscopic content has aroused extensive attention. However, much less work has been done on the perceptual evaluation of stereoscopic image retargeting. In this paper, we first build a Stereoscopic Image Retargeting Database (SIRD), which contains source images and retargeted images produced by four typical stereoscopic retargeting methods. Then, the subjective experiment is conducted to assess four aspects of visual distortion, i.e. visual comfort, image quality, depth quality and the overall quality. Furthermore, we propose a Visual Comfort Assessment metric for Stereoscopic Image Retargeting (VCA-SIR). Based on the characteristics of stereoscopic retargeted images, the proposed model introduces novel features like disparity range, boundary disparity as well as disparity intensity distribution into the assessment model. Experimental results demonstrate that VCA-SIR can achieve high consistency with subjective perception

No-reference Stereoscopic Image Quality Assessment Using Natural Scene Statistics

We present two contributions in this work: (i) a bivariate generalized Gaussian distribution (BGGD) model for the joint distribution of luminance and disparity subband coefficients of natural stereoscopic scenes and (ii) a no-reference (NR) stereo image quality assessment algorithm based on the BGGD model. We first empirically show that a BGGD accurately models the joint distribution of luminance and disparity subband coefficients. We then show that the model parameters form good discriminatory features for NR quality assessment. Additionally, we rely on the previously established result that luminance and disparity subband coefficients of natural stereo scenes are correlated, and show that correlation also forms a good feature for NR quality assessment. These features are computed for both the left and right luminance-disparity pairs in the stereo image and consolidated into one feature vector per stereo pair. This feature set and the stereo pair׳s difference mean opinion score (DMOS) (labels) are used for supervised learning with a support vector machine (SVM). Support vector regression is used to estimate the perceptual quality of a test stereo image pair. The performance of the algorithm is evaluated over popular databases and shown to be competitive with the state-of-the-art no-reference quality assessment algorithms. Further, the strength of the proposed algorithm is demonstrated by its consistently good performance over both symmetric and asymmetric distortion types. Our algorithm is called Stereo QUality Evaluator (StereoQUE)