Mixed Criticality Systems - A Review : (13th Edition, February 2022)

This review covers research on the topic of mixed criticality systems that has been published since Vestal’s 2007 paper. It covers the period up to end of 2021. The review is organised into the following topics: introduction and motivation, models, single processor analysis (including job-based, hard and soft tasks, fixed priority and EDF scheduling, shared resources and static and synchronous scheduling), multiprocessor analysis, related topics, realistic models, formal treatments, systems issues, industrial practice and research beyond mixed-criticality. A list of PhDs awarded for research relating to mixed-criticality systems is also included

Qualität und Nutzen - Über den Gebrauch von Zeit-Wert-Funktionen zur Integration qualitäts- und zeit-flexibler Aspekte in einer dynamischen Echtzeit-Einplanungsumgebung

Scheduling methodologies for real-time applications have been of keen interest to diverse research communities for several decades. Depending on the application area, algorithms have been developed that are tailored to specific requirements with respect to both the individual components of which an application is made up and the computational platform on which it is to be executed. Many real-time scheduling algorithms base their decisions solely or partly on timing constraints expressed by deadlines which must be met even under worst-case conditions. The increasing complexity of computing hardware means that worst-case execution time analysis becomes increasingly pessimistic. Scheduling hard real-time computations according to their worst-case execution times (which is common practice) will thus result, on average, in an increasing amount of spare capacity. The main goal of flexible real-time scheduling is to exploit this otherwise wasted capacity. Flexible scheduling schemes have been proposed to increase the ability of a real-time system to adapt to changing requirements and nondeterminism in the application behaviour. These models can be categorised as those whose source of flexibility is the quality of computations and those which are flexible regarding their timing constraints. This work describes a novel model which allows to specify both flexible timing constraints and quality profiles for an application. Furthermore, it demonstrates the applicability of this specification method to real-world examples and suggests a set of feasible scheduling algorithms for the proposed problem class.Einplanungsverfahren für Echtzeitanwendungen stehen seit Jahrzehnten im Interesse verschiedener Forschungsgruppen. Abhängig vom Anwendungsgebiet wurden Algorithmen entwickelt, welche an die spezifischen Anforderungen sowohl hinsichtlich der einzelnen Komponenten, aus welchen eine Anwendung besteht, als auch an die Rechnerplattform, auf der diese ausgeführt werden sollen, angepasst sind. Viele Echtzeit-Einplanungsverfahren gründen ihre Entscheidungen ausschließlich oder teilweise auf Zeitbedingungen, welche auch bei Auftreten maximaler Ausführungszeiten eingehalten werden müssen. Die zunehmende Komplexität von Rechner-Hardware bedeutet, dass die Worst-Case-Analyse in steigendem Maße pessimistisch wird. Die Einplanung harter Echtzeit-Berechnungen anhand ihrer maximalen Ausführungszeiten (was die gängige Praxis darstellt) resultiert daher im Regelfall in einer frei verfügbaren Rechenkapazität in steigender Höhe. Das Hauptziel flexibler Echtzeit-Einplanungsverfahren ist es, diese ansonsten verschwendete Kapazität auszunutzen. Flexible Einplanungsverfahren wurden vorgeschlagen, welche die Fähigkeit eines Echtzeitsystems erhöhen, sich an veränderte Anforderungen und Nichtdeterminismus im Verhalten der Anwendung anzupassen. Diese Modelle können unterteilt werden in solche, deren Quelle der Flexibilität die Qualität der Berechnungen ist, und jene, welche flexibel hinsichtlich ihrer Zeitbedingungen sind. Diese Arbeit beschreibt ein neuartiges Modell, welches es erlaubt, sowohl flexible Zeitbedingungen als auch Qualitätsprofile für eine Anwendung anzugeben. Außerdem demonstriert sie die Anwendbarkeit dieser Spezifikationsmethode auf reale Beispiele und schlägt eine Reihe von Einplanungsalgorithmen für die vorgestellte Problemklasse vor

Energy-Aware Real-Time Scheduling on Heterogeneous and Homogeneous Platforms in the Era of Parallel Computing

Multi-core processors increasingly appear as an enabling platform for embedded systems, e.g., mobile phones, tablets, computerized numerical controls, etc. The parallel task model, where a task can execute on multiple cores simultaneously, can efficiently exploit the multi-core platform\u27s computational ability. Many computation-intensive systems (e.g., self-driving cars) that demand stringent timing requirements often evolve in the form of parallel tasks. Several real-time embedded system applications demand predictable timing behavior and satisfy other system constraints, such as energy consumption. Motivated by the facts mentioned above, this thesis studies the approach to integrating the dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS) policy with real-time embedded system application\u27s internal parallelism to reduce the worst-case energy consumption (WCEC), an essential requirement for energy-constrained systems. First, we propose an energy-sub-optimal scheduler, assuming the per-core speed tuning feature for each processor. Then we extend our solution to adapt the clustered multi-core platform, where at any given time, all the processors in the same cluster run at the same speed. We also present an analysis to exploit a task\u27s probabilistic information to improve the average-case energy consumption (ACEC), a common non-functional requirement of embedded systems. Due to the strict requirement of temporal correctness, the majority of the real-time system analysis considered the worst-case scenario, leading to resource over-provisioning and cost. The mixed-criticality (MC) framework was proposed to minimize energy consumption and resource over-provisioning. MC scheduling has received considerable attention from the real-time system research community, as it is crucial to designing safety-critical real-time systems. This thesis further addresses energy-aware scheduling of real-time tasks in an MC platform, where tasks with varying criticality levels (i.e., importance) are integrated into a common platform. We propose an algorithm GEDF-VD for scheduling MC tasks with internal parallelism in a multiprocessor platform. We also prove the correctness of GEDF-VD, provide a detailed quantitative evaluation, and reported extensive experimental results. Finally, we present an analysis to exploit a task\u27s probabilistic information at their respective criticality levels. Our proposed approach reduces the average-case energy consumption while satisfying the worst-case timing requirement

Generalizing List Scheduling for Stochastic Soft Real-time Parallel Applications

Advanced architecture processors provide features such as caches and branch prediction that result in improved, but variable, execution time of software. Hard real-time systems require tasks to complete within timing constraints. Consequently, hard real-time systems are typically designed conservatively through the use of tasks? worst-case execution times (WCET) in order to compute deterministic schedules that guarantee task?s execution within giving time constraints. This use of pessimistic execution time assumptions provides real-time guarantees at the cost of decreased performance and resource utilization. In soft real-time systems, however, meeting deadlines is not an absolute requirement (i.e., missing a few deadlines does not severely degrade system performance or cause catastrophic failure). In such systems, a guaranteed minimum probability of completing by the deadline is sufficient. Therefore, there is considerable latitude in such systems for improving resource utilization and performance as compared with hard real-time systems, through the use of more realistic execution time assumptions. Given probability distribution functions (PDFs) representing tasks? execution time requirements, and tasks? communication and precedence requirements, represented as a directed acyclic graph (DAG), this dissertation proposes and investigates algorithms for constructing non-preemptive stochastic schedules. New PDF manipulation operators developed in this dissertation are used to compute tasks? start and completion time PDFs during schedule construction. PDFs of the schedules? completion times are also computed and used to systematically trade the probability of meeting end-to-end deadlines for schedule length and jitter in task completion times. Because of the NP-hard nature of the non-preemptive DAG scheduling problem, the new stochastic scheduling algorithms extend traditional heuristic list scheduling and genetic list scheduling algorithms for DAGs by using PDFs instead of fixed time values for task execution requirements. The stochastic scheduling algorithms also account for delays caused by communication contention, typically ignored in prior DAG scheduling research. Extensive experimental results are used to demonstrate the efficacy of the new algorithms in constructing stochastic schedules. Results also show that through the use of the techniques developed in this dissertation, the probability of meeting deadlines can be usefully traded for performance and jitter in soft real-time systems

Parallel Real-Time Scheduling for Latency-Critical Applications

In order to provide safety guarantees or quality of service guarantees, many of today\u27s systems consist of latency-critical applications, e.g. applications with timing constraints. The problem of scheduling multiple latency-critical jobs on a multiprocessor or multicore machine has been extensively studied for sequential (non-parallizable) jobs and different system models and different objectives have been considered. However, the computational requirement of a single job is still limited by the capacity of a single core. To provide increasingly complex functionalities of applications and to complete their higher computational demands within the same or even more stringent timing constraints, we must exploit the internal parallelism of jobs, where individual jobs are parallel programs and can potentially utilize more than one core in parallel. However, there is little work considering scheduling multiple parallel jobs that are latency-critical. This dissertation focuses on developing new scheduling strategies, analysis tools, and practical platform design techniques to enable efficient and scalable parallel real-time scheduling for latency-critical applications on multicore systems. In particular, the research is focused on two types of systems: (1) static real-time systems for tasks with deadlines where the temporal properties of the tasks that need to execute is known a priori and the goal is to guarantee the temporal correctness of the tasks prior to their executions; and (2) online systems for latency-critical jobs where multiple jobs arrive over time and the goal to optimize for a performance objective of jobs during the execution. For static real-time systems for parallel tasks, several scheduling strategies, including global earliest deadline first, global rate monotonic and a novel federated scheduling, are proposed, analyzed and implemented. These scheduling strategies have the best known theoretical performance for parallel real-time tasks under any global strategy, any fixed priority scheduling and any scheduling strategy, respectively. In addition, federated scheduling is generalized to systems with multiple criticality levels and systems with stochastic tasks. Both numerical and empirical experiments show that federated scheduling and its variations have good schedulability performance and are efficient in practice. For online systems with multiple latency-critical jobs, different online scheduling strategies are proposed and analyzed for different objectives, including maximizing the number of jobs meeting a target latency, maximizing the profit of jobs, minimizing the maximum latency and minimizing the average latency. For example, a simple First-In-First-Out scheduler is proven to be scalable for minimizing the maximum latency. Based on this theoretical intuition, a more practical work-stealing scheduler is developed, analyzed and implemented. Empirical evaluations indicate that, on both real world and synthetic workloads, this work-stealing implementation performs almost as well as an optimal scheduler

Algorithms and architectures for the multirate additive synthesis of musical tones

In classical Additive Synthesis (AS), the output signal is the sum of a large number of independently controllable sinusoidal partials. The advantages of AS for music synthesis are well known as is the high computational cost. This thesis is concerned with the computational optimisation of AS by multirate DSP techniques. In note-based music synthesis, the expected bounds of the frequency trajectory of each partial in a finite lifecycle tone determine critical time-invariant partial-specific sample rates which are lower than the conventional rate (in excess of 40kHz) resulting in computational savings. Scheduling and interpolation (to suppress quantisation noise) for many sample rates is required, leading to the concept of Multirate Additive Synthesis (MAS) where these overheads are minimised by synthesis filterbanks which quantise the set of available sample rates. Alternative AS optimisations are also appraised. It is shown that a hierarchical interpretation of the QMF filterbank preserves AS generality and permits efficient context-specific adaptation of computation to required note dynamics. Practical QMF implementation and the modifications necessary for MAS are discussed. QMF transition widths can be logically excluded from the MAS paradigm, at a cost. Therefore a novel filterbank is evaluated where transition widths are physically excluded. Benchmarking of a hypothetical orchestral synthesis application provides a tentative quantitative analysis of the performance improvement of MAS over AS. The mapping of MAS into VLSI is opened by a review of sine computation techniques. Then the functional specification and high-level design of a conceptual MAS Coprocessor (MASC) is developed which functions with high autonomy in a loosely-coupled master- slave configuration with a Host CPU which executes filterbanks in software. Standard hardware optimisation techniques are used, such as pipelining, based upon the principle of an application-specific memory hierarchy which maximises MASC throughput

Embedded System Design

A unique feature of this open access textbook is to provide a comprehensive introduction to the fundamental knowledge in embedded systems, with applications in cyber-physical systems and the Internet of things. It starts with an introduction to the field and a survey of specification models and languages for embedded and cyber-physical systems. It provides a brief overview of hardware devices used for such systems and presents the essentials of system software for embedded systems, including real-time operating systems. The author also discusses evaluation and validation techniques for embedded systems and provides an overview of techniques for mapping applications to execution platforms, including multi-core platforms. Embedded systems have to operate under tight constraints and, hence, the book also contains a selected set of optimization techniques, including software optimization techniques. The book closes with a brief survey on testing. This fourth edition has been updated and revised to reflect new trends and technologies, such as the importance of cyber-physical systems (CPS) and the Internet of things (IoT), the evolution of single-core processors to multi-core processors, and the increased importance of energy efficiency and thermal issues