Experimental Evaluation of Branching Schemes for the CSP

The search strategy of a CP solver is determined by the variable and value ordering heuristics it employs and by the branching scheme it follows. Although the effects of variable and value ordering heuristics on search effort have been widely studied, the effects of different branching schemes have received less attention. In this paper we study this effect through an experimental evaluation that includes standard branching schemes such as 2-way, d-way, and dichotomic domain splitting, as well as variations of set branching where branching is performed on sets of values. We also propose and evaluate a generic approach to set branching where the partition of a domain into sets is created using the scores assigned to values by a value ordering heuristic, and a clustering algorithm from machine learning. Experimental results demonstrate that although exponential differences between branching schemes, as predicted in theory between 2-way and d-way branching, are not very common, still the choice of branching scheme can make quite a difference on certain classes of problems. Set branching methods are very competitive with 2-way branching and outperform it on some problem classes. A statistical analysis of the results reveals that our generic clustering-based set branching method is the best among the methods compared.Comment: To appear in the 3rd workshop on techniques for implementing constraint programming systems (TRICS workshop at the 16th CP Conference), St. Andrews, Scotland 201

Distributed mode estimation through constraint decomposition

Thesis (S.M.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2010.Cataloged from PDF version of thesis.Includes bibliographical references (p. 131-134).Large-scale autonomous systems such as modern ships or spacecrafts require reliable monitoring capabilities. One of the main challenges in large-scale system monitoring is the difficulty of reliably and efficiently troubleshooting component failure and deviant behavior. Diagnosing large-scale systems is difficult because of the fast increase in combinatorial complexity. Hence, efficient problem encoding and knowledge propagation between time steps is crucial. Moreover, concentrating all the diagnosis processing power in one machine is risky, as it creates a potential critical failure point. Therefore, we want to distribute the online estimation procedure. We introduce here a model-based method that performs robust, online mode estimation of complex, hardware or software systems in a distributed manner. Prior work introduced the concept of probabilistic hierarchical constraint automata (PHCA) to compactly model both complex software and hardware behavior. Our method, inspired by this previous work, translates the PHCA model to a constraint representation. This approach handles a more precise initial state description, scales to larger systems, and to allow online belief state updates. Additionally, a tree-clustering of the dual constraint graph associated with the multi-step trellis diagram representation of the system makes the search distributable. Our search algorithm enumerates the optimal solutions of a hard-constraint satisfaction problem in a best-first order by passing local constraints and conflicts between neighbor sub-problems of the decomposed global problem. The solutions computed online determine the most likely trajectories in the state space of a system. Unlike prior work on distributed constraint solving, we use optimal hard constraint satisfaction problems to increase encoding compactness. We present and demonstrate this approach on a simple example and an electric power-distribution plant model taken from a naval research project involving a large number of modules. We measure the overhead caused by distributing mode estimation and analyze the practicality of our approach.by Henri Badaro.S.M

On the Structure of Decision Diagram-Representable Mixed Integer Programs with Application to Unit Commitment

Over the past decade, decision diagrams (DDs) have been used to model and solve integer programming and combinatorial optimization problems. Despite successful performance of DDs in solving various discrete optimization problems, their extension to model mixed integer programs (MIPs) such as those appearing in energy applications has been lacking. More broadly, the question which problem structures admit a DD representation is still open in the DDs community. In this paper, we address this question by introducing a geometric decomposition framework based on rectangular formations that provides both necessary and sufficient conditions for a general MIP to be representable by DDs. As a special case, we show that any bounded mixed integer linear program admits a DD representation through a specialized Benders decomposition technique. The resulting DD encodes both integer and continuous variables, and therefore is amenable to the addition of feasibility and optimality cuts through refinement procedures. As an application for this framework, we develop a novel solution methodology for the unit commitment problem (UCP) in the wholesale electricity market. Computational experiments conducted on a stochastic variant of the UCP show a significant improvement of the solution time for the proposed method when compared to the outcome of modern solvers

Distributed constraint satisfaction for coordinating and integrating a large-scale, heterogeneous enterprise

Market forces are continuously driving public and private organisations towards higher productivity, shorter process and production times, and fewer labour hours. To cope with these changes, organisations are adopting new organisational models of coordination and cooperation that increase their flexibility, consistency, efficiency, productivity and profit margins. In this thesis an organisational model of coordination and cooperation is examined using a real life example; the technical integration of a distributed large-scale project of an international physics collaboration. The distributed resource constraint project scheduling problem is modelled and solved with the methods of distributed constraint satisfaction. A distributed local search method, the distributed breakout algorithm (DisBO), is used as the basis for the coordination scheme. The efficiency of the local search method is improved by extending it with an incremental problem solving scheme with variable ordering. The scheme is implemented as central algorithm, incremental breakout algorithm (IncBO), and as distributed algorithm, distributed incremental breakout algorithm (DisIncBO). In both cases, strong performance gains are observed for solving underconstrained problems. Distributed local search algorithms are incomplete and lack a termination guarantee. When problems contain hard or unsolvable subproblems and are tightly or overconstrained, local search falls into infinite cycles without explanation. A scheme is developed that identifies hard or unsolvable subproblems and orders these to size. This scheme is based on the constraint weight information generated by the breakout algorithm during search. This information, combined with the graph structure, is used to derive a fail first variable order. Empirical results show that the derived variable order is 'perfect'. When it guides simple backtracking, exceptionally hard problems do not occur, and, when problems are unsolvable, the fail depth is always the shortest. Two hybrid algorithms, BOBT and BOBT-SUSP are developed. When the problem is unsolvable, BOBT returns the minimal subproblem within the search scope and BOBT-SUSP returns the smallest unsolvable subproblem using a powerful weight sum constraint. A distributed hybrid algorithm (DisBOBT) is developed that combines DisBO with DisBT. The distributed hybrid algorithm first attempts to solve the problem with DisBO. If no solution is available after a bounded number of breakouts, DisBO is terminated, and DisBT solves the problem. DisBT is guided by a distributed variable order that is derived from the constraint weight information and the graph structure. The variable order is incrementally established, every time the partial solution needs to be extended, the next variable within the order is identified. Empirical results show strong performance gains, especially when problems are overconstrained and contain small unsolvable subproblems

Constraint-based protocols for distributed problem solving

AbstractDistributed Problem Solving (DPS) approaches decompose problems into subproblems to be solved by interacting, cooperative software agents. Thus, DPS is suitable for solving problems characterized by many interdependencies among subproblems in the context of parallel and distributed architectures. Concurrent Constraint Programming (CCP) provides a powerful execution framework for DPS where constraints define local problem solving and the exchange of information among agents declaratively. To optimize DPS, the protocol for constraint communication must be tuned to the specific kind of DPS problem and the characteristics of the underlying system architecture. In this paper, we provide a formal framework for modeling different problems and we show how the framework applies to simple yet generalizable examples

Personaneinsatz- und Tourenplanung für Mitarbeiter mit Mehrfachqualifikationen

In workforce routing and scheduling there are many applications in which differently skilled workers must perform jobs that occur at different locations, where each job requires a particular combination of skills. In many such applications, a group of workers must be sent out to provide all skills required by a job. Examples are found in maintenance operations, the construction sector, health care operations, or consultancies. In this thesis, we analyze the combined problem of composing worker groups (teams) and routing these teams under goals expressing service-, fairness-, and cost-objectives. We develop mathematical optimization models and heuristic solution methods for an integrated solution and a sequential solution of the teaming- and routing-subproblems . Computational experiments are conducted to identify the tradeoff of better solution quality and computational effort

The GRT Planning System: Backward Heuristic Construction in Forward State-Space Planning

This paper presents GRT, a domain-independent heuristic planning system for STRIPS worlds. GRT solves problems in two phases. In the pre-processing phase, it estimates the distance between each fact and the goals of the problem, in a backward direction. Then, in the search phase, these estimates are used in order to further estimate the distance between each intermediate state and the goals, guiding so the search process in a forward direction and on a best-first basis. The paper presents the benefits from the adoption of opposite directions between the preprocessing and the search phases, discusses some difficulties that arise in the pre-processing phase and introduces techniques to cope with them. Moreover, it presents several methods of improving the efficiency of the heuristic, by enriching the representation and by reducing the size of the problem. Finally, a method of overcoming local optimal states, based on domain axioms, is proposed. According to it, difficult problems are decomposed into easier sub-problems that have to be solved sequentially. The performance results from various domains, including those of the recent planning competitions, show that GRT is among the fastest planners