On uncertainty propagation in image-guided renal navigation: Exploring uncertainty reduction techniques through simulation and in vitro phantom evaluation

Image-guided interventions (IGIs) entail the use of imaging to augment or replace direct vision during therapeutic interventions, with the overall goal is to provide effective treatment in a less invasive manner, as an alternative to traditional open surgery, while reducing patient trauma and shortening the recovery time post-procedure. IGIs rely on pre-operative images, surgical tracking and localization systems, and intra-operative images to provide correct views of the surgical scene. Pre-operative images are used to generate patient-specific anatomical models that are then registered to the patient using the surgical tracking system, and often complemented with real-time, intra-operative images. IGI systems are subject to uncertainty from several sources, including surgical instrument tracking / localization uncertainty, model-to-patient registration uncertainty, user-induced navigation uncertainty, as well as the uncertainty associated with the calibration of various surgical instruments and intra-operative imaging devices (i.e., laparoscopic camera) instrumented with surgical tracking sensors. All these uncertainties impact the overall targeting accuracy, which represents the error associated with the navigation of a surgical instrument to a specific target to be treated under image guidance provided by the IGI system. Therefore, understanding the overall uncertainty of an IGI system is paramount to the overall outcome of the intervention, as procedure success entails achieving certain accuracy tolerances specific to individual procedures. This work has focused on studying the navigation uncertainty, along with techniques to reduce uncertainty, for an IGI platform dedicated to image-guided renal interventions. We constructed life-size replica patient-specific kidney models from pre-operative images using 3D printing and tissue emulating materials and conducted experiments to characterize the uncertainty of both optical and electromagnetic surgical tracking systems, the uncertainty associated with the virtual model-to-physical phantom registration, as well as the uncertainty associated with live augmented reality (AR) views of the surgical scene achieved by enhancing the pre-procedural model and tracked surgical instrument views with live video views acquires using a camera tracked in real time. To better understand the effects of the tracked instrument calibration, registration fiducial configuration, and tracked camera calibration on the overall navigation uncertainty, we conducted Monte Carlo simulations that enabled us to identify optimal configurations that were subsequently validated experimentally using patient-specific phantoms in the laboratory. To mitigate the inherent accuracy limitations associated with the pre-procedural model-to-patient registration and their effect on the overall navigation, we also demonstrated the use of tracked video imaging to update the registration, enabling us to restore targeting accuracy to within its acceptable range. Lastly, we conducted several validation experiments using patient-specific kidney emulating phantoms using post-procedure CT imaging as reference ground truth to assess the accuracy of AR-guided navigation in the context of in vitro renal interventions. This work helped find answers to key questions about uncertainty propagation in image-guided renal interventions and led to the development of key techniques and tools to help reduce optimize the overall navigation / targeting uncertainty

Toward Real-Time Video-Enhanced Augmented Reality for Medical Visualization and Simulation

In this work we demonstrate two separate forms of augmented reality environments for use with minimally-invasive surgical techniques. In Chapter 2 it is demonstrated how a video feed from a webcam, which could mimic a laparoscopic or endoscopic camera used during an interventional procedure, can be used to identify the pose of the camera with respect to the viewed scene and augment the video feed with computer-generated information, such as rendering of internal anatomy not visible beyond the image surface, resulting in a simple augmented reality environment. Chapter 3 details our implementation of a similar system to the one previously mentioned, albeit with an external tracking system. Additionally, we discuss the challenges and considerations for expanding this system to support an external tracking system, specifically the Polaris Spectra optical tracker. Because of the relocation of the tracking origin to a point other than the camera center, there is an additional registration step necessary to establish the position of all components within the scene. This modification is expected to increase accuracy and robustness of the system

Augmented reality for computer assisted orthopaedic surgery

In recent years, computer-assistance and robotics have established their presence in operating theatres and found success in orthopaedic procedures. Benefits of computer assisted orthopaedic surgery (CAOS) have been thoroughly explored in research, finding improvements in clinical outcomes, through increased control and precision over surgical actions. However, human-computer interaction in CAOS remains an evolving field, through emerging display technologies including augmented reality (AR) – a fused view of the real environment with virtual, computer-generated holograms. Interactions between clinicians and patient-specific data generated during CAOS are limited to basic 2D interactions on touchscreen monitors, potentially creating clutter and cognitive challenges in surgery. Work described in this thesis sought to explore the benefits of AR in CAOS through: an integration between commercially available AR and CAOS systems, creating a novel AR-centric surgical workflow to support various tasks of computer-assisted knee arthroplasty, and three pre–clinical studies exploring the impact of the new AR workflow on both existing and newly proposed quantitative and qualitative performance metrics. Early research focused on cloning the (2D) user-interface of an existing CAOS system onto a virtual AR screen and investigating any resulting impacts on usability and performance. An infrared-based registration system is also presented, describing a protocol for calibrating commercial AR headsets with optical trackers, calculating a spatial transformation between surgical and holographic coordinate frames. The main contribution of this thesis is a novel AR workflow designed to support computer-assisted patellofemoral arthroplasty. The reported workflow provided 3D in-situ holographic guidance for CAOS tasks including patient registration, pre-operative planning, and assisted-cutting. Pre-clinical experimental validation on a commercial system (NAVIO®, Smith & Nephew) for these contributions demonstrates encouraging early-stage results showing successful deployment of AR to CAOS systems, and promising indications that AR can enhance the clinician’s interactions in the future. The thesis concludes with a summary of achievements, corresponding limitations and future research opportunities.Open Acces

Towards Transcervical Ultrasound Image Guidance for Transoral Robotic Surgery

Purpose: Trans-oral robotic surgery (TORS) using the da Vinci surgical robot is a new minimally-invasive surgery method to treat oropharyngeal tumors, but it is a challenging operation. Augmented reality (AR) based on intra-operative ultrasound (US) has the potential to enhance the visualization of the anatomy and cancerous tumors to provide additional tools for decision-making in surgery. Methods: We propose and carry out preliminary evaluations of a US-guided AR system for TORS, with the transducer placed on the neck for a transcervical view. Firstly, we perform a novel MRI-transcervical 3D US registration study. Secondly, we develop a US-robot calibration method with an optical tracker and an AR system to display the anatomy mesh model in the real-time endoscope images inside the surgeon console. Results: Our AR system reaches a mean projection error of 26.81 and 27.85 pixels for the projection from the US to stereo cameras in a water bath experiment. The average target registration error for MRI to 3D US is 8.90 mm for the 3D US transducer and 5.85 mm for freehand 3D US, and the average distance between the vessel centerlines is 2.32 mm. Conclusion: We demonstrate the first proof-of-concept transcervical US-guided AR system for TORS and the feasibility of trans-cervical 3D US-MRI registration. Our results show that trans-cervical 3D US is a promising technique for TORS image guidance.Comment: 12 pages, 8 figures. Accepted by Information Processing for Computer Assisted Interventions (IPCAI 2023