Point Cloud Registration for LiDAR and Photogrammetric Data: a Critical Synthesis and Performance Analysis on Classic and Deep Learning Algorithms

Recent advances in computer vision and deep learning have shown promising performance in estimating rigid/similarity transformation between unregistered point clouds of complex objects and scenes. However, their performances are mostly evaluated using a limited number of datasets from a single sensor (e.g. Kinect or RealSense cameras), lacking a comprehensive overview of their applicability in photogrammetric 3D mapping scenarios. In this work, we provide a comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art (SOTA) point cloud registration methods, where we analyze and evaluate these methods using a diverse set of point cloud data from indoor to satellite sources. The quantitative analysis allows for exploring the strengths, applicability, challenges, and future trends of these methods. In contrast to existing analysis works that introduce point cloud registration as a holistic process, our experimental analysis is based on its inherent two-step process to better comprehend these approaches including feature/keypoint-based initial coarse registration and dense fine registration through cloud-to-cloud (C2C) optimization. More than ten methods, including classic hand-crafted, deep-learning-based feature correspondence, and robust C2C methods were tested. We observed that the success rate of most of the algorithms are fewer than 40% over the datasets we tested and there are still are large margin of improvement upon existing algorithms concerning 3D sparse corresopondence search, and the ability to register point clouds with complex geometry and occlusions. With the evaluated statistics on three datasets, we conclude the best-performing methods for each step and provide our recommendations, and outlook future efforts.Comment: 7 figure

Evaluation of 3D Feature Descriptors for Multi-modal Data Registration

We propose a framework for 2D/3D multi-modal data registration and evaluate 3D feature descriptors for registration of 3D datasets from different sources. 3D datasets of outdoor environments can be acquired using a variety of active and passive sensor technologies including laser scanning and video cameras. Registration of these datasets into a common coordinate frame is required for subsequent modelling and visualisation. 2D images are converted into 3D structure by stereo or multi-view reconstruction techniques and registered to a unified 3D domain with other datasets in a 3D world. Multi-modal datasets have different density, noise, and types of errors in geometry. This paper provides a performance benchmark for existing 3D feature descriptors across multi-modal datasets. Performance is evaluated for the registration of datasets obtained from high-resolution laser scanning with reconstructions obtained from images and video. This analysis highlights the limitations of existing 3D feature detectors and descriptors which need to be addressed for robust multi-modal data registration. We analyse and discuss the performance of existing methods in registering various types of datasets then identify future directions required to achieve robust multi-modal 3D data registration

Evaluation of 3D Feature Descriptors for Multi-modal Data Registration

We propose a framework for 2D/3D multi-modal data registration and evaluate 3D feature descriptors for registration of 3D datasets from different sources. 3D datasets of outdoor environments can be acquired using a variety of active and passive sensor technologies including laser scanning and video cameras. Registration of these datasets into a common coordinate frame is required for subsequent modelling and visualisation. 2D images are converted into 3D structure by stereo or multi-view reconstruction techniques and registered to a unified 3D domain with other datasets in a 3D world. Multi-modal datasets have different density, noise, and types of errors in geometry. This paper provides a performance benchmark for existing 3D feature descriptors across multi-modal datasets. Performance is evaluated for the registration of datasets obtained from high-resolution laser scanning with reconstructions obtained from images and video. This analysis highlights the limitations of existing 3D feature detectors and descriptors which need to be addressed for robust multi-modal data registration. We analyse and discuss the performance of existing methods in registering various types of datasets then identify future directions required to achieve robust multi-modal 3D data registration