3 research outputs found
The practice of qualitative parameterisation in the development of Bayesian networks
The typical phases of Bayesian network (BN) structured development include
specification of purpose and scope, structure development, parameterisation and
validation. Structure development is typically focused on qualitative issues
and parameterisation quantitative issues, however there are qualitative and
quantitative issues that arise in both phases. A common step that occurs after
the initial structure has been developed is to perform a rough parameterisation
that only captures and illustrates the intended qualitative behaviour of the
model. This is done prior to a more rigorous parameterisation, ensuring that
the structure is fit for purpose, as well as supporting later development and
validation. In our collective experience and in discussions with other
modellers, this step is an important part of the development process, but is
under-reported in the literature. Since the practice focuses on qualitative
issues, despite being quantitative in nature, we call this step qualitative
parameterisation and provide an outline of its role in the BN development
process.Comment: 6 pages, 2 figures, technical not
Adding Local Constraints to Bayesian Networks
Abstract. When using Bayesian networks, practitioners often express constraints among variables by conditioning a common child node to induce the desired distribution. For example, an ‘or ’ constraint can be easily expressed by a node modeling a logical ‘or ’ of its parents ’ values being conditioned to true. This has the desired effect that at least one parent must be true. However, conditioning also alters the distributions of further ancestors in the network. In this paper we argue that these side effects are undesirable when constraints are added during model design. We describe a method called shielding to remove these side effects while remaining within the directed language of Bayesian networks. This method is then compared to chain graphs which allow undirected and directed edges and which model equivalent distributions. Thus, in addition to solving this common modelling problem, shielded Bayesian networks provide a novel method for implementing chain graphs with existing Bayesian network tools