Action research in physical education: focusing beyond myself through cooperative learning

This paper reports on the pedagogical changes that I experienced as a teacher engaged in an action research project in which I designed and implemented an indirect, developmentally appropriate and child‐centred approach to my teaching. There have been repeated calls to expunge – or at least rationalise – the use of traditional, teacher‐led practice in physical education. Yet despite the advocacy of many leading academics there is little evidence that such a change of approach is occurring. In my role as teacher‐as‐researcher I sought to implement a new pedagogical approach, in the form of cooperative learning, and bring about a positive change in the form of enhanced pupil learning. Data collection included a reflective journal, post‐teaching reflective analysis, pupil questionnaires, student interviews, document analysis, and non‐participant observations. The research team analysed the data using inductive analysis and constant comparison. Six themes emerged from the data: teaching and learning, reflections on cooperation, performance, time, teacher change, and social interaction. The paper argues that cooperative learning allowed me to place social and academic learning goals on an even footing, which in turn placed a focus on pupils’ understanding and improvement of skills in athletics alongside their interpersonal development

Short- and long-term effects of a multi-component physical activity intervention in primary school

There is compelling evidence that physical activity has numerous health benefits during childhood and adolescence. Insufficient levels of physical activity on the other hand can consequently affect cardiovascular and bone health, which may result in severe chronic diseases later in life. Cardiovascular disease and osteoporosis are two of the major chronic diseases affecting a large proportion of the adult population. Both diseases have their origins in childhood and it has been shown that for both, physical activity plays an important role in their prevention. The number of children not being sufficiently active has reached an alarming level and threatens to impose major health burdens worldwide. Thus, developing effective strategies to enhance children’s physical activity levels is of paramount interest for public health. School provides an optimal setting for physical activity promotion, since all children spend a large portion of their time there. This dissertation discusses a school-based randomized controlled trial aimed at increasing children’s physical activity levels and consequently their cardiovascular and bone health. The „Kinder- und Jugendsportstudie“ (KISS) is a school-based physical activity intervention lasting one school year. Of all primary school classes in the cantons of Aargau and Baselland comprising about 10% of the Swiss population, 28 first and fifth grade classes were randomly selected and allocated into an intervention (16 classes; n=297 children) and a control (12 classes, n=205 children) group. The mandatory and stringent multi-component intervention program consisted of daily physical education lessons, daily short activity breaks during academic lessons, and physical activity homework. Children in the control group had the compulsory three physical educations per week. The aim of this dissertation was to assess the effectiveness of KISS on cardiovascular risk and bone health and to explore whether the program was sufficiently effective in order to maintain health benefits over the following three years. In addition, this dissertation will provide a systematic update of existing school-based intervention studies aiming at increasing children’s physical activity and a quantification of physical education-related physical activity. There is strong evidence that school provides a promising setting for physical activity promotion. All school-based intervention studies done in recent years showed positive effects in at least one domain of physical activity. The most successful interventions had the design of a randomized controlled trial, were done over one school year using a multi-component approach integrated into the school curriculum, taught by physical education experts and involving family members. A common intervention strategy was to increase quantity and/or quality of physical education lessons. The particular role of physical education and its contribution to overall physical activity was the center of attention in the second publication of this dissertation. Even if children’s physical activity levels during physical education are relatively low, physical education contributes substantially to overall physical activity. Due to its nature of being a randomized controlled trial in children with a stringent physical activity program in and outside physical education over one school year and with the inclusion of physical education experts, KISS had excellent pre-conditions for being an effective program. Indeed, the results after nine month of intervention are promising. Compared to controls, children of the intervention group showed 14% reduced cardiovascular risk score, 5% reduced body mass index and skinfold thickness, 6% improved aerobic fitness, 18% higher physical activity levels, and 5-8% higher bone mineral content and bone mineral density. Three years after cessation of the program, intervention children still showed higher aerobic fitness and bone mineral content levels at weight-bearing sites of the skeleton compared to the control group. All other beneficial effects have disappeared. Even if short-term effects of the intervention are promising, the major key from a public health perspective is whether the effects of the prevention done during childhood will persist into late adolescence and adulthood. Although the maintained effects on aerobic fitness and bone health have considerable impact on public health, most of the beneficial health effects were not maintained three years after the intervention. This indicates that an intervention over one year is too short for maintained overall health effects. Thus, physical activity programs throughout the school years are needed. Our findings contribute to the growing body of evidence that school-based interventions can increase children’s health; however the major challenge now, is to find effective implementation strategies to transfer such programs into the real-world setting

Inclusion and education in the United Kingdom

Paper describes inclusion and education in the United Kingdom

Advancing task involvement, intrinsic motivation and metacognitive regulation in physical education classes: the self-check style of teaching makes a difference

It was hypothesized that “self-check” style of teaching would be more preferable in terms of creating a mastery-oriented climate, and promoting adaptive achievement goals, intrinsic motivation and metacognitive activity in physical education classes. Two hundred seventy-nine (N = 269) 6-grade students were randomly divided into two groups that were taught four consecutive physical education lessons of the same content following either “practice” or “self-check” styles of teaching respectively. Students responded on questionnaires prior and after the intervention. Results revealed significant interactions between groups and measurements. Students in the “self-check” style group scored higher in scales measuring mastery-oriented climate, mastery goal, intrinsic motivation and metacognitive processes and lower in scales measuring performance-goals and performance-oriented motivational climate. These results underscore the importance of using styles of teaching that enhance opportunities for deep cognitive processing and promote mastery-goals and mastery-oriented climates

Contours of Inclusion: Frameworks and Tools for Evaluating Arts in Education

This collection of essays explores various arts education-specific evaluation tools, as well as considers Universal Design for Learning (UDL) and the inclusion of people with disabilities in the design of evaluation instruments and strategies. Prominent evaluators Donna M. Mertens, Robert Horowitz, Dennie Palmer Wolf, and Gail Burnaford are contributors to this volume. The appendix includes the AEA Standards for Evaluation. (Contains 10 tables, 2 figures, 30 footnotes, and resources for additional reading.) This is a proceedings document from the 2007 VSA arts Research Symposium that preceded the American Evaluation Association's (AEA) annual meeting in Baltimore, MD

Identifying and engaging 'disengaged' and 'disruptive' students

This paper outlines concerns in the UK about students who are disruptive in class and/or disengaged from the normal educational process. After discussing who these students are and estimating their numbers, the paper looks at recent research on how best to meet their needs. This research indicates the appropriateness of the British government's recent softening of its position on 'inclusion'. The studies cited indicate that far more can be done in 'normal' school settings to promote engagement but that special provision can sometimes be more appropriate. If social inclusion as adults is the overarching aim, what matters more than the physical location of the education offered are the qualities, skills, commitment and energies of the professionals involved. The values of staff, the quality of their relationships with the students and their imaginative, flexible delivery of appropriate curricula are crucial, as is the need to support these professionals in their demanding task.peer-reviewe

Cooperative games and inclusion in physical education

De acuerdo con los principios teóricos de la praxeología motriz este estudio examinó cuatro tipos de conductas motrices cooperativas: ajustadas [AJUS], desajustadas [DESAJ], perversas [PER]) y de pacto (PACT) de 40 niños (18 con discapacidades and 22 sin discapacidades) de 8-11 años que participaron en un programa diseñado para promover la inclusión a través de juegos cooperativos. Las conductas motrices más frecuentes (24%) fueron las AJUS. Modelos de regresión múltiple mostraron que las variables dependientes tuvieron un considerable poder de explicación: AJUS, 34%; DESAJ, el 22%; PERV, 30% y 3% PACT. Con respecto a las variables independientes analizadas, es decir, la edad, el género y si la persona tenía discapacidad, sólo esta última explicó algunas de las conductas observadas.Based on the theoretical principles of motor praxeology this study examined four types of cooperative motor behaviours, namely well-matched [WMAT], mismatched [MISMAT], destructive [DEST] and cooperative agreement (PACT), among 40 children aged 8-11 years (18 children with disabilities and 22 without disabilities) who were taking part in a workshop designed to promote inclusion through cooperative games. The most commonly observed motor behaviour (24%) was WMAT. Multiple regression models showed that the dependent variables had considerable explanatory power: WMAT, 34%; MISMAT, 22%; DEST, 30%; and PACT 3%. With respect to the independent variables analysed, namely age, gender and whether or not the child had disabilities, only the latter explained some of the observed behaviour

Pedagogy, curriculum, teaching practices and teacher education in developing countries

This rigorous literature review focused on pedagogy, curriculum, teaching practices and teacher education in developing countries. It aimed to: 1. review existing evidence on the review topic to inform programme design and policy making undertaken by the DFID, other agencies and researchers 2. identify critical evidence gaps to guide the development of future research programme

Influence of Teaching Style on Physical Education Adolescents’ Motivation and Health-Related Lifestyle

According to various WHO reports in 2018, a large number of adolescents worldwide are either overweight or obese. This situation is the result of not following a healthy and balanced diet, combined with a lack of practice of physical activity. In this sense, Physical Education classes could help to solve the problem. The present study seeks to analyze the relationship between the role of the teacher in relation to the structural dimensions of the PE teaching environment and the basic psychological needs and self-motivation of adolescents as determinants of their behaviors related to eating habits and the practice of physical activity. A total of 1127 secondary school adolescents between the ages of 13 and 18 participated in this study. Questionnaires were used: Perceived Autonomy Support Scale, Psychologically Controlling Teaching Scale, Basic Psychological Needs in Physical Education, Frustration of Psychological Needs in PE context, Physical Activity Class Satisfaction Questionnaire, Perceived Locus of Causality Revised, and WHO’s Global school-based student health survey. A structural equations model was elaborated to explain the causal relationships between the variables. The results showed that autonomy support positively predicted the three structural dimensions of PE classes, while, in contrast, they were negatively predicted by psychological control. The three structural dimensions positively predicted the satisfaction of psychological needs and negatively predicted the thwarting of psychological needs. Self-determined motivation was positively predicted by the satisfaction of psychological needs and negatively predicted by the thwarting of psychological needs. Finally, self-determined motivation positively predicted healthy eating habits and the practice of physical activity and negatively predicted unhealthy eating habits. Certainly, the results obtained in this study support the postulates of the self-determination theory, demonstrating the predictability of PE class context towards the adoption of healthy lifestyle habits, such as a proper diet and the regular practice of physical activity