Egypt’s Failed Democratic Transition: Why the Labour Movement Matters

Abstract

This article analyses the failure of Egypt’s democratic transition between 2011 and 2013, highlighting the often-overlooked role of the labour movement. While dominant approaches in transition studies emphasise socio-economic factors, elite dynamics or the middle class, this study argues that the absence of an independent labour movement rooted in the industrial working class critically undermined Egypt’s prospects for democratic consolidation. Drawing on interviews with Egyptian trade unionists and relevant literature, the article uses process-tracing to situate the Egyptian experience within broader debates on democratisation. It contrasts this experience with transitions in Tunisia, Brazil, South Africa, Poland and South Korea—where labour movements were central actors. Challenging modernisation theory and elite-focused models, it adopts an actor-centred perspective that foregrounds organised labour. The article concludes that although Egypt’s working class played a key role in mobilising dissent, it lacked the institutional strength to shape the transition. The Egyptian case underscores the enduring relevance of labour movements, especially in an era of democratic backsliding and neoliberal fragmentation