Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Does Britain or the United States Have the Right Gasoline Tax?

By Ian Parry and Kenneth Small


This paper develops an analytical framework for assessing the second-best optimal level of gasoline taxation, taking into account unpriced pollution, congestion, and accident externalities and interactions with the broader fiscal system. We provide calculations of the optimal taxes for the United States and the United Kingdom under a wide variety of parameter scenarios, with the gasoline tax substituting for a distorting tax on labor income. Under our central parameter values, the second-best optimal gasoline tax is $1.01 per gallon for the United States and $1.34 per gallon for the United Kingdom. These values are moderately sensitive to alternative parameter assumptions. The congestion externality is the largest component in both nations, and the higher optimal tax for the United Kingdom is due mainly to a higher assumed value for marginal congestion cost. Revenue-raising needs, incorporated in a “Ramsey” component, also play a significant role, as do accident externalities and local air pollution. The current gasoline tax in the United Kingdom ($2.80 per gallon) is more than twice this estimated optimal level. Potential welfare gains from reducing it are estimated at nearly one-fourth the production cost of gasoline used in the United Kingdom. Even larger gains in the United Kingdom can be achieved by switching to a tax on vehicle miles with equal revenue yield. For the United States, the welfare gains from optimizing the gasoline tax are smaller, but those from switching to an optimal tax on vehicle miles are very large.gasoline tax, pollution, congestion, accidents, fiscal interactions

OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1997). 32Resources for the Future Parry
  2. (1999). 33Resources for the Future Parry and Small Fridstrøm, Lasse,
  3. (2000). 34Resources for the Future Parry and Small International Energy Agency,
  4. (2000). 35Resources for the Future Parry and
  5. (1997). 36Resources for the Future Parry
  6. (1995). 37Resources for the Future Parry and
  7. (1927). A Contribution to the Theory of Taxation.”
  8. (1992). A Review of New Demand Elasticities with Special Reference to Short and Long Run Effects of Price Changes.”
  9. (2000). A Survey of the UK Tax System. Briefing note No. 9, Institute for Fiscal Studies,
  10. (1991). An Aggregate Accident Model Based on Pooled, Regional Time-Series Data.” Accident Analysis and Prevention
  11. (1996). An Economic Analysis of Fuel Use per Kilometre by Private Cars.”
  12. (2001). Comparing the Efficiency of Alternative Policies for Reducing Traffic Congestion.”
  13. (1969). Congestion theory and transport investment.”
  14. (1994). Congestion Trends in Metropolitan Areas.” In: National Research Council, Curbing Gridlock: Peak-period Fees to Relieve Traffic Congestion,
  15. (1997). Costs of Environmentally Motivated Taxes in the Presence of Other Taxes:
  16. (2001). Discrete Choice Models and Optimal Two-Part Tariffs in the Presence of Externalities:
  17. (2000). Economic Commission for Europe,
  18. (1999). Economics at the Wheel: The Costs of Cars and Drivers.
  19. (1998). Economists’ Views about Parameters, Values and Policies: Survey Results in Labor and Public
  20. (1998). Efficient Transport for Europe: Policies for Internalization of External Costs.
  21. (2000). Environmental Externalities of Motor Vehicle Use.”
  22. (2000). Environmental Levies and Distortionary Taxation: Pigou, Taxation, and Pollution.” Working Paper 7917,
  23. (1994). Environmental Policy, Public Finance, and the Labor Market in a Second-Best World.”
  24. (1995). Estimating the External Costs of UK Passenger Transport: The First Step towards an Efficient Transport Market.” Environment and Planning A
  25. (1996). Explaining the Variation in Elasticity Estimates of Gasoline Demand in the United States:
  26. (2000). External Effects of Transport.”
  27. (1993). Full Cost Pricing of Highways. Department of Transportation,
  28. (1997). Full Social Cost of Transportation in Europe.” In: The Full Costs and Benefits of Transportation,
  29. (1996). Gasoline and Travel Demand Models Using Time Series and Cross-Section Data from
  30. (1998). Gasoline Demand Revisited: An
  31. (2000). Health Effects in a Model of Second Best Environmental Taxes.”
  32. (1991). Highway Statistics
  33. (1999). Household Adjustment to Gasoline Price Change: An Analysis Using 9
  34. (2001). Household Gasoline Demand in Canada.” Econometrica 69(6): 1697-1709. 39Resources for the Future Parry and Small APPENDIX:
  35. (2000). Information Agency,
  36. (2000). International Financial Statistics Yearbook:
  37. (1991). Is the Gasoline Tax Regressive?” In
  38. (1999). Labor Supply: A Review of Alternative Approaches.”
  39. (1978). Leisure is weakly separable in our utility function. Therefore when its price changes due to a change in tL, the resulting changes in the demands for consumption and for travel occur only through a change in disposable income (Layard and Walters
  40. (1994). Managing the Global Commons: The Economics of Climate Change.
  41. (1978). Microeconomic Theory. M cGraw-Hill,
  42. (1996). Optimal Environmental Taxation in the Presence of Other Taxes:
  43. (1976). Optimal taxation⎯An Introduction to the Literature.”
  44. (1981). Optimal Taxes and the
  45. (1996). Policies and Measures for Reducing Energy Related Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Lessons from Recent Literature.
  46. (2000). Policy Analysis in the Presence of Distorting Taxes.”
  47. (1990). Pricing and Congestion: Economic Principles Relevant to Pricing Roads.”
  48. (2000). Reforming Transport Pricing in the European Union. Edward Elgar,
  49. Report #7 in the series: The Annualized Social Cost of Motor-Vehicle Use in the United States, based on 1990-1991 Data.
  50. (2001). Revenue Recycling and the Welfare Effects of Road Pricing.”
  51. (1964). Road Pricing: The Economic and Technical Possibilities. Her Majesty's Stationery Office,
  52. (1987). Road User Charges
  53. (1988). Road User Charges in
  54. (1989). Road Work: A New Highway Pricing and Investment Policy.
  55. (1992). Should Carbon Taxes Be Additional to Other Transport Fuel Taxes?”
  56. (1998). Summary of the Nonmonetary Externalities of Motor-Vehicle Use. Report #9 in the series: The Annualized Social Cost of Motor-Vehicle Use in the United States, based on 1990-1991 Data.
  57. (1997). The Annualized Social Cost of Motor-Vehicle Use in the US, 1990-1991: Summary of Theory , Data, Methods, and Results. Report #1 in the series: The Annualized Social Cost of Motor-Vehicle Use in the United States, based on 1990-1991 Data.
  58. (1998). The Costs and Benefits of Reducing Air Pollutants Related to Acid Rain."
  59. (1991). The Costs of Highway Crashes.
  60. (2002). The Demand for Automobile Fuel: A Survey of
  61. (1990). The Economics of Global Warming.
  62. (2000). The Efficiency Effects of Transport Policies in the Presence of Externalities and Distortionary Taxes.”
  63. (2001). The Fatality Risks of Sport-Utility Vehicles, Vans,
  64. (1999). The Health Costs of Motor-Vehicle-Related Air Pollution.”
  65. (1982). The Long-Run Structure of Transportation and Gasoline Demand.”
  66. (1994). The Social Costs of Greenhouse Gas Emissions: An Expected Value Approach.”
  67. (1961). The Theory and Measurement of Private and
  68. (2001). Transportation Energy Data Book. Publication ORNL-6966,
  69. (2000). Transportation Statistics Great Britain:
  70. (1992). Urban Transportation Economics.
  71. (1999). Urban Transportation.”
  72. (2000). Vehicle Emission Trends.
  73. (2000). Warming the World: Economic Models of Global Warming.
  74. (2000). Yearbook of Labor Statistics

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.