Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Anatomy of a failure: how we knew when our design went wrong, and what we learned from it

By William Gaver, John Bowers, Tobie Kerridge, Andy Boucher and Nadine Jarvis


In this paper, we describe the failure of a novel sensor-based system intended to evoke user interpretation and appropriation in domestic settings. We contrast participants' interactions in this case study with those observed during more successful deployments to identify 'symptoms of failure' under four themes: engagement, reference, accommodation, and surprise and insight. These themes provide a set of sensitivities or orientations that may complement traditional task-based approaches to evaluation as well as the more open-ended ones we describe here. Our system showed symptoms of failure under each of these themes. We examine the reasons for this at three levels: problems particular to the specific design hypothesis; problems relevant for input-output mapping more generally; and problems in the design process we used. We conclude by noting that, although interpretive systems such as the one we describe here may succeed in a myriad of different ways, it is reassuring to know that they can also fail, and fail incontrovertibly, yet instructively

Topics: G440, W201, W280
Year: 2009
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2005). Affect: from information to interaction. doi
  2. (2007). Cultural commentators: Non-native interpretations as resources for polyphonic assessment. doi
  3. (2007). Electronic furniture for the Curious Home: Assessing ludic designs in the field. doi
  4. (2007). Enhancing ubiquitous computing with user interpretation: field testing the home health horoscope. doi
  5. (1995). Representing the user.
  6. (2007). Research through design as a method for interaction design research in HCI. doi
  7. (2003). Sense and sensibility: evaluation and interactive art. doi
  8. (2006). Staying Open to interpretation: Engaging multiple meanings in design and evaluation. doi
  9. (2006). Tableau machine: an alien presence in the home. CHI '06 Extended Abstracts, doi
  10. (2004). Technology as Experience. doi
  11. (2006). The sensual evaluation instrument: developing an affective evaluation tool. doi
  12. (2007). The three paradigms of HCI. doi
  13. (2006). When Second Wave HCI meets Third Wave challenges. NordCHI doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.