Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The promise of long-term effectiveness of school-based smoking prevention programs: a critical review of reviews

By Brian R Flay


I provide a review and critique of meta-analyses and systematic reviews of school-based smoking prevention programs that focus on long-term effects. Several of these reviews conclude that the effects of school-based smoking prevention programs are small and find no evidence that they have significant long-term effects. I find that these reviews all have methodological problems limiting their conclusions. These include severe limiting of the studies included because of performance bias, student attrition, non-reporting of ICCs, inappropriate classification of intervention approach, and inclusion of programs that had no short-term effects. The more-inclusive meta-analyses suggest that school-based smoking prevention programs can have significant and practical effects in both the short- and the long-term. Findings suggest that school-based smoking prevention programs can have significant long-term effects if they: 1) are interactive social influences or social skills programs; that 2) involve 15 or more sessions, including some up to at least ninth grade; that 3) produce substantial short-term effects. The effects do decay over time if the interventions are stopped or withdrawn, but this is true of any kind of intervention

Topics: Review
Publisher: BioMed Central
OAI identifier:
Provided by: PubMed Central

Suggested articles


  1. (1993). A meta-analysis of adolescent smoking prevention programs.
  2. (2003). A Randomized
  3. (1989). A skills training approach to smoking prevention among hispanic youth.
  4. (2004). Aban-Aya I: Effects of 2 prevention programs on high-risk behaviors among African American youth: A randomized trial. Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine
  5. (1999). Acculturation and Cigarette Smoking Among African Americans: Replication and Implications for Prevention and Cessation Programs.
  6. (2004). Acculturation and Tobacco Use Among Chinese Americans. Am Public Health Assoc
  7. (2003). Adolescent and young adult tobacco prevention and cessation: current status and future directions.
  8. (1988). Affective and social influences approaches to the prevention of multiple substance abuse among seventh grade students: Results from Project SMART. Preventive Medicine
  9. (1990). African-American and Hispanic-American adolescents, HIV infection and preventive intervention. AIDS Education and Prevention
  10. (1978). Alcohol and drug education: Models and outcomes. Health Education Monographs
  11. (2000). Approaches to substance use prevention utilizing school curriculum plus social environment change. Addictive Behaviors
  12. (2004). Approaches to tobacco control: the evidence base.
  13. (2003). B: A meta-evaluation of 11 school-based smoking prevention programs.
  14. (2001). Biglan A: EDITORIAL: The Hutchinson Smoking Prevention Project: A Lesson on Inaccurate Media Coverage and the Importance of Prevention Advocacy. Prevention Science
  15. (1996). BM: The effectiveness of Drug Abuse Resistance Education (Project DARE): 5-Year follow-up results. Preventive Medicine
  16. (2007). CH: The Devil Is in the Details: Examining the Evidence for" Proven" School-Based Drug Abuse Prevention Programs. Evaluation Review
  17. Changing Adolescent Smoking Prevalence. Where it is and why. Smoking and Tobacco Control:
  18. (1986). CL: The efficacy of peer leaders in drug abuse prevention.
  19. (2006). Communicating Prevention: The Effects of the keepin'it REAL Classroom Videotapes and Televised PSAs on MiddleSchool Students' Substance Use.
  20. (2003). Culturally Grounded Substance Use Prevention: An Evaluation of the keepin'it REAL Curriculum. Prevention Science
  21. (2004). De Vries H: Effects of inschool and tailored out-of-school smoking prevention among Dutch vocational school students. Health Education Research
  22. (2007). De Vries H: The effects of a three-year smoking prevention programme in secondary schools in Helsinki. The European Journal of Public Health
  23. (2007). Design and evaluation of a tobacco-prevention program targeting Chinese American youth in New York City. Nicotine & Tobacco Research
  24. (1976). Developing a social psychological strategy of deterrence. Preventive Medicine
  25. (1994). DL: Cops in the classroom: A longitudinal evaluation of Drug Abuse Resistance Education (DARE).
  26. (1996). DM: A Meta-Analysis of Smoking Prevention Programs After Adjustment for Errors in the Unit of Analysis.
  27. (1996). DR: Public health approaches to tobacco use prevention and cessation in the US. J Public Health Manag Pract
  28. (1980). Drug education: A turn on or a turn off.
  29. (1990). Drug use prevention programs, gender, and ethnicity: Evaluation of three seventh-grade project SMART cohorts. Preventive Medicine
  30. (2008). E: Effective practices for school-based tobacco use prevention. Preventive Medicine
  31. (2006). E: The Drug Resistance Strategies Intervention: Program Effects on Substance Use. Health Communication
  32. (2002). Effective ingredients of school-based drug prevention programs A systematic review. Addictive Behaviors
  33. (1999). Effective prevention programs for tobacco use.
  34. (1996). Effectiveness of a school-based substance abuse prevention program.
  35. (2005). Effectiveness of adolescent smoking prevention strategies.
  36. (1995). Effectiveness of Culturally Focused and Generic Skills Training Approaches to Alcohol and Drug Abuse Prevention Among Minority Adolescents: Two-Year Follow-Up Results. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors
  37. (1990). EM: A cognitive-behavioral approach to substance abuse prevention: one-year follow-up. Addictive behaviors
  38. (1993). ER: Do drug prevention effects persist into high school? How Project ALERT did with ninth graders. Preventive Medicine
  39. (1989). Essential elements of school-based smoking prevention programs.
  40. (1990). et al.: Effects of program implementation on adolescent drug use behavior: The Midwestern Prevention Project (MPP). Evaluation Review
  41. (2000). et al.: Evaluation of a Tobacco and Alcohol Use Prevention Program for Hispanic Migrant Adolescents: Promoting the Protective Factor of Parent-Child Communication. Preventive Medicine
  42. (2000). et al.: Investing in youth tobacco control: a review of smoking prevention and control strategies. Tobacco Control
  43. (2005). et al.: Standards of evidence: Criteria for efficacy, effectiveness, and dissemination. Prevention Science
  44. (2003). et al.: The European Smoking prevention Framework Approach (EFSA): an example of integral prevention. Health Education Research
  45. et al.: The European Smoking prevention Framework Approach (ESFA): effects after 24 and 30 months.
  46. (2003). et al.: The European Smoking Prevention Framework Approach (ESFA): short-term effects. Health Education Research
  47. Evaluation: The state of the art and the sorry state of science. Edited by: Cordray DS.
  48. (2006). Family physicians and youth tobacco-free education: Outcomes of the Colorado Tar Wars program.
  49. (1996). FB: Factors affecting attrition in a longitudinal smoking prevention study. Preventive Medicine
  50. (1989). Five-and six-year follow-up results from four seventh-grade smoking prevention strategies.
  51. (1994). Flewelling RL: How Effective Is Drug Abuse Resistance Education? A Meta-Analysis of Project DARE Outcome Evaluations.
  52. (2005). FP: A systematic review of school-based smoking prevention trials with long-term follow-up.
  53. (1998). GS: Assessing the effects of schoolbased drug education: A six-year multilevel analysis of Project D.A.R.E.
  54. (2002). Hanewinkel R: Effectiveness of the "Smoke-Free Class Competition" in Delaying the Onset of Smoking in Adolescence. Preventive Medicine
  55. (1984). Health education and the science teacher: Incitation to a debate. Education and Health
  56. (1964). Inducing resistance to persuasion.
  57. (2009). International-University of North CarolinaTobacco Induced Diseases
  58. (1996). JA: Three-Year Follow-Up of Drug Abuse Resistance Education (D.A.R.E.). Evaluation Review
  59. (1989). JH: Primary prevention of chronic diseases in adolescence: Effects of the Midwestern Prevention Project on tobacco use.
  60. (2006). JLR: The Principle of Cultural Grounding in School-Based Substance Abuse Prevention: The Drug Resistance Strategies Project.
  61. (1998). JP: Peer helping/involvement: An efficacious way to meet the challenge of reducing alcohol, tobacco, and other drug use among youth?
  62. (2004). Jr: Challenges in tobacco use prevention among minority youth. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev
  63. (2003). JW: A brief review of adolescents and tobacco: what we know and don't know.
  64. (2006). Lack of sustainable prevention effect of the "Smoke-Free Class Competition" on German pupils. Preventive Medicine
  65. (2005). LaFromboise T: State of the science on psychological intervention for ethnic minorities. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology(2005)
  66. (1998). Lang SW: Twelfth grade followup of the effectiveness of a middle school-based substance abuse prevention program.
  67. (2005). LL: Since school-based tobacco prevention programs do not work, what should we do?
  68. (1988). Locklear VS: Preventing substance abuse among American-Indian adolescents: A bicultural competence skills approach.
  69. (1995). Long-term follow-up results of a randomized drug abuse prevention trial in a white middle-class population. JAMA
  70. (2003). ML: keepin'it REAL: A drug resistance curriculum tailored to the strengths and needs of preadolescents of the southwest.
  71. (2003). NJ: Innovative approaches to youth tobacco control: introduction and overview.
  72. (1996). No Smoking Class' competitions in Finland: their value in delaying the onset of smoking in adolescence.
  73. (1994). NR: Seven-year follow-up of a smoking-prevention program for children.
  74. (2004). outcome effectiveness revisited.
  75. (1999). Pallonen U: Effects of thirty four adolescent tobacco use cessation and prevention trials on regular users of tobacco products. Subst Use Misuse
  76. (2000). PM: Hutchinson Smoking Prevention Project: Long-term randomized trial in school-based tobacco use prevention – results on smoking.
  77. (1992). Positive evidence on effectiveness of selected smoking prevention programs in the United States.
  78. (1990). Preventing adolescent drug abuse through a multimodal cognitivebehavioral approach: Results of a 3-year study.
  79. (1993). Preventing adolescent drug use: Long-term results of a junior high program.
  80. (1999). Preventing adolescent health-risk behaviors by strengthening protection during childhood. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
  81. (1987). Preventing substance abuse among American Indian and Alaska Native youth: Research issues and strategies.
  82. (1994). Preventing tobacco use among young people: A report of the Surgeon General.
  83. (2002). Prevention of tobacco use in adolescents: review of current findings and implications for healthcare providers. Curr Opin Pediatr
  84. (2002). Primär-und Sekundärprävention des Rauchens im Jugendalter: Effekte der Kampagne „Be SmartDon't Start" Primary and Secondary Prevention of Smoking in Adolescents: Results of the Campaign „Be Smart-Don't Start". Gesundheitswesen
  85. (1999). Project DARE: No Effects at 10-Year Follow-Up.
  86. (1993). Psychological impact of biculturalism: Evidence and theory. Psychological Bulletin
  87. (1978). R: A Meta-Analysis of Adolescent Psychosocial Smoking Prevention Programs Published Between
  88. (2001). Re: Hutchinson Smoking Prevention Project: Long-term randomized trial in school-based tobacco use prevention – results on smoking.
  89. (2000). Reducing tobacco use: A report of the Surgeon General.
  90. (1999). RL: Cultural sensitivity in public health: Defined and demystified.
  91. (2005). S: An Alternate Route to Policy Influence: How Evaluations Affect DARE.
  92. (1997). School health promotion programs over the past decade: a review of the smoking, alcohol and solar protection literature. Health Promotion International
  93. (2007). School-based programmes for preventing smoking (Review). The Cochrane Library
  94. (2005). School-based smoking prevention in children and adolescents: review of the scientific literature.
  95. (2006). School-based smoking prevention programs for adolescents in South Korea: a systematic review. Health Education Research
  96. (2009). School-based smoking prevention programs with the promise of long-term effectiveness. Tobacco Induc Dis
  97. (2005). School-based smoking prevention research: Letter to the editor.
  98. (1992). School-based substance use prevention: A review of the state of the art in curriculum, 1980–1990. Health Education Research: Theory and Practice
  99. (2001). School-based tobacco use prevention and cessation: where are we going.
  100. (2003). Sing RA: Prevention of smoking in adolescents with lower education: A school based intervention study.
  101. (1989). Six-year follow-up of the first Waterloo school smoking prevention trial.
  102. (1994). SL: Long-Term Evaluation of Drug Abuse Resistance Education. Addictive Behaviors
  103. (1978). Smoking education programs 1960–1976.
  104. (2005). Smoking prevention for ethnically diverse adolescents: 2-year outcomes of a multicultural, school-based smoking prevention curriculum in Southern California. Preventive Medicine
  105. (1998). Stackpole KM: School-based adolescent drug prevention programs:
  106. (2003). Standards for Evidence and Evidence for Standards: The Case of School-Based Drug Prevention.
  107. (1997). Stratton HH: Effectiveness of school-based drug prevention programs: A meta-analysis of the research.
  108. (2003). Sussman S: A review of 25 long-term adolescent tobacco and other drug use prevention program evaluations. Preventive Medicine
  109. (2007). The Long-Term Promise of Effective School-Based Smoking Prevention Programs. In Ending the tobacco problem: A blueprint for the nation Edited by: Bonnie
  110. (2000). The Minnesota DARE PLUS Project: Creating community partnerships to prevent drug use and violence.
  111. (2001). The Role of Public Social Control in Urban Neighborhoods: A Multi-Level Analysis of Victimization. Criminology
  112. to Control Tobacco Use in the United States: A Blueprint for Public Health Action in the 1990's.
  113. (1996). Tudor-Smith C: Preventing Adolescent smoking: a review of options.
  114. (1998). Vartiainen E: European smoke-free class competition. Tobacco Control
  115. (2000). Well-Meaning Programs Can Have Harmful Effects! Lessons From Experiments of Programs Such as Scared Straight. Crime & Delinquency
  116. (2007). Why Smoking Prevention Programs Sometimes Fail: Does Effectiveness Depend on Sociocultural Context and Individual Characteristics? Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers & Prevention

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.