Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Pedagogies of engagement in science: A comparison of PBL, POGIL, and PLTL*

By Thomas Eberlein, Jack Kampmeier, Vicky Minderhout, Richard S Moog, Terry Platt, Pratibha Varma-Nelson and Harold B White


Problem-based learning, process-oriented guided inquiry learning, and peer-led team learning are student-centered, active-learning pedagogies commonly used in science education. The characteristic features of each are compared and contrasted to enable new practitioners to decide which approach or combination of approaches will suit their particular situation

Topics: Articles
Publisher: Wiley Subscription Services, Inc., A Wiley Company
OAI identifier:
Provided by: PubMed Central
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.g... (external link)
  • Suggested articles


    1. (2004). A course to prepare peer leaders to implement a student-assisted learning method,
    2. (1999). A guided inquiry general chemistry course,
    3. (2003). A Pilot Systematic Review and Meta-analysis on the Effectiveness of Problem-Based Learning. Available at Accessed
    4. (2008). A Simons
    5. (1986). A taxonomy of problem-based learning methods,
    6. (2005). A White Paper for Facilitating POGIL Activities in Large Classes. Available at Accessed
    7. (2007). Active and Cooperative Learning. Available at unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/Cooperative_Learning.html. Accessed
    8. (1991). Active Learning: Cooperation in the College Classroom, Interaction Book,
    9. (2003). An innovative selection and training program for problem-based learning (PBL) workshop leaders in biochemistry,
    10. (2001). Beyond Affirmative Action: Reframing the Context of
    11. (2007). Bridging the educational research-teaching gap: the importance of bridging the gap between science education research and its application in biochemistry teaching and learning barriers and strategies.
    12. (1996). Bringing ProblemBased Learning to Higher Education: Theory and Practice, JosseyBass,
    13. (2007). Challenges and rewards of offering peer-led team learning in a large general chemistry course,
    14. (2005). Chem-2-Chem: a one-to-one supportive learning environment for chemistry.
    15. (2005). Chemists’ Guide to Effective Teaching, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River,
    16. (2005). Commentary: Generating discussion during examinations,
    17. (2002). Commentary: Problem-based testing,
    18. (2007). Comparing the Performance of Groups of Students with and without PLTL Workshops. Available at Accessed
    19. (2005). Comparison of student performance in cooperative learning and traditional lecture-based biochemistry classes,
    20. (2003). CONFCHEM, Non-Traditional Teaching Methods: Paper 7, Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning. Available at http:// Accessed
    21. (2006). Cracolice
    22. (2007). Cracolice (2005) Evaluation of student learning in a PLTL classroom. Progressions 6, 6. Available at www.sci.ccny.cuny. edu/ ~ chemwksp/newsletter.html. Accessed
    23. (2003). Creating Significant Learning Experiences: An Integrated Approach to Designing College Courses, Jossey-Bass,
    24. (2008). Curriculum Materials, Laboratory. Available at Accessed
    25. (1996). Dan tries problem-based learning: A case study,
    26. (2005). Departing from lectures: An evaluation of a peer-led guided inquiry alternative,
    27. (1997). Designing effective group activities: Lessons for classroom teaching and faculty development,
    28. (2003). Disciplinary differences or modes of curriculum practice: Who promised to deliver what in problem-based learning?
    29. (2007). Evaluating peer-led team learning: a study of long-term effects on former workshop leaders.
    30. (1938). Experience and Education, Collier and Kappa Delta Pi,
    31. (2008). Facilitation: The role of the instructor, in
    32. (2006). Foundations of Chemistry: Applying POGIL Principles,
    33. (2004). Foundations of Problembased Learning,
    34. (2007). General, Organic, and Biological Chemistry: A Guided Inquiry,
    35. (2003). Herreid
    36. (2000). How People Learn:
    37. III (2001) Peer facilitators of in-class groups: adapting problem-based learning to the undergraduate setting,
    38. (2002). Implementation of a peerled team learning instructional approach in an undergraduate organic chemistry course,
    39. (2006). Instructor’s Guide to Process-Oriented GuidedInquiry Learning,
    40. (2008). Introductory Chemistry Modules: A Guided Inquiry Approach, Preliminary Edition,
    41. (2004). Introductory course based on a single problem: Learning nucleic acid biochemistry from AIDS research,
    42. Koeske (2006) Peer instruction in the general chemistry laboratory: Assessment of student learning.
    43. (2007). Learning, Upcoming Events. Available at ~ chemwksp/events.html. Accessed
    44. (2007). Lecture-free biochemistry: A process-oriented guided inquiry approach,
    45. (2005). Measuring the effects of peer-led team learning.
    46. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes,
    47. (2003). Multiple-choice questions-a reprieve,
    48. (2002). Myths about assessing the impact of problembased learning on students,
    49. (1999). New directions in teaching chemistry: A philosophical and pedagogical basis,
    50. (2007). On the successful use of inquiry-driven experiments in the organic chemistry laboratory,
    51. (1999). Operational Organic Chemistry: A ProblemSolving Approach to the Laboratory Course, 3rd ed., Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River,
    52. (2004). Organic Chemistry: A Guided Inquiry,
    53. (2006). Peer-led team learning (PLTL) in organic chemistry: student performance, success, and persistence in the course.
    54. (2001). Peer-Led Team Learning: A Guidebook, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River,
    55. (2001). Peer-Led Team Learning: A Handbook for Team leaders, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River,
    56. (2001). Peer-Led Team Learning: General, Organic, and Biological Chemistry, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River,
    57. (2004). Physical Chemistry, A Guided Inquiry: Atoms, Molecules, and Spectroscopy,
    58. (2004). Physical Chemistry, A Guided Inquiry: Thermodynamics,
    59. (2008). POGIL implementation in large classes,
    60. (2008). POGIL in chemistry courses at a large urban university: A case study,
    61. (2007). Problem-Based Learning Clearinghouse. Available at https://chico. Accessed
    62. (2001). Problem-based learning in large and very large classes, in
    63. (2007). Problem-Based Learning or Related Sites. Available at Accessed
    64. (2008). Problem-Based Learning, Available at http://www.udel. edu/pbl/. Accessed
    65. (1993). Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues.
    66. (1980). Problem-based Learning: An Approach to Medical Education.
    67. (1994). Problem-Based Learning: How to Gain the Most from PBL,
    68. (2007). Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning, Available at http:// Accessed
    69. (2007). Process oriented guided inquiry learning: POGIL and the POGIL project,
    70. (2000). Process workshops—A new model for instruction,
    71. (2007). Process-Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning, Upcoming Events. Available at Accessed
    72. (2006). Radical Change in Large-Scale Instruction. Available at P116B060026 &printGrantyes. Accessed
    73. (1993). Research literature as a source of problems,
    74. (2003). Response to: The problem with problembased medical education: promises not kept by
    75. (2004). Scientific teaching,
    76. (1964). Six Psychological Studies, Vintage,
    77. (2003). Statistical evaluation: peerled team learning in an organic chemistry course.
    78. (2007). Stimulating attitudes of inquiry with problem-based learning, in
    79. (2001). Student active learning methods in physical chemistry,
    80. (2007). Student Assessment of Learning Gains (SALG) survey. Available at Accessed
    81. (2007). Studies of POGIL Student Learning Outcomes. Available at Accessed
    82. (1997). Talking about Leaving: Why Undergraduates Leave Science,
    83. (2005). Team-Based Learning: A Transformative Use of Small Groups in College Teaching,
    84. (1991). The Challenge of Problem Based Learning,
    85. (2007). The many faces of inductive teaching and learning,
    86. (2001). The many forms of constructivism,
    87. (2001). The Power of Problem-Based Learning: A Practical ‘‘How To’’ for Undergraduate Courses in Any Discipline,
    88. (1966). The Psychology of Intelligence,
    89. (1998). The workshop chemistry project: peer-led team learning,
    90. (2001). The workshop project: Peer-led team learning in chemistry.
    91. (1990). They’re Not Dumb, They’re Different, Research Corporation,
    92. (1998). Thinking Toward Solutions: Problem-Based Learning Activities for General Biology, Saunders,
    93. (2001). Undergraduate group facilitators to meet the challenges of managing multiple PBL groups, in
    94. (1997). Untimed individual/group exams, problembased learning,
    95. (2000). Vygotsky’s zone of proximal development: A theory base for peer-led team learning,
    96. (1995). We never said it would be easy,
    97. (2008). Welcome to the PLTL Page! Available at http://www.sci.ccny.cuny. edu/~chemwksp/. Accessed
    98. (2002). What happens next? A followup study of workshop leaders at St.
    99. (2001). Why does my cruorine change color?

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.