Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Seeking evidence for the role of ontological assumptions in the thinking of managers and professional

By JA Rooke, LJ Koskela and D Seymour

Abstract

Shingo's (1988) seminal innovation in the theory of production management can be seen as a re-conceptualization of production as flow rather than transformation (Koskela 1992). These alternatives can in turn be regarded as reflections of opposing ontological positions which have dominated Western philosophy, holding respectively that reality is constituted of either temporal process, or atemporal substance (Roochnik 2004). Koskela & Kagioglou (2005) suggest that lean production philosophy is based in a process ontology, radically different from the atemporal metaphysics underlying conventional methods and theories. Chi (1992) has argued that the disjunction between ontological categories such as 'substance' and 'process' can constitute a particularly acute barrier to understanding. Studies such as Itza-Ortiz, Rebello & Zollman (2003) have demonstrated the possibility of specifying and classifying learners' mental models as an aid to learning. We examine procedures typically adopted in Quantity Surveying, Structural Engineering Design and Project Planning, in order to specify the mental models involved. We find evidence of an underlying substance ontology. Methods of measurement used in Quantity Surveying are designed to account for physical, rather than temporal properties. In design, the emphasis is on representing the properties of the finished structure, rather than the processes by which it is constructed. More subtly, the temporal dimensions of the construction process are represented in project planning as 'lumps' of time, thus ignoring important facets of their nature as events. We conclude that attention to the role of ontological categories in industry thinking will facilitate the teaching of process oriented approaches to construction project management

Topics: HD00280070, other
OAI identifier: oai:usir.salford.ac.uk:2599

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2000). An exploration towards a production theory and its application to construction,
  2. (1992). Application of the New Production Philosophy to Construction’,
  3. (2001). Bills of Quantities Versus Activity Schedules for Civil Engineering Projects,'
  4. (1991). CESMM 3: Civil Engineering Standard Method of Measurement, (third edition)
  5. (1993). Ethnography in Organizations, Sage, doi
  6. (1994). Ethnography; Principles in Practice (Second Edition)
  7. (2002). Ethnomethodology’s Program: Working out Durkheim’s Aphorism,
  8. (1994). From Things to Processes: A Theory of Conceptual Change for Learning Science Concepts,'
  9. (2005). Learning, knowledge and authority on site: a case study of safety practice’, doi
  10. (1997). Limitations of the use of tolerances for communicating design requirements to site,’ doi
  11. (2004). Making-Do – The Eighth Category of Waste,’
  12. (1988). Non-stock production :the Shingo system for continuous improvement, Productivity Press,
  13. (1998). Obstacles to implementing total quality management doi
  14. (2005). On the metaphysics of production’
  15. (2004). Planning for Claims; An Ethnography of Industry Culture’, doi
  16. (1993). Quality Planning and Analysis, (third edition)
  17. (2001). Researching Culture on Construction Projects, A thesis submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, School of Engineering,
  18. (2004). Retrieving the Ancients.
  19. (1998). Shielding Production: Essential Step in Production Control,'
  20. (2005). Studies of Work: Achieving Hybrid Disciplines doi
  21. (2005). The Civil Engineering Standard Method of Measurement (CESMM), accessed on 19th
  22. (2003). The Claims Culture; A Taxonomy of Industry Attitudes’, doi
  23. (1996). The effectiveness of formal quality management systems in achieving the required cover in reinforced concrete,’ doi
  24. (1998). The engineering and construction contract: an NEC
  25. (2000). The Last Planner System of Production Control, A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Engineering of The University of Birmingham for the degree of
  26. (2002). The Processes and Challenges of Conceptual Change,'
  27. (2002). The Production of Management Knowledge: Philosophical Underpinnings of Research Design.
  28. (1989). The Theory of Tolerances, BS 5606,
  29. (1992). Two Incommensurable, Asymmetrically Alternate Technologies of Social Analysis',

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.