Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

On non-overt specifiers

By P Rowlett


I consider non-overt specifiers, in particular two contexts in which they have been posited. First, SpecIP: in finite clauses in nullsubject languages, SpecIP is standardly assumed to be occupied by a null pronominal (little pro) (Rizzi 1982a). Second, SpecNegP: in negative clauses in languages whose sole overt negative marker is\ud associated with NegE, SpecNegP is claimed to be occupied by a null polarity operator (OP) (Haegeman 1995). A specifier, like a complement, is a syntactic dependant of a head. I argue that the null hypothesis is that a head does not have a dependant unless it needs one; a head is capable of ‘doing its job’ on its own, and will therefore be dependant-free, unless it is in some relevant sense\ud lacking, whereby the dependant provides what is missing. In this light, I review the evidence for non-overt specifiers in SpecIP/Spec-NegP and show that the evidence does not stand up to close examination, and that the facts can be accounted for by assuming that the relevant heads can ‘do their job’ without a specifier, and that, consequently, their projections not only have no overt specifier, but actually have no specifier position, either, and therefore no nonovert specifier

Topics: P1, mem_text_and_place
Publisher: European Studies Research Institute, University of Salford
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2000a) The syntax of specifiers and heads: the collected essays of
  2. (2000b) ‘The spec–head configuration’,
  3. (2000). (Non-)occurrence of sentential no in Spanish negative sentences’,
  4. (1994). A new look at the null-subject parameter’, paper presented at CONSOLE III,
  5. (1998). A non-overt negative operator in
  6. (1997). A notional theory of syntactic categories. Cambridge:
  7. (1993). A riddle on negation
  8. (1999). Adjectival modifiers and the specifier–adjunct distinction’,
  9. (2000). Adult null subjects in non-null-subject languages’,
  10. (1984). After binding: on the interpretation of pronouns.
  11. (1992). Agreement and subjects. Doctoral dissertation, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona.
  12. AND KEN SAFIR (1989a) ‘The null subject parameter and parametric theory’,
  13. (1998). Approaches to the evolution of language. Cambridge:
  14. (1995). Asymmetries in the scope of Russian negation’,
  15. (2002). C, T and the subject: that–t phenomena revisited’,
  16. (1992). Contribution à l’étude de la négation en f]ngbè’, MS, Université du Québec à Montréal.
  17. (1996). Economy and optionality: interpretations of subjects in
  18. (1997). Elements of grammar: a handbook of generative syntax.
  19. (1999). English grammar: a generative perspective.
  20. (1999). EPP without Spec,IP’,
  21. (2002). Foundations of language: brain, meaning, grammar, evolution.
  22. (2001). French ne in non-verbal contexts’,
  23. (1993). French sentential negation and LF piedpiping’,
  24. (1991). Functional heads and inflectional morphemes’,
  25. (1986). Head-marking and dependent-marking grammar’,
  26. (1982). Issues in Italian syntax.
  27. (1997). Jespersen, negative concord and AN binding’,
  28. (1977). L’emploi productif du ne dans le français parlé à Montréal’, Le Français Moderne, 45: 243–256. English version published as ‘The productive use of ne in spoken Montreal French,
  29. (1985). L’histoire de la négation et la typologie romane’, in Linguistique comparée et typologie des langues romanes (Actes du XVIIème congrès international de linguistique et philologie romanes).
  30. (1998). Language evolution and the minimalist program: the origins of syntax’,
  31. (1991). Licensing conditions on phrase structure. Doctoral dissertation,
  32. (1990). Natural language and natural selection’,
  33. (1997). Negation and polarity: syntax and semantics.
  34. (1917). Negation in English and other languages.
  35. (1996). Negation in Irish and the representation of monotone decreasing quantifiers’,
  36. (1982). Negation, wh movement and the null-subject parameter’,
  37. (1996). Negative configurations in French. Doctoral dissertation,
  38. (1991). Negative heads and the Neg Criterion’,
  39. (1983). On the formal syntax of West Germania.
  40. (1983). On the interaction of root transformations and lexical deletive rules’,
  41. (1998). On the supposed “counterfunctionality” of Universal Grammar: some evolutionary implications’,
  42. (1993). On the syntactic derivation of negative sentence adverbials’,
  43. (1981). Origins of phrase structure.
  44. (1994). Pied-piping and specifier-head agreement’,
  45. (1989). Pro-drop in Chinese: a generalized control theory’,
  46. (1998). Prosody, focus and word order.
  47. (1990). Relativized minimality.
  48. (1970). Remarks on nominalizations’,
  49. (2001). Romance languages and linguistic theory 1999.
  50. (1998). Sentential negation in French. Oxford:
  51. (1996). Situating que’,
  52. (1982). Some concepts and consequences of the theory of government and binding.
  53. (1999). Specifiers as secondary heads’,
  54. (2000). Subject” and EPP in Greek: the discontinuous subject hypothesis’, MS,
  55. (1996). Subjects and subject positions in Irish’,
  56. (1997). Syntactic theory and the structure of English: a minimalist approach. Cambridge:
  57. (1997). Syntax: structure, meaning and function. Cambridge: doi
  58. (2000). The acquisition of syntax.
  59. (1998). The acquisition of the pro-drop parameter by nonnative speakers of Spanish. Doctoral dissertation,
  60. (1993). The Celtic languages.
  61. (1997). The fine structure of the left periphery’,
  62. (2000). The French language today: a linguistic introduction, second edition.
  63. (1995). The minimalist program.
  64. (1924). The philosophy of grammar. London: Allen and Unwin.
  65. (2002). The syntax of fronting in French and Guadeloupe Creole. Doctoral dissertation,
  66. (1999). The syntax of negation in Russian: a minimalist approach. Stanford, Calif.: Center for the Study of Language and Information.
  67. (1995). The syntax of negation. Cambridge:
  68. (2002). The syntax of non-canonical quantification: a comparative study. Doctoral dissertation,
  69. (2002). The syntax of Spanish. Cambridge:
  70. (1996). The syntax of the Celtic languages. Cambridge:
  71. (1987). Topic, pronoun and agreement in
  72. TSOULAS (eds) (1999b) Specifiers: minimalist approaches.
  73. (1989). Verb movement, universal grammar and the structure of IP’,
  74. (1999). Without specifiers’,
  75. (1985). X-bar and X-plain: a study of X-bar theories of the phrase structure component. Doctoral dissertation,
  76. (1977). X-bar syntax: a study of phrase structure.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.