Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

‘In the name of capability’: a critical discursive evaluation of competency-based management development

By Tim Finch Lees, Chris Mabey and Andreas Liefooghe

Abstract

This paper illustrates a number of ways in which competency or capability-based management development (CBMD) can work simultaneously both for and against the interests of organizational agents. It does so by demonstrating how CBMD might usefully be understood as both ideological and quasi-religiously faith-based. These features are shown to provide opportunities for resistance and micro-emancipation alongside those for repression and subordination. The study employs a combination of ‘middle range’ discourse analytical techniques. In the first instance, critical discourse analysis is applied to company documentation to distil the ideological stance of an international organization’s CBMD programme. Critical discursive psychology is then used to assess the ways in which employees’ evaluative accounts both support and resist such stance. The analysis builds upon previous insights from Foucauldian studies of CBMD by foregrounding processes of discursive agency. It also renders more visible and discussible the assumptions and dilemmas that CBMD might imply

Topics: manop
Publisher: Sage Journals
Year: 2005
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.bbk.ac.uk.oai2:300

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2005). 25This paper has been published in Human Relations and the final (edited, revised and typeset) version is available in Human Relations
  2. (2005). 26This paper has been published in Human Relations and the final (edited, revised and typeset) version is available in Human Relations
  3. (2005). 27This paper has been published in Human Relations and the final (edited, revised and typeset) version is available in Human Relations
  4. (2005). 28This paper has been published in Human Relations and the final (edited, revised and typeset) version is available in Human Relations
  5. (2005). 29This paper has been published in Human Relations and the final (edited, revised and typeset) version is available in Human Relations
  6. A c k e r s doi
  7. (1996). Accou n t i n g in detai l : accou n t i n g for indiv i d u a l perfo rma n c e . Critical Perspectives on Accounting,
  8. (1996). Accounting in detail: accounting for individual performance. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, doi
  9. (1993). Achie v i n g strat e g i c coher e n c e in HRD throu g h comp e t e n c e - b a s e d manag e men t and orga n i z a t i o n deve l o p me n t . Personnel Review,
  10. (1993). Achieving strategic coherence in HRD through competence-based management and organization development. Personnel Review, doi
  11. (2001). Analy si n g mascu l i n i t y : inter p r e t a t i v e repert o i r e s , ideolo g i c a l dile mm a s and subje c t posit i o n s .
  12. (2001). Analysing masculinity: interpretative repertoires, ideological dilemmas and subject positions. In
  13. (1993). Assessment centres: Identifying and developing competence.
  14. (1997). Born again? The ethics and efficacy of the conversion experience in contemporary management development. doi
  15. (2000). Build i n g an ideo l o g i c a l fortr e s s : The role of spiri t u a l i t y , encap s u l a t i o n and sense m a k i n g .
  16. (2000). Building an ideological fortress: The role of spirituality, encapsulation and sensemaking. doi
  17. (2002). Chiap e l l o , E. & Fairc l o u g h , N. Under s t a n d i n g the new manag e m e n t ideol ogy : A trans d i s c i p l i n a r y contr ib u t io n from criti c a l disco u r s e analy si s and new socio l o g y of capit a l i s m.
  18. (1999). co mp et e n c i e s and ub erm e n s c h : Refle c t i o n s on human an d inhu man resou r c e manag e men t . Organization,
  19. (1999). competencies and ubermensch: Reflections on human and inhuman resource management. Organization, doi
  20. (1998). Creating a training and development strategy. Londo n : Inst i t u t e of Perso n n e l and Deve l o p me n t ,
  21. (1998). Creating a training and development strategy. London: Institute of Personnel and Development,
  22. (1998). Demera t h ,
  23. (1992). Designing and achieving competency.
  24. (2000). Devel o p i n g manag e r s : the funct i o n a l , the sy mboli c , the sacred and the profane . Organization Studies ,
  25. (2000). Developing managers: the functional, the symbolic, the sacred and the profane. Organization Studies, doi
  26. (1994). Discou r s e an aly si s in an occupa t i o n a l conte x t .
  27. (2004). Discou r s e and instit u t io n s . Academy of Management Review,
  28. (1992). Discourse & social change. Cambridge: doi
  29. (1994). Discourse analysis in an occupational context.
  30. (2004). Discourse and institutions. doi
  31. (1987). Discourse and social psychology: Beyond attitudes and behaviour. doi
  32. Discourse as data . Lond on : Sage , 2001a . Faircl o u g h , N. Criti c a l disco u r s e analy sis as a method in socia l scien t i f i c resea r c h .
  33. (2001). Discourse as data. doi
  34. (2001). Discu r s i v e , Rheto r i c a l & Ideolo g i c a l M essag e s .
  35. (1997). Does management development add value? doi
  36. (2000). Doing critical management research. doi
  37. (2000). Doing critical management research. London : Sage , doi
  38. (2003). Eleme n t s of a semio t i c theor y of relig i o n . Method and theory in the study of religion ,
  39. (2003). Elements of a semiotic theory of religion. Method and theory in the study of religion, doi
  40. (1992). Fairc l o u g h , N. Discourse & social change. Camb r i d g e : Poli ty Pres s ,
  41. (1988). Feminism & Foucault: Reflections on Resistance.
  42. (1988). Feminism & Foucault: Reflections on Resistance. Bost o n : North e a s t e r n Unive r s i t y Press , xi-xi x ,
  43. (1998). Foucault, management and organization theory . Lond on : Sage ,
  44. (1998). Foucault, management and organization theory. doi
  45. (1996). From outw a r d boun d to inward bound ’ : The prophe t i c voice s and discur s i v e practi c e s of spiri t u a l manage m e n t develo p m e n t . Human Relations,
  46. (2004). From outward bound to inward bound’: The prophetic voices and discursive practices of spiritual management development. Human Relations, doi
  47. (2002). Grugu l i s , I. Nothi n g seri o us? Cand i d a t e s ’ use of humou r in manag e m e n t trai n i n g . Human Relations,
  48. (2002). How tight are the ties that bind stake h o ld e r group s? Organization Science,
  49. (2002). How tight are the ties that bind stakeholder groups? Organization Science, doi
  50. (1995). HRM and the irresis t i b l e rise of the discour s e of co mp ete n c e . Personnel Review,
  51. (1995). HRM and the irresistible rise of the discourse of competence. Personnel Review, doi
  52. (1985). Id eology as a cultural sy stem . In R. Bococ k & K. Thomp so n (Eds) , Religion and ideology.
  53. (2002). Ident i ty regul a t i o n as organ i z a t i o n a l contr o l : produci n g the appro p r i a t e indiv i d u a l .
  54. Identity regulation as organizational control: producing the appropriate individual. doi
  55. (1985). Ideology as a cultural system. In
  56. (1986). Is strategic management ideological? doi
  57. (2000). Karrem a n , D. Varie t i e s of disco u r s e : on the study of organ i z a t i on s thro ug h discou r s e ana ly si s . Human Relations,
  58. (1984). Lindb e c k , G. The nature of doctrine. Londo n : SPCK ,
  59. (1996). Making up managers: contemporary managerial discourse and the constitution of the 'competent' manager. Report to ESRC (London:
  60. (1999). Manag e men t devel o p me n t as a game of meani n g l e s s outco me s . Human Resource Management Journal,
  61. (1999). Management development as a game of meaningless outcomes. Human Resource Management Journal, doi
  62. (1999). McCar t n e y , S. The capaci t y spira l : Four weddin g s and a funera l .
  63. (2001). Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis. doi
  64. (2001). Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis. Lond o n : Sage , doi
  65. Methods of critical discourse analysis. Lond on : Sage , 2001b . Fairc l o u g h
  66. (2002). Nothing serious? Candidates’ use of humour in management training. Human Relations, doi
  67. (1992). On the idea of eman c i p at i o n in mana g e men t and orga n i z a t i o n studi e s . Academy of Management Review,
  68. (1992). On the idea of emancipation in management and organization studies. doi
  69. (1994). Organi z a t i o n a l co mp et e n c i e s : cre ati n g a strate g i c beha vi o u r a l frame w o r k for select i o n and asse ss m e n t . In N. Anders o n & P. Herrio t t (Eds. ) , International handbook of selection and assessment. Lond on : Wiley ,
  70. (1994). Organizational competencies: creating a strategic behavioural framework for selection and assessment.
  71. (2001). Raisi n g perfo r m a n c e throu g h peopl e : the eight h comp e t e n c y survey . Competency and Emotional Intelligence Benchmarking,
  72. (2001). Raising performance through people: the eighth competency survey.
  73. (1995). Rec rui t m e n t , sele ct i o n and assess m e n t . In
  74. (1997). Refram i n g Fouca u l t : The case of perform a n c e apprai s a l .
  75. (1997). Reframing Foucault: The case of performance appraisal.
  76. (1994). Reframing Human resource management: Power, ethics and the subject at work. doi
  77. (1994). Reframing Human resource management: Power, ethics and the subject at work. London : Sage , doi
  78. (1985). Relig i o n in mo der n Brita i n .
  79. (1985). Religion in modern Britain. In
  80. (2003). Remember re-engineering? The rhetorical appeal of a managerial salvation device. doi
  81. Revie w artic l e : HRMis m a nd the langu a ge s of re-pr e s e n t a t i o n .
  82. (1997). Review article: HRMism and the languages of re-presentation. doi
  83. (2001). Rhetorical & Ideological Messages. In
  84. (1998). Sacred companies: Organizational aspects of religion and religious aspects of organizations. doi
  85. (1982). Sacred persi s t e n c e : To ward s a redesc r i p t i o n of canon. In Imagining religion: From Babylon to Jonestown. Chicag o : Unive r s i t y of Chica g o Press ,
  86. (1982). Sacred persistence: Towards a redescription of canon. In Imagining religion: From Babylon to Jonestown. Chicago:
  87. (1996). Salam a n , G. Making up managers: contemporary managerial discourse and the constitution of the 'competent' manager. Repor t to ESRC (Lond o n : ESRC ) ,
  88. (1995). selection and assessment. In
  89. (1986). Shriva s t a v a , P. Is strat e g i c manag e m e n t ideol o g i c a l ?
  90. (2003). Spirit u a l i ty , manag e m e n t and organ i z a t i o n . Organization ,
  91. (1998). Stori e s of devel o p m e n t and exploi t a t i o n : milita n t voices in enterp r i s e cultur e . Organization,
  92. (1998). Stories of development and exploitation: militant voices in enterprise culture. Organization, doi
  93. Stren g t h is ignor a n c e ; slave r y is freed o m : Manag i n g cultu r e in moder n organ i z a t i o n s .
  94. (1993). Strength is ignorance; slavery is freedom: Managing culture in modern organizations. doi
  95. (2005). T h is pape r has been pub lish ed in Human Relations an d the fina l (edited , revis e d and type s e t) vers ion is availab le in Human Relatio n s
  96. (2005). T h is pape r has been pub lish ed in Human Relations an d the fina l (edited , revis e d and type s e t) vers ion is availab le in Human Relatio n s 58/9 1185 -12 22 . Sep t
  97. (1988). Techn o l o g i e s of the self.
  98. (1988). Technologies of the self. In doi
  99. (1996). Th e making of the comp et e n t manage r : co mp et e n c y develo p m e n t , person a l effect i v e n e s s and Foucau l t . Management Learning ,
  100. (1997). The arena thesi s : Manag e m e n t devel o p m e n t as a plural i s t i c meeti n g point.
  101. (1997). The arena thesis: Management development as a pluralistic meeting point. In doi
  102. (1999). The capacity spiral: Four weddings and a funeral. doi
  103. (1996). The condu c t of manag e men t an d the manag e m e n t of condu c t : Conte mp o r a r y manag e r i a l disco u r s e and the const i t u t i o n of the ‘comp e t e n t ’ manager .
  104. (1996). The conduct of management and the management of conduct: Contemporary managerial discourse and the constitution of the ‘competent’ manager. doi
  105. (1997). The consequ e n c e s of co mp et e n c e : A critic a l asses s m e n t of the Manag e men t NVQ. Personnel Review,
  106. (1997). The consequences of competence: A critical assessment of the Management NVQ. Personnel Review, doi
  107. (2001). The double edge of comp et e n c y train i n g : contr a d i c t o r y discou r s e s and lived experi e n c e .
  108. (2001). The double edge of competency training: contradictory discourses and lived experience. doi
  109. (1997). The faith of the managers: When management becomes religion . Lond on : Cass e l l ,
  110. (1997). The faith of the managers: When management becomes religion. doi
  111. (1986). The Foucault reader . P. Rabi n o w (Ed) , Harmo n d s w o r t h : Peng u in ,
  112. (2000). The limit s of discou r s e analy si s in organi z a t i o n a l analy si s . Organization,
  113. (2000). The limits of discourse analysis in organizational analysis. Organization, doi
  114. (1996). The making of the competent manager: competency development, personal effectiveness and Foucault. Management Learning, doi
  115. (2000). The Manag e m e n t NVQ: A critiq u e of the my th of relev a n c e .
  116. (2000). The Management NVQ: A critique of the myth of relevance. doi
  117. (1984). The nature of doctrine. doi
  118. (1989). The postmodern condition: A report on knowledge. Manche s t e r : Manche s t e r Unive r s i t y Press ,
  119. (1989). The postmodern condition: A report on knowledge. Manchester: doi
  120. (1998). Theor i z i n g subj e c t i v i t y in organ i z a t i o n s : The failu r e of Fouca u l d i a n studi e s ? Organization Studies ,
  121. (1998). Theorizing subjectivity in organizations: The failure of Foucauldian studies? Organization Studies, doi
  122. (1999). Too much, too littl e and too often : A critiq u e of du Gay’s analy si s of enterp r i s e . Organization, doi
  123. (1999). Too much, too little and too often: A critique of du Gay’s analysis of enterprise. Organization, doi
  124. (1998). Transcending sacred and secular: Mutual benefits in analyzing religious and nonreligious organizations.
  125. (2002). Understanding the new management ideology: A transdisciplinary contribution from critical discourse analysis and new sociology of capitalism. doi
  126. (2000). Varieties of discourse: on the study of organizations through discourse analysis. Human Relations, doi
  127. (1998). Willi a ms (Eds. ) , Sacred companies: Organizational aspects of religion and religious aspects of organizations. New York: Oxfor d Unive r s i t y Press ,
  128. (1993). Woodr u f f e , C. Assessment centres: Identifying and developing competence . Lond o n : IPM,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.