Article thumbnail

Benchmarking Regional Innovation: A Comparison of Bavaria, Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland

By Stephen Roper


Regional regeneration strategies based on developing innovation capability have received much support in recent years. Evaluation of the effectiveness of such initiatives has, however, been limited largely to an assessment of the impact of such strategies on policy frameworks and attitudes. Based on innovation survey data covering nearly a decade, this paper outlines a number of external innovation benchmarks for core and peripheral regions within the EU. The benchmarks considered cover the innovation objectives, constraints resources, linkages and outputs of manufacturing firms. Despite considerable efforts in recent years to develop the innovation capability and institutional support framework for innovation in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, the benchmarks still point to a substantial performance gap between the Irish and German study regions and provide little evidence of convergence over the 1991-99 period. The benchmarks also suggest other more general points emphasising, for example, a general shortening of product lifecycles and a related shift towards more radical innovation. More disappointing is in that in each of the study regions the development of environmentally friendly products is given a low and diminishing priority by manufacturing firms.

OAI identifier:

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.

Suggested articles


  1. (1998). A
  2. (1998). An Economic Agenda for the Northern Ireland Assembly’,
  3. (1982). An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change’,
  4. (1997). Antecedents and Consequences of Cross Functional Co-operation:
  5. (1997). Can Regional Policy Affect Firms' Innovation Potential in Lagging Regions?’, paper presented to the 37th European Congress of the Regional Science Association,
  6. (1996). Determinants of Innovation the Message from New Indicators,
  7. (2000). Different Paths to Success: Electronics Growth in Ireland and Israel’, Environment and Planning
  8. (1998). Do Networks Matter for Innovation? The Usefulness of the Economic Network Approach
  9. (1992). Do Regions Matter for R&D?’,
  10. (1999). Economic Outlook – Germany’, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development,
  11. (2000). Emergence and growth of high-tech activity
  12. (1995). Empirical Studies of Innovative Activity’
  13. (1996). Factors Determining R&D and Innovation Expenditure in German Manufacturing Industries’, in Kleinknecht, A (ed) ‘Determinants of Innovation – The Message from New Indicators’,
  14. (1999). Final Report of the On-Going Evaluation of the Regional Innovation
  15. (1997). Foreign Direct Investment to a Peripheral Country – The Case of Ireland’
  16. (1996). Industrial Training and Technological Innovation’,
  17. (2000). Innovation and E-Commerce: A Cross-Border
  18. (1993). Innovation and Firm Size - The New Learning’,
  19. (1995). Innovation and Industry Evolution,
  20. (1994). Innovation and the Skill Mix: Chemicals and Engineering
  21. (2001). Innovation, Networks and Plant Location; Evidence for Ireland’,
  22. (1998). Innovation, Networks and the Diffusion of Manufacturing Best Practice: A Comparison of Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland’,
  23. (1995). Innovations and R&D in Northern Ireland manufacturing: a Schumpeterian approach’,
  24. (1999). Innovative Linkages and Proximity: Empirical Results from Recent Surveys of Small and Medium Sized Firms in German Regions’,
  25. (1982). Inside the Black Box’,
  26. (1998). Learning from Collaboration:
  27. (2000). Local Learning from Multinational Plants: Knowledge Transfers in the Supply Chain’, Regional Studies,
  28. (1998). Local Milieu and Innovations: Some Empirical Results’,
  29. (1999). Make and Buy in Innovation Strategies: Evidence from Belgian Manufacturing Firms’,
  30. (1995). Making Knowledge Work for Us – A Strategic View of Science, Technology and Innovation
  31. (1998). Mapping Innovation Networks’,
  32. (1993). Multinational Enterprises and the Global Economy,
  33. (1993). National Innovation Systems,
  34. (1993). National Innovation Systems: Britain’, in Nelson, R R (ed) ‘National Innovation Systems: A Comparative Analysis’,
  35. (1994). Opening the Frontier; Recent Spatial Impacts in the Former Inner-German Border Zone’,
  36. (1992). Operational Models on Industrial Innovation and Spatial Development: A Case Study for the Netherlands’,
  37. (1997). Organising Diversity - Evolutionary Theory, Network Analysis and Post-socialism,
  38. (2000). Patterns of Networking in the Innovation Process: A Comparative Study of the UK, Germany and Ireland”,
  39. (1997). Product Innovation and Small Business Growth: a Comparison of the Strategies of German,
  40. (1999). Publicly Funded
  41. (1995). Recent developments in Irish industrial policy’,
  42. (1998). Regional Concentration and Dynamics of Fast Growing Industries in Baden-Wurttemberg and Israel’, ISIArbeitspapiere Regionalforschung,
  43. (1993). Regional Innovation Policies Compared’,
  44. (1998). Regional Innovation Systems’,
  45. (1995). Regional Problems and Policy in the UK”,
  46. (2000). Scale, Appropriability Conditions and the Organisation of R&D , Working Paper 42, NIERC,
  47. (1998). Science and Technology Infrastructure in Baden-Württemberg and Its Orientation towards Future Regional Development',
  48. (1989). Spatial Dispersion of Technological Innovation: A Case Study for the Netherlands By Means of Partial Least Squares’,
  49. (1995). Territorial Dynamic, Innovative Milieus and Regional Policy’,
  50. (1999). The determinants of innovation: R&D, technology transfer and networking effects”,
  51. (1998). The Economic Possibilities for a Scottish Parliament’,
  52. (1999). The future of the high-skill equilibrium in Germany’, Oxford review of economic policy,
  53. (2000). The German Skill Creation System and Team Based Production: Competitive Asset or Liability?’, forthcoming
  54. (1997). The learning region: institutions, innovation and regional renewal,
  55. (1997). The learning region: institutions, innovation and regional renewal’,
  56. (2000). The learning region? Integrating gender equality into regional economic development’,
  57. (1991). The New Competition: Institutions of Industrial Restructuring’,
  58. (1997). Workplace Innovations in the Republic of Ireland’,