Location of Repository

Innovation and the Evolution of Market Structure for Internet Access in the United States

By Shane Greenstein


How and why did the U.S. commercial Internet access market structure evolve during its first decade? Commercial Internet access market structure arose from a propitious combination of inherited market structures from communications and computing, where a variety of firms already flourished and entrepreneurial norms prevailed. This setting nurtured innovative behavior across such key features as pricing, operational practices, and geographic coverage. Inherited regulatory decisions in communications markets had a nurturing effect on innovative activity. On-going regulatory decisions also shaped the market’s evolution, sometimes nurturing innovation and sometimes not. This narrative and analysis informs conjectures about several unique features of U.S. market structure and innovative behavior. It also informs policy debates today about the role of regulation in nurturing or discouraging innovation behavior.

OAI identifier:

Suggested articles



  1. (1992). 10 Once again, this is a simplification. See Kahin
  2. 2 To be sure, this is a statement about the size of activity, not the private or social rate of return on investment.
  3. (1995). 4 For example, see the series of studies on use by the National Telecommunications Information Administration (NTIA)
  4. (1999). 5 There is considerable writing in each of these veins. See e.g.,
  5. (1992). 7 This is a simplification of a complex history. See e.g.,
  6. (1999). 8 In an intriguing footnote,
  7. (2004). A Nation Online: Entering the Broadband Age.”
  8. (1998). aol.com: How Steve Case Beat Bill Gates, Nailed the Netheads, and Made Millions in the War for the Web, Random House;
  9. (1994). Arming American scientists: NSF and the provision of scientific computing facilities for universities, 1950-1973,”
  10. Avi Goldfarb, and Shane Greenstein 2003a “The geographic dispersion of commercial Internet use.”
  11. (2006). Broadband in the United States,” in (eds) Martin Fransman, Global Broadband Battles:
  12. (2000). Building and Delivering the Virtual World: Commercializing Services for Internet Access.”
  13. (1992). Building Information Infrastructure,
  14. (1995). Building the NSFNet: A Partnership
  15. (1999). Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace, Basic Books,
  16. (2001). Commercialization of the Internet: The Interaction of Public Policy and Private Actions,"
  17. (2002). Constructing the Divide: Spatial Disparities in
  18. (2006). Coordination Costs and Standard Setting: Lessons from 56K,” in (eds) Shane Greenstein and Victor Stango, Standards and Public Policy,
  19. (2006). Delay and de jure Standardization: Exploring the Slowdown
  20. (2006). Differentiated Entry into Competitive Telephony,”
  21. (2005). Digital crossroads: American telecommunications policy in the Internet age,
  22. (1998). Do Commercial ISPs Provide Universal Access?"
  23. (2002). Evaluating the Competitive Effects of
  24. (2003). Excessive (?) Entry of National Telecom Networks,
  25. (1998). Falling Through the Net II:
  26. (1995). Falling Through the Net: A Survey of the ‘Have Nots’
  27. (1997). Falling Through the Net: Defining the Digital Divide.”
  28. (1999). High Stakes, No Prisoners, A Winner’s Tale of Greed and Glory in the Internet Wars,
  29. (2005). How did Location Affect adoption of the Internet by Commercial Establishments? Urban density versus Global Village.”
  30. (2002). Information Technology Industries in the New
  31. (2001). Interconnecting the Network of Networks.
  32. (2001). Internet growth: Myth and reality, use and abuse,”
  33. (2006). Internet Traffic Exchange: Market Developments and Measurement of Growth, Working Paper on Telecommunication and Information Service Policies. OECD,
  34. (1993). Internet: Getting Started.
  35. (1999). Inventing the Internet,
  36. (2000). Local Access Pricing
  37. (2000). Local Access Pricing and E-Commerce.,
  38. (2001). Local Network Competition,"
  39. (2006). Making Waves: The Interplay between Market Incentives and Organizational Capabilities in the Evolution of Industries,” Working paper.
  40. Odlyzko (2006), “Internet Growth: Is there a Moore’s Law for Data Traffic?”
  41. (2006). Pricing at the On-Ramp for the Internet: Price Indices for ISPs in the 1990s.”
  42. (2005). Regulating Vertical Integration in Broadband: Open Access versus
  43. (2001). Rethinking the Design of the Internet: The End-to-End Arguments vs. The Brave New World.”
  44. (2002). Revenge of the Bellheads: How the Netheads Lost
  45. (2004). Ruling the Root : Internet Governance and the Taming of Cyberspace,
  46. (2006). Setting Standards in Markets: Browser Wars,”
  47. (2002). Setting the Stage: The New Economy Endures Despite Reduced
  48. (2006). Software Infrastructure of the Commercializing Internet” in (eds) William Aspray and Paul Ceruzzi, The Internet and American Business, forthcoming
  49. (2005). Statistical Abstract of the United States, 125 th Edition.,
  50. (2000). Stronger then Barbed Wire: How Geo-Policy Barriers Coinstruct Rural Internet Access,”
  51. (2004). Telecommunications and Computers: A Tale of Convergence,” in (ed) W. Aspray, Chasing Moore’s Law: Information Technology Policy in the United States. SciTech Publishing; Raleigh,
  52. (2002). Telecommunications and Rural Economies: Findings from the Appalachian Region,
  53. (2005). Ten Years after the 1996 Telecommunications Act.
  54. (1989). The Anticompetitive uses of Regulation: United States v. AT&T
  55. (2005). The Corporate Digital Divide:
  56. (2001). The demand for bandwidth: second telephone lines and on-line services.”
  57. (2000). The Digital Handshake: Connecting Internet Backbones,” Working Paper No. 32.,
  58. (2006). The Evolution of the Market Structure for Internet Access Greenstein ______________________________________________________________________________
  59. (2002). The Evolution of the Market Structure for Internet Access Greenstein ______________________________________________________________________________ ———.
  60. (2003). The Failure of Good Intentions: The WorldCom Fraud and the
  61. (1999). The FCC and the Unregulation of the Internet,” Working paper 31, Federal Communications Commission, Office of Planning and Policy,
  62. (2003). The Growth and Development of the Internet in the United States. in (ed) Bruce Kogut, The Global Internet Economy.
  63. (1996). The Internet Access Cookbook.
  64. (2006). The Internet before Commercialization” in (eds) William Aspray and Paul Ceruzzi, The Internet and American Business, forthcoming
  65. (1996). The Internet Report.
  66. (1995). The Internet Tidal Wave,” May 20. Internal Microsoft memo.
  67. (2002). The Origins and Evolution of the Internet,"
  68. (1998). The State of the Net: the New Frontier,
  69. (1997). The U.S. National Information Infrastructure Initiative: The Market, the Web, and the Virtual Project,”
  70. (1994). The Whole Internet - 2nd Edition. O'Reilly &
  71. (1992). The Whole Internet. O'Reilly &
  72. (2006). Understanding Why Universal Service Obligations May Be Unnecessary: The Private Development of Local Internet Access Markets,”
  73. Universal Access and Local
  74. (1999). Weaving the Web, The Original Design and Ultimate Destiny of the World Wide Web by Its Inventor, Harper Collins;
  75. (2002). Who Says Elephants Can’t Dance? Harper Collins;

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.