Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Patient dignity in nursing : a phemomenological study

By Miliica Ruth Matiti

Abstract

This research is concerned with patient dignity in nursing. It proposes the\ud introduction of the concept of Perceptual Adjustment Level (PAL) in order to resolve\ud the problem of the definition of patient dignity and its maintenance within nursing\ud care. The aims of the study are to identify how patients and nurses perceive patient\ud dignity, to investigate the extent to which patient dignity is maintained and to identify\ud nursing care activities in maintaining patient dignity. The implications of the findings\ud of this study for nursing education and the development of policy on clinical practice\ud are also examined.\ud \ud \ud The literature review revealed a paucity of research on patient dignity. There\ud was no clear definition of dignity that could be understood by both nurses and patients\ud during their day to day interaction. Little was known of the maintenance of patient\ud dignity and its influencing factors. A qualitative methodology utilising a\ud phenomenological approach was used. A total of 102 patients and 94 nurses from\ud medical and surgical wards in three hospitals within the United Kingdom were\ud interviewed using semi-structured interview techniques.\ud \ud \ud Although neither patients nor nurses specifically defined patient dignity, they\ud came up with similar categories in terms of how they perceived patient dignity:\ud privacy, respect, communication, the need for information, involvement in care,\ud independence, patients' choice, form of address, decency and confidentiality. Control\ud was only mentioned by patients. Although there was congruence between how the\ud patients and nurses described patient dignity, it emerged that nurses tended to operate\ud on different levels from how patients perceived the maintenance of their dignity.\ud While nurses utilised primarily their own perception of dignity to maintain patient\ud dignity, it was discovered that hospitalised patients went through a process of\ud adjustment of their notion of dignity and came to a level they could accept. As a\ud result a new concept termed Perceptual Adjustment Level (PAL) is proposed. Patients\ud felt dignified if events matched with this level. This research has, therefore, proposed\ud a tentative definition of patient dignity as the fulfilment of patients' expectations or\ud needs in terms of values within each patient's perceptual adjustment level taking into\ud account the hospital environment.\ud \ud \ud The need for assessing patients to discover their perceptual adjustment level\ud has been highlighted. A number of patients were satisfied with how their dignity was\ud maintained but a significant number were not. Ways of improving the maintenance of\ud patient dignity have also been proposed. In order to maintain patient dignity, nurses\ud should consider six questions: "what?" signifies the needs of dignity which should be\ud met. "Why?" highlights the importance of full explanations of the purpose of tasks\ud carried out on patients, and whether it matters to the patient. "Who?" relates to who is\ud going to perform the task on her or him? "Where?" considers whether privacy will be\ud ensured when the tasks will be done and "how?" sensitively the tasks will be done? It\ud is also important to make the patient aware "when?" tasks will be carried out. The\ud main factors that influenced the maintenance of patient dignity are revealed and\ud implications for nursing practice, management, education and research are discussed

Topics: RT, RA
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.hud.ac.uk:4599

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1985). (a) Nursing: Human Science and Human Care - A Theor y of Nursing. Appleton - Century - Crofts.
  2. (1985). (b) Nursing - The Philosophy and Science of Caring. Colorado
  3. (1990). (Ed). Nursing Research Methods, Critical Appraisal and Utilisation. The C. V. Mosby Company. St Louis.
  4. (2000). A Broad Minded.
  5. (1993). A Concept Analysis of Withdrawal: Application of Hybrid Model of Concept Development. In
  6. (1993). A Conceptual Clarification of Respect.
  7. (1990). A Dictionar y of Nursing Theory and Research. Sage Publications.
  8. (1999). A First Class Service or A First Class Headache.
  9. (1995). A Hermeneutic Study of the Experiences of relatives of Critically ill Patients.
  10. (1975). A Hospital Stress Rating Scale.
  11. (1986). A Hybrid Model for Concept Development. In
  12. (1991). A Method of Analysing Interview Transcripts in Qualitative Research. Nursing Education Today.
  13. (1992). A New Introduction to Sociolog y Theories.
  14. A Philosophy of Nursing. What is it? What is it not? In
  15. (1997). A Study to Ascertain Gynaecological Patient's Perceived Levels of Embarrassment with Physical and Psychological Care given by Female and Male Nurses.
  16. (1998). African Social and Cultural Structures - An Invaluable Resource for Professionals and Voluntary Organisations.
  17. (1997). An Introduction to Research for Midwives Books for Midwives Press. Hochland and Hochiand Ltd.
  18. (2000). Analysis and Evaluation of Contemporary Nursing Knowledge - Nursing Models and Theories.
  19. (1991). Approaches to Qualitative and Quantitative Methodological Triangulation.
  20. (1968). Asylums Harmondsworth.
  21. (1961). Asylums: Essays on Social Situation of Mental Patients and other Inmates.
  22. (1997). At Risk from Gender Care? Nursin g Management Vol
  23. (1990). Basic of Oualitative Research,
  24. (1998). Basic Steps in Planning Nursing Research. From Ouestion to Proposal. Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
  25. (1994). Bioethics - A Nursing Pers pective.
  26. (1982). Body and Self - A Dialect: In
  27. (2001). Care:
  28. (1988). Care: The Essence of Nursing and Health. In
  29. (1997). Caring and Communicatin g - The Interpersonal Relationship in Nursing.
  30. (1966). Childhood and Society.
  31. (1997). Choosing a Strategy for Concept Analysis in Nursing Research: Moving Beyond Wilson. In
  32. (1951). Client - Centred Therapy, its Current Practices, Implications and Theory.
  33. (1967). Communicating with the Patient.
  34. (1989). Concept Analysis and Development of Nursing Knowledge. The Evolutionary Cycle.
  35. (1994). Concept Clarification in Professional Practice.
  36. (1982). Concept Clarification: An Overview. In
  37. (1991). Concise Dictionary and Thesaurus.
  38. (1996). Considering Nursing Resource 'Caring Time'.
  39. (1994). Critical Care Today. In
  40. (1985). Death with Dignity.
  41. (1994). Declaration on the Promotion of Patient's Rights
  42. (1995). Designing samples. In
  43. (1999). Dignity and Health: The UDHR's Revolutionary First Article. Health and the Rights.
  44. (1990). Dignity in Dementia. Nz Nursing Journal.
  45. (1999). Dignity: The Study of Preoperative Patients.
  46. (2000). Doctor-patient Communication about Drugs: The Evidence for Shared Decision Making. Soc Sci Med
  47. (1983). Doctors Style. In
  48. (1975). Doing Phenomenolo gy. Essays on and in Phenomenology.
  49. (1981). Effective Evaluation. Jossey - Bass Publishers.
  50. (1990). English Dictionary. New Edition. Heinemann Educational.
  51. (1988). Ethical Considerations in Qualitative Research.
  52. (1995). Ethical Issues in Research.
  53. (2000). Ethical issues. In
  54. (1998). Evaluating Methods for Collecting Data in Published Research. In
  55. (1998). Exploratory Designs. In
  56. (1997). Exploring the Concept of Undocumentedness: The Meaning of A Person's Immigration Status to Nursing Care. In
  57. (1997). Exploring the Meaning of Dissatisfaction with Health Care: Towards a Grounded Theory. PhD Thesis.
  58. (1991). Factors Which Influence How Nurses Communicate with Cancer Patients.
  59. (1994). Focus on Qualitative Methods - The use of Quotes
  60. (1986). From Practice to Grounded Theory: Oualitative Research in Nursin g. Manlo Park.
  61. (1993). Fundamental Skills and Concepts in Patient .
  62. (1948). Groundwork of Metaphysic of Morals (Translated by PATON H.J), Harper and Row Publishers.
  63. (1990). Guidance Standards for Residential Homes for Elderly People - Caring for Ouality.
  64. (1997). Health Care, Human Worth and the Limits of the Particular.
  65. (1998). Health Communication -Strategies for Health Professionals. Appleton and Lange.
  66. (1990). Historic and Epistemological Dimensions of Care and Caring with Future Directions. In
  67. (1971). Human Dignity and the Promise of Technology.
  68. (1970). Human Rights and Human Dignity. In
  69. (1975). Humanising Health Care.
  70. (2001). Humour between nurse and patient, among staff: analysis of nurses' diaries.
  71. (1996). Implementation of a Philosophy, Rigor and Representation.
  72. (1991). In Defence of Modernity - Role Complex and Individual Autonomy.
  73. (2000). Including the Person with Dementia In Designin g and Delivering Care.
  74. (1969). Individual Behaviour - A Perpetual Approach to Behaviour. Harper
  75. (1999). Integrating Communication Skills and Historytaking.
  76. (1973). International Code for Nurses - Ethical Conce pts Applied to Nursing.
  77. (1971). Interpersonal Aspects of Nursing.
  78. (1991). Learning to Live Again: Other Process of Adjustment following a Heart Attack in
  79. (1968). Levianthan. Penguin Books. London
  80. (1990). Limited Autonomy and Partnership: Professional Relationships in Health Care.
  81. (1992). Living with Altered Body Image: The Cancer Experience.
  82. (1990). Lo gic of Practice.
  83. (1978). Loss and Grief in Medicine. Bailliere Tindall.
  84. (1999). Made to Measure. Health Services Journal.
  85. (2001). Maintaining the Dignity and Autonomy of Older People.
  86. (1999). Making a Difference. Strengthening the Nursin g Midwifery and Health Visiting Contribution to Health and Health Care.
  87. (1992). Making Time for Patients.
  88. (1994). Managin g Health Services-Effective Communication. The Open University. Milton Keynes - 241 -NHS
  89. (1994). Medical Ethics-The Moral Responsibilities of Physicians.
  90. (1934). Mind. Self and Society.
  91. (1997). Mixed is No.
  92. (1993). Mobility: A Concept Analysis.
  93. (1988). New Dimensions of Human Caring Theory.
  94. (2000). Not because they are Old". An Independent Inquiry into the Care of Older People on Acute Wards in General Hospitals, Health Advisory Service
  95. (1994). Nurseclient Interaction. Implementing the Nursing Process.
  96. (1989). Nurses Perception of Stress in Preoperative Surgical Patients.
  97. (1995). Nursin g and Health-care Research - A Practical Guide.
  98. (1979). Nursing -The Philosophy and Science of Caring. Little, Brown and Company.
  99. (1997). Nursing as A Moral Art in
  100. (1996). Nursing Elderly People with Dignity and Respect.
  101. (1996). Nursing Research - The Ap plication of Qualitative Approaches. Croom Helm.
  102. (1985). Nursing Research - The Application of Qualitative Approaches.
  103. (1974). On Being Ignored: The Effects of the Violation of Implicit Rules of Social Interaction.
  104. (1970). On Death
  105. (1990). Ouestiormaire and Interviewing.
  106. (2002). Party Leaders Trade Blows in NIHS war over Rose. 94. The Times. Thursday,
  107. (1990). Patient Participation: The Literature.
  108. (1989). Patients' and Nurses Perceptions of Symptoms of Distress in Cancer.
  109. (2001). Patients' Perceptions of Selfdetermination as Expressed in the Context Care.
  110. (1994). Patients' Privacy -
  111. (1973). Personal Control Over Aversive Stimuli and Its Relationship to Stress.
  112. (1959). Phenomenological Analysis: Exemplified in a Study of the Experience of Being Really Understood,
  113. (1976). Philosophical Hermeneutics (Translated and Edited by
  114. (2000). Philosophy of Nursing - A New Vision of Health Care.
  115. (1992). planning Ethically Responsible Research- A Guide for Students and Internal Review Borth.
  116. (1998). Populations and Samples: Identifying the Boundaries of
  117. (1991). Power in the Caring Professions.
  118. (1992). Preserving Dignity for Disabled.
  119. (1967). Principles and Practice of Nursing.
  120. (1967). Privacy and Freedom.
  121. (1998). Privacy in Hospital.
  122. (1978). Privacy. In
  123. (1994). Private enterprise (Organising a Ward to Ensure Patient
  124. (1997). Professional Identity: Values Embedded in Meaningful Nursing Practice.
  125. (1997). Promoting Autonomy and Independence For Older People Within Nursing Practice: A Literature Review.
  126. (1978). Psychological Research as Phenomenologists View It. In
  127. (1992). Psychology - The Science of Mind
  128. (1993). Psychology and Health Care. Bailliere Tindall.
  129. (1997). Psychology in Counselling and Therapeutic Practice.
  130. (1995). Qualitative Interviews in Medical Research.
  131. (1999). Qualitative Methods. In
  132. (1992). Qualitative Research Meaning and Language.
  133. (1993). Real World Research.
  134. (1998). Recognizing Research Processes in Research - Based Literature. In
  135. (2001). Register 37. Autumn
  136. (1990). Research Involving Patients.
  137. (2001). Respect. Nursing Times.
  138. (1990). Respecting Clients' Dignity. In
  139. (1995). Rigour and Qualitative Research.
  140. (1994). Schools of Phenomenology: Implications for Research.
  141. (1970). Shame.
  142. (1985). Sketch of a Psychological Phenomenological Method. In
  143. (2000). Society - The Basics. Prentice Hall.
  144. (1988). Strategies for Theor y Construction in Nursing. Appleton and Lange.
  145. (2001). Supporting Medical Students to take Responsibility for Developing their Communication Skills.
  146. (1984). Targets for Health for All, WHO Regional Office for Europe.
  147. (1990). Terminal Care Support Teams - The Hospital-Hospice.
  148. (1993). The A-Z of Quality - A Guide to quality Initiatives in the N}IS. NHS Management Executive.
  149. (1975). the Behavioural Measure: Conceptualising, Researching and Analysing Psychological Factors in Nursing Research.
  150. (1996). The Canadian Nursing Issues and Perspectives.
  151. (2001). The concept of Care in Male Nurse Work: An Ontological Hermeneutic Study in Acute Hospitals.
  152. (1978). The Concept Of Nursing Diagnosis. In
  153. (1994). The Concept of Respect in Nursing.
  154. (1964). The Conduct of Inquiry.
  155. (1994). The Delphi Technique: A Worthwhile Research Approach for Nursing.
  156. (1988). The Delphi technique: It's Contribution to the Evaluation of Professional Practice In
  157. (1989). The Delphi Technique. The Australian
  158. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research.
  159. (1989). The Effects of Nursing Care on Human Di gnity in Critically Ill Adults. Dissertation,
  160. (1993). The Elements of Moral Philosoith y. McGraw-Hill Inc.
  161. (2001). The Essence of Care. Patient - Focused Benchmarking for Health Care Practitioners.
  162. (1993). The Handbook for Care Assistants and Health Care Support Workers. A Care Concern Publication.
  163. (1992). The Health of Health Care Organisations. Work Stress.
  164. (1966). The Hidden Dimension. Double Day.
  165. (1973). The Homeless Mind -Modernisation and Consciousness. Random House Vintage.
  166. (2000). The Human Rights Act - A Practical Guide for Nurses.
  167. (1990). The Hybrid Model for Concept Development: It's Value for the Study of Therapeutic Alliance.
  168. (1953). The Interpersonal Theory of Psychiatry.
  169. (2001). The Interplay of Knowledge and Decision Making between Doctors and Nurses in Critical Care.
  170. (1998). The Meaning of Patient Satisfaction: An Exploration of high reported levels. Social Science and Medicine.
  171. (1990). The Midwifery Process. In
  172. (1975). The Need for a Conceptual Framework. In
  173. (2001). The NT-IS Plan - An Action Guide for Nurses, Midwives and Health Visitors.
  174. (1997). The Nurse Communicates.
  175. (1994). The Observation of Intimate Aspects of Care: Privacy and Dignity. In
  176. (1995). The Paradox of Comfort.
  177. (1993). The Participation of Hospital Nurses in the Multidisciplinary Ward Round on a Cancer-therapy Ward.
  178. (1991). The Patient Chater's- A Charter for Health Scotland.
  179. (1992). The Patient's Charter-Raising Standards.
  180. (1976). The Power of Name. Pychology Toda y.
  181. (2000). The Practical Implications of Teaching Philosophy to Practitioners: Dignity - A Pilot Study.
  182. (2001). The Practice of Nursin g Research: Conduct, Critique, and Utilisation.
  183. (1986). The Problem of Rigor
  184. (1995). The Professional Nurse - Coping With Change. Now and The Future. Chapman and Hall.
  185. (1991). The Professional Values of English Nursing Graduates.
  186. (1968). The Psychology of Being.
  187. (1980). The Psychology of the Sick Bed.
  188. (1992). The Role of the Nurse on the Consultant's Ward Round. Nursing Times.
  189. (1990). The Social Knowledge and Social Development. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly.
  190. (1951). The Social System. The Free Press.
  191. (1983). Theor y and Nursing - A Systematic Approach.
  192. (1995). Theor y and Nursing - A Systematic Approach. The C.V.
  193. (2000). Theories of Reflection for Learning. In
  194. (1997). Thinking and Caring: New Perspective on Reflection. In
  195. (1963). Thinking with Conce pts.
  196. (1996). Towards Further Clarification of the Concept of Dignity.
  197. (1994). Understandin g Patients. Bailliere Tindall.
  198. (1993). Understandin g Research - A Scientific Approach for Health Care Professionals.
  199. (1992). Understanding/Responding - A Communication Manual For Nurses.
  200. (2001). Valuing People as Individuals: Development of an Instrument through a survey of Person-centredness in Secondary Care.
  201. (1998). Ward Rounds: Is the Nursing Contribution Still Devalued?
  202. (1989). Watson's Philosophy and Theory of Human Caring in Nursing.
  203. (1996). Watson's Theory of Trans Personal Caring. In
  204. (1998). With Respect to Old Age: Long Term Care - Rights and Responsibilities - A Report by Royal Commission on Long Term Care.
  205. (1985). World Book Encyclopaedia.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.