Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Professional identities, inter-professional relationships and collaborative working : an investigation using a constructivist phenomenological approach

By Angela Ross


This research project sets out to explore, analyse and theorise the way district nurses\ud and social care workers construe their identity, and their relationships within the\ud changing context of collaborative projects. Unlike previous research in this field, this\ud project offers an alternative, relational view of exploring professional identities and\ud inter-professional relationships. The research adopted a constructivist\ud phenomenological approach drawing upon the theories of personal construct\ud psychology (Kelly, 1955) and existential phenomenology (Merleau Ponty, 1962), as\ud elaborated by Butt (2004, 1998).\ud \ud \ud The project consists of three studies. The first empirical work is a preliminary study\ud using individual interviews of students undertaking degree courses in community\ud nursing or social work. This study is concerned with examining the students' concepts\ud of what it means to belong to a particular occupational group and the influences that\ud shape their ideas. Using focus groups and individual interviews, the second study\ud explores how district nurses and social care workers negotiate their identity as a result\ud of national changes and service developments. The final study explores interprofessional\ud relationships of individual district nurses and social care workers, using\ud reflective interview techniques (Hargreave, 1979, Salmon, 2003).\ud \ud \ud In keeping with phenomenological methodology, data was analysed using template\ud analysis (King, 2004). A number of emerging constructs were identified that highlight\ud the personal, historical and contextual influences upon professional role construction\ud and inter-professional relationships, notably: visibility and recognition, role flexibility\ud and rigidity. In particular the findings illustrate how professional identity is\ud constructed, challenged, and reconstructed, through on-going interaction. To facilitate\ud role re-construction and sociality, the reflective interview techniques were adapted\ud and extended to encourage practitioners to reflect upon their every-day practice and\ud relationships when working in a multi-disciplinary setting

Topics: RT, HV, RA
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1999). A Grounded Hermeneutic Editing Approach,
  2. (1979). A History of the Nursing Profession, Frome and London: Butler and Tanner Ltd.
  3. (2003). A psychology for teachers, in F.Fransella (ed)
  4. (1991). A social psychology of organizing: People, processes and contexts, NY and London: Harvester Wheat sheaf.
  5. (1954). A Theory of Social Comparison Processes, Human Relations
  6. (1989). An Introduction to ExistentialPhenomenological Thought in Psychology,
  7. (1999). An introduction to Qualitative Research,
  8. (1988). An Introduction to the Social History of Nursing,
  9. (1991). An introduction to the social identity approach
  10. (1999). Are focus groups an appropriate tool for studying organisa√ľonal change? in
  11. (1934). Attitudes versus actions,
  12. (2000). Boundary work and the (un) making of the professions,
  13. (1989). Caring for people: Community Care in the next decade and beyond.
  14. (1999). Clinical Research: A Multimethod Typology and Qualitative Roadmap,
  15. (2000). Code of conduct, ethical principles and guidelines,
  16. (1981). Collaboration between the health and social services: Parti, A case study of joint care planning,
  17. (1980). Collaboration in Organizations : Alternatives to Hierarchy, NY and London:
  18. (2001). Collaboration, facilities and communities in day care services for older people,
  19. (2000). Collaborative care Inter-professional Interagency and inter-professional London:
  20. (1998). Collaborative care,
  21. (1988). Comments on the motivational status of self-esteem in social identity and inter-group discussion.
  22. (1991). Community Care, G. in Scrambler (ed) Sociology as applied to medicine, London: Bai here Tindall.
  23. (1988). Community care: Agenda forAction.
  24. (1997). Constructivism and the logic of explanation,
  25. (1994). Constructivist, Intepretist approaches to human inquiry,
  26. (1992). Contact and Collaboration with General Practitioners: A comparison of social workers and community Psychiatric Nurses,
  27. (1993). Conversational realities: Constructing life through language,
  28. (1994). Coordinating Community care,
  29. (1996). Council for Nursing Midwifery and Health Visiting,
  30. (1998). Creaking Joints,
  31. (1987). District Nursing edition,
  32. (1995). Diverse Identities,
  33. (1999). Doing Interpretative Analysis In
  34. (2000). Doing Qualitative Research; A Practical Handbook,
  35. (2002). Embedding practice based, Inter-professional education into the curriculem.
  36. (1995). Ethical Conflicts in Psychology,
  37. (1988). Ethics and values in applied social research London: Sage publications.
  38. (1999). Evaluation of the Fast Response Scheme: Part one - Staff reactions. Unpublished report.
  39. (1981). Experimental study of positive and negative intergroup attitudes between experimentally produced groups. Oklahoma: Strong and Robinson.
  40. (1999). First Assessment a review of district nursing services in England and
  41. (1998). From collaboration to commissioning: developing relationships between primary health and social services,
  42. (2002). From Triangle to Spiral: Reflective practice
  43. (1996). Fundamental Considerations about Work Groups,
  44. (1970). George Kelly: Constructive Innocent and Reluctant Existentialist,
  45. (1984). grids are all very well, but....'
  46. (1967). Group conflict and Co-operation London: Routledge and Kegan Paul Ltd.
  47. (1996). Group construing: The impact of professional training,
  48. (1991). Health Professions,
  49. (1995). Innovation and Change,
  50. (1997). Inter-professional collaboration: problems and prospects,
  51. (1994). Inter-professional developments in Britain: an overview,
  52. (2000). Inter-professional Education Today, Yesterday and Tomorrow: A review commissioned by The learning and teaching Support Network for
  53. (2001). Inter-professional team working: what makes a team work well?
  54. (1991). Intergroup contact: Social identity and social cognition,
  55. (1996). Intergroup relations in Organizations,
  56. (1985). Interview Methodologies for Construct Elicitation: Searching for the Core, in F.Epting and A.W. Landfield (eds.) Anticipating Personal Construct Psychology, Lincoln and London:
  57. (1996). InterViews : An introduction to Qualitative Research Interviewing, London: Sage publications.
  58. (1996). Introducing focus groups,
  59. (2000). Introducing qualitative research in psychology, adventures in theory and method,
  60. (1999). Introduction: the challenge of focus groups,
  61. (2003). Involvement in innovation: the role of identity,
  62. (1999). Key informants,
  63. (2001). Learning for inter-professional and interagency practice in the new social work curriculum: evidence from earlier research study.
  64. (1998). Life Histories,
  65. (1995). Life Story Research,
  66. (1992). Living and relating: An introduction to phenomenology,
  67. (2001). Looking back on social work education,
  68. (2000). Making Organizational Change to Achieve Improvement and Inter-professional Learning: Perspectives from Health Professions Educators,
  69. (1998). Managing multidisciplinary teams in the NHS.
  70. (1934). Mind Self and Society, Chicago and London:
  71. (1994). Models of inter-professional work, likely theories and possibilities, in A. Leathard (ed) Going Inter-professional: Working Together for Health and Welfare,
  72. (1985). Naturalistic Inquiry,
  73. (1993). Nurse education- A reflective Approach,
  74. (1983). Nursing in Society: A historical perspective,
  75. (2000). Nursing The Image; media culture and professional identity.
  76. (2002). Organisational Behavioural Analysis An integrated approach,2" edition,
  77. (2000). Organisational culture and quality of health care,
  78. (2000). Paradigmatic controversies, contradictions and emerging confluences,
  79. (1999). Partnerships in Primary and Social Care: integrating services for vulnerable people,
  80. (1996). PCP: Cognitive or social psychology?"
  81. (2000). Personal Construct Psychology, Constructivism and Postmodern thought. Hrl:
  82. (1994). Phenomenological research Methods,
  83. (1977). Phenomenology and the social world: the philosophy of MerleauPonty and its relation to the social sciences, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  84. (1962). Phenomenology of Perception,
  85. (1998). Philosophical Dimensions of Personal Construct psychology, London and
  86. (1979). Politics and I dentity in South Africa,
  87. (1992). Postmodern Epistemology of Practice,
  88. (1992). Primary Care Teamwork- making it a reality,
  89. (1999). Primary health care and social care: working across professional boundaries, Part one; The changing context of inter-professional relationships,
  90. (1994). Principles of Biomedic Ethics,
  91. (1993). Processes of managing strategic change,
  92. (2001). Profesionalism the third logic,
  93. (1969). Professional employees in a bureaucratic structure: Social work,
  94. (1997). Professional Personhood: training territoriality and tolerance,
  95. (1999). Professionalisation and professionalism: issues for inter-professional care,
  96. (1998). Professionalisation and the caring professions,
  97. (2000). Professionalism and Boundaries of the former sector: the example of social and community care",
  98. (2000). Professionalism definitions in 'managing' health services: perspectives on the differing views of clinicians and general mangers in an NHS Trust,
  99. (1998). Professions and Community Nursing,
  100. (1992). Professions and patriarchy,
  101. (1998). Prospects of Partnership",
  102. (1996). Psychological Constuctivisms: A Metatheoretical Differentiation,
  103. (2002). Qualitative data AnalysIs: Explorations with Nvivo, Buckiiigham;
  104. (2002). Qualitative Research in Nursing,
  105. (1998). Qualitative research methods in health technology assessment: a review of the literature, Basingstoke: The Basingstoke press.
  106. (1999). Quality in Qualitative Research,
  107. (1997). Realities and Relationships: Soundings in Social Construction. London:
  108. (1964). Reference groups: exploration into conformity and deviation of adolescents.
  109. (1931). reprint) Fact and Essence,
  110. (1999). Research practice Settings: A case study approach,
  111. (1992). Researching Lived Experience, Human Science for an action sensitive pedagogy,
  112. (1996). Rigour and Qualitative research,
  113. (1997). Sedimentation and Elaborative Choice,
  114. (1993). Self and Other: Communication and Love, in K.Hoelle (ed) Merleau Ponly and Psychology,
  115. (1995). Semi Sthictured Interviewing and Qualitative Analysis,
  116. (1969). Semi-professionalism and social work: A theoretical perspective,
  117. (1992). Shaping strategic change: making change in large organizations: The case of the National Health Service,
  118. Shifting the balance of power within the NHS,
  119. (1979). Social being a theory for social psychology,
  120. (1978). Social Change and The Development of the Nursing Profession:
  121. (1999). Social Identfications: A Social psychology of intergroup relations and group processes,
  122. (1991). Social Influence, Bucks:
  123. (1990). Social motivation, self-esteem and social identity,
  124. (1979). Social Networks and Interpersonal Constructs,
  125. (1984). Social Psychology and Organisational change,
  126. (1999). Social work and Social Care,
  127. (1997). Social work and Society,
  128. (1998). Social work in Practice: An evaluation of the care management received by elderly people from social workers based in GP practices in South Worcestershire,
  129. (1983). Sociality and Cognition in personal construct theory,
  130. (1998). Sociality, role and Embodiment,
  131. (1982). Studying Intergroup Relations Embedded in Organizations,
  132. (1969). Symbolic Interactionism, Englewood Cliffs. NJ:Prentice Hall.
  133. (1997). Technioques of validation in qualitative research: A practical commentary,
  134. (1994). The Art of Interviewing,
  135. (2000). The Challenge of Professionalism.,
  136. (1990). The Community Care Act,
  137. (1977). The community of self,
  138. (1987). The contact hypothesis in intergroup relations,
  139. (1998). The foundations of Social Research: Meaning and Perspective in the Research Process. London: Sage publications.
  140. (1997). The introduction of a hospital at home service: a staff perspective,
  141. (1985). The Man Who Mistook His Wjfe for a Hat,
  142. (1998). The monastic tradition and community care
  143. (2002). The person in social psychology,
  144. (1979). The personal and Interpersonal in Construct Theory: Social and Individual Aspects of Relationships,
  145. (1930). The phenomenology of Edmund Husserl: The Paris Lectures,
  146. (2003). The Problem Of Bracketing in Phenomenology,
  147. (1989). The professionalisation of nursing: the uncertain path,
  148. (1994). The psychology of Interpersonal Behaviour,
  149. (1955). The Psychology of personal Constructs, Volume one: A theory of Personality,
  150. (1991). The Psychology of Personal Constructs, Volume two: Clinical diagnosis and psychotherapy,
  151. (1967). The Psychology of the Unknown,
  152. (2000). The retreat from professionalism,
  153. (1977). The Rise of Professionalism; a sociological analysis,
  154. (1967). The social construction of reality; a treatise in the sociology of knowledge,
  155. (1995). The Social Construction Of validity,
  156. (1989). The Social Psychology of Work 2nd edition,
  157. (1995). The Sociology of Professions.
  158. (1997). The teamwork experience: An investigation into the personal constructs of shift managers, team leaders and team members:
  159. (1983). The theory of Profession: State of the Art,
  160. (1998). The use of Self in qualitative research, in J.T.E, Richards (ed) Handbook of Qualitative research methods for psychology and social science.
  161. (1998). The use of Stories,
  162. (2002). The Victoria Climbie Inquiry. Norwich HMSO. Available:
  163. (1999). The way forward for joint working? Involving primary care in the commissioning of social services,
  164. (1994). Theories of Intergroup relations; International Social psychological perspectives, 2nI edition,
  165. (2003). Three Epistemological Stances for qualitative Inquiry: Interpretivisim, Hermeneutics, and Social Constructionism,
  166. (2004). Understanding People, Basingstoke: Paigrave Macmillan
  167. (1993). User participation and Inter-professional Collaboration in Community Care.
  168. (2004). Using templates in the thematic analysis of text,
  169. (1995). War and peace among the health tribes in
  170. (2003). What is Social Work? Context and Perspectives ,
  171. (1993). When to use focus groups and Why,
  172. (1993). Why change programmes don't produce change?
  173. (1990). Women As Healer,
  174. (1987). Women as providers of health care, NY: World Health Organization Publications.
  175. (1997). Working Together,
  176. (1994). Working together: Lessons for collaboration between health and social services,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.