Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

An exploration of conflict handling among Quakers

By Susan Margaret Robson

Abstract

The Quaker community is committed to conflict resolution; it might be expected that\ud the community itself is conflict free. This study explores this proposition and presents\ud a counter narrative: conflict does exist among Quakers, with its roots in the culture of\ud the organization.\ud \ud \ud An ethnographic case study was undertaken in a context of observing participation,\ud where the researcher was also actively responsible inside the organization. The\ud project included: 39 semi-structured interviews with Key Informants, Grassroots\ud Quakers and Edge Quakers; a collaborative inquiry workshop with 20 self-selected\ud participants; recording of reflections over six months with a final workshop.\ud \ud \ud The study finds a dominant community narrative telling how the Quaker task is to\ud 'mend the world' and live in a'peaceable kingdom'. This is achieved by ignoring\ud conflict within the organization, defensively following the maxim 'don't ask, don't tell,\ud don't even think about it'. A distinctive pattern of conflict handling is revealed;\ud aversion precedes avoidance, relationship is privileged above outcome, and\ud moderation and restraint are required. Conflict which does surface and persists\ud focuses on the interpretation of Quaker identity. The culture of aversion from conflict\ud makes it difficult for Quakers to articulate conflict experience; they lack confidence\ud and are hesitant. Counter narratives and personal narratives are not made public.\ud Consequently there are very few collectively articulated stories about Quaker conflict\ud handling.\ud \ud \ud A constructivist narrative framework acknowledges the power in the internalised\ud collective narrative. As proud individual nonconformists, Quakers minimise the\ud coercive power of the collective narrative, which positions them as stultified in\ud conflict, with their agency neutralized. It is argued that one way of creating radical\ud change is to encourage the telling of more stories of Quaker conflict, providing new\ud parts in the play

Topics: HT, BR, HN, BX
OAI identifier: oai:eprints.hud.ac.uk:5945

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1997). A Community of Interests: Semai Conflict Resolution. In
  2. (1963). A Conceptual Scheme for Organizational Analysis. Administrative Science Quarterly,
  3. (1998). A Godless Unitarian Quaker Buddhist.
  4. (1988). A Minority of One. London: Quaker Home Service.
  5. (1997). A Participatory Inquiry Paradigm.
  6. (1995). A Sociological Analysis of the Modem Quaker Movement. Unpublished
  7. (1996). A Sociological Analysis of the Theology of Quakers.
  8. (1963). A Theory of Personality: The Psychology of Personal Constructs.
  9. (2002). A Time for Stories. Quaker Monthly.
  10. (2000). Action Research in Organisations. London and
  11. (2001). Action Science: Creating Communities of Inquiry in Communities of Practice. In
  12. (2003). Adjoining `Quaken Wood" for retreat and nature study. New for
  13. (2000). Against Speech. In Consequences: Peterloo Poets.
  14. (1997). An Indian Tapestry.
  15. (1988). An Interview. Whole Earth Review,
  16. (1995). An Introduction to Social Constiuctionism.
  17. (1678). Apology for the true Christian Divinity.
  18. (1997). Argyrrs & Schön's theory on congruence and learning ion line] Available at www.
  19. (1949). Authority, Leadership and Concern.
  20. (2000). Becoming Adult Becoming Christian. San Francisco:
  21. (1994). Being Together. London: Quaker Home Service & Woodbrooke College.
  22. (1989). Between psychology and psychotherapy.
  23. (1993). Beyond Consensus - Salvaging the Sense of the Meeting. Pendle Hill Pamphlet 307:
  24. (1983). Beyond Majority Rule: Philadelphia Yearly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends.
  25. (1986). Beyond Power and Control: Toward a second order family systems therapy. Family Systems Medicine,
  26. (1993). Beyond Two Dimensions: a Grounded Theory Model of Conflict Handling Behaviour.
  27. (1995). Boundaries of The Soul: The Practice of Jung's Psychology.
  28. (1992). Bringing Conflict out from behind the Scenes. In
  29. (1995). British Quakers and Conflict: a directory of projects. Quaker Peace and Service and Quaker Social Responsibility and Education.
  30. (1962). Building the Institutions of Peace. London: Quaker Home Service.
  31. (1989). Case Study Research: Design and Methods Sage,
  32. (1974). Change: Principles of Problem Formation and Problem Resolution.
  33. (1995). Chapter 9. Stages of Group Development and The Group Imago. In
  34. (1950). Childhood and Society.
  35. (1989). Children Act
  36. (1931). Church Government. Religious Society of Friends.
  37. (1998). Claiming the Prizes of Assertiveness: Gender and Conflict Handling Intentions among some Yorkshire Managers.
  38. (2002). Co-operative Inquiry: Changing Interprofessional Practice. Systemic Practice and Action Research,
  39. (2003). Co-operative Inquiry. In
  40. (1995). Collins Dictionary of Sociology.
  41. (2000). Community Narratives: Tales of Terror and Joy.
  42. (2001). Conclusion: Broadening the Bandwidth of Validity: lssues and Choice Points for Improving the Quality of Action Research. In
  43. (2003). Confession, catharsis or cure? Rethinking the uses of reflexivity as methodological power in qualitative research?
  44. (1997). Conflict Avoidance and Resolution Among the Toraja of South Sulawesi, Indonesia. In
  45. (1999). Conflict in Congregations. In
  46. (1997). Conflict Resolution in Native Margariteno Society. In
  47. (1984). Conflict Resolution in Quaker Families.
  48. (1997). Conflict within Interdependence: Its value for productivity and individuality. In
  49. (1997). Congregation and Community.
  50. (2004). Congregations, Narratives and Identity. A Quaker Case Study. In
  51. (2002). Connecting Anthropology and Quakerism: Transcending the Insider/Outsider Dichotomy.
  52. (1998). Constructive Conflicts: From Escalation to Revolution. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield.
  53. (1999). Contemporary Conflict Resolution.
  54. (2004). Contemporary Quakerism and the Reflexive Self. In
  55. (1989). Contingency, Irony and Solidarity. Cambridge:
  56. (1995). Crisis and Renewal.
  57. (1997). Cultural Variation in Conflict Resolution.
  58. (1992). Cultures of War and Peace: A comparative study of Waorani and Semai. In
  59. (1995). Designing Qualitative Research. Thousand Oaks,
  60. (1977). Developing a Forced-Choice Measure
  61. (2003). Discourse Analysis. In
  62. (1997). Disquiet in The Land.
  63. (1996). Division of Labour in the Social Construction of Argument.
  64. (2000). Doing Qualitative Research Differently.
  65. (2003). e-mail from Bob Hale.
  66. (1951). Effects of Group Pressure on the Modification and Distortion of Judgement. In
  67. (1912). Elementary Forms of Religious Life.
  68. (1992). Emergence v Forcing: Basics of Grounded Theory Analysis. Mill
  69. (2002). Establishing a Co-operative Inquiry Group: The Perspective of a "First Time Inquirer". Systemic Practice and Action Research,
  70. (1995). Extract 20.71. In
  71. (1986). Family Therapy.
  72. (1998). FAU The Third Generation: Friends Ambulance Unit Post War Service and International Service.
  73. (1949). Fierce Feathers. In A Book of Quaker Saints. London: Longmans Green
  74. (2000). Fighting among Friends: The Quaker Separation of 1827. In
  75. (1994). First Among Friends:
  76. (2003). Focus Groups. In
  77. (1997). Fragmentation and the Sense of Self. In Construct sms in the Human Sciences.
  78. (1989). Friendly Patriotism: British Quakerism and the Imperial Nation 1890-1910. Unpublished Ph. D.,
  79. (1988). Friends Divided: Conflict and Division in the Society of Friends.
  80. (2003). Friends Quarterly. What Jesus means to me.
  81. (1996). Friends? Reaching Out, 18,4-6. Quaker Home Service QHS.
  82. (1999). From 'The Woman's' Point of View: Feminist Approaches to Organization Studies. In
  83. (1998). From God's Time to Historical Time: Secular Amillennialism. In
  84. (1996). From LYMBO to BYMBO.
  85. (2001). From Religion to Ethics: Quaker Amillennialism. In
  86. (1984). From the Native's Point of View: on The Nature of Anthropological Understanding. In
  87. (1998). George Fox: The Journal.
  88. (2002). Going Native in Reverse": The Insider as Researcher In British Wicca. In
  89. (1991). Gospel Order. A Quaker Understanding of Faithful Church Community.
  90. (1992). Grounded Hermeneutic Research. In
  91. (2000). Grounded Theory: Objectivist and Constructivist Methods.
  92. (1965). Group Psychotherapy. The Psychoanalytic Approach.
  93. (1999). Group Therapies and Group Dynamics www. humannature. com/rmyoung/papers/pap118. html,
  94. (1982). Groupthink: Psychological Studies of Policy Decisions and Fiascos.
  95. (2002). Habitus and the Storied Self.
  96. (2003). Handbook of Qualitative Research.
  97. (1992). Hidden Conflict in Organizations. Newbury Park Ca.:
  98. (1959). How to Interview.
  99. (2000). Identity Politics and Environmental Conflict Dynamics: A Reexamination of the Negotiated Rulemaking Process.
  100. (1997). Images of Organization. Thousand Oaks,
  101. (2002). Insider/Outsider Perspectives on Ritual in Soka Gakkal International - UK. In
  102. (1999). Integrating Gender, Faith and Learning: women's midlife passage In the experience of some Quaker and Roman Catholic adult students.
  103. (1975). Interpersonal Conflict Handling Behaviour as Reflections of Jungian Personality Dimensions. Psychological Reports,
  104. (1991). Interpersonal Conflict.
  105. (2003). Interpretative Phenomenonological Analysis. In
  106. (1981). Interviewing women: A Contradiction in Terms. In
  107. (1994). Interviewing. In
  108. (2000). Introducing Narrative Psychology.
  109. (2003). Introduction to Type and Conflict. Palo Alto: Consulting
  110. (2002). Introduction: Theorizing Faith. In
  111. (1992). Invitation to Personal Construct Psychology.
  112. (2000). Is your Money Working for the World Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust.
  113. (1984). It's great to have someone to talk to": The Ethics and Politics of Interviewing Women. In
  114. (2003). Journeying through Conflict. Baptist Training Pack.
  115. (1999). Jung and the Quaker Way. London: Quaker Home Service.
  116. (1993). Knowledge forAc fon: A Guide to Overcoming Barriers to Organizational Change. San Francisco CA:
  117. (1995). Knowledge, Knowledge Work and Organizations: An Overview and Interpretation.
  118. (1952). Laughter in Quaker Gray.
  119. (1982). Leadership: the Management of Meaning.
  120. (1988). Learning How to Leam: Applied Theory for Adults. Milton Keynes:
  121. (2002). Light to Live by.
  122. (2000). Living Without Law.
  123. (1999). Making Peace with Conflict.
  124. (2003). Making Sense of the'Group Mind'.
  125. (1985). Manual: a Guide to the Development and Use of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. Palo Alto: Consulting
  126. (1949). Margaret Fell, Mother of Quakerism.
  127. (1995). Mary Parker Follett Prophet of Management.
  128. (1990). Method, Methodology and Epistemology in Feminist Research Processes. In
  129. (1987). Milan Systemic Family Therapy.
  130. (1967). Mind, Self and Society.
  131. (1992). Myers- Briggs Type Indicator and ConflictHandling Intention: an Interactive Approach.
  132. (1998). Narrative Approach to Assessing Interactions Between Society, Community and Person.
  133. (2003). Narrative Mediation: Assisting in the renegotiation of discursive positions.
  134. (2000). Narrative Mediation. A New Approach to Conflict Resolution. San Francisco:
  135. (1986). Narrative Psychology: The Storied Nature of Human Conduct.
  136. (2000). Narratives as
  137. (1994). Now we are Quakers: the Experience and Views of New Members. York: Quaker Outreach in
  138. (1985). Observation as Inquiry and Method.
  139. (1998). Organisational Culture.
  140. (1967). Organization and Power in The Society of Friends 1852-1859. In
  141. (1977). Organization Design.
  142. (1999). Organizational Behaviour.
  143. (1996). Organizational Change and Personal Mythology. Personnel Review,
  144. (1967). Organizational Conflict: Concepts and Models. Administrative Science Quarterly,
  145. (1987). Organizational Culture: A Critical Assessment.
  146. (1996). Organizational Learning ll:
  147. (1991). Organizational Memory.
  148. (1959). Our Adult World and its Roots in Infancy. Human Relations,
  149. (1977). Outline of a Theory of Practice.
  150. (1998). Pacifists in Action: The experience of the Friends Ambulance Unit in the Second World War.
  151. (2000). Paradigmatic Controversies, Contradictions and Emerging Confluences. In
  152. (1996). Peace by Peaceful Means: Peace and Conflict, Development Geertz,
  153. (1993). Peace is a Process. London: Quaker Home Service.
  154. (2003). Personal Communication-The Peaceable Kingdom In the New Testament.
  155. (2000). Personal Communication.
  156. (1992). Personalizing Identity and Socializing Self. In
  157. (2001). Peter Berger and the Study of Religion. London and
  158. (1984). Portrait in Grey. A short history of the Quakers. London: Quaker Home Service.
  159. (1999). Positioning Theory.
  160. (2003). Power Relations and Reflexivity in Interviewing. Paper presented at the Quaker Studies Research Association Summer School
  161. (1974). Power. A Radical View.
  162. (1986). Praying for Justice.
  163. (1997). Productive Conflict: The Importance of Conflict Management and Conflict Issue. In
  164. (1969). Psychology and Religion: West and East.
  165. (1966). Psychology as an exercise in paradox.
  166. (2002). Quaker Ethnographers: A Reflexive Approach. In
  167. (1995). Quaker Faith and Practice: Britain Yearly Meeting.
  168. (2004). Quaker Families and Business Networks in nineteenth century Darlington.
  169. (1993). Quaker Justice in Seventeenth Century Pennsylvania. Friends Quarterly(October
  170. (2000). Quaker Thought. In
  171. (1995). QuakerFaith and Practice: the book of Christian Discipline of the Yearly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) in Britain. Britain Yearly Meeting.
  172. Quakerism Past and Present an Inquiry into the Causes of its Decline
  173. (2002). Quakerly Conflict The Cultural Logic of Conflict in The Religious Society of Friends. Unpublished Doctoral Thesis,
  174. (1992). Quakers and Social Justice.
  175. (1982). Quakers and the Use of Power. Pendle Hill Pamphlet 241.
  176. (1995). Quakers in Britain:
  177. (1986). Quakers in Conflict
  178. (1999). QuakerSpealc Quaker Outreach in
  179. (1997). Qualitative Analysis of Self Narratives: A Constructivist Approach to the Storied Nature of Identity. Retrieved 30.08.04,2004, from www.
  180. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis:
  181. (2002). Qualitative Data Analysis: Explorations with NVivo.
  182. (1994). Qualitative Research. In
  183. (1988). Quality and Quantity in Social Research. London: Unwin Hyman.
  184. (2001). Questions of Identity among 'Buddhist Quakers'.
  185. (2000). Rachel Pinney 1909-1996. Friends Quarterly,
  186. (1993). Real World Research.
  187. (1998). Reflections on a vice centred relational method. In
  188. (1996). Reflexive Dialogue in Transformation.
  189. (1999). Relationship between the Big Five Personality Factors and Conflict Management.
  190. (1986). Religious Commitment, Peace Activism and Marital Violence in Quaker Families.
  191. (1981). Research on Conflict Handling Behaviour: An Experimental Approach.
  192. (1997). Resolving Identity Based Conflict. San Francisco:
  193. (2003). Review of Living without Law.
  194. (2000). Semi-Detached Idealists: The British Peace Movement and International Relations.
  195. (1977). Servant Leadership.
  196. (1999). Some Dare Call it Power. In
  197. (1998). Some Introverted Thoughts.
  198. (2004). Spirited Living: Waging Conflict, Building Peace.
  199. (2002). Statement of Ethical Practice for the British Sociological Association.
  200. (2000). Storytelling in Organizations. Oxford:
  201. (1999). Studying Organization: Theory and Method.
  202. (1994). Surrendered Men: Peacable Enclaves in the Post Enlightenment World. In
  203. (2002). Tabular Statement The Membership of Britain Yearly Meeting for the year ending 31
  204. (1988). Talking in Silence: Ministry in Quaker Meetings.
  205. (1988). Teaching Systemic Thinking: DC Associates.
  206. (2002). Telling it like it is: Understanding Adult Women's Life-long Disclosures of Childhood Sexual Abuse. In
  207. (1995). Telling Sexual Stories.
  208. (1912). The Beginnings of Quakerism.
  209. (1996). The British Psychological Society: Code of Ethics.
  210. (1992). The Character of Organizations. Palo Alto: Consulting
  211. (1997). The Circular Structure of Power.
  212. (1978). The Civilising Process.
  213. (2000). The Clerk's Role. The Friend 21.01.2000,7-8.
  214. (1950). The Collective Memory.
  215. (1977). The Community of Self. In
  216. (1988). The Conflict- Handling Modes: Toward More Precise Theory.
  217. (1984). The Constitution of Society.
  218. (1995). The Construction of Social Reality.
  219. (1973). The Content of the Form: Narrative Discourse and Historical Representation.
  220. (2001). The death of Christian Britain. Understanding Secularisation 1800-2000.
  221. (1988). The Debate on Individualism.
  222. (1989). The Difference in the Meaning of Forcing in the Conflict Management of Actors and Observers. In
  223. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory.
  224. (1997). The Effectiveness of Mixing Problem Solving and Forcing. In
  225. (1997). The Effects of Conflict on Strategic Decision Making Effectiveness and Organizational Performance.
  226. (1991). The Ethics of Social Research.
  227. (1985). The Experience of Self. In
  228. (1982). The Fires of Levana:
  229. (2000). The Foundations of the Gospel Order. The Friends Quarterly(April
  230. (1991). The Hermeneutic Spiral. Downers Grove,
  231. (1994). The Individual, Work and Organization.
  232. (1992). The Individuated Self Concept: a Critical Analysis of Social Constructionist Writing on Individualism.
  233. (1997). The Inevitability of Conflict but not of Violence. In
  234. (1993). The Intergenerational Transmission of Disciplinary Practices and Approaches to Conflict. Human Organization,
  235. (1993). The Invention of Corporate Culture: a History of the Histories of Cadbury.
  236. (1952). The Journal of George Fox. Cambridge:
  237. (1999). The Journey toward Reconciliation.
  238. (1921). The Later Periods of Quakerism.
  239. (2000). The Light in Their Consciences: The Early Quakers in Britain 1646-1666.
  240. (1964). The Managerial Grid.
  241. (1995). The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator.
  242. (1999). The Organizational Culture War Games. In
  243. (2002). The Peaceable Kingdom. Paper presented at the Quaker Theology Seminar.
  244. (1973). The politics of organizational decision making.
  245. (1979). The Post Modem Condition: A Report on Knowledge.
  246. (1991). The Power of Balance.
  247. (1998). The Powers That Be:
  248. (2001). The Practice of Co-operative Inquiry: Research 'with' rather than 'on' People. In
  249. (2002). The Practice of Co-operative Inquiry.
  250. (1969). The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.
  251. (1993). The Psychology of Decision Making:
  252. (2002). The Quaker Peace Testimony and its Contribution to the British Peace Movement: an overview.
  253. (1993). The Quaker Peace Testimony: A Workbook for Individuals and Groups: Quaker Peace and Service.
  254. (2001). The Quaker Shadow. Paper presented at the Worcester and Shropshire MM.
  255. (2003). The Quaker Testimonies: Quaker Books. Quaker Peace and Social Witness QWG.
  256. (1998). The Qualitative Research Interview. In
  257. (1975). The Reflection Process in Casework Supervision. London: Institute of Marital Studies.
  258. (1983). The Reflective Practitioner. How Professionals Think in Action:
  259. (1984). The Reformation of American Quakerism 1748-1783.
  260. (1997). The Religious Basis of Resistance and Nonresponse: A Methodological Note.
  261. (1992). The Report of the Inquiry into the Removal of Children from Orkney in
  262. (2002). The risk of 'going observationalist': negotiating the hidden dilemmas of being an insider participant observer.
  263. (1919). The Second Period of Quakerism.
  264. (2003). The Self as the Basis of Religious Faith. In
  265. (1994). The Sense of the Meeting: An Anthropology of Vernacular Quakerism. Unpublished Ph. D,
  266. (1990). The Sexuality of Organization.
  267. (1996). The Sexuality of Organization. In
  268. (1997). The Shape of Living. Grand Rapids:
  269. (2004). The Significance of Gender for Congregational Studies. In
  270. (1966). The Social Construction of Reality. A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge.
  271. (1969). The Social Reality of Religion.
  272. (1993). The Social Structure of Right and Wrong. San Diego:
  273. (1956). The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud.
  274. (2000). The Third Side.
  275. (2001). The Two Oceans. The Dark and The Light.
  276. (2004). The'Self among Early Friends and Today. Friends Quarterly.
  277. (2002). They too are Quakers: A Survey of 199 Non-theist Friends.
  278. (1986). Thomas Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument. Tuxedo,
  279. (2003). Three journeys towards reflexivity. In
  280. (1984). Toward an anthropology of self and
  281. (1963). Towards a Quaker View of Sex. London: Friends Home Service Committee.
  282. (1981). True Justice. Swarthmore Lecture. London: Quaker Home Service Czarniawska, B.
  283. (2004). Understanding People.
  284. (1999). Using NVivo in Qualitative Research.
  285. (2003). Validity and Qualitative Psychology. In
  286. (1970). Victorian Quakers.
  287. (2003). Violence, Beauty and The Peace Testimony. Paper presented at the Quaker Studies Research Association Conference.
  288. (1992). Visionary Women.
  289. (2001). War Prevention Works.
  290. (2002). We shall forever eat frugally off clean plates: an analysis of the background, presentation and effect of the 1986 Swarthmore Lecture. Unpublished M. Phil in Quaker Studies,
  291. (1993). What are our Monthly Meetings doing? A Concern for Revitalisation of Meetings for Businessl992-1993. London: Quaker Home Service.
  292. (1963). When Friends Attend to Business.
  293. (1964). When Prophecy Fails.
  294. (2002). Witness against War. Researching the History of the Quaker Peace Testimony. Quaker Studies,
  295. (1995). Women Managers Moving On.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.