The impact of structural adjustment on trade unions in Egypt

By Laila Gad

Abstract

The following research focuses on trade union organisations, and in particular trade union officialdom in Egypt. The study examines the extent to which trade union officials at the various levels of the trade union hierarchy are reacting to reforms instigated by structural adjustment policies. The adoption of structural adjustment and economic reform measures as proposed by the World Bank and IMF have resulted in the government's withdrawal of some of the benefits and privileges it accorded to workers. Public sector workers are particularly affected by these changes, thereby posing a challenge to trade union officialdom, since the bulk of trade union membership is within the public sector. Trade union officials are reacting to the reform measures by trying to balance their role as representatives of workers' interests and their role in administering state policy. Whereas in the past these two roles were reconcilable, however, with liberalisation of the economy and the adoption of structural adjustment measures that is no longer tenable. Trade unionism has been weakened by the incorporation of union officials within government corporate structures, making it more difficult for trade union officialdom to challenge the reform measures adopted by the government. Rather, trade union officials are opting for `co-operation' both with the government and with management in enterprises, to the cost of workers. In enterprises, trade union officials emphasise that the interests of work and workers are inseparable. At the level of the confederation and general unions, union officials present themselves as working to keep workers' rights, but also as partners with the government in its drive for growth. By so doing trade union officials are de-politicising trade unionism, and instead focus on economic gains. Union officials are redefining their role away from workers. Trade union action at the various levels is not based on what workers want or demand, but rather on what trade union officials want, in the belief that workers do not truly know their interests. As a result, trade union action has promoted the interests of union officials rather than that of the workers. Trade unionism has become in a sense a shell without a content. However, there is evidence that there are pressures to democratise trade unionism and make it more responsive to worker demands. These pressures are from within the worker base, from trade union officials particularly at the enterprise level who are affilited to political parties, and from external forces like the Islamists. However these forces have their limitations, particularly in the face of institutionalised sectors that are capable of reproducing themselves and promoting their interests

Topics: HD
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1132

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1983). (series: Adjustment and Equity in Developing Countries. series editor Christian Morrisson)
  2. (1991). 75 `Arran Min Tarikh AlHaraka Al-Nagabeya AI-Misreya (75 Years Of The History Of the Egyptian Trade Union Movement). Cairo: Al-Arabi for Publishing and Distribution.
  3. (1990). A Political Economy Of The Middle East: State, Class, And Economic Development. doi
  4. (1988). Abdel-Moneim E1-Ghazaly El-.
  5. (1992). Adjustment and Equity in Developing Countries: A New Approach. doi
  6. (1995). AI-Haraka Al-Naqabeya Al-Misreya `Abr Meat . in: (The Egyptian Trade Union Movement Over One-Hundred Years). Cairo: Al-Itihas Al-Islamy Al-Dawly Lil Amal.
  7. (1993). Al-'Ema! a Al-?. atJa F il Qita' Al-'Am: Al-Khalfeya Wal Mulabasat Wa Mutatalebat Al-Tarsheed ", (Excess Labour In The Public Sector: Background and Requirements fier Rationalising) Cairo: Unpublished Paper.
  8. (1993). Al-Bank al-Dawly wa Mushkelat a! -tanmeya al-igtisadeya fi dual al-alam al-thaleth (The World Bank and Problems of Economic development in the Third World). Cairo: Dar AlNahda A1-Arabeya.
  9. (1967). Al-Haraka AI-Omaleya Fi Misr, 1899-1952 (The Labour Movement In Egypt, 1899-1952). Cairo: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi LiI Tiba'a Wal Nashr.
  10. (1994). Al-Haraka Al-'umaleya fl ma'rakat al-tahawul: derasatfil intikhabat al-nagabeya 1991. (The Workers' Movement in the Struggle for transformation: studies on the trade union elections 1991) Cairo: Markaz al-derasat al-arabeya.
  11. (1987). Al-Idrabat Wa Ma'azaq al-Elaqat al-sinaeya flu qitaa' al-am" (Strikes and the predicament of industrial relations in the public sector). Qadaya Fikreya,
  12. (1994). Al-Itar Al-Iqtisadi Lilseyasay Al-Mu'athera Ala AlSayedat AI-Mu 'elat Fi Misr" (The Economic Framework Of The Policies Impacting Women Heading Households
  13. (1996). Al-Marge' Fi Sharh Ahkam Nuzum AlTa'meen Al-Igtimaee Fi Misr. (The Reference In Explaining The Applied Social Insurance System
  14. (1992). Al-Masira Al-Tarikheya Lil Itihad Al-Am Li Nakabal Omal Misr Fi 35 Aman:
  15. (1996). Al-Mgtama' Wal Dawla Fi! Watan Al-Arabi Fi Titel Al-Seyasat Al-Ra'smaleya Al-Gadida: Misr (Society And State In The Arab World Under The New Capitalist Policies: Egypt).
  16. (1990). Arab Republic of Egypt: Economic Readjustment With Growth.
  17. (1983). Askarat Al-Haya Al-Omaleya Wal Naqabeya Fi Misr. (The Militarisation of Labour and Trade Unions In Egypt).
  18. (1993). Beyond The Impasse: New Directions doi
  19. (1994). Civil Society And Democratization In
  20. (1973). Class Conflict In Egypt: doi
  21. (1984). Dalil Al-Tashkilat Al-Nakabeya Fi Misr:
  22. (1992). Economic And Political Liberation In Egypt And The Demise Of State Femisism" doi
  23. (1995). Egypt Human Development Report
  24. (1961). Egypt In Search Of Political Community. doi
  25. Egypt: Employment And Unemployment Trends. doi
  26. (1968). Egypt: Military Society. Translated by Charles Lam Markmann.
  27. (1978). Egypt's Uncertain Revolution Under Nasser And Sadat. doi
  28. (1984). Egyptian Labour Abroad: Mass Participation and Modest returns" MERIP Reports, doi
  29. (1985). Egyptian Politics Under Sadat: The PostPopulist Development Of An Authoritarian-Modernizing State. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers. doi
  30. (1979). Egyptian State Capitalism In Crisis: Economic Policies And Political Interests 1967-1971. " doi
  31. (1991). Employment And Structural Adjustment: Egypt
  32. Evolution And Strategies Of Reform ". In Heba Handoussa & Gillian Potter. Employment And Structural Adjustment: Egypt
  33. (1993). Exposed To Innumerable Delusions: Public Enterprise And State Power In doi
  34. (1995). Gender And Development In The Arab World: Women's Economic Participation, Patterns And Policies. doi
  35. (1994). Humum Misr wa azmat al-'ukul al-shaba (The Worries of Egypt and the crisis of young minds). Cairo: Markaz al-gil lil dirasat al-shababeya wal igtima'eya.
  36. Igtimaeya Linukhbat al-Infilah al-Igtisady Fil Mogtansaa' al-hfisry 388 1974-1980 (Who Owns Egypt?! An
  37. (1952). ila 1981. (Workers and Politics: The Political Role of the Labour Movement
  38. (1988). International Co-operation for Development, Employment and an End to Poverty: Trade Union Responses to the Structural Adjustments of the 1980s"
  39. (1993). Irrational Workers: The Moral Economy of Labour Protest In Egypt". doi
  40. (1993). Labor Markets In The Arab Countries: A Survey.
  41. (1979). Labour And Politics In Egypt, 1919-1939" doi
  42. (1989). Labour, Capital, And The State In Nasserist Egypt, 1952-1961 " doi
  43. (1992). Lamahat Min Dor Al-Omal Fil Haraka Al-Ishterakeya AlMisreya "(Glimpses On the Role Of Workers In the Egyptian Socialist Movement). Qadaya Fikreya,
  44. (1991). Man Yamluk Misr?! Derasa Tahlileya Lil Usul al.
  45. (1971). Marxism And The Sociology Of Trade Unionism. doi
  46. (1987). Mashru' Li Islah Al-Haraka Al-Nakabeya AlMisreya (A Proposal To Reform The Egyptian Trade Union Movement). Dar Al-Filer Al-Islamy.
  47. (1993). Million 'Amel Ya'taredun Tarik Ansar AlKhaskhasa Heya Al-Hal" (A Million Workers Stand In The Way Of The Supporters Of Privatization Is The Solution).
  48. (1996). Ministry Of Economy And International Cooperation.
  49. (1983). Muthakerat Wa Watha'ek Min Tarik!. Omal Misr., Kifah Omal Al-Nasig (Memoirs and documents From The History Of Egyptian Workers: The Struggle of Textile Workers) Book One. Cairo: M adbouli.
  50. (1982). Muthakerat Wa Watha'ek Min Tarikh Omal stiisr: At. Omal Wal Intikhabat Al-Barlamaneya (Memoirs and documents Fro m -1.1c 395 History Of Egyptian Workers: Workers and Parliamentary Elections) Book Two.
  51. (1996). Nisa' Yataqadamn A1-Sufuf' (Women In The Front Rows) AI-Yassar.
  52. (1993). Populism, Liberalisation and Popular Participation: Industrial Democracy in Egypt". doi
  53. (1994). Private Voluntary Organizations In Egypt: Islamic Development, Private Initiative, And State Control. Gainsvilte: doi
  54. (1995). Program Of Assistance To The Egyptian Trade Union Federation
  55. (1995). Programme Of Economic Reform & Structural Adjustment And Its Effect On Egyptian Woman In Labour Force.
  56. (1991). Report And Recommendation Of The President Of The International Bank For Reconstruction And Development To The Executive Directors On A Proposed Structural Loan In
  57. (1991). Report Of The General Committee On The General Principles Of The Program To Liberate The National Economy In One Thousand Days. (In English).
  58. (1983). Sadat's Legacy, Mubarak's Dilemmmna" doi
  59. (1989). State Ownership And The Problem Of The Work Incentive: An Egyptian Case Study. " doi
  60. (1990). Structural Adjustment in Africa: Insights from the Experiences of Ghana and Senegal". doi
  61. (1992). Subsidization Policies In Egypt: Neither Economic Growth Nor Distribution ". doi
  62. (1995). Taking Stock Of Egypt's Assets".
  63. (1986). Tarikh AI-Haraka Al-Shuyu'eya Al-Misreya Min
  64. (1987). Tarikh Al-Tabaka Al-Amela AI-Misreya Rtunth Nushu'aha Hata Sanat
  65. (1987). Tataur al-sina'a al-Misreya Munth `ahd Mohammed Ali Hata `ahd Abdel Nasser. (The Development of Egyptian Industry from the Mohammed Ali era to the Nasser era).
  66. (1978). The Arab Nation: Nationalism and Class Struggles. doi
  67. (1983). The Egypt of Nasser and Sadat: The Political Economy of Two Regimes. doi
  68. (1974). The Egyptian Economy 1952-1972. doi
  69. (1993). The Nationalization Of The IMF: The Nature and Evolution Of The Official Discourse On Economic Reform In
  70. (1988). The New International Labour Studies: An Introduction. doi
  71. (1991). The Political Economy Of Poverty, Equity, And Growls: Egypt And Turkey. doi
  72. (1995). The Political Environment Of Economic Reform In Egypt: The Labor Movement Vs. Privatisation Revisited. " Amsterdam Middle East Papers,
  73. (1992). The Politics Of Economic Adjustment: International Constraints, Distributional Conflicts, And The State. doi
  74. (1992). The Politics Of Economic Reform doi
  75. (1993). The Politics Of Economic Reform In Egypt" doi
  76. (1991). The Public Sector In Egypt: Organisation.
  77. (1986). Tinker, Tailor, Textile Worker: Class and Politics doi
  78. (1989). Unruly Corporatism: Associational Life in Twentieth Century Egypt. doi
  79. (1995). WDR). World Development Report 1995: Workers In An Integrating World. doi
  80. (1995). Will Arab Workers Prosper Or Be Left Out
  81. (1980). Women And Industrial Work In Egypt: The Chubra ElKheima Case"
  82. (1991). Workers Against the State: Actors, Issues and Outcomes in Egyptian Labour/State Relations,
  83. (1996). Workers And The World Economy". doi
  84. (1994). Workers and Working Classes In The Middle East: Struggles, Histories, Historiographies. doi
  85. (1987). Workers On The Nile: Nationalism, Communism, Islam, and the Egyptian Working Class, doi
  86. (1993). Workers' Struggles in Mubarak's Egypt. Unpublished MA thesis, The American University in Cairo.

Please contact us if you think this content is not Open Access according to the BOAI definition.

Submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.