Location of Repository

Primary science: an analysis of changing policy, policy text and practice

By Sandra Lesley Eady


This thesis sets out to examine the extent to which primary science is a complex interplay between educational and political perspectives which in turn has influenced and shaped the way primary schools interpret, reconstruct and implement science in practice. This study uses a policy trajectory to consider the changing conceptions of primary science within the arenas of policy influence, policy text and practice in relation to its curriculum content, related pedagogy and assessment. In addition, it examines the nature and impact of professional development to support the implementation of primary science in practice. Evidence was collected through a series of interviews with elite figures in education, a regional survey of primary schools, along with in-depth cases studies in order to develop a deeper understanding primary science within the policy to practice context. The findings would indicate that despite a succession of top down science education policy reforms, there are still concerns about the extent to which teachers have sufficient science subject knowledge to develop conceptual understanding, a clear idea of the purpose of science investigations and how to use formative asiessment as an effective way of diagnosing pupil understanding. Furthermore, the evidence would suggest that the emphasis placed on summative assessment and accountability has narrowed teachers' conceptions of primary science. The implications are that science policy reform needs to acknowledge existing practice and support a wider definition of science that includes an appreciation of the historical and cultural aspects of science together with an understanding of technological applications. In addition, a more robust infrastructure of professional development needs to be in place which places more emphasis on the science co-ordinator to support teaching and learning in order to provide teachers with access to a changing knowledge base and opportunities to update skills in primary science. Unless these implications are given serious consideration the unrelenting focus on performativity and accountability will prevent any real development of creativity and innovation in the primary science curriculum

Topics: LB1501
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1142

Suggested articles



  1. (1992). (Exploration of Science Project)
  2. (1993). 11 Teacher's Guides and 22 Pupils' Books for Key Stage 2,
  3. (1995). 1987-1995 - The Struggle to Formulate a National Curriculum for Science in England and Wales.
  4. (1993). 386 Office for Standards in Education
  5. (1994). A longitudinal study of a constructivist approach to improving primary school teachers' subject matter knowledge in science.
  6. (1992). A longitudinal study of primary teachers' perceived competence in and concerns about NC implementation',
  7. (1998). A scheme of work for Key Stages I and 2 Science London: Department for Education and Employment Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
  8. (1998). A Sense of professionalism: the impact of 20-day courses in subject knowledge on the professional development of teachers.
  9. (1978). An alternative to Piagetian Psychology for Science and Mathematics Education.
  10. (2004). Anecdote, opinion and whim: lessons in curriculum development from primary science education in England and Wales.
  11. (1990). Assessing Science in the Primary Classroom: Observing Activities.
  12. (1998). Assessment and classroom learning Assessment
  13. (1999). Assessment, Learning Theories and Testing systems' in
  14. (1992). Assessment, Recording and Reporting. A Report by
  15. (1998). Basics of Qualitative Research.
  16. (1998). Beyond 2000: Science education for the future. ' London; King's College School of Education.
  17. (1996). Beyond constructivism.
  18. (1987). Beyond Process.
  19. (1996). Beyond the National Curriculum.
  20. (1998). C: American Educational Research Association
  21. (1978). Case study and case records: towards a contemporary history of education.
  22. (1999). Case study research in educational settings Buckingham:
  23. (1995). Central Policy and teacher response: scientific investigation in the National Curriculum of England and Wales.
  24. (2003). Changes in Primary Teachers' Scientific Knowledge and Understanding During a Two Year In-service Programme.
  25. (1994). Changing English Primary Schools? The Impact of the Education Reform Act at Key Stage One.
  26. (1992). Choice and Diversity White Paper.
  27. (1989). Classroom conceptual change: philosophical perspectives.
  28. (1999). Concept Cartoons, teaching and learning in science: an evaluation.
  29. (1996). Constructivism and Evidence from Children's Ideas.
  30. (1997). Constructivist metaphors of learning science.
  31. (2003). Constructivist Pedagogy.
  32. (2002). Constructivist teaching
  33. (1997). Constructivist Teaching and Teacher Education: Theory and Practice. In
  34. (2002). Continuity and Progression in Science Teaching at Key Stages 2 and 3.
  35. (1995). Crisis within the Primary Classroom.
  36. (1993). Curriculum co-ordination: a lost opportunity for primary school development? School Organisation,
  37. (1992). Curriculum Organisation and Classroom Practice in Primary Schools: A Discussion Paper.
  38. (1991). Curriculum Policy.
  39. (2002). Developing conceptual Understanding in Primary Science.
  40. (1994). Dimensions of Content.
  41. (2000). Do teachers support causal understanding though their discourse when teaching primary science?
  42. (1978). Does content matter in primary science?
  43. (2000). Doing Qualitative Research: A Practical Handbook.
  44. (2004). Doing quantitative research in education with SPSS.
  45. eds (2003) Qualitative Research Practice.
  46. (1999). Education and Employment/Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
  47. (2003). Education and Skills
  48. (1994). Education Reform. Milton Keynes:
  49. (1984). Education Support Grants. In Elizabeth House,
  50. (1968). Educational Psychology: A cognitive view.
  51. (1998). Effective Teachers of Literacy. London: Teacher Training Agency Millar,
  52. (1997). Effective Teachers of Numeracy Final Report London: Kings College London.
  53. (1999). Effective Teaching of Science A review of research. Edinburgh: Scottish Council for Research in Education.
  54. (2000). Emerging issues' in
  55. (1992). Ethical Guidelines.
  56. (2005). Evidence-based practice in science education: the researcher-user interface.
  57. (1990). Examinations and Assessment Council
  58. (1970). Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes' in 1. Lakotos and A. Musgrave eds, Criticism and the growth of Knowledge Cambridge:
  59. (1994). Focus groups: A practical guide for applied research 2nd edn. Thousand Oaks:
  60. (2002). for Education and Skills /Teacher Training Agency
  61. (1992). Forces A guide for Teachers. London: National Curriculum Council.
  62. (1993). Formative and Summative Assessment by Teachers.
  63. (2002). Framing Constructivism in Practice as the Negotiation of Dilemmas: An Analysis of the Conceptual, Pedagogical, Cultural and Political Challenges Facing Teachers.
  64. (1989). From constructivism to social constructivism: a Vygotskian perspective on teaching and learning science.
  65. (1992). Group Interviews as a Research Tool.
  66. (1993). How can we specify concepts for primary science
  67. (1999). How did You Get to be a Good Primary Science Teacher.
  68. (1998). How Teachers Change.
  69. (1972). Human Understanding Volume 1: The Collective use and Evolution of Concepts.
  70. (1992). Improving primary teachers' understanding of science concepts - theory into practice.
  71. (1988). Initiatives in Primary Science: an Evaluation Report.
  72. (1990). INSET for Primary Science in the National Curriculum in England and Wales: are the real needs of teachers perceived?
  73. (2002). Inside the Literacy hour. - Learning from Classroom experience. London: Routledge Falmer.
  74. (1999). Inside the Primary Classroom: 20 years on.
  75. (1980). Inside the Primary Classroom. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  76. (2003). Interactive Whole Class Teaching' in the National Literacy Strategy.
  77. (2001). Interpreting Qualitative Data.
  78. (2001). Interviewing children' in
  79. (1996). Investigations by Order Policy, curriculum and science teachers'work under the Education Reform Act Nafferton: Studies in Education.
  80. (1991). Issues in SATs Development and the Practice of Teacher Assessment.
  81. (1999). Labour, Learning and the Economy: a 'policy sociology'perspective.
  82. (1993). Leaming to Teach.
  83. (1985). Learning in Science; the implications of Children's science.
  84. (1998). Learning to Investigate'
  85. (2000). Learning to teach science in the primary school',
  86. (1978). Mind in Society. ý the development of higher psychological processes.
  87. (1987). National Curriculum Science Working Group. Interim Report. London:
  88. (1993). New Strategies in Social Research. Cambridge:
  89. (2005). No science today-the demise of primary science.
  90. (1972). Objective Knowledge.
  91. of Education and Science NVelsh Office (1985a) Science 5-16: a statement of policy.
  92. (2005). Office for Standards in Education
  93. (2005). Office for Standards in Education Ofsted
  94. (1994). Policy and curricular change: modeling science in the National Curriculum for England and Wales.
  95. (1992). Policy and Practice
  96. (1997). Policy and Practice in Primary Education: Local Initiative, National Agenda. 2nd edn.
  97. (1996). Practical work: Its Role in the Understanding of Evidence.
  98. (1978). Primary Education in England. A Report by HM1 London:
  99. (2005). Primary Schooling under New Labour: The irresolvable contradiction of excellence and enjoyment.
  100. (2005). Primary Science in the UK a scoping study. Final Report to the Wellcome Trust London: The Wellcome Trust.
  101. (1996). Primary Science: Past and Future Directions.
  102. (1996). Primary Teacher's confidence about teaching science and technology.
  103. (1997). Primary teachers' understanding of concepts of science: impact on confidence and teaching.
  104. (2002). Problems with the assessment of performance in practical science: which way now?
  105. (1990). Process and content in the National science curriculum.
  106. (1990). Processes and Concepts Exploration) Research Reports, Evaporation and Condensation
  107. (2005). Pupil Voice is here to stay An occasional paper London, Teaching and Learning Research Programme London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
  108. (2001). Quantitative methods in Educational Research: the role of numbers made easy.
  109. (1999). Questionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement.
  110. (1996). Real World Research.
  111. (2002). Reconstructing Science in Education: in sights and strategies for making it more meaningful.
  112. (1995). Reflections on the implementation of National Curriculum Science Policy for the 5-14 age range: findings and interpretation form a national evaluation study in England.
  113. (1992). Reforming Education and changing schools: case studies in policy sociology.
  114. (1999). Researching Education.
  115. (1999). School Science and public understanding of science.
  116. (2001). Schools Achieving Success White Paper London:
  117. (1994). Science 7-1 Ideveloping primary teaching skills.
  118. (1976). Science and Primary Education A post of responsibility No 3.
  119. (1974). Science and Primary Education Papers No I The present situation.
  120. (1988). Science at If: A Review of Survey Findings 1980-84
  121. (1991). Science in the National Curriculum
  122. (1981). Science in the school curriculum. In
  123. (1983). Science Report for teachers: 1 Science at age 11. London: Assessment Performance Unit:
  124. (1984). Science Report for teachers: 4 Science Assessment Framework Age 11 Assessment Performance Unit:
  125. (1985). Science Report for teachers: 6 Practical Testing at ages 11,13 and 15 Assessment Performance Unit:
  126. (1986). Science Report for teachers: 8 Planning Scientific Investigations at age II Assessment Performance Unit:
  127. (1994). Science Teaching.
  128. (2002). Science Without Literacy: a ship without a sail?
  129. (2004). Still no pedagogy? Principle, pragmatism and compliance in primary education.
  130. (1989). Student's conceptions and the learning of science.
  131. (1996). Subject Coordinators: They can't make it alone.
  132. (1993). Teacher Assessment at Key Stage One.
  133. (1998). Teacher Training Agency
  134. (1992). Teachers' conceptual understanding in science: needs and possibilities in the primary phase.
  135. (1967). Teachers' Guide I, Apparatus and Animals and Plants.
  136. (2003). Teaching and Learning in Science. A guide to recent research and its applications.
  137. (1999). Textual support for primary science teaching? '
  138. (1995). The Art of Case Study Research.
  139. (1994). The challenge of science'
  140. (1995). The changing role of the primary school curriculum co-ordinator
  141. (1955). The Construction of Reality in the Child London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  142. (1994). The Constructivist Paradigm and Some Implications for Science Content and Pedagogy.
  143. (1997). The impact of a National Curriculum development on teaching and learning behaviours.
  144. (1991). The impact of INSET: The case study of Primary Science.
  145. The knower of the known; the nature of knowledge in research on teaching.
  146. (1989). The Knowledge base for the beginning teacher
  147. (1999). The Knowledge Bases of the Expert Teacher.
  148. (1989). The knowledge, beliefs and attitudes of the mathematics teacher: A model.
  149. (1993). The National Curriculum and its assessment: final report London: SCAA
  150. (1999). The National Numeracy Strategy. Suffolk:
  151. (1960). The Process of Education. Cambridge:
  152. (1983). The Pupil as Scientist? Milton Keynes:
  153. (1994). The Rise and Fall of Constructivism.
  154. (2004). The role of assessment in the implementation of science in the primary school. Paper presented at
  155. (1970). The Structure of Scientific revolutions.
  156. (1986). Those who understand: knowledge growth in teaching.
  157. (1962). Thought and Language.
  158. (1981). Towards a Science of Science Teaching.
  159. (1995). Versions of Primary Education.
  160. (2000). What Pupils Say. Changing Policy and Practice
  161. (2000). What Teachers Do. Changing Policy and practice in Primary Education.
  162. (2001). Where's the Content? The Role of Content

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.