Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Constructing insecurity: Australian security discourse and policy post-2001

By Matt McDonald

Abstract

This article explores the construction of security in the contemporary Australian context, arguing that the Australian government has represented, and attempted to construct support for, a statist, exclusionary and militaristic conception or discourse of security. This understanding of security is evident in the government’s representation and response to a range of issues since 2001, including asylum-seekers, terrorism and the war in Iraq. In exploring the processes through which the Australian government has elaborated this discourse and sought to create resonance for it in a domestic context, I argue that there remain important bases not simply for contesting this conception of security, but for acknowledging immanent possibilities for the understanding of security in the Australian context to change in normatively progressive ways. Acknowledging these possibilities is important in identifying the potential for progressive change in Australian security policy, while also shedding light on the role of security in the modern political project

Topics: JZ
Publisher: Sage Publications Ltd.
Year: 2005
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:1242

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2003). A leap into the past- in the name of the national interest’, doi
  2. Across the Abyss’, doi
  3. (2003). After the Bali Cocoon Falls Away’, The Age.
  4. Although this need not always be the case, as the analysis of Australia’s approach to asylum-seekers will demonstrate.
  5. (2004). An earlier draft of this paper was presented at the International Studies Association conference in
  6. (2003). Asylum-seekers in Australia’s international relations’, doi
  7. Attacks taint refugee saga’,
  8. (1995). Australia’s Foreign Relations in the World of the 1990s (Melbourne: Melbourne UP,
  9. (2003). Australia’s self-image as a regional and international security actor: some implications of the Iraq war’, doi
  10. (2002). Australia’s self-image’; George, ‘Will the chickenhawks?’;
  11. Australian security policy, post-11 September’, doi
  12. Australian security policy’, doi
  13. (2001). Boat people are campaign fodder in Australia’, Reuters News.
  14. Camilleri argues that the government had decided to deploy troops to assist the US in Iraq as early as mid-2002. ‘A leap into the past’,
  15. (1997). Changing Worlds of Security’,
  16. Creating the Second Cold War, doi
  17. (1999). Culture, Strategy and Foreign Policy Change: The Road to Oslo’, doi
  18. (2002). Defence Spending will rise: PM’, Australian Financial Review.
  19. (2003). Don’t encourage war disunity’,
  20. (1996). Facing an Uncertain Future: Defence and Security under the Howard Government’,
  21. Facing an Uncertain Future’,
  22. (1997). Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT), In the National Interest: Australia’s Foreign and Trade Policy White Paper (Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia,
  23. Govt continues linking refugees to terrorists’, Australian Associated Press.
  24. (2003). Howard joins the attack on Paris’,
  25. (2003). Howard links Iraq war to Bali’, The Age.
  26. Howard says need to redouble border checks’, Australian Associated Press.
  27. (2002). Human Security and the Construction of Security’, Global Society. doi
  28. Human Smuggling, National Security, and Refugee Protection’, doi
  29. (2001). In Australian Associated Press (AAP), ‘Illegal boats could be a pipeline for terrorists: Reith’, Australian Associated Press.
  30. In Fear of Security. This has been applied in particular to Australia’s conception of the region, and narratives of identity that have encouraged positioned (white) Australia as in need of protection from an ethnically and culturally different region.
  31. (2003). In war, remember Bali,
  32. Inside/ Outside: International Relations as Political Theory (Cambridge: doi
  33. Mattern ‘The Power Politics of Identity’, doi
  34. (2003). National polls indicated that Australians were split in their support for Australian involvement in the war in Iraq with UN approval, but were strongly opposed to Australian involvement without it.
  35. (2004). off limits’,
  36. (2003). On elements of this dynamic within Europe, for example, see A. Geddes,
  37. On the basis of state power in this context, for example, see J.Weldes et al., ‘Introduction: Constructing Insecurity’,
  38. (2001). On these points, see Walker, ‘The Subject of Security’, in Krause and Williams (eds.); and Burke, In Fear of Security: Australia’s Invasion Anxiety (Sydney: Pluto,
  39. (1996). On this latter point see,
  40. (2001). p.193; Edmund Rice Centre, ‘Debunking the Myths about Asylum Seekers’.
  41. (2001). Perspectives on Australian Foreign Policy, doi
  42. Perspectives on Australian foreign policy’, doi
  43. (2002). Perspectives on Australian Foreign Policy’; doi
  44. (1958). Philosophical Investigations (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, doi
  45. (2003). PM unrepentant on Bali link’,
  46. (2001). Politics of fear works well for PM’, Sydney Morning Herald.
  47. Politics of fear’, doi
  48. (2001). Politics of Fear’;
  49. (1992). Prison Notebooks, doi
  50. (2003). Public opinion swings behind PM’,
  51. (1991). Renaissance of Security Studies’, doi
  52. (1995). Securitization and Desecuritization’,
  53. (2001). Security and Emancipation’, doi
  54. Security and Immigration’. doi
  55. (1986). Security and Society
  56. (1999). Security, Strategy and Critical Theory (Boulder, Colorado: Lynne Reinner, doi
  57. (2003). Shanahan noted that support for the war reached 50% by the 5 th day of conflict in
  58. Shocked Howard vows steely pursuit of terrorists’, Australian Associated Press.
  59. (2004). Specifically regarding changes to legislation governing temporary protection visas for asylum-seekers. Department of Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs, Measures for Temporary Protection and Temporary Humanitarian Visa Holders.
  60. (1990). Strategic Discourse/ Discursive Strategy: The Representation of ‘Security Policy’ in the Video Age’, doi
  61. Strategy and Foreign Policy Change’) provides an excellent example of the processes through which political leaders might go about creating opportunities for particular security conceptions and practices to attain support from their domestic population.
  62. (1998). Such a criticism evokes concerns elaborated by Copenhagen School theorists, namely that ‘securitizing’ particular issues demonstrates a failure of the political process to deal with these issues effectively, encouraging what Buzan et al. describe as ‘panic
  63. Surveys indicated that up to 76% of Australians opposed intervention in Iraq at the time of Australia’s official commitment of troops, while large protests occurred throughout major Australian cities to oppose the government’s stance.
  64. (2001). Tampa asylum seekers caught in political deadlock’.
  65. (2001). Terror threat is real- Howard’, The West Australian.
  66. (1996). The Politics of Security doi
  67. (1999). The Study of Discourse in International Relations: A Critique of Research and Methods’, doi
  68. (2001). US armed with $40b war chest’,
  69. (2003). Vaile spurned on Iraq comments’,
  70. (2002). We are at greater risk now than ever-
  71. (2001). Why Incumbency is Such a Big Factor for the Caretaker’, The Age.
  72. (2003). Will the chickenhawks come home to roost? Iraq, US preponderance and its implications for Australia’, doi
  73. Will the chickenhawks?’,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.