Location of Repository

Food shortages and economic institutions in the Democratic Peoples' Republic of Korea

By Suk Lee

Abstract

This thesis aims to understand the 1987-99 food crisis in the DPRK. We begin by establishing the fact that the country faced several previous food shortages, including the 1945-46 urban foods crisis, the 1954-55 rural food crisis and the 1970-73 food shortage, all of which triggered and motivated corresponding institutional changes in agriculture. And we find that in order to overcome repeated food shortages the country has developed several distinctive economic institutions such as administrative/quantitative production control in agriculture, state grain marketing, food rationing, central monopoly of agricultural trade and supplementary food supply institutions.\ud \ud On the basis of this finding, we proceed into the analysis of the food crisis. Specifically, three controversial issues are examined. First, did it escalate into famine? If it did, how severe was the famine? Second, what was the causation of the famine? How did it unfold and what features did it have? Third, did the food crisis change the DPRK agriculture?\ud \ud With respect to the first issue we estimate the number of excess deaths during the food crisis using official population figures. It shows that there existed a famine that claimed 688 thousand excess deaths in 1994-99. For the second issue we argue that the famine had several unique features. First it was ‘absolute food availability decline (FAD) famine’ in which no policies were feasible to prevent it. Second, it was urban famine where industrial population in the north-eastern part of the country suffered most. Third, it was ‘famine-in-slow motion’ that victims persistently weakened for a long period rather than perished in a short space of time, due to the mixed result of massive FAD and systematic national coping strategies. Concerning the final issue we show that it is not necessarily true that the food crisis genuinely changed the DPRK agriculture as generally conceived

Topics: HC, DS
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:2505

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1998). 0. "The Aid of Agricultural Equipment to North Korea".
  2. (1982). 11. On Juche Idea. The Korean Workers'
  3. (1973). 395 Social Science Academy. Our Party's Policy to Solve Peasant and Agricultural Problems. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  4. (1996). 396 Ministry of Unification. Bukhan Gyungje Tongyejip [Collected North Korean Economic Statistics].
  5. (1996). A Coming Crisis on the Korean Peninsula? "
  6. (1996). A Empirical Study on North Korea's Economic Crisis". Dongbuka Nonchong
  7. (1990). A Model of Crisis in a Peasant Economy. "
  8. (1991). A Note on the Number of 1933 Famine Victims".
  9. (1999). A Starving Nation. "
  10. (1996). A Study on North Korean Agricultural Policy and Food Problem, Korea Research Institute for National Unification,
  11. (1996). A Study on North Korean Grain Statistics in the 1950s", Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  12. (1989). A Trial Estimation of an Economic Model of North Korea. " the paper presented to the International
  13. (1999). Advisory Group. "Report to The Speaker, U. S. House of Representatives ."
  14. (1996). Agricultural Foundation
  15. (1999). Agricultural Policies". Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  16. (1999). Agricultural Reform in North Korea.
  17. (1975). Agriculture and Farmers in North Korean Cooperative Farms.
  18. (1998). Articles Agricultural Cooperative Federation (Research Department). "North Korea's Agricultural Condition and North-South Korean Agricultural Cooperation"
  19. (1998). Assessing the Food Situation in North Korea. "
  20. (1983). Assessment on Agricultural Production Capabilities in North Korea, Korea Rural Economic Research Institute,
  21. (1995). Balanced Development of Rural Economy in County and the Improvement of People's Living".
  22. (1965). Balanced Improvement of Living Condition of Labourers, Office Workers and Peasants".
  23. (1990). Basic Conditions for Agricultural Specialisation".
  24. (1996). Bukhan Gyungje Jipyojip [Collected North Korean Economic Indicators].
  25. (1996). Calamity and Reform in China: State, Rural Society, and Institutional Change Since the Great Leap Famine. Stanford,
  26. (1986). Causes of Famine". Food Policy;
  27. (1987). China's Changing Population.
  28. (1991). Chosun Nongupsa [The Agricultural History
  29. (1931). Chris. In Praise of Maoist Economic Planning: Living Standards and Economic Development in Sichuan Since
  30. (1996). Chulpansa. Bukhan Gyungje Jaryojip [Colletced Materials for North Korean Economy]. Minjok Tongil Chulpansa,
  31. (1998). Classification of Economic Equilibriums in People's Economic Planning".
  32. (1990). Collectivization and China's Agricultural Crisis in 1959-1961
  33. (1997). Communal Dining and the Chinese Famine of 1958-1961. " Economic Development and Cultural Change;
  34. (1994). Correctness and Vitality of Dear Leader Comrade Kim Jong II's Theory of County's Position and Roles".
  35. (1963). County Cooperative Management Committee and Agricultural Problem.
  36. (1992). Current Trade Situation of Agricultural Products and Its Prospects in the DPRK". Korean Agricultural Economy Research Institute, North Korean Agriculture and Agricultural Reform in Socialist State, Seoul,
  37. (1999). Deforestation in North Korea and Managing Forests After Unification". Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  38. (1998). Demographic Methods.
  39. (2000). Development Structure and Performance of the DPRK Economy: Empirical Indications. "
  40. (1999). Donghyang [North Korean Agricultural Trend]
  41. (1997). DPR Korea Humanitarian Situation Report. "
  42. (1997). DPR Korea Situation Report. "
  43. (1997). Early Warning of North Koreans at Refugee Risk: Victims of Nature or Policy [in English]. " the paper presented at the
  44. (1991). Eberstadt, Nicholas. "North Korea As an Economy Under Multiple Severe Stresses: Analogies and Lessons From Past and Recent Historical Experience".
  45. (1998). Economic Differences Among Counties in Our Country and the Conditions for Their Resolution".
  46. (1994). Economic Planning. North Korean Economy,
  47. (1992). Economic Research Institute for North East Asia. "Caloric Intake in North
  48. (1997). Ecoomic Conditions in North Korea and Prospects for Reform. "
  49. (1962). Enterprise Method in the Guidance of County Cooperative Management Committee". Kulloja [Workers];
  50. (1997). Entitlement Failure? " Development and Change;
  51. (1995). Estimate of the Supply and Demand for Grain in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea:
  52. (1998). Estimating the
  53. (1993). Famine Analysis: A Study of Entitlements
  54. (1997). Famine and Economics. "
  55. (1988). Famine and Household Coping Strategies. " World Development;
  56. (1958). Famine in China,
  57. (2001). Famine in North Korea: Causes and Cures. "
  58. (1999). Famine in North Korea. "
  59. (1984). Famine That Kills: Darfur,
  60. (1998). Famine: a Simple General Equilibrium Model. "
  61. (1981). Famines.
  62. (1949). Feeding China: the Experience Since
  63. (1999). Figures Tell: Statistical Analysis of 3 Million Famine Deaths in North Korea. " Wolgan Chosun [Monthly Chosun];
  64. (1998). Final Report to Benjamin A. Gilman (R-NY), The Chairman of International Relations Committee,
  65. (1997). Food Supply and Demand in North Korea".
  66. (1994). for Asian Culture. Bukhan Gyungje Tongye Jaryojip [Collected Materials for North Korean Economic Statistics].
  67. (1995). for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. "DPR Korea - Floods Situation Reports No.
  68. (1999). Forecasting North Korea's Food Situation in the 1998/99. "
  69. (1992). Foreign Trade of North Korea 1946-1988". PhD Dissertation,
  70. (1973). Great Leader Comrade Kim Il Sung's Creative Reproduction Theory and Its Magnificent Realisation. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  71. (1986). Great Leader Comrade Kim Il Sung's Socialist Theory of Wage of Agricultural Labour. Science Encyclopaedia Publisher,
  72. (1946). Gwanryon Munseojip [Collected Documents for North Korean
  73. (1997). Gyung Ryang. "Famine in North Korea: Is There a Solution? " Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  74. (1996). Heavy Rains and Floods Information Reports
  75. (1971). Highly Intensive Agricultural Production Is the Main Task for Rural Economic Development". Kulloja [Workers];
  76. (1948). Hui. In Front of the Second Year of North Korean Consumer Association". Sovjohap [Consumer Association];
  77. (1989). Hunger and Public Action.
  78. (1993). Introduction to Modern North Korean Economy. Daedong Chulpansa,
  79. (1999). Is Aid the Answer? " The
  80. (1974). It's High Time for Us to Guide Agriculture by Enterprise Methods [in English]. Foreign Language Publications,
  81. (1981). Juche Nongbub and Its Great Vitality".
  82. (1993). Jucke Nongbub Created by Great Leader Comrade Kim IL Sung and and Its Vitality".
  83. (1999). Kim Ii Sung 's North Korea.
  84. (1997). Korea Will Muddle Through. "
  85. (1992). Korean Agriculture and Agricultural Reform in Socialist State, Seoul,
  86. (1963). Land Reform, Collectivisation and the Peasants in North Korea. "
  87. (1995). Land Survey Under the Wise Leadership of Great Leader Comrade Kim Il Sung and Dear Leader Comrade Kim Jong Il". Ryuksa Gwahak [Historical Science];
  88. (1996). Maintaining North Korean Regime and Food Problem".
  89. (1987). Markets and Famines.
  90. (1999). Mass Famine Looms As Crops Fail. " Electronically Acessesed at Http: \\Www. Megastories. Com\
  91. (1990). More Light on the Scale of Repression and Excess Mortality in the Soviet Union in the 1930s".
  92. (1999). Mortality in North Korean Migrant Households: a Retrospective Study. "
  93. (1997). News Briefing: 97's Crop Production Assessment and 98's Food Supply and Demand in North Korea".
  94. (1999). News Briefing: Assessing the Economic Recovery Signs in North Korea"
  95. (1999). News Briefing: Assessment of North Korea's Food Situation and Its Reliance on the External Food Aid".
  96. (1998). News Briefing: Food Aid to North Korea and Its Future Plan".
  97. (1997). News Briefing: Food Supply and Demand in North Korea".
  98. (1998). News Briefing: Overall Assessment on the
  99. (1998). News Briefing: The Recent Situation of North Korean Farmers' Markets and the Analysis of Market Prices".
  100. (1997). North Korea Becomes
  101. (1996). North Korea Food Aid Assessment (May-June
  102. (1998). North Korea's Agricultural Condition and Food Problems. "
  103. (1999). North Korea's Agricultural Policy in 1999. "
  104. (1997). North Korea's Food Problem Could Be Solved.
  105. (1998). North Korea's Interlocked Economic Crisis. " Asian Survey;
  106. (1997). North Korea's Internal Assessment on the Reasons for Economic Crisis". Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  107. (1997). North Korean Food Shortages: U. S and Allied Responses. " CRS Report, for Congress
  108. (1996). North Korean Price Policies and Their Reforms. Korean Institute for International Economic Policy, Seoul,
  109. Nutrition of North Korean Children". the paper presented to the International Symposium on "Nutrition Problems of North Korean Children: Current Status and Possible Solutions" hosted by KDI School,
  110. (1995). of Humanitarian Affairs. "Assessment of Damage and Immediate Relief Requirements Following Preliminary Findings of United Nations Assessment Mission. "
  111. (1999). Office. "News Briefing: Estimates of North Korean Population".
  112. (1997). On the Knife Edge of a Major Famine.
  113. (1993). Optimal Intertemporal Consumption Decision Under the Threat of Starvation. "
  114. (1984). Our People's Struggle to Complete Dry-field Irrigation under the Wise Leadership of Great Leader Comrade Kim Ii Sung". Ryuksa Gwahak [Historical Science];
  115. (1994). Overall Assessment on "The Third 7 Year Plan"
  116. (1999). Own Style Statistics': Availability and Reliability of Official Quantitative Data For The Democratic People's Republic of Korea. " the paper presented at "Advancing Statistics for the Next Millennium"
  117. (1948). Peasant Federation and Consumer Association". Sovjohap [Consumer Association];
  118. (1999). Policy Reforms in the DPRK: Limits and Opportunities". Unpublished Paper,
  119. (1997). Political and Economic Human Rights Violation in
  120. (1997). Problem and Agricultural Reform in North Korea [in English] ". the paper presented at the
  121. (1988). Process of Famine: Causes and Consequences in Sudan" Development And Change;
  122. (1995). Production and Consumption of Agricultural Input. Korean Rural Economy Research Institute,
  123. (1997). Prospects for a North Korean External Economic Opening". Henriksen,
  124. (1998). Prospects of Grain Production, Consumption and Trade in North Korea. "
  125. (1993). Rational Reform of Production Structure Is an Important Condition for the Unified and Detailed Planning".
  126. (1999). Recent Changes in North Korean Agricultural Policies and Prospects for Food Supply and Demand". Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  127. (1970). Reinforcing Statistical Works Is a Necessary Condition for the Construction of Socialism and Communism".
  128. (1995). Report - FAO/WFP Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to The Democratic People's Republic of Korea".
  129. (1999). Review of United States Policy Towards North Korea: Findings and Recommendations. "
  130. (1997). Reviewing Assessments on North Korea's Food Problem [in Korean]. "
  131. (1999). Rigorous Speculation: The Collapse and Revival of the North Korean Economy. "
  132. (1974). Sang hoon. The North Korean Economy. Stanford, Hoover Institution Press,
  133. (1998). Seeds Aid Program".
  134. (1986). Sen's Analysis of Famine: A Critique".
  135. (1998). Sharing Movement. "The Food Crisis of North Korea: Witnessed by 399 1,694 Food Refugees [in English]".
  136. (1985). Social Science Academy publisher,
  137. (1996). Special Alert No. 267: Democratic People's Republic of Korea".
  138. (1996). Special Alert No. 270: Democratic People's Republic of Korea".
  139. (1997). Special Alert No. 275: FAO/WFP Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. "
  140. (1997). Special Alert No. 277: FAO/WFP Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. "
  141. (1999). Special Report - FAO! WFP Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea".
  142. (1999). Special Report - FAO/WFP Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea".
  143. (1998). Special Report - FAOIWFP Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to the Democratic People's Republic of Korea".
  144. (1995). Stalin, Grain Stocks And The Faime Of 1932-1933. " Slavic Review; Fall
  145. (1990). Standing in the Front of Agricultural Frontier Vol. ]. The Korean Workers'
  146. (1977). Starvation and Exchange Entitlements: A General Approach and Its Application to the Great Bengal Famine. "
  147. (1998). Statement by Choi Su Hon, Vice Minister of Foreign Affairs of the DPR Korea. " the speech made at "Thematic Round Table Meeting on Agricultural Recovery and Environmental Protection For the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) ",
  148. (1997). Status of Public Health- Democratic People's Republic of Korea,
  149. (1991). Struggles to Establish Vegetable Production Bases
  150. (1997). Study on Past and New Election Laws in North Korea".
  151. (1998). Study on the Changes in the Economic Articles of the New North Korean Constitution (1998.9.5)". Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  152. (1977). Study on the Economic Account System in North Korea. Ministry of Unification,
  153. (1999). Supply and Demand for Grains
  154. (1993). Tabulation on the Population Census of the Demographic People's Republic
  155. (1957). Technical Change and Aggregate Production Function. " Review of' Economic and Statistics;
  156. (1962). Technological Standardisation of Labour".
  157. (1947). The
  158. (1998). The AREP 1998-2000 Action Plan. " the paper presented to "Thematic Round Table Meeting on Agricultural Recovery and Environmental Protection For the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) ",
  159. (1993). The Campaign for the Mechanisation of Rice-Transplanting Under the Wise Leadership of Great Leader Comrade Kim Il Sung".
  160. (1993). The Causation and Prevention of Famines:
  161. (1993). The Causation and Prevention of Famines: A Reply".
  162. (1999). The Crisis in North Korea: Seeds of Hope". Working Paper,
  163. (1997). The Crisis of North Korea's Food Rationing System and Prospects for Market Reform. Samsung Economic Research Institute,
  164. (1995). The Current Situation of North Korea.
  165. (1958). The Development of Socialist Commerce in Our Country. " Social Science Academy, The Socialist Economy Building in Our Country, Social Science Academy publisher,
  166. (1961). The DPRK (North Korea) Place of publication is Pyongyang and language is Korean unless otherwise stated Official History Texts and Economic Statistics Central Bureau of Statistics.
  167. (1999). The Economic Impact of North Korea's Food Crisis". KDI Policy Forum;
  168. (1999). The Economics of Famine.
  169. (1997). The Economics of Korean Unification. "
  170. (1995). The Entitlement Approach to Famine: An Assessment. "
  171. (1993). The Essence and Features of Agricultural Procurement in Socialist Society".
  172. (1990). The Establishment of Agricultural Development Model for Intermediary Areas during 6
  173. (1995). The Establishment of Socialist System in the DPRK 1945-61 [in Japanese]".
  174. (1985). The Experience of Agricultural Management and Support. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  175. (1989). The Experience of Cooperative Farm Management. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  176. (1989). The Experience of Establishing Economic Ties Between Urban and Rural Areas. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  177. (1986). The Experience of Solving Food Problem. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  178. (1999). The Food Crisis and Nutrition of Population in North Korea".
  179. (1985). The Guiding Principles of Juche Sasang. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  180. (1997). The Heads of Houeholds Eat Least"
  181. (1988). The Historical Experience of Solving Rural Problems in Our Country. Social Science Academy Publisher,
  182. (1996). The Individualism of North Koreans and the Possibility of the Socail System". Bukhan [North Korea];
  183. (1996). The Institute of Contemporary International Problems. "The DPRK Report" Distributed by Nautilus Institute.
  184. (1960). The Korean Workers' Party Publisher. Socialist Reorganisation of Private Manufacture and Commerce in Our Country.
  185. (2000). The Level of Famine Deaths in North Korea and Its Policy Implications. " Bogun Bokji Forum [Health and Welfare Forum];
  186. (1999). The Limitation of the Changes in North Korean Economic Policies in the 1990s. " Tongil Gyunje [Unified Economy];
  187. (1985). The Making of the Soviet System.
  188. (1985). The Meanings and Roles of County in Building Socialism". Kulloja [Workers];
  189. (1997). The North Korean Economy: Collapse, Stasis or Reform? " Brookings Discussion Papers
  190. (1993). The North Korean Famine and Its Demographic Impacts. "
  191. (2000). The Origin of South and North Koreas' Economic Structures and Their Developments.
  192. (1990). The Political Economy of Hunger: Vol.
  193. (1999). The Politics of Famine in North Korea. " USIP Special Report
  194. (1992). The Population of
  195. (1998). The Prospects for North Korea's Survival. "
  196. (1998). The Reality of Agriculture and Some Problems of Agricultural Production Statistics
  197. (1996). The Road to the Market in North Korea: Projects, Problems, and Prospects [in English]". the paper presented to The
  198. (1990). The ROK (South Korea) Place of publication is Seoul and language is Korean unless otherwise stated The DPRK Laws and Statistics published by
  199. (1999). The Situation of North Korean Farmers' Markets and Their Implications". Tongil Gyungje [Unified Economy];
  200. (1999). The Soviet Famine Of 1932-3 And The Crisis in Agriculture". the paper prepared for BASEES99,
  201. (1998). The Soviet Famines of 1931-3 and the Chinese Famines of 1959-61 in Comparative Historical and Regional Perspectives''". the paper presented to AASCOCSIANZSA
  202. (1999). The State of World Children 1999,1999 United States General Accounting Office. "North Korea Restricts Food Aid Monitoring. " Report to the Chairman,
  203. (1998). The Survey of 109 North Korean Food Refugees".
  204. (1960). The Victorious Realisation of Marxist-Leninist Agricultural Programs in Our Country.
  205. (1998). The Weather Factor and Variability in China's Grain Supply. "
  206. (1985). Theory of Society and History in Juche Sasang. Social Science Academy publisher,
  207. (1992). Understanding Famine
  208. (1995). Welfare, and Development: A Festschrift
  209. (1998). Why has Juche Nongbub failed? ", Kukdong Munje [Far Eastern Problems],
  210. (1998). World Food Program. "Nutrition Survey of The DPRK. "
  211. (1993). Yonguso [Research Institute for North Korean Affairs]. The Reality of the DPRK. Bukhan Munje Yonguso,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.