Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Comparative Evaluation Of Space Vector Based Pulse Width Modulation Techniques In Terms Of Harmonic Distortion And Switching Loss

By V S S Pavan Kumar Hari


Voltage source inverters (VSI) are popular in variable speed induction motor drive applications. Pulse width modulation (PWM) is employed to achieve variable voltage variable frequency output from a fixed DC bus voltage. The modulation method greatly influences the harmonic distortion in line current and the inverter switching loss. This thesis evaluates a few space vectorbased PWM techniques which reduce the harmonic distortion and/or the inverter switching loss, compared to conventional space vector PWM (CSVPWM), at a given average switching frequency. In space vector-based PWM, the average voltage vector applied over a sub-cycle equals the commanded reference vector, thereby maintaining voltsecond balance. The given average vector can be realized by applying the voltage vectors of the inverter in different sequences. CSVPWM employs a switching sequence in which all the phases switch once in a sub-cycle. Sequences, in which a phase is clamped, while the other two phases switch once in a sub-cycle have been reported in literature. Further, certain special switching sequences have also been reported recently. These special sequences involve switching a phase twice, while switching the second phase once and clamping the third phase in a sub-cycle. This work investigates the use of such special switching sequences to reduce line current distortion and inverter switching loss in an induction motor drive. The influence of various switching sequences on line current ripple and inverter switching loss is discussed in the thesis. Comparison of the sequences in terms of switching loss leads to a hybrid PWM technique, which deploys the best sequence to reduce switching loss under a given operating condition. This technique is referred to as minimum switching loss PWM (MSLPWM). Further, a procedure for design of hybrid PWM techniques to achieve reduced line current distortion as well as inverter switching loss is elaborated. Four such specially designed hybrid PWM techniques are discussed. Analytical methods are presented for the evaluation of total RMS harmonic distortion factor of line current and inverter switching loss corresponding to different PWM techniques. The MSLPWM and the hybrid PWM techniques are evaluated analytically in terms of harmonic distortion and switching loss. It is observed that the switching loss corresponding to MSLPWM is considerably less than that with CSVPWM over the entire range of power factor. The reduction in switching loss with MSLPWM is as high as 36% at high power factors close to unity, while it is not less than 22% at power factors close to zero. MSLPWM also reduces the harmonic distortion for power factors close to unity at high modulation indices. Compared to CSVPWM, the hybrid PWM techniques result in a maximum reduction of about 40% in the harmonic distortion at fundamental frequencies close to 50Hz, and about 30% reduction in switching loss at power factors close to unity. The various PWM techniques are tested on a constant V /f induction motor drive with a digital control platform based on ALTERA Cyclone II field programmable gate array (FPGA) device. With a 10kVA IGBT based inverter feeding a 2.2kW, 415V, 50Hz, three-phase induction motor, the total RMS harmonic distortion factor of line current (IT HD) is measured at different fundamental frequencies for the various PWM techniques. The average switching frequency is 2.44kHz. The measured values of IT HD show a reduction in distortion with the hybrid PWM techniques over CSVPWM at high speeds of the drive. The relative values of IT HD corresponding to different PWM techniques agree with the theoretical predictions. With the 10kVA IGBT based inverter feeding a 6kW, 400V, 50Hz, 4pole, three-phase induction motor, the switching losses corresponding to CSVPWM and MSLPWM are evaluated and compared. This is done by measuring the steady state temperature rise of the heat sink over the ambient for the two techniques under different conditions. The thermal measurements are carried out at different loads with power factor ranging from 0.14 to 0.77. The measurements are also carried out at different fundamental frequencies (or modulation indices). Further, to separate conduction (constant) losses and switching (variable) losses, the heat sink temperatures are measured at two different switching frequencies, namely 2.44kHz and 4.88kHz. It is observed that the temperature rise due to MSLPWM is less than that due to CSVPWM consistently under various operating conditions. The thermal measurements confirm the theoretical prediction of reduction in switching loss with MSLPWM. Measurements of heat sink temperature rise corresponding to CSVPWM, MSLPWM and the hybrid PWM techniques are carried out at a higher power factor of 0.98 (lag) with the inverter feeding an RL load (instead of an induction motor). The hybrid PWM and MSLPWM result in lower switching losses as indicated by the reduction in temperature rise

Topics: Pulse Circuits, Electronic Circuits, Electric Switching Circuits, Pulse Width Modulation (PWM), Minimum Switching Loss Pulse Width Modulation (MSLPWM), Hybrid Pulse Width Modulation, Space Vector Based Pulse Width Modulation, Conventional Space Vector Pulse Width Modulation (CSVPWM), Harmonic Distortion, Switching Loss, Electronic Engineering
Year: 2008
OAI identifier:
Download PDF:
Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following location(s):
  • (external link)
  • Suggested articles

    To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.