Location of Repository

Participation in disaster relief

By P. R. T. Ntata

Abstract

This thesis examines the issue of participation of affected populations in disaster relief, which is receiving increasing attention from researchers, planners and practitioners. This concern comes out of the widely documented experience in development studies that beneficiary participation is essential for programmes to succeed. Similar arguments are being applied to disaster relief. However, despite much rhetoric, examples of genuine grassroots participation both in relief and development continue to be rare. I review the concept of participation in Chapter One and, in Chapter Two, the many possible reasons as to why participation of beneficiaries continues to be a problematic issue. In Chapter Three, I review the concept of humanitarianism and the implications of changes in humanitarian assistance on participation. In Chapters Four, Five and Six, I present three case studies, different by geographical, socio-political context and type of disaster. All the three studies contain material collected through fieldwork involving a qualitative methodology. I have indicated, in each study, the range of data collection tools used. In Chapter Seven, I compare and evaluate the findings of the three case studies. I present overall conclusions of the thesis in Chapter Eight. The main conclusions of the thesis are that beneficiary participation continues to be a problematic issue because groups that have power derived from ownership of economic resources or politics seem unwilling to share that power with the people they seek to assist. Their unwillingness to do so has, in turn, many causes including, lack of trust by aid organisations of local power structures and organisations, poor bureaucratic orientation, a self-given superiority of moral virtue and technical expertise, and sometimes limitations imposed by operational, structural and accounting procedures. I argue that some of these limitations could be addressed through financially supporting and enhancing the capabilities of member-based grassroots structures. I also argue that more effort needs to be devoted to research on how willingness to adhere to the ideals of humanitarian assistance can be generated on the part of aid agencies and donors

Topics: HV
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3081

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1995). 77ze politics of humanitarian intervention,
  2. (1961). 7he achieving society, doi
  3. (1982). A
  4. (1993). A frameworkfor survival., Health, human rights, and humanitarian assistance,
  5. (1995). A Situational Analysis ofNsanje District.
  6. (1994). A voice for the excluded: popular participation in develqpment. ý Utopia or necessity, London: Zed Books/UNRISD.
  7. (1977). An Introduction to the sociology of rural development. doi
  8. (1999). An Ongoing omission: Adolescent and Adult Malnutrition in Famine Situations' in Field Exchange, Special Focus: South Sudan, Emergency Nutrition Network Sanders,
  9. (1995). and lAbecier, A
  10. (1984). Approaches to participation in rural development,
  11. (1992). Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee: Promoting Popular Participation"
  12. (1999). Beneficiary Voice: Towards Shared Social Learningfor Humanitarian programmes
  13. (1998). Beyond methodologies: coalition-building for participatory technology development', doi
  14. (1998). Beyond the magic bullet? Lessons and conclusions'
  15. (1981). Bureaucratic Reorientation for Participatory Rural Development,
  16. (1992). Capacity Building for Participatory Organisations'
  17. (1971). Capitalism and underdevelopment doi
  18. (1996). Children amongst the mirage, Ahmedabad: SEWA Reception Centre.
  19. (1988). Community Participation in Development Projects: The World Bank Experience, World Bank discussion papers, Washington D. C: The World Bank. doi
  20. (1999). Coordinating a Humanitarian Response in Sudan' in Field Exchange, Special Focus: South Sudan,. Emergency Nutrition Network.
  21. (1997). Critical reflections on rapid participatory rural appraisal' doi
  22. (1998). Crop Failure in Dolocha, Ethiopia: A participatory emergency Response' doi
  23. (1991). Democratising development. 77ze role of voluntary organisations, doi
  24. (1976). Dissent on development, London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson. doi
  25. (1997). Doing the right thing: Relief agencies, moral dilemmas and moral responsibility in political emergencies and war' doi
  26. (1996). Early Warning Systems (FEWS) doi
  27. (1962). Economic development and social change in south India, doi
  28. (1997). Famine crimes: Politics and the disaster relief industry in Africa, doi
  29. (1999). Famine, Conflict and Response: a Basic Guide, Connectcut:
  30. (1985). Fitting projects to people',
  31. (1959). Fivejamilies: Mexican case studies in the culture ofpoverty, Basic Books.
  32. (1997). Framing participation: development projects, professionals, and organisations' doi
  33. (1996). Frontline diplomacy: Humanitarian aid and conflict in Africa, Colorado: Lynne Rienner doi
  34. (1999). Humanitarian Assistance in Sudan in 1998, Analysis and evaluation Paper (AEP)
  35. (1996). Humanitarian challenges and intervention: World politics and the dilemmas of help, doi
  36. (1996). Humanitarian intervention in contemporary conflict, doi
  37. (1993). Humanitarianism across religions and cultures' doi
  38. (1986). Imposing Aid. ý Emergency assistance to refugees, doi
  39. (1999). Inclusive planning and allocation for rural services' Development in practice, doi
  40. (1996). Intemational Committee of the Red Cross
  41. (1996). Introduction and overview'
  42. (1992). Introduction' doi
  43. (1985). Knowledge from Social Science for development policies and projects', doi
  44. (1969). Latin America: underdevelopment or revolution, doi
  45. (1999). Linking" and "empowering": key concepts for intervention following war and disaster' doi
  46. (1970). Me culture of poverty'
  47. (1992). Mere Women are Leaders,
  48. (1997). Ministry of Relief and Rehabilitation Affairs
  49. (1970). Motivations, values, and attitudes of subsistence farmers: towards a subculture of peasantry',
  50. (1977). Networks and Marginality: Life in a Mexican shanty town, doi
  51. (1998). NGO performance and accountability: introduction and overview' doi
  52. (2000). NGO responses to Hurricane Mitch: Evaluations for accountability and learning,
  53. (1998). NGOs and advocacy: how well are the poor represented? ' Development in practice, doi
  54. (1977). nypoorpeople staypoor, London: Temple Smith. I 359 Lomnitz, L
  55. (1962). On the theory of change, l9linois:
  56. (1996). Operation Lifeline Sudan: a Review,
  57. (1995). Options for the reform of the international system for humanitarian assistance'
  58. (1984). Participation today, London: The Industrial Participation Association.
  59. (1991). Participatory Approaches to Rural Development, doi
  60. (1992). Participatory development and the World Bank: opportunities and concerns' doi
  61. (1997). Participatory Development: an approach sensitive to class and gender' doi
  62. (1992). Participatory development: myths and dilemmas, Washington: the World Bank.
  63. (1995). Participatory Development: Toward Liberation or Co-optation'
  64. (1998). Participatory methodologies: double edged swords, Development in practice, doi
  65. (1997). Participatory project evaluation: letting local people have their say'
  66. (1977). Pathways to participation, London: Associated Business Programmes Ltd.
  67. (1995). Peasant Organisation and Participation in Tanzania'
  68. (1992). Power, Protest and Participation: Local elites and the politics of development in India, doi
  69. (1993). Practicing development, doi
  70. (1995). Preface' doi
  71. (1991). Projects with People: The Practice ofparticipation in Rural Development,
  72. (1966). protest and change, doi
  73. (1998). Rebuilding communities in a refugee settlement, Oxfam GB. doi
  74. (1998). Rebuilding Our Lives: a Documentation of the
  75. (1998). Record of October Meeting, ODI, London: www. ainap. ora/meetillizs/pdfs ALNAP,
  76. (1997). Relief agencies and moral standing in war: principles of humanity, neutrality, impartiality and solidarity doi
  77. (1996). Relief-Development continuum: Limitations and possibilities in complex emergencies: The case of Rwanda'
  78. (1983). Rural Development: Putting the last first, doi
  79. (1996). Save the Children Fund (UK) doi
  80. (1985). Shortcut and participatory methods for gaining social infonnation for projects,
  81. (1959). Social change in the industrial revolution, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  82. (1963). Social change, Englewood Cliffs, doi
  83. (1996). Socio-economic and Production System Study of Wetland Use. Main Text and Working Paper Fortman,
  84. (1960). Sociological factors in economic development,
  85. (1998). Sudan's Foreign Policy Environment. Some Implications for Humanitarian Assistance. Analysis and Evaluation Paper (AEP)
  86. (1992). Temystifying Popular Participation: Institutional Mechanisms for Popular Participation'
  87. (1996). Tepoliticising development: The uses and abuses of participation', doi
  88. (1992). The Building Blocks of Participation: Testing a Social Methodology'
  89. (1974). The concept of "marginality" as applied to squatter settlements'
  90. (1993). The concerns of recipient nations'
  91. (1997). The Daily Times. February,
  92. (1947). The folk society', doi
  93. (1995). The international system of humanitarian relief in the "New World Order"
  94. (1996). The origins of unease: setting the context of current ethical debate, background paper for the Forum on Ethics in Humanitarian Aid,
  95. (1999). The Political Economy of War, with Special Reference to Sudan and Bahr El Ghazal, Analysis and Evaluation
  96. (2000). The politics ofprinciple: the principles of humanitarian action in practice,
  97. (1960). The stages of economic growth, doi
  98. (1997). The Sudan Conflict. Historical and Political Background, -Analysis and Evaluation Paper (AEP) IV,
  99. (1979). Theories of underdevelopment, doi
  100. (1995). Theory and Practice of participatory Development at Grassroots level: Fact and Fiction in Sri Lanka'
  101. (1999). Training andNenvorking in Participation.
  102. (1998). Who Changes: Institutionalising Participation in Development,
  103. (1998). Whose Development? an Ethnography of Aid,
  104. (1990). Work and Control in a Peasant Economy: A History of 77ie Lower Tchiri Valley ofMalawi 1859 - doi
  105. (2000). Workshop on Participatory Approaches in Emergencies, Action Aid.
  106. (1998). Yhe south Sudan Vulnerability Study, Nairobi: The Save the Children Fund

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.