Location of Repository

Alternative empires : Soviet montage cinema, the British documentary movement & colonialism

By Martin Stollery


This is a study of Soviet montage cinema and the British\ud documentary movement of the 1930s which brings together two\ud usually divergent methodologies: postcolonial theory and "new"\ud film history. The first chapter develops new insights into Eisenstein's\ud October and Vertov's The Man With the Movie Camera, The second\ud analyses two less well-known Vertov films, One Sixth of the Earth and\ud Three Songs\ud of Lenin, from the perspective of postcolonial theory,\ud The third considers Pudovkin's Storm Over Asia and traces its reception\ud in both the Soviet Union and England. The fourth and fifth chapters\ud expand general issues and themes raised by the first two, and pursue\ud specific questions raised by the third. These final chapters resituate the\ud work of the British documentary movement in relation to the culture\ud of British imperialism. This shift of focus entails the analysis of the\ud production and contemporary critical reception of a number\ud of films which have been marginalised in most retrospective\ud historical accounts of the movement.\ud By recontextualising these two groups of films, this study attempts\ud to demonstrate how their various representations of the non-Western\ud world are intertwined with and necessarily involve considering other\ud issues, such as: periodisation within film history; the "influence" of Soviet\ud montage on the British documentary movement; the construction\ud of authorship; the division between "high" and "low" culture; the\ud relationship between politics and film aesthetics; the postcolonial\ud challenge to Marxism; cinematic internationalism. The first two\ud chapters also integrate an ongoing critique of certain trends within\ud post-1968 film theory and criticism, which developed in close\ud association with a retrieval and revaluation of Soviet montage\ud cinema and Soviet avant-garde culture of the 1920s, One of the\ud aims of this thesis is to question some of the assumptions of this work,\ud whilst at the same time demonstrating that historical research, even\ud as it attempts to reconstruct former contexts, need not consign its\ud objects of study to the past, but can be used instead to raise\ud questions relevant to the present. In this respect, the thesis tries to\ud remain closer to the spirit of post-1968 than does much of the more\ud recent, "new" historical research into Soviet cinema and the British\ud documentary movement, to which it is nevertheless greatly indebted

Topics: PN1993
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:3954

Suggested articles



  1. (1) Film Journals: Close-Mo 1927-33 Film Art 1933-7 Cinema quarterly 1932-6 World Film News 1936-9. (2) Public Records Office, Kew:
  2. 68 and Film Culture, doi
  3. (1959). A Dying Colonialism doi
  4. (1991). A Face to the Shtetl: Soviet Yiddish Cinema 1924-36",
  5. (1982). Advertising in doi
  6. (1986). After the Great Divide, doi
  7. (1975). Alexander Korda: The Man Who Could rk Miracles,
  8. (1982). All That is Solid Melts Into Air doi
  9. (1984). An Avant-Garde for the 80s", Framework 24,
  10. (1969). An Economic History of the doi
  11. An Essay Towards The Man With the Movie Camera", doi
  12. and Robert Macmillan eds., "Document: John Grierson on Hollywood's Success", doi
  13. (1934). Andrei Zhdanov and others, Soviet Writers Congress
  14. (1991). Armor Fou", October 56, doi
  15. (1971). Art in Revolution: Russian Art in the Twenties",
  16. (1977). Artists in Revolution, doi
  17. (1966). Better Fewer, But Better" [1923], in Collected Works:
  18. (1986). Boy's Own Empire: Feature Films and Imperialism",
  19. (1986). Bringing the Empire Alive": The Empire Marketing Board and Imperialist Propaganda, 1926-1933",
  20. (1986). Britain's Outstanding Contribution to the Film: The Documentary-Realist Tradition",
  21. (1980). British Documentary in the 1930s and "Independence": Re contextualising a Film Movement",
  22. (1984). Caritalist Democracy in Britain, doi
  23. (1990). Cinema and Everyday Life: Soviet Workers Clubs of the 1920s",
  24. (1985). Cinema and State: The Film Industry and the British Government 1927-84, doi
  25. (1979). Cinema in the Thirties: Documentary Film and the Labour Movement",
  26. (1973). Cinema Weekly and Cinema Truth",
  27. (1988). Cinema, Censorship and Sexuality, doi
  28. (1990). Collets Guide to Moscow,
  29. (1989). Colonising Egypt, Cambridge, doi
  30. (1987). Constructivism in Film, Cambridge, doi
  31. (1992). Contested Culture: The Image, the Voice and the Law, doi
  32. (1993). Conventions of Sound in Documentary", doi
  33. (1978). Cultural Revolution as Class War",
  34. (1975). Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison doi
  35. (1973). Documentary Diary, doi
  36. (1939). Documentary Film [1936], revised and enlarged edition, London, Faber and Faber,
  37. (1979). Dreams of Adventure, doi
  38. (1971). Dziaa Vertov, Paris, Editions Champs Libre,
  39. (1979). Dziaa Vertov: A Guide to References and Resources,
  40. Early Sound Counterpoint", doi
  41. Early Soviet Cinema: The Spontaneous and the Planned, 1917-2411, doi
  42. (1993). Eisenstein and Russian Symbolist Culture: an Unknown Script of October",
  43. (1988). Eisenstein at 90", Sight and Sund 57: 3,
  44. (1975). Eisenstein, Vertov and the Montage Principle",
  45. Eisenstein's Epistemological Shift", doi
  46. Eisenstein's October",
  47. (1991). England and the Aeroplane, doi
  48. (1977). Entertainment and Utopia"
  49. Eothen [1844], Icon Books, doi
  50. (1963). Esth"ti e et Psychologie du Cinema; Volume I, Paris, Editions Universitaires,
  51. (1982). European Empires From Conquest to Collapse 1815-1960, doi
  52. (1966). Experiment in Autobiography: Volume One [1934], London, Victor Gollancz/The Cresset Press,
  53. (1988). Feminist Orientalism and Orientalist Marxism", New Left Review 170,
  54. (1980). Film and Political Organisations in Britain, 1929-39", in Don Macpherson ed., Traditions of independence,
  55. (1979). Film Art: An Introduction, doi
  56. (1972). Film as Film, doi
  57. (1957). Film Form and The Film Sense [1942/1949], doi
  58. (1929). Film Problems of Soviet Russia,
  59. (1979). Film Propaganda: Soviet Russia and Nazi Germany, doi
  60. (1983). Film Style and Technology: History and Analysis, doi
  61. (1979). Film's Instituional Mode of Representation and the Soviet Response", doi
  62. (1973). For God and Country", doi
  63. (1975). From Magician to Epistemologist: Vertov's The Man With the Movie Camera", doi
  64. (1936). From the Theory and Practice of a Script Writer" doi
  65. (1979). Grierson: A Documentary BioaraDhy London, Faber and Faber,
  66. (1987). Heavenly Bodies: Film Stars and Society, doi
  67. (1985). Hegemony and Socialist Strategy, doi
  68. History, Recognition",
  69. (1983). Immoral Memories, doi
  70. (1916). Imperialism, or the Highest Stage of Capitalism doi
  71. (1986). In the Service of the State: The Cinema Alexander Dovzhenko, doi
  72. (1992). In Theory: Classes, doi
  73. (1980). Independence" and the Thirties",
  74. (1991). Independent" Filmmaking and the State in the 1930s",
  75. (1990). Intertitles to Three Sonas of Lenin", doi
  76. (1990). Interview with Homi Bhabha: The Third Space" doi
  77. (1992). Invisible Eye", Sight and Sound 1: 10 (new series),
  78. (1960). Islam and the West: The Making of an Image, doi
  79. (1981). Ivan the Terrible, doi
  80. Jeremy Bentham in Russia", American Slavic and East European Review 15,1956,
  81. (1983). John Grierson and the Documentary Film Movement", doi
  82. (1989). Kino and the Woman Question, doi
  83. (1989). Labour and Russia,
  84. (1909). Leaves of Grass [1863], London, Cassell and Co.,
  85. (1989). Making Meaning, doi
  86. (1978). Marx and the End of Orientalism, doi
  87. (1977). Marxism and Literature, doi
  88. (1973). Marxism and the Philosophy of Language, doi
  89. (1983). Masters of Soviet Cinema, doi
  90. (1973). Montage October: Dialectic of the Shot",
  91. (1987). Narration in the Fiction Film, doi
  92. (1987). Notes for a Film of Capital" [1927-8),
  93. (1979). On Photography, doi
  94. (1978). Orientalism, doi
  95. (1978). Parliamentary Debates. IV MISCELLANEOUS Rick Altman, "The American Film Musical: Paradigmatic Function and Mediatory Structure"
  96. (1978). Pashukanis and the Withering Away of the Law",
  97. (1933). Preface to Rudolph Arnheim,
  98. (1973). Problems of Everyday Life,
  99. (1984). Propaganda and Empire, doi
  100. Reality at Second Hand", doi
  101. (1983). Red and Hot, doi
  102. (1992). ReiDresentina Reality,
  103. (1989). Representing the Colonized: Anthropology's Interlocutors", doi
  104. (1985). Representing the Nation: British Documentary Film 1930-45", doi
  105. Revolution, Collectivization and Soviet Cinema: Eisenstein's Old and New and Dovzhenko's E,. ├Żarth",
  106. (1989). Revolutionary Dreams, doi
  107. (1974). Revolutionary Soviet Film Posters, doi
  108. (1958). Rotha on the Film, London, Faber and Faber, doi
  109. (1920). Russia in the Shadows,
  110. (1983). Russian Constructivism, doi
  111. (1980). Russian Formalism: History, Doctrine [1955], The Hague, doi
  112. (1986). Selected Work in Three Volumes, doi
  113. (1978). Sergei Eisenstein" [1949], in Herbert Marshall ed., The Battleship Potemkin,
  114. (1980). Sergei Eisenstein",
  115. (1977). Sexuality and Power or the Two Others (part one)", Framework 6,
  116. (1990). Sitney, Modernist Montage, doi
  117. (1977). Slow Fade to Black, doi
  118. (1985). Soviet Cinema in the Silent Era, 1918-1935, doi
  119. Soviet Cinema in the Twenties: National Alternatives", doi
  120. (1970). Soviet Composers and the Development of Soviet Music, doi
  121. Soviet Film Distribution and Exhibition in Germany, 1921-33", doi
  122. Soviet Films, Censorship and the British Government: A Matter of the Public Interest", doi
  123. (1992). Soviet Politics 1917-1991, doi
  124. (1966). Stalin, revised edition, doi
  125. (1984). The Age of the Dream Palace,
  126. (1980). The Avant-Garde Attitude in the 1930s",
  127. (1990). The British Documentary Film Movement 1926-1946, Cambridge, doi
  128. (1971). The British in Egt, London, Weidenfeld and Nicolson,
  129. The Camera Eye and the Film",
  130. (1985). The Cinema After Babel: Language, Difference and Power", Screen 26: 3/4, doi
  131. (1992). The Cognitive Instrument in the Service of Revolutionary Change": Sergei Eisenstein, Annette Michelson, and the Avant-Garde's Scholarly Aspiration", doi
  132. (1987). The Colonial Harem, doi
  133. (1988). The Colonized Eve,
  134. (1963). The Communist Manifesto [1848], Peking, Peking Foreign Languages Press,
  135. (1973). The Country and the City, doi
  136. (1971). The Documentary Tradition, doi
  137. (1980). The Dominant Ideolocrv Thesis, London, George Allen and Unwin, doi
  138. The Fate of Popular Cinema in the Stalin Era", doi
  139. (1960). The Film Till Now [1930], revised and updated edition,
  140. (1970). The German Ideoloav [1847],
  141. (1963). The Heart to Artemis, doi
  142. (1933). The History of the Russian Revolution: Volume Two, doi
  143. (1982). The Hollywood Musical, doi
  144. (1990). The Island and the Aeroplane",
  145. (1992). The Issue of National Cinema and British Film Production",
  146. (1978). The Jewish Intelligentsia and Russian Marxism, doi
  147. (1988). The Jews of the Soviet Union, Cambridge, doi
  148. (1990). The Kinetic Icon in the Work of Mourning: Prolegomena to the Analysis of a Textual System", doi
  149. (1974). The Long View, doi
  150. (1964). The Modern History of Soviet Central doi
  151. (1971). The New Imperialism, doi
  152. (1991). The Origins of Soviet Cinema: A Study in Industry Development", doi
  153. (1980). The Pleasure Dome [1972], oxford, oxford
  154. (1981). The Point of Expression in Avant-Garde Film"
  155. (1979). The Politics of Soviet Cinema 1917-29, doi
  156. (1981). The Projection of Britain, Cambridge, doi
  157. (1932). The Projection of England
  158. (1975). The Rise and
  159. (1974). The Surrogate Proletariat, doi
  160. (1988). The Tradition of the Victim in Griersonian Documentary",
  161. (1973). Theories of Film, doi
  162. (1987). There Ain't No Black in the doi
  163. (2000). Towards doi
  164. (1971). Two Types of Film Theory" doi
  165. (1988). Visible Images,
  166. (1980). Vsevelod Pudovkin",
  167. (1989). War and Cinema, doi
  168. (1992). We Were Born to Turn a Fairytale into Reality: Svetlvi put" and the Soviet Musical of the 1930s and 1940s",
  169. (1967). What is Cinema?: Volume One,
  170. (1986). Who Wants to Know What and Why? ",
  171. (1992). Women and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate, doi
  172. (1983). Writing About Cinema: Close-Up 1927-33", PhD thesis,
  173. (1972). Youna Soviet Filmmakers,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.