Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

New Deal and minority ethnic young people : training, employment and integration?

By Patrick Boateng


New Deal for Young People was hailed as the Labour government's flagship'\ud initiative when it was introduced nationally in April 1998. The programme\ud promised to help young people who have been unemployed and claiming\ud Jobseeker's Allowance to find work and improve their prospects of gaining and\ud sustaining employment. It is especially pertinent to young people from minority\ud ethnic groups who have been identified as having an increased tendency to be\ud unemployed. However, the government's expressed intention to bring about\ud parity of job outcomes for minority ethnic young people has not been matched\ud with any real commitment, nor has it been matched at local level by the\ud Employment Service as well as employers with changes required to improve\ud institutional procedures and practices for the delivery of the programme.\ud This thesis presents the findings of research conducted in Southern Derbyshire.\ud Using both qualitative and quantitative approaches, it examines the perspectives\ud and experiences of young people from minority ethnic groups as they pass\ud through the various stages of New Deal, including work-placements. It argues\ud that young people from these groups have not benefited from the programme to\ud the same extent as their White counterparts

Topics: HD
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (2201) 'Non-meritocratic Job Requirements and the Reproduction of Class Inequality: An Investigation',
  2. (Eds. ) Racism and Equal Opportunities Policies in the 1980s (second edition) Cambridge:
  3. (1997). A big dealT, Connexions,
  4. (1995). A Dictionary of Feminist theory, 2 nd edn. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf Hutton,
  5. (2002). A New Deal for young people from minority ethnic communities in the UK,
  6. (1991). a) Annual Report,
  7. (2000). Afterword: Racism and the Research Process,
  8. (1992). Against the Odds: The Education and Labour Market Experience of Black Young People. Sheffield:
  9. (1994). annual Report,
  10. (1962). Anti-Minotaur: The myth of a value-free sociology,
  11. Audit Commission on (2004) The Journey to Race Equality,
  12. (1997). Benefit Sanctions for the unemployed: Tough Love or Rough Treatment? London: Employment Policy Institute,
  13. (1997). Beyond policy and politics: contingencies of employment equity'
  14. (1985). Bin-ningham LEA and Schools: Referral and Suspension of Pupils, Report of a Formal Investigation,
  15. (1984). Black and White Britain: the third PSI Survey,
  16. (1987). Black Youth Futures.
  17. (2001). Breaking down the Barriers: improving Asian access to social rented housing, Chartered Institute of Housing.
  18. (1996). Britain's Ethnic Minorities,
  19. (1998). British ethnic minorities and employment training: redressing or extending disadvantage? ',
  20. (1998). Brokering a New Deal: the design and delivery of welfare to work;,
  21. (2001). Building Cohesive Communities,
  22. (2003). Cabinet Office Report
  23. (1992). Careers and Identities,
  24. (2003). Changing patterns of ethnic disadvantage in employment',
  25. (1980). Cheerleaders and Ombudsman: The Sociology of Race Relations
  26. (1997). Choices and penalties: a discussion paper on the policy of directing unemployed people to attend mandatory government programmes,
  27. (1983). Danger! Astrologers at work: a critical note on the narrow orthodoxy of race relations research',
  28. (1996). Declining racial disadvantage in the British labour market,
  29. (1997). Discourses of Social Inclusion and integration: From the European Union to New Labour', paper presented at the Europlan Sociological Association Conference,
  30. (1994). Discplining the subject: the power of competence'.
  31. (1993). Doing Research on Sensitive topics,
  32. (1996). Education and Training for 16-18 Year Olds: Individual Paths and National Trends. Policy Studies Institute.
  33. (1986). Education for Some: The Educational and Vocational Experiences of 15-18 Young People of Minority Ethmc Groups,
  34. (1990). Equal Opportunities Policy and Race Equality,
  35. (1989). Equal opportunity in the private sector: the limits of voluntarism'
  36. (2003). Equality and Diversity in Local Government in
  37. (1988). Ethnic Minorities and the Careers Service: An Investigation into Processes of Assessment and Placement. A Report for the Department of Employment by the Centre for Research in Ethnic Relations,
  38. (1990). Ethnic minorities and the Careers Service. Department of Employment.
  39. (1984). Ethnic Minorities and the Youth Training Scheme,
  40. (2001). Ethnic Minorities in the Labour Market; Comparative Policy Approaches (Western Europe)', Report commissioned by the Performance and Innovation Unit, Cabinet Office.
  41. (1983). Ethnic Minorities: their experience on YOP,
  42. (1999). Ethnic Minority Strategy: Engaging ethnic minority jobseekers, businesses and providers.
  43. (1999). Europe: The Third Way/Die Nene Mitte (available via www.
  44. European Commission/House of Conu-nons (I 996b) Government response to the second report from the Employment Committee, Session 1995-96: the right to work/workforce, annex,
  45. (2002). Evaluation of 6 and 12 Month Enhanced JSA Process,
  46. (1994). Evaluation of Workstart pilots, report No 279,
  47. (1990). Feminist methodologies in criminology: A new approach or old wine in new bottles?
  48. (1979). Field Research in Minority Communities: Ethical, Methodological and Political Observations by an Insider',
  49. (1987). For Richer, For Poorer: Growing Up
  50. (1995). for Voluntary organisations
  51. (1998). From equality to social inclusion; New Labour and the Welfare State;
  52. (2000). From full employment to employability: a new deal for Britain's unemployedT,
  53. (2001). Gaining Access
  54. (1998). Getting People Back to Work', Centre Piece Autumn:
  55. (1997). Getting Welfare to Work, London: Labour Party.
  56. (1986). Growing Up at the Margins. Milton Keynes:
  57. (1978). In search of power',
  58. (1982). In the abundance of water there is thirsty: sociology and black 'pathology',
  59. (1980). Interviewer variability: a review of the problem',
  60. (2001). Labour Market Participation of Ethnic Groups.
  61. (1984). Learning from the Field: A Guide from Experience with the collaboration of Kathleen King Whyte,
  62. (1997). Letter from Howells, K. Parliamentary Under Secretary of State, WEE to B Grant MP,
  63. (2003). Local Government Act 1999: Part I Best Value and Performance Improvement,
  64. (1995). Making Welfare Work,
  65. (1980). Managing the underclass': a further note on the sociology of race relations in Britain'. race and Class,
  66. (1988). Medical School Admissions: Report of a Formal Investigation into St George's Hospital Medical School,
  67. (2000). Minority Ethnic participation and achievement in education, training and labour
  68. (1989). Monitoring equal opportunities policies: principles and practice',
  69. (1998). New ambitions for our country: Anew Contract for Welfare,
  70. (1997). New Deal - Fair Deal? Black young people in the labour market. Barnado's,, The Children's Society and Youthland.
  71. (2000). New Deal and Ethnic Minority Participants in Labour Market Trends,
  72. (1999). New Deal for Young People: Leavers with Unknown Destinations, Sheffield: Employment Service Research and Development
  73. (2000). New Deal for Young People: National Survey of Participants: Stage 1. Sheffield: Employment Service Research and Development report
  74. (2001). New Deal for Young People: National Survey of Participants: Stage 2, Employment Service,
  75. (2001). New Deal for Young People: Survey of Leavers of to Unknown Destinations. Employment Service,
  76. (2000). New Deal for Young People: The National Options, Sheffield: Employment Service Research and Development
  77. (1998). New Deal for Young Unemployed People: A Good Deal for Employers?
  78. (1998). New Deal: Engaging Ethnic Minority Job Seekers and Businesses. London: Employment Service.
  79. (2000). New Deals for Young People and for Long Ten-n Unemployed: Survey of Employers, ESR 58, Employment Service,
  80. (1998). New Labour - New Labour Discipline',
  81. (2000). New Labour and the third way in British welfare state: a new and distinctive approach?
  82. (1999). NewPackaging, Old Deal? New Labour and Employment Policy Innovation',
  83. (1991). Objectivity and truth: Problems in doing feminist research
  84. (1992). On feminist methodology: male reason versus female empowerment,
  85. (2000). Partnership Practice,
  86. (1999). Poverty, Exclusion and New Labour', Critical Social Policy 19(l):
  87. (1994). Practising Feminist Research; The Intersection of Gender and Race in the Research Process'
  88. (1994). Qualitative Data analysis for Applied Policy Research, in A Bryman and R Burgess (eds) Analysing Qualitative Data.
  89. (2003). Quality in Qualitative Evaluation: A framework for assessing research evidence,
  90. (2000). Race and Ethnicity in Modern Britain (second edition) Oxford:
  91. (1994). Race of Interview Effects: A brief Comment' Sociology:
  92. (1989). Race Relations Research and Social Policy: A Review of Some Recent Debates and Controversies, Policy Papers in Ethnic Relations No. 18 Warwick, Centre for Research in Ethnic Relations.
  93. (2000). Race Research for the Future: Ethnicity
  94. (1992). Race, Discourse and Labourism,
  95. (1995). Race, Education and Work: the Statistics of Inequality.
  96. (2004). Race, Ethnicity and Difference: Imagining the Inclusive Society,
  97. (1994). Race, ethnicity and nation: International perspectives on social conflict,
  98. (1987). Race, Training and Employment,
  99. (1994). Race;, employment and equal opportunities: towards a political economy and an agenda for the 1990s', The Sociological Review
  100. (1977). Racial Disadvantage in Britain,
  101. (1968). Racial DiscnMination in England,
  102. (1993). Racial discrimination against doctors from ethnic minorities,
  103. (1985). Racial Discrimination: 17 years After the Act.
  104. (1998). Racial Equality and the New Deal,
  105. (1993). Racism and Migration in
  106. (1986). Racism and Recruitment: Managers, organisations and equal opportunities in the labour market,
  107. (1987). Racism and the YTS',
  108. (1998). Recruiting Long Tenn Unemployed People,
  109. (1999). Reinforcing the New
  110. (2000). Releasing Potential - young people on ageism at work,
  111. (2001). Researching Social Life,
  112. (1983). Response effects',
  113. (1991). Second Review of the Race Relations Act 1976: Consultative Paper',
  114. (1983). Skill Seekers: Black Youth, Apprenticeships and Disadvantage,
  115. (1997). Speech at the Aylesbury Estate,
  116. (1999). Statistical First Release: New Deal for Young People and Long Tenn Unemployed People aged 25+.
  117. (1995). Status Zero', Youth and the 'Underclass' Debate: Some considerations, paper presented at Youth
  118. (1987). Talking about YTS: the views of black young people',
  119. (1996). The Careers Library initiative:
  120. (1996). The Concept of Social Exclusion and the New Darkhermian Hegemony Critical Social Policy 46:
  121. (1992). The dilemmas of vocational training policy: some comparative lessons',
  122. (1995). The Drop Out Society: Young People on the Margin, National Youth Agency,
  123. (1990). The Emerging British Underclass. London: IEA, Health and Welfare Unit.
  124. (1996). The Employment Service national customer satisfaction survey
  125. (1988). The Finns That Like to Say 'Nol. Birmingham Trade Union Resource Centre.
  126. (1990). The future of Jobcentres, labour market policy and the Employment Service, employment paper
  127. (1998). The Inclusive S6ciety? '
  128. (1993). The Leaming Imperative.
  129. (1986). The Local Politics of Race,
  130. (1998). The Long Tenn Unemployed: What can be done? '
  131. (1949). The Methodology of the Social Sciences,
  132. (1995). The moment of municipal feminism: gender and class in 1980s local government'
  133. (1974). The New Black Sociology: Reflections on the Insiders and the Outsiders Controversy'
  134. (1995). The Politics of Social Research,
  135. (1995). The Slate, Young People and Youth Training,
  136. (1999). The Stephen Lawrence Inquig: Report of an inquiry by Sir William
  137. (1961). The Structures of Science. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul Newell.
  138. (1988). The study of sensitive subjects',
  139. (1986). The Theory and Practice of Equal Opportunity Policies: Liberal and Radical Approaches',
  140. (1995). Tontnuing vocational training in Europe',
  141. (1993). Towards a social market', Training Tomorrow,
  142. (1992). Training Enterprise Councils: the last throw of voluntarism? ',
  143. Transport, Local Government and the Regions (2001) Strong Local Leadership - Quality Public Services,
  144. (1985). Turning s Blind Eye': Racial Oppression and the unintended consequences of White 'non-racism'.
  145. (1987). Two-Track Training: Sex Inequalities and YTS.
  146. (1985). Typical Girls?
  147. (1997). Underworked and Underpaid',
  148. (1994). Vocational education and training for the young' in Sisson,
  149. (2000). Welfare Stages:
  150. (2001). Welfare Theory: An Introduction,
  151. (1999). Welfare to Work: National problems, local solutions? Critical Social Policy 19(4).
  152. (1967). Whose side are you on?
  153. (1999). Work for those Who Can, Security for Those who Cannot: a Third Way in Social Security Reform? ' Paper presented at Social Policy Association Annual Conference, Roehampton,
  154. (1998). Workfare: a political etymology',
  155. (1997). Workforce: Ideology for a New Underclass, Toronto:
  156. (2003). Working for an Inclusive Britain: An Evaluation of the West Midlands Forum Pilot Project, West Midlands Forum.
  157. (1997). Working nation: welfare refonn and the Australian Job Compact for the longterm unemployed,
  158. (1994). Workstart pilots: qualitative study, final report to the DE and ES,
  159. (1999). Young Caribbean mean and the labour market: a comparison with other ethnic groups, York Publication Services (Joseph Rowntree Foundation).
  160. (1997). Young people and Social Change,
  161. (2003). Young people, employment and the induction process, 347 Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
  162. (1995). Youth and Employment in Modem Britain,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.