Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Trade unions and employment relationship in privatised state enterprises : a case-study of the finance and petroleum industries in Nigeria

By Godwin Esierumua Erapi


Privatisation (defined as change of ownership and control of State-owned enterprises-\ud SOEs) is a controversial economic and political policy that elicits diverse opinions and\ud academic conclusions on its impact. With regard to its impact on industrial relations, the\ud privatisation literature concludes that in most privatised SOEs, problems anise between\ud unions and management over some important dimensions of the employment relationship.\ud This Author's search of the privatisation literature led to the emergence of two hypotheses,\ud as follows:\ud I. The employment relationship changes in its expression and management in\ud privatised enterprises as a consequence of the change in ownership and control,\ud structure and product market competition arising from privatisation; and,\ud 2. The employment relationship in privatised enterprises changes, not necessarily as a\ud consequence of privatisation, but as a consequence of changes in\ud managerial/corporate strategies, national and firm-level industrial relations policies\ud and other environmental factors not related to privatisation.\ud Data was collected from two privatised finance SOEs and one privatised petroleum SOE in\ud Nigeria to test these hypotheses. Some key findings emerged which differ slightly from the\ud conclusions of the privatisation literature, as represented by these two hypotheses. First, the\ud study concludes that contrary to the conclusion of the privatisation literature, the observed\ud changes in the employment relationship of privatised SOEs are mediated by the different\ud effects of environmental and sectoral factors, economic centrality, the nature of the unions\ud involved in bargaining and the balance of bargaining power between unions and\ud management, as determined by the development context of the country concerned.\ud Secondly, the study concludes that contrary to the conclusions of the privatisation\ud literature, the employment relationship in privatised enterprises changes as a consequence\ud of changes in managerial/corporate strategies and fin-n-level industrial relations strategies\ud directly related to privatisation. These conclusions suggest the need to slightly modify the\ud conclusions of the privatisation literature and theory to take account of the economic,\ud institutional and political differences between developing and developed economies, rather\ud than seek to apply similar theories and conclusions to both development contexts like is\ud currently the case

Topics: HD
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1984). 2- 78 trap'? The case of the Manufacturing Industries in Eritrea", downloaded from 1-i! ip: //www.
  2. (2001). 39 Firms listed for phase 11". This Day News, Lagos, Nigena, downloaded htlp: //www. thisdayonline. com/news/20010322newsO4. html from Thisday News.
  3. (1991). A flexible future: aspects of the flexibility debates and some unresolved issues',
  4. (1992). A union in change: a case study of the National Communication Union: Privatisation and Organisational Change. M. A thesis,
  5. (2001). Abridged Annual Reports and Accounts.
  6. (1992). Adjusting privatization: case studies from developing countries.. doi
  7. (1992). An Introduction to Collective Bargaining and Industrial Relations. doi
  8. (1962). An Introduction to Industrial Relations in Nigeria. London:
  9. (1966). and 1967. The evidence of the TUC to the Royal Commission on Trade Unions and Employers Associations.
  10. (2001). Annual Report and Accounts,
  11. (1993). Approaches to Social Enquiry. Oxford and Cambridge, doi
  12. (1996). Assessing Comparative Efficiency of The State-Owned, Mixed, and Private Sectors in Indian Industry",
  13. (1992). Bargaining Powe .
  14. (1996). Bargaining power and local labour market influences on wage determination".
  15. (2003). Behavioral Factors Influencing Union Bargaining Power", downloaded from http:
  16. (1995). Bureaucrats in Business. Oxford:
  17. (1990). Casting nets qnd testing specimens: Two grand methods of psychology.
  18. (1993). Chanjging public sector industrial relations: a case study of the privatisation of
  19. cited in Kikeri and Nellis, doi
  20. (1999). Collective Agreement". Lagos: NUPENG/NOLCHEM PlcNUPENG and PENGASSAN.
  21. (1984). Collective Bargaining in the Nigerian Private Sector",
  22. (2003). Communiqu6 issued at the end of a mediatory meeting held with PENGASSAN, NUPENG, NNPC, BPE, Federal Ministry Of Petroleum Resources,
  23. (2000). competition and regulation, Pans : OECD, doi
  24. (2002). Conference of Workers.
  25. (1998). Developments in the Insurance Industry in Nigeria"
  26. (1983). Distribution of total and retrenched staff by employers,
  27. (2001). Domestic Committee (First Bank Plc).
  28. (2001). Downloaded hqp: //papers. ss com/sol3/papers. cfm? abstract id=290604 mI from Galal,
  29. (1991). Emerging Trends in Public Sector Collective Bargaining: Implications for Industrial Relations in the 1990s",
  30. (1997). Employee Relations. doi
  31. (2002). Enterprise Reform and Labour in North Africa'
  32. (1971). European industrial Relations Observatory, downloaded from 287 http: //www. eiro. eurofound. le/1 999/12/study/index. html
  33. (1998). Federal Office of Statistics (FOS).
  34. (2003). Financial Highlights for the year ended 31
  35. (2000). Fiscal and Macroeconomic Aspects of Privatisation", doi
  36. (1998). Five-year Financial Summary.
  37. (1997). Five-year Financial Summqry.
  38. (2001). From State to Market: A Survey of Empirical Studies on Privatisation. doi
  39. (2004). Fuel hike: Marketers are fraudulent, liars- Akpatason, NUPENG President" in 'The Vanguard',
  40. (1999). Funding and Partnership Option for the Nigerian Economy in the Next Millennium"
  41. (2002). Government dumps NNPC privatisation" in 'Daily Champion', October 17,2002. Downloaded from htlp: //allafrica. com/sustainable/stories/200210170147. html
  42. (2000). Industrial Relations in Nigeria: Tbeory and Features (Second Edition).
  43. (1998). Industrial relations theory and trade union strategy",
  44. (1986). Industrial Relations: A development dilemma",
  45. (1988). Is Privatization the Answer? " Finance & Development. The World Bank & IMF.
  46. (1997). Labour and social dimensions of rivatization and restructuring - Public utilities Water, gas, electricity. Part 1: Africa .
  47. (2001). Labour vs. First Bank",
  48. (2002). Law and Collective Bargaining Power: Results of a Simulated Study", doi
  49. (1998). Macroeconomic framework for 1998-2000 Rolling Plan and
  50. (2000). Management in Nigeria"
  51. (1987). Management Policies towards labour: The unionisation of Nigerian employers",
  52. (1994). Memorandum of Understanding dated
  53. (2004). Ministry of Petroleum Resources, and the Department of Petroleum Resources.
  54. (2002). Nigeria shelves planned privatisation of NNPU in Company News: Africa, volume 7, issue no. 22, Wednesday,
  55. (2004). Nigerian Labour wams Shell on job cuts" (Wednesday,
  56. (2001). Nigerian privatisation venture co-operation falls".
  57. (2001). NNPC: Privatisation or Commercial i sation? National Interest Versus Economic Viability, paper presented at the workshop on Privatisation/Commercialisation programme in Nigeria: Challenges for labotirManagement Relations".
  58. (2001). NUBIFIE representation to the Executive Secretary, NEABIAI on various burning issues that had afflicted the union and suggestions for repositioning/growth of the union".
  59. (1994). op cit,
  60. (1987). Organisation (ILO). doi
  61. (2003). Organisation (UNIDO). doi
  62. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development doi
  63. (2000). Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). doi
  64. (1999). Ownership or Competition? An Evaluation of the Effects of Privatisation on Industrial Relations Institutions, Processes and Outcomes", doi
  66. (2002). PENGASSAN Gives Seven-Day Ultimatum" in 'The Vanguard', May 23,2002. Downloaded from http: //allaftica. com/stories/200205230660. html
  67. (2002). PENGASSAN plans nationwide campaign against privatisation of refineries" in 'The Vanguard',
  68. (2001). Pertinent questions on casualisation/contract labour". A 271 paper presented at the Workshop on 'Casualisation'
  69. (1992). Policy, Planning and Research", Paper 400, cited in
  70. (1997). Privatisation and Efficiency: Industry effects of the sale of British Airways", doi
  71. (1993). Privatisation and Employment Relations. London and
  72. (1999). Privatisation and its benefits: Theory and Evidence".
  73. (2002). Privatisation and Labour: responses and consequences in global perspective.
  74. (1999). Privatisation and liberalisation in European telecommunications: comparing Britain, the Netherlands and France. doi
  75. (1995). Privatisation and Marketization'
  76. (1997). Privatisation and regulation: some comments on the U. K experience, London: Chattered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy.
  77. (1999). Privatisation and supply chain management : on the effective alignment of purchasing and supply after -privatisation. doi
  78. (2000). Privatisation and the Distribution of Assets and Income in Brazil", Working Papers, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace,
  79. (1991). Privatisation and the management of Industrial Relations in electricity distribution', doi
  80. (1998). PrivatIsation in Africa.
  81. (2000). Privatisation in Canada: Operating, Financial and Stock Price Performance with International Comparisons", working pape , doi
  82. (1996). Privatisation in the Arab countries: programmes, achievements and lessons". Paper presented at the Conference on Development Economics held at the Norwegian School of Economics and Business Administration,
  83. (2000). Privatisation in Transition Countries. "
  84. (1998). Privatisation of Nigerian public utilities: barriers and constraints"
  85. (2000). Privatisation, competition and regulation: twenty-ninth Wincott Memorial Lecture at Bishop Partridge Hall, Church House,
  86. (1991). Privatisation, Regulation and Industrial Relations", doi
  87. (2001). Privatisation: First phase yield N19 billion".
  88. (1989). Privatisation: the facts.
  89. (2000). Privatisation" (the electronic edition of the special country report on Nigeria published in Forbes Global,
  90. (1982). Privatising Public Enterprises: An Analysis of the Government's Case", Political Quarterl , doi
  91. (2001). Privatization in competitive sectors: The Record so far", Private Sector Advisory Services, World Bank, October 29,2001, Washington D. C: The World Bank.
  92. (1988). Privatization in Less Developed Countries: An Overview"
  93. (2003). Pros and Cons of Privatisation of Refineries under focus"
  94. (2001). Public Enterprises. doi
  95. (1997). Public Offerings of State-Owned and Privately-Owned Firms: An International Comparison", doi
  96. (2000). Resolutions of Management and Unions of Unipetrol Nigeria Ple with the Core Investor".
  97. (2002). Results of the Nigeria Firm Survqy (Final Version-
  98. (2003). Review of collective agreement between Nigeria Employers Association of Banks,
  99. (2000). Reviewing the Effectiveness of Privatisation as Enterprise Sales" , in Privatisation: An International Review of Performance,
  100. (2003). Shelve =N=-1.50k fuel tax, TUC tells FG" in 'The Vanguard' Wednesday, December 31,2003, downloaded from http: //www.
  101. (2003). Sociological Association (SASA) Congress on 'Resistance, Reconstruction and Democracy in Post-colonial Africa' doi
  102. (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis. doi
  103. (2000). State Shareholding and Corporate Performance: A Study of a Unique Chinese Data Set", Working Pape , London Business School,
  104. (1992). Surviving Your Dissertation: A Comprehensive Guide to Content and Process. doi
  105. (2003). Technical Efficiency in Some Privatised Enterprises in Nigeria", Paper Presented at the Eight Annual Conference on Econometric Modelling for Africa held at
  106. (2001). Terins of Settlement of Suit Number
  107. (1987). The argument for privatisation',
  108. (1995). The Art of Case Study Research. Thousand Oaks,
  109. (1999). The benefits of privatisation: Evidence ftom Mexico",
  110. (2001). The Bureau of Public Enterprises. doi
  111. (1979). The Changing System of Industrial Relations doi
  112. (2003). The Economic Intelligence Unit. doi
  113. (1998). The financial and operating perfon-nance of privatised finns during the 1990s" mimeo,
  114. (1997). The financial and operating performance of newly pnvatised firms: Evidence from developing countries", mimeo, Universite Laval, cited in Sheshinski and Lopez-Calva,
  115. (1994). The financial and operating performance of newly privatised firms: an international empirical analysis", doi
  116. (1998). The financial and operating performance of newly privatised firms: Evidence from developing countries", doi
  117. (1997). The government as a shareholder: A case from the United States",
  118. (1964). The History of Trade Unionism. London: Longman Green and Company.
  119. (1995). The impact of privatisation on distributional equity"
  120. (1990). The impact of privatisation on industrial relations in the water industry", unpublished paper presented to the Cardiff Business
  121. (1996). The impact of public policy on the banking system in Nigeria'.
  122. (1999). The imperative of privatisation. " Statement by President Olusegun Obasanjo on the occasion of the inauguration of the National Council on Privatisation at the Presidential Villa,
  123. (1999). The new protectionists: the privatisation of US trade policy",
  124. The Nigerian Stock Exchange. 1994.1994 Fact Book.
  125. (1987). The place of the Petroleum Industry in the Nigerian economy" (Text of a lecture delivered at the Command and Staff College,
  126. (1998). The privatisation of Japanese national railways. New York/London: doi
  127. (1994). The reconstruction of industrial relations in the privatised water industry', doi
  128. (1985). The rise and fall of Nigeria's Second Republic London: doi
  129. (2004). The UK's privatisation experiment: The passage of time permits a sober assessment",
  130. The welfare consequences of selling public entS!, Mrises. doi
  131. (1968). Trade Unions and Industrial Relations. doi
  132. (2002). Trade unions and institutional reform: Nigerian experiences with South African and Ugandan Comparisons",
  133. (2000). Trade unions at the crossroads. Employment and work relations in context series,
  134. (2000). Trends in unionisation and collective bargaining. Geneva: International Labour Office,
  135. (2003). Trivatisation, Labour, and Social Safety Nets'. Washington D. C: IMF, downloaded from httv: HR-ru.
  136. (1993). Understanding Employee Relations.
  137. (2001). Union bargaining power: A View from Japan".
  138. (2004). Unionisation of workers in the banking industry". NLC letter to 56 Nigerian banks dated February 23,2004. Downloaded from http: //wwW. nlcng. org├Żbanks/lettertobanks. htm Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation
  139. (1966). Urban Real Wages and the Nigerian Trade Union Movement, 1939-60', doi
  140. (2002). Wage discrimination system". NUBIFIE Letter to the Managing Director of Lion Bank Plc dated January 22,2002,
  141. (1987). Water works- keep it public: the trade unions response to the threat of privati-sation in the water industr . M. A thesis,
  142. (1999). When does privatisation work? The impact of private ownership on corporate performance in transition economies", doi
  143. (2001). Workers may shut utilities over privatisation". The Guardian Online,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.