Location of Repository

The feminisation of clerical work 1870-1914

By Stephen David McKenna


The following thesis has five main objectives: -\ud 1. To describe the role and position of women in clerical work in the\ud period circa 1870 to 1914.\ud 2. To understand the origins of the role and position of women in\ud clerical work hierarchies and to offer reasons for this role and\ud position.\ud 3. To use and link theoretical perspectives which are useful in\ud helping us to understand the origins of the role and position of\ud women in clerical work.\ud 4. To consider the impact of wider social structure upon the roles\ud and position of women in clerical work.\ud 5. To develop an overall framework for understanding the role and\ud position of women in society and in work.\ud These objectives will now be briefly expanded.\ud 1. To describe the role and position of women in clerical work in the\ud period circa 1870 to 1914.\ud Throughout the thesis considerable space is given to describing the\ud actual work, status and market situations of female clerks. This\ud descriptive element is the background against which the theoretical\ud framework is developed and tested. It also offers us some\ud appreciation of what work was actually like for female clerks in\ud the 1870 to 1914 period, and allows us to compare their conditions\ud with late twentieth century clerks.\ud 2. To understand the origins of the role and position of women, in\ud clerical work hierarchies and to offer reasons for this role and\ud position\ud The thesis seeks to investigate the historical process through which\ud females entered clerical work over the period 1870 to 1914. It seeks to\ud assess the role of economic environment in drawing women into clerical\ud work, and the changing 'status' of those women who become clerks. The\ud thesis notes the 'status' of clerical work in the 1870-1914 period\ud and how the perception of such work was changing.\ud 3. To utilise and link theoretical perspectives which are useful in\ud helping us to understand the origins of the role and position of\ud women in clerical work\ud The central objective of the thesis is to offer a theoretical\ud framework for the analysis and comprehension of women's role and\ud position within clerical work. In order to achieve this two\ud approaches to the study of historical development are drawn on.\ud Firstly, the concept of patriarchy; secondly elements of the\ud labour process debate. It is argued throughout the thesis, but\ud particularly in chapters six to eight, that within the context\ud of clerical work, the 'gender dimension' is of crucial significance\ud in determining the nature of female office work; their pay and\ud conditions of work; their job prospects and opportunities; the\ud determination of 'skill' in the office; control within the office.\ud In short, the existence of a Patriarchal frame of reference has\ud contributed to the structuration of and divisions within the\ud clerical labour force.\ud 4. To consider the impact of wider social structure upon the role and\ud position of women in clerical work\ud Intimately linked to objective three, the thesis aims to consider\ud the impact of wider social structure and values on the role and\ud position of women in clerical work. The importance of wider social\ud values concerning the role and position of women within society\ud is considered and related to the structuration of employment. The\ud thesis argues that wider social structure and values are of crucial\ud importance in determining the role and position of women within\ud clerical work.\ud 5. To develop an overall framework for understanding the role and\ud position of women in society and in work\ud The overall objective of this thesis is to contribute to the body\ud of literature which seeks to understand the manner in which female\ud employment patternsare determined, in part, by patriarchal social\ud relations; that is, relations between men and women. It offers no\ud assessment of how to overcome this problem, but, through recognition\ud of the interrelationship between economic or capitalist development\ud and patriarchal social relations in the clerical work context, the\ud thesis aims to inform and educate on the subtlety and insidiousness\ud of this relationship

Topics: HD
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:4157

Suggested articles



  1. (1855): Sisters of Charity.
  2. (1856): The Communion of Labour.
  3. (1857): Women and Work.
  4. (1906). (1863)): Shall My Daughter Learn a Business? Fingerpost
  5. (1865): Essays on Women's Work. doi
  6. (1869): Women's Work and Women's Culture: a series of essays.
  7. (1875): Silent Sisterhood, doi
  8. (1878): The Clerks Grievance.
  9. (1880): The Merchants Clerk.
  10. (1883): How Women May Earn a Living.
  11. (1884): Work for Women.
  12. (1886): Occupations for Women other than Teaching.
  13. (1887): Women and Work: an essay.
  14. (1888): A Dictionary of Employment Open
  15. (1891): The Typewriter Girl.
  16. (1894): Employment for Girls.
  17. (1894): Women's Work.
  18. (1897): Modern Business Methods.
  19. (1897): Outlines of Business Knowledge Requisite for Women.
  20. (1898): Beginners Guide to Office Work.
  21. (1976a): Victorian Clerks,
  22. (1976b): 'The Social Economy of Late Victorian Clerks',
  23. (1978a): 'The Contradictions in Ladies Education',
  24. (1978b): 'The Domestic Ideology and Women's Education',
  25. (ed)(1979): Technology and Toil
  26. (ed)(1981): The Unhappy Marriage of Marxism and Feminism, doi
  27. (Sir Lyon Playfair); 1886-90 (Sir Matthew White Ridley).
  28. (1900). 294 Countess of Aberdeen (ed)
  29. (1977). A Framework for British Business History', doi
  30. (1909). A Guide. doi
  31. (1932). A Short History of Women, doi
  32. (1977). A Widening Sphere, doi
  33. (1911). Accounts of Expenditure of Wage Earning Women and Girls,
  34. (1965). An Economic History of England, doi
  35. and Lady Dilke (1890): Clerks and Shop Assistants of both Sexes.
  36. (1913). Association of Women Clerks and Secretaries
  37. (1979). Beyond the Domestic Labour Debate',
  38. Blackie (1888): Commercial Education: Women Workers.
  39. (1953). By Hand and Brain, Allen and Unwin,
  40. (1979). Capitalism, Patriarchy and Job Segregation by Sex', doi
  41. (1976). Capitalism, The Family and Personal Life, doi
  42. (1979). Capitalist Patriarchy and the Case for Socialist Feminism, Monthly Review doi
  43. (1981). Class and the Corporation, doi
  44. (1975). Class in a Capitalist Society, doi
  45. (1971). Class Inequality and Political Order, doi
  46. (1986). Class, Status and Gender',
  47. (1958). Clerical Unions in the Civil Cervice, Blackwell and Mott,
  48. (1915). Commercial Work and Training for Girls.
  49. Committee Appointed to Consider the. doi
  50. Contemporary Books and Articles T. Anderson (1882): History of Shorthand.
  51. (1979). Contested Terrain, doi
  52. Davidson (1894): What our Daughters Can Do For Themselves.
  53. (1979). Developing a theory of capitalist patriarchy and socialist feminism', doi
  54. (1986). Developing the managerial strategies approach to the labour process; Capital and Class, doi
  55. (1902). Educated Working Women. doi
  56. et al (eds)
  57. et al (eds) (1975): Job Redesign,
  58. et at (eds) (1986a): Managing the Labour Process,
  59. (1906). Evidence before the Select Committee on Post Office Servants (Charles Edward Hobhouse),
  60. (1985). Family ideology: identification and exploration, doi
  61. (1980). Female Shorthand Typists and Typists, doi
  62. (1981). Female Underemployment in Urban Labour Markets',
  63. (1964). Feminism and Family Planning in. Victorian England, doi
  64. (1977). Feminism and Female Emigration, 1861-1866, in M. Vicinus (ed), op cit.
  65. (1978). Feminism and Materialism, doi
  66. (1909). for the Employment of Women doi
  67. (1981). Foreign Trade: Competition and the Expanding International Economy',
  68. (1983). Gamarnikow et al (eds)
  69. (1981). Girls Growing up in Late Victorian and Edwardian doi
  70. (1981). Girls Wives and Factory Lives, doi
  71. Graffenried (1890): Needs of Self-Supporting Women.
  72. Harper (1894): Revolted Women-Past, Present and to Come.
  73. (1971). Hidden from History, doi
  74. Hill (1881): Business Aspects of Ladies Work.
  75. Hodgson (1869): The Education of Girls and the Employment of Women of the Upper Classes.
  76. Houlston's Industrial Library (1877): The Banker's Clerk.
  77. (1971). Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses' doi
  78. (1972). Ideology and Utopia, doi
  79. (1982). If it's only women it doesn't matter so much',
  80. (1974). Image and Reality: the Myth of the Idle Victorian Woman, '
  81. (1980). In defence of Patriarchy',
  82. (1986). Industrialisation, Gender Segregation and Stratification',
  83. (1969). Industry and doi
  84. (1977). Industry and Labour, doi
  85. (1986). Jobs for the Girls: The Expansion of Clerical Work for Women, 1850-1914',
  86. (1974). Labor and Monopoly Capital, Monthly Review doi
  87. Ladies (1893): Ladies at Work, Papers on Paid Employment for Ladies. doi
  88. Ladies Association for the Care of Girls (1893): Women Workers.
  89. (1982). Making Histories,
  90. (1976). Management Strategy and. doi
  91. (1979). Marxism and Feminism, Towards a More Progressive Union', Capital and Class, doi
  92. (1965). Mergers in Britain Manufacturing Industry, 1880-1918', Oxford Economic Papers,
  93. Milne (1857): The Industrial and Social Position of Women in the Middle and Lower Ranks.
  94. Milne (1870): Industrial Employment of Women in Middle and Lower Ranks.
  95. (1966). Monopoly Capital, Monthly Review Press, doi
  96. (1983). Not so much a factory, more a form of patriarchy: Gender and Class during Industrialisation; in E. Gamarnikow et al (eds), op cit.
  97. (1911). Office Organisation and Management. doi
  98. (1899). Office Routine for Boys and Girls
  99. (1976). Office Work for Women: an historical review', doi
  100. (1979). On Patriarchy', doi
  101. Orchard (1871): The Clerks of Liverpool.
  102. Parsons (1876): Clerks: their position and advancement.
  103. (1983). Patriarchal Exploitation and the Rise of English Capitalism',
  104. (1978). Patriarchy and relations of production', in A. Kuhn and A. Wolpe (eds), op cit.
  105. (1986). Patriarchy at Work, Polity, doi
  106. (1981). Peasants, Patriarchy and the Feudal Mode of Production in England', doi
  107. (1984). Post Office Workers, Allen and Unwin, doi
  108. (1909). Professions for Girls.
  109. Publications (In. chronological order) The Reorganisation of the Civil Service - The Northcote-Trevelyan Report,
  110. Reports of the Local Government Board, 1873-74,1886,1899,1909-10. Reports and Evidence of the Royal Commissions on the Civil Service.
  111. (1978). Sex and Class in the Labour Process',
  112. (1982). Sex and Skill in the Organisation of the Clothing Industry;
  113. (1978). Sexual Division of Labour: the Case of Nursing',
  114. (1982). Sexual Harassment at Work,
  115. (1982). Skilled Manual Workers in the Labour Process', doi
  116. (1980). Social Stratification and Occupations, doi
  117. (1978). Soldon
  118. (1977). Some notes on female wage labour', doi
  119. Southam (1894): Typewriting as a Means of Earning a Livelihood.
  120. (1909). Statistics of Women's Life and Employment. doi
  121. (1972). Stereotypes of Femininity in a Theory of Sexual Evolution',
  122. (1972). Suffer and be Still: Women in the Victorian Age, doi
  123. (1982). Taylorism, Responsible Autonomy and Managerial Strategies', inS. Wood (ed), op cit.
  124. (1976). Technology, the Labour Process and the Working Class, Monthly Review Press,
  125. (1958). The Blackcoated Worker, doi
  126. (1916). The Business Girls Handbook.
  127. (1928). The Cause: A Short History of the Women's Movement in
  128. (1977). The Changing Social Structure of England and Wales, doi
  129. (1973). The Class Structure of Advanced Societies, doi
  130. (1848). The Clerk's Instructor and Manual
  131. (1935). The Condition of Clerical Labour in Britain,
  132. (1982). The Degradation of Work,
  133. (1974). The Dialectic of Sex,
  134. (1967). The Emergence of the Large-Scale doi
  135. (1979). The Enormous File,
  136. (1980). The Family Wage', doi
  137. (1980). The family wage': some problems for socialists and feminists', doi
  138. (1977). The Forgotten Women of the Period: Penny Weekly Magazines of the 1840s and 1850s', in M. Vicinus (ed) op cit.
  139. (1972). The Genesis of the Northcote-Trevelyan Report',
  140. (1985). The Ghost in the Labour Process', in D. Knights et al (eds), op cit.
  141. (1976). The History of the Housewife', in E. Malos (ed), op cit.
  142. (1982). The Home Office 1848-1914, doi
  143. (1974). The housewife and her labour under capitalism',
  144. (1913). The Junior Woman Secretary.
  145. (1916). The Lady Clerks Manual.
  146. (1981). The Marriage of Capitalist and Patriarchal Ideologies: Meanings of Male Bonding and Male Ranking in US Culture', in L. Sargent (ed), op cit.
  147. (1983). The Nature of Work,
  148. (1978). The Nineteenth Century Woman: Her Cultural and Physical World, doi
  149. (1976). The Other Side of the Paycheck: Monopoly Capitalism and the Structure of Consumption',
  150. (1976). The Politics of Housework, Ahlon and Busby,
  151. (1928). The Railway Clerk's Association and its path of progress,
  152. (1981). The Role of Trade Unions in the Promotion of Equal Opportunities, research commissioned by the EOC/SSRC.
  153. (1970). The Royal Exchange Assurance, Allen and Unwin, doi
  154. (1982). The sexual division of labour and the labour process', in S. Wood (ed), The Degradation of Work,
  155. (1959). The Social Structure of the Family',
  156. (1977). The Sociological Imagination doi
  157. (1974). The Tender Technicians: the Feminisation of Public Librarianship, doi
  158. (1979). The Trouble with Patriarchy',
  159. (1972). The Victorian Governess',
  160. (1971). The Victorian Woman, Allen and Unwin,
  161. (1982). Typing our way to freedom: is it true that new office technology can liberate women? ' in E Whitelegg et al (eds), op cit. doi
  162. (1972). Utilitarianism and Bureaucracy',
  163. Vanderbilt (1884): What To Do With Our Girls.
  164. (1973). Victorian Ladies at Work, David and Charles, doi
  165. (1977). Victorian Masculinity and the Angel in the House', in M. Vicinus (ed), op cit.
  166. (1977). Victorian Wives and Property',
  167. (1981). What is the real material base of patriarchy and capital', in L. Sargent (ed), op cit.
  168. (1967). White-Collar
  169. (1982). Whitelegg et al (eds)
  170. (1981). Woman Lost and Found: the Impact of Feminism on History',
  171. (1973). Women and social stratification: a case of intellectual sexism', doi
  172. (1986). Women and the 'Service Class',
  173. (1978). Women and the Division of Labour',
  174. (1901). Women and their Work.
  175. (1977). Women and Trade Unions, doi
  176. Women in Insurance; - doi
  177. (1984). Women in Trade Unions, doi
  178. (1938). Women Servants of the State, doi
  179. (1983). Women, Gender Relations and Wage Labour', in E. Gamarnikow et al (eds), op cit.
  180. (1978). Women, Sex and Class', in A. Kuhn and A. Wolpe (eds), op cit.
  181. (1980). Women's Oppression Today, doi
  182. (1979). Women's Place is at the Typewriter: the Feminisation of the Clerical Labour Force',
  183. (1978). Women's work and theories of class and stratification', doi
  184. (1980). Word Processing and the Transformation of Patriarchal Relations doi
  185. (1985). Work Organisation',
  186. (1914). Working Women in Seven Professions.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.