Location of Repository

English Romanesque tympana : a study of architectural sculpture in church portals c.1050-c.1200

By Duncan Blair Cameron Givans


This thesis presents a study of the use made of tympana in English Romanesque\ud portals and the evidence they offer for religious, social and cultural expression in village\ud churches where the vast majority of examples are preserved. In order to achieve this a\ud significant proportion of the analysis has been addressed to the manner in which people\ud may have interpreted what they saw. For the convenience of the reader basic descriptions\ud of all examples noted during the course of the research and details of manorial and patronal\ud circumstances are given as the Handlist in Volume 2.\ud The first two chapters establish the parameters of the research, outline the social\ud and religious environment during the period, and the art historical principles underpinning\ud the research. Chapter III examines the distribution of examples in geographical terms and\ud the use made of tympana in different categories of building. In chapter IV the structural\ud and compositional formulation of tympana is analysed and the use made of geometric\ud ornament. Chapter V assesses images of Christ and the relationship between these and the\ud representation of power. Chapter VI examines other human figural iconography through\ud the categories of figure-types depicted. The subject of chapter VII is the use of\ud compositional types as a means to assess the use made of beast imagery.\ud The thesis demonstrates for the first time in a systematic and quantified manner\ud that tympana are a significant feature of English Romanesque portals and that a strong\ud decorative character is shared by all tympana, thus contributing to the adornment of the\ud house of God in a befitting manner. It argues that the iconography was composed so as to\ud ensure the utility of the images as a focus for devotion for a wide variety of audiences and\ud as a means of expressing social values, particularly through the relationship between the\ud figures depicted and the representation of temporal power. The thesis also confirms that\ud the religion presented by examples with figural sculpture is centred on the authority of God\ud and the saints and on iconic symbols, rather than exemplars for emulation, reflecting the\ud conservative nature of devotion in local communities. The thesis therefore raises\ud important issues in relation to our understanding of portals as architectural features, the\ud expression of religious devotion and social values in local communities during the period,\ud and the use of portals in the practice of religious devotion

Topics: BR, NA
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:4168

Suggested articles



  1. (1990). A Commentary on the Bible, with supplement
  2. (1997). A Latin Dictionary (Oxford 1879). Lewis et a11997:
  3. (1983). A Legend and its Image: The Aerial Flight of Alexander the Great in Medieval Art (Groningen 1995). Schmitt doi
  4. (1991). A Romanesque Viritatio Spulchri at Kempley', Burlington Ma a ne Vol.
  5. (1990). A Short History of St Mary the Virgin, Horton church guide, no date, c.
  6. (1985). Adam of Eynsham, Magna vita sancti Hugonis" The life of Hugh of Lincoln, 2 Vols. doi
  7. (1984). Age of Chivalry: Art in Plantagenet England 1200-1400, Royal Academy of Arts, London, exhibition catalogue (London 1987). Alford
  8. (1912). An Account ofMedievalFigure-Sculpture in England (Cambridge
  9. (1976). Annals of WWichcombe and Sudeley (London 1877). Deshman
  10. (1999). Antiquities of Shropshire, 12 Vols. (London 1854-60). Faith
  11. (1996). Appendix: The Prefaces of Quadripartitud,
  12. (1997). Architectural Sculpture in Romanesque England Forms, Functions and Audience,
  13. (1974). Art and Patronage in the Engluh Romanesque, Society of Antiquaries of London Occasional Paper, New Series No.
  14. (1990). Ashley church guide, no date, c.
  15. (1994). B. Abou-el-Haj, The Medieval Cult of the Saints- Formations and Transformations doi
  16. (1946). Beakhead Ornament in Norman Architecture',
  17. (1997). Beowulf. The Monsters and the Critics: Sir Israel Gollancz Memorial Lecture, The British Academy,
  18. (1972). Bishop ofAmiens, Carmen de Hastingae proelio doi
  19. (1965). Brooke Gilbert Foliot and his Letters doi
  20. (1990). Building Stone in Norfolk'
  21. (1980). Cathars and Catholics in a French Village 1294-1324 (Harmondsworth 1980). Lees 1881: T. Lees, 'An Attempt to Explain the Sculptures over the South and West Doors of Long Marton Church', Transactions of the Cumberland and Westmoreland Antiquarian and
  22. (1981). Christ Church Cathedra4 Canterbury, Corpus vitrearum Medii Aevi: doi
  23. (1996). Church Archaeology: Research Directions for the Future, Council for British Archaeology Research Report No. 104 doi
  24. (1990). Concerning Angouleme, Riders and the Art of Gregorian Reform', doi
  25. (1999). Corfe 1999: Corfe Castle, National Trust guide to Corfe doi
  26. (1984). Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture Vol I. " County Durham and Northumberland Published in 2 Parts doi
  27. (1988). Corpus ofAnglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture Vol II: Cumberland, Westmorland and Lancashire North-of-the-Sands doi
  28. (1964). Councils and Synods nith other documents relating to the English Church 2,1205-1313,2 Vols. doi
  29. (1969). Croom
  30. (1972). Cross (eds), Eleven Old English Rogationtide Homilies (Toronto 1982). Beckwith doi
  31. (1995). Debate: The Pastoral Organization of the Anglo-Saxon Church: a review of the Minster Hypothesis', Early Medieval History, doi
  32. (1977). Durham Episcopal Charters 1071-1152, Surtees Society Vol.
  33. (1980). Ecclesiastical Culture and Folklore in the Middle Ages: Saint Marcellus of Paris and the Dragon',
  34. (1991). English Art 1100-1216,
  35. (1922). English Heritage Book of Wharram Perry, Deserted Medieval Village (London 1990). Bilson
  36. (1980). English Seals From the Mid-Ninth Century to 1100', journal of the British Archaeological Association Vol. doi
  37. (1961). English Stone Building, new edn. (London 1994). Cochrane 1994: L. Cochrane, Adelard of Bath: The First English Scientist (London 1994). Cockayne
  38. (1980). et as Collections Towards the History and Antiquities of the County of Hereford (Hereford 1804-1915). Dyer
  39. (1908). Etruscan and Roman Architecture (Harmondsworth 1970). Bond doi
  40. (1990). Eyre: The Norman Church at Aston Eyre, Aston Eyre church guide, no date, c.
  41. (1969). Finberg
  42. (1983). Fitz Nigel Dialog us de scaccario
  43. (1973). Further Thoughts on the Boar at St Nicholas' Church, Ipswich',
  44. (1963). Gethyn Jones, 'An Eleventh Century Tympanum' doi
  45. (1980). Guide to Barfrrystone Church and its World Famous Carvings Barfreston church guide, 91h edn. no date, c.
  46. (1950). Herefordshire Domesday x. 1160-70, Pipe Roll Society Vol.
  47. (1999). III et Edw. I in Turr' Lond' et in Curia receptae scaccarii Westm' asservati, 2 Vols., Record Commission (London 1812-18). Impey 1999: E. Impey, 'The Manor House, Boothby Pagnell, Lincolnshire',
  48. (1954). IL Willems, Augustine, In johannis Evangelium tractatus CXXIV(Tumholt 1954).
  49. (1972). Images of Lust: Sexual Carvings on Medieval Churches (London 1986). Werkmeister 1972: 0. K Werkmeister, `The Lintel Fragment Representing Eve From Saint-Lazare, Autun', Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes Vol. doi
  50. (1986). Latin for Local Historians, an introduction, 2nd edn.
  51. (1994). Law and Government in Medieval England and Normandy: Essays in Honour of Sir James Holt (Cambridge doi
  52. (1994). Law, and Lordship in Anglo-Norman England (Oxford 1994). Hudson 1996a: doi
  53. (1995). Layamon's Brut orHystoria Brutonum (London
  54. (1979). Le dragon terrasse, theme triomphal depuis Constantin',
  55. (1986). Les Ateliers de sculpture de Saint-etienne de Caen au XI° at au XII° siecles',
  56. (1995). Les linteaux en batiere romans d'Auvergne. Recherche sur la typologic et les origines', Cahiers de civilisation mediivale doi
  57. (1995). Literacy in Anglo-Saxon England: The Evidence from Inscriptions', doi
  58. (1973). liturgy and Drama in the Anglo-Norman Adam, Medium Aevum Monographs: New Series Vol. 3
  59. (1962). London 1878). Grabar 1969: A. Grabar, Christian Iconography: A Study of its Origins, doi
  60. (1997). Ludlow Castle: Its History and Buildings (Logaston 2000). Shopkow 1997: L Shopkow, History and Community : Norman Historical Writing in the Eleventh and Twelfth Centuries doi
  61. (1990). Lyne: Stoke Lyne Parish Church, Stoke Lyne church guide, no date, c.
  62. Medieval Architecture, Me&eva Learning: Builders and Masters doi
  63. (1998). Medieval Art: Recent Perspectives. A Memorial Tribute to C. R Dodwell doi
  64. (1971). Medieval Religious Houses, England and Wales, 2nd edn. doi
  65. (1981). Medieval Religious Houses: Scotland, 2nd edn. (London 1976). Cowdrey doi
  66. (1998). Millinaire monastique du Mont Saint-Michel III: histoire et vie monastiques doi
  67. (1927). Mynors (eds. & trans), Historia ecclesiastica gentis Anglorum, Bede's Ecclesiastical History of the English people (Oxford 1969). Collingwood
  68. (1881). Notes on the History of Beckford',
  69. (1988). Piers Plowman and Local Iconography. The Font at Eardisley, Herefordshire', doi
  70. (1956). Pop ular Religion in Late Saxon England- Elf Charms in Context (Chapel Hill doi
  71. (1984). Popular Religion in the Middle Ages. - Western Europe (London doi
  72. (1988). Portals and Politics in the Early Italian City State: The Sculpture of Nicholaus in Context Parma doi
  73. (1996). Reece doi
  74. (1921). Remarks on a Norman Tympanum at Fownhope and others in Herefordshire', Transactions of the Woolhope Naturalists' Fieldclub for 1918-20
  75. (1982). Renaissance and Renewal in the Twelfth Century doi
  76. (1995). Rewriting Old English in the Twelfth Century (Cambridge 2000). Swanson
  77. (1957). Romanesque Arches Decorated with Human and Animal Heads',
  78. (1988). Romanesque Carvings From St John the Baptist Church, Hagley, and Dudley Priory', Transactions of the Worrestershirr Archaeological Society, 3Id Series Vol.
  79. (2000). Romanesque Churches of the Loire and Western France
  80. (1992). Romanesque Sculpture and the Spectator', doi
  81. (2001). Romanesque Tympana: A Study of Architectural Sculpture in Church Portals c. 1050-c. 1200 3 Volumes Duncan Blair Cameron Givans I ., ýr { '1f ý 'S:: .., Volume. 3 Thesis submitted for the degree o?
  82. (1991). Rouse (eds. ), Registrum Anglie de l'bris doctorum et auctorum veterum, based on the Latin text established doi
  83. (1995). Salter (eds. ) The Register of St Augustine's Abbey, Canterbury, commony called the Black Book 2 Vols. (London 1915-24). Tweddle et al
  84. (1983). Scandinavian Influence in Norman Literature of the Eleventh Century',
  85. (1997). Sculpture and Patronage in a Shropshire Manor. A Group of TwelfthCentury Sculptures from Alveley', doi
  86. (1991). Semiotics and Art History', doi
  87. (1990). Siddington Parish Church, Siddington church guide, no date, c. doi
  88. (1997). Sir Garvain and the Green Knight 2nd eds., revised by N. Davis (Oxford 1967). Toman
  89. (1990). Stanley: The Parish Church of St Swithin, Leonard Stanley, Leonard Stanley church guide, no date, c.
  90. (1913). Summerson
  91. (1905). Supplementary Notes on the Sculpted Tympana at Quenington', doi
  92. (1962). The Anglian Cathedral of North Elmham, Norfolk: Analysis and Excavation by the Ancient Monuments Branch of the Ministry of Public Buildings and Works',
  93. (1981). The Anglo-Norman Village',
  94. (1986). The Anglo-Saxon Church: Papers on History, Architecture and Archaeology in Honour of Dr doi
  95. (1976). The Archaeological Study of Churches, Council for British Archaeology Research Report No. 13 doi
  96. (1997). The Arts and Learning',
  97. (1980). The Church of St Keri and St Petroc Egloskerry, Egloskerry church guide, no date, c.
  98. (1996). The Civil War of 1139-53
  99. (1979). The Dymock School of Sculpture (Chichester 1979). Gillingham
  100. (2000). The Early Phase of Appropriation of Parish Churches in Medieval England', doi
  101. (1983). The Early Romanesque Tower of Sompting Church, Sussex',
  102. (1979). The English Church 1066-1154 (London 1979). Barnard doi
  103. (1983). The History and Antiquities of the Counties of Westmorland and Cumberland, 2 Vols. (London 1777). Nichols 1795-1815:
  104. (1997). The Iconography of Christ Victor in Anglo-Saxon Art A New Approach to the 'Harrowing of Hell' Relief in Bristol Cathedral',
  105. (1967). The Letters and Charters of Gilbert Foliot, Abbot of Gloucester (1139-48), Bishop of Hereford (1148-63), and London (1163-87) doi
  106. (1979). The Letters of John of Salisbury: Vol II, The Later Letters 1163-1180 doi
  107. (2000). The Life ofSt Anselm Archbishop of Canterbury by Eadmer (Oxford 1962). Southern
  108. (1924). The Lincolnshire Domesday and the 1indrey Survey, with an introduction
  109. (1987). The Local Church in Domesday Book and Before',
  110. (1988). The Medieval Imagination doi
  111. (1993). The MedievalAlexander, text edited by
  112. (1999). The Monastic Order in Yorkshire 1069-1215 doi
  113. (1992). The Peace of God Social Violence and Religious Response in France Around the Year 1000 doi
  114. (1965). The Saga of the Volrungs (London 1965). Finucane
  115. (1970). The Saint in Medieval Literature', Modern Language Review Vol. doi
  116. (1959). The Sculptural Decoration of Halford Church, Warwickshire, unpublished MA report, University of London
  117. (1977). The Stained and Painted Glass',
  118. (1963). The Transition from Romanesque to Gothic in English Sculpture', Acts of the 201h International Congress of the History of Art
  119. (1998). trans), Anselm of Canterbury: The Major Works
  120. (1952). Two Peasant Contributions to Church Endowments', English Historical Review Vol. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.