Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Prospects for the upskilling of general workers in Britain : a case study comparison of the English and Irish dairy processing industries

By Enda James Hannon

Abstract

While there is strong evidence that longstanding systemic weaknesses in the British\ud economy continue to lead to negative strategic, skills and employment outcomes across\ud much of British industry, there has in recent years been a notable lack of empirical research\ud in the skills and employment relations fields aimed at examining the potential for upskilling\ud or 'employment upgrading' to be achieved for general workers. It is apparent that issues of\ud political economy and in particular the relationship between institutional contexts,\ud competitive performance and skills/employment outcomes at sector level have been largely\ud neglected.\ud This thesis seeks to partly fill this gap by presenting data from a comparative case study of\ud the English and Irish dairy processing industries, the central focus of which was an\ud examination of the consequences for company strategies, employee skills, employment and\ud wage levels of the overriding emphasis on the promotion of competition and efficiency and\ud the lack of a strong industrial policy in the former, and in contrast the existence of a strategic\ud and resource intensive industrial policy in the latter. This research provides an ideal\ud opportunity to address two issues of current theoretical concern, namely the potential for an\ud industrial policy to facilitate upskilling and debates regarding the advantages and\ud disadvantages of different 'varieties of capitalism'.\ud In general terms, the industrial policy context in England was found to inhibit investment in\ud product development and in particular moves by processors in to higher value, advanced\ud market niches, with negative consequences for employee skills and comparatively low wages\ud resulting. However these outcomes were to some extent mitigated by the presence in the UK\ud industry of a number of high-investing foreign multinationals who undertook very\ud substantial new product development, thereby facilitating some notable upskilling for\ud production workers.\ud In Ireland, while significant limitations in both the nature and extent of impact were\ud identified, the 'benign' industrial policy context was found to support processors in moving\ud into advanced product markets, and consequently underpinned the creation of substantial\ud opportunities for upskilling alongside a high standard of living for production operatives.\ud However skills outcomes at workplace level were found to be heavily contingent on a\ud number of different factors, with upskilling not found to be either an automatic or likely\ud consequence of a move up market. In addition, the fact that vocational training in the\ud industry continued to be of a predominantly informal, on-the-job nature was found to create\ud significant tensions and lead to dissatisfaction on the part of production operatives.\ud This research demonstrates the general value of the adoption of a supportive/strategic\ud industrial policy in terms of the potentially positive consequences resulting for strategy,\ud skills and employment outcomes. However it also highlights how the potential of such a\ud policy to facilitate upskilling is limited, being heavily influenced/determined by the\ud structural makeup and key characteristics and trends within particular sectors and product\ud markets. In addition, the need to address broader systemic issues relating to work\ud organisation, the labour process and the nature of vocational training systems is emphasised.\ud More broadly, the findings highlight the problematic nature of the central theoretical\ud conclusion and policy recommendation from the varieties of capitalism literature, that liberal\ud market economies like the UK should accentuate the deregulated/fluid nature of capital,\ud labour and product markets and focus attention on activities/sectors dominated by 'radical'\ud as opposed to 'incremental' innovation; and in contrast arguably demonstrate the need for\ud and potential of the development of thick institutional structures and substantial industry\ud support measures, even in 'traditional' sectors such as dairy

Topics: HD
OAI identifier: oai:wrap.warwick.ac.uk:4471

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2000). (200 1): Varieties of Capitalism: the institutional foundations ofcomparative advantage, doi
  2. (1996). 1): In Demand: Adult Skillsfor the 21" Century, London: the Cabinet Officc, Performance and Innovation Unit,
  3. 8). High Level Skills, Knowledge Transfer and Industrial Performance:
  4. (1995). A doi
  5. (1987). A second look at productivity, machinery and skills in Britain and Germany', doi
  6. (2000). A Strategic Review of the Irish Dairy Sector, Dublin: Irish Cooperative Organistion Society.
  7. (2003). a): The World Market for Dairy products, Global report,
  8. (1986). Ae British Worker Question. - a new look at Workers and Productivity in Manufacturing, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  9. (2002). Afanaging Employment Change: The New Realities of Work, doi
  10. Agriculture and Food (2000a): Agrifood2010: Alain Report, Dublin: the Stationery Office.
  11. (2003). Agriculture and Food (2000b): Agrifood 2010: Plan of Action, Dublin: the Stationery Office, Department of Trade and Industry (2005): The State Aid Guide., guldancefor state aid practitioners,
  12. (2004). Ahead of the Curve. - Ireland's Place in the Glohal Economy, Enterprise Strategy Group Report,
  13. and O'Donnell (2003): 'Industrial Relations, HRM and Performance,
  14. (1995). Apples and Oranges Revisited: Contextualiscd Comparisons and the Study of Comparative Labor Politics', Politics and society, doi
  15. (2003). Beyond butter, cheese and powder: non. traditional dairy products: facts, implications and challenges',
  16. (2003). Book Review of Managing Employment Change: The New Realities of
  17. (1993). Britain's low skill equilibrium: a problem of dernand? ', doi
  18. (1998). British Manufacturing Organization and Workplace Industrial Relations: Some Attributes of the New Flexible Firm', doi
  19. (1989). Building theories from Case Study research', doi
  20. (1994). Case Studies in Organisational ResearcW,
  21. (1997). Clusters in Ireland. The Irish Dairy Processing Industry: An Application of Porter's Cluster Analysis,
  22. (2000). Collaborative Production" and the Irish Boom: Work Organisation, Partnership and Direct Involvement in Irish Workplaccs',
  23. (1998). Comparative International Industrial Relations'. doi
  24. (2001). Competition, competitiveness and Enterprise policies',
  25. (2004). Competitive Performance in Irish Industry',
  26. (1999). Competitiveness and the Problem of Low Skill Equilibria: a comparative analysis", doi
  27. (2002). Contemporary Strategy Analysis: Concepts, Techniques and Applications, 4th edition,
  28. (1999). Contractual (in) Security, Labour Regulation and Competitive Performance in the Port Transport Industry. A Contextualized Comparison of Britain and Spain', doi
  29. (2000). Converging Divergences: IF'or"Vide Changes in Employment Systems, doi
  30. (1999). Creating Self-Sustaining, Ifigh-Skill Ecosystems', doi
  31. (2003). Dairy Facts and Figures doi
  32. Defra (2002a): Strategyfor Sustainable Farming and Food - Facing the Future, London: Department of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.
  33. Defra (2002b): Response to the Report ofthe Policy Commission on the Future of Farming and Food by HMGovernment, Cm 5709, London: Department of the Environment Food and Rural Affairs.
  34. (2002). Developing a Political Economy of SkillT,
  35. (1997). Different Responses to Common Demands: Firms, Institutions and Training in Europe', doi
  36. (2003). EC State Aid Law andPolicy, Oxford: I lart.
  37. (1999). Education and Trainingfor Development in East
  38. (2000). Employers Skill Survey: Case Study -Food Manufacturing Sector (National Skills Task Force Report SKT34),
  39. (1999). Employers' perceptions and implementation of S/N-VQs in Britain: a critical overview', doi
  40. (2003). Employment Relations and Corporate Governance', doi
  41. (1997). Employment Relations in a Changing Morld Economy, doi
  42. (1995). Enterprise-related Training and State Policy in Ireland: The Training Support Scheme,
  43. Euromonitor (2003b): Packaged Food in Ireland,
  44. (2004). European Integration and Industrial Relations: Multi-Level Governance in the Making, doi
  45. (1993). Evolution of the Irish Dairy sector since
  46. (2005). Exploring Corporate StrateV, 7"' edition,
  47. (2005). Exploring the Concept of 1:, mployer Demand for Skills and Qualifications: Case Studies from tho Public Sector',
  48. (2003). French capitalism transformed, yet still a third variety of capitalism', doi
  49. (2005). Growth in Output and Living Standards Pay Determination,
  50. (1998). In the Eye of the Beholder: Ethnography in tile Study of Work',
  51. (1999). Indigenous and Foreign Industry: Characteristics and Performance'
  52. (1996). Industrial Policy in
  53. (2003). Introduction: The British Industrial Relations Tradition
  54. (1999). Ire Skills Ilia Answer? The Political Economy of Skill Creation
  55. (1995). It Ain't what you do, it's the way that you do it: Production Organisation and Skill Utilisation in Commercial Vehicles', doi
  56. (2002). Job Insecurity and lVork intensification, doi
  57. (1998). Large-Scale National Surveys for it jel Mapping, Monitoring, and Theory Development',
  58. (1999). Localised leaming and industrial competitiveness', doi
  59. (1983). lVhyAre the British Radat Manufacturing?,
  60. (1979). Manufacturing Consent, doi
  61. (1992). Markets, Firms and the Management ofLabour in Afodern Britain, Cambridge:
  62. (2000). Methods Matter Changes in Industrial Relations Research and their Implications', doi
  63. (2001). Milk Task Force Report, London: DEFRA (available at littp: //www,
  64. (2000). Models of Capitalism: Growth andStagnation
  65. (1999). National Economic and Social Council
  66. (1999). New Technology Industries',
  67. (2001). Organizational Proximity and Institutional Learning: The Evolution of a Spatially Dispersed Network in the Irish Furniture Industry',
  68. (1999). Pay and working time: towards organisation based systems? ', doi
  69. (1999). Pay Equity and the National Minimum Wagewhat do the Theories tell us? ', doi
  70. (1992). Policy Review Group
  71. (2003). Prices and Profitability in the British dairy chain, Report to the Milk Development Council, London: Milk Development Council.
  72. (1989). Productivity and Vocational Skills doi
  73. (1995). Productivity, Education and Training. - an internationalperspeclive, Cambridge:
  74. (1985). Productivity, machinery and skills in a sample of British and German manufacturing plants: results of a pilot enquiry', doi
  75. (1989). Productivity, machinery and skills: clothing manufacture in Britain and Germany', doi
  76. (1994). Productivity, Product Quality and Workforce Skills: Food Processing in Four European Countries' doi
  77. (2002). Public Policy, the Performance of Firms, and the 'Missing Middle': The Case of the Employment Regulations, and a Role for Local Business Networks", doi
  78. (2003). Putting Skills to work: learning and employment at the Start of the Century', doi
  79. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis: an expanded sourcehook, 2"d edition,
  80. (1991). Qualitative Methods in Management Research,
  81. (2003). Re-visiting the Nordic Approaches to Work Reorganization and Job Redesign: Lessons for UK Skills policy', doi
  82. (2000). Realism and Social Science, doi
  83. (2002). Reframing Employment Relations: the Case for Ncopluralism', doi
  84. (2000). Reorganisation of Milk Marketing Arrangements in the United Kingdom, doi
  85. (1990). Reshaping Work: the Cadbury Experience, Cambridge: doi
  86. (1999). Scottish Food and Drink Strategy, Glasgow: Scottish Enterprise. (available at wwNy. scottishfooda! ]dý1[ink, goill,
  87. (1999). Sectoral Training Initiatives in the US: Building Blocks of a New Workforce Preparation System? ',
  88. (1997). Selecting Case Studies in Business Research',
  89. (2003). Serving the InnovalionAgenda, Brochure prepared for the Moorepark Food Research Open Day,
  90. (1996). Skill Shortages in the Clothing Industry: An Endemic Problem? ", doi
  91. (2003). Skills and Competitive Strategy in the UK Fitness industry', doi
  92. (1989). Skills and the limits of neo-liberalism: the enterprise of the future as a place of leaming', doi
  93. (1992). Social Institutions and Economic Performance, doi
  94. (2004). Social Research Methods, 2 nd edition, doi
  95. (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis, doi
  96. (1999). Still a Model for the Industrialized CountriesT,
  97. (2003). Strategic Development Plan for the Irish Dairy Processing sector, Dublin: Enterprise Ireland/ICOS/Irisli Dairy Industry Association.
  98. (2003). Strategy and Human Resource Alanagement, doi
  99. (1992). Ta rechcrchd comParative cn relations industricllcs. ' Vapport de ]a tradition ethnographique,
  100. (2003). Tackling the Low Skills Equilibrium. - A Review of Issues and Some New Evidence',
  101. (2002). Taylorism, targets and the pursuit of quantity and quality by call ccntre management, doi
  102. (1999). The Assessment: Knowledge, Skills and Competitiveness', Oxford Review ofEconomic Policy, doi
  103. (1998). The Associallonal Economy. - Firms, Regions and innovation,
  104. (2005). The British Journal of Industrial Relations: Position and Prospect',
  105. (1991). The British Milk Marketing SYstern- implications for 1992', Proceedings ofthe 25" E4AE Sentinar,
  106. (1994). The British production regime: a societal specific systcm? ', doi
  107. (2005). The Challenging but promising future of industrial relations. developing theory and method in context-sensitive research'. doi
  108. (2002). The Chilled Food Alarket, a f5bn Five-Year Growth Opportunity,
  109. (1990). The Competitive Advantage ofAlations, doi
  110. (2003). The Demand and Supply of Skills in the Food Processing Sector, Report of Expert Group on Future Skills Needs,
  111. (1992). The Demise of the National Union in Italy: Lessons for Comparative Industrial Relations Theory', doi
  112. (2001). The dynamics of informality: employment relations in small f ims and the clTects of regulatory change', doi
  113. (1993). The Economics of Training, London' Harvester Wheatsheaf. doi
  114. (1988). The failure of training in Britain: Analysis and Prescription', Oxford Review of Economic Policy, doi
  115. (2000). The flexible developmental State: Globalisation, information technology, and the 'Celtic tiger"', doi
  116. (1999). The Future of the High-Skills Equilibrium in Germany'. doi
  117. (1999). The German Apprenticeship System under Strain',
  118. (2003). The Historical Evolution of British Industrial Relations', doi
  119. (2003). The Impact of the National Minimum Wage in Small Firms', doi
  120. (2002). The Impact of the National Minimum Wage on the Apparel industry, doi
  121. (2000). The Implications of Structural Change in the UK dairy industryfor dairy processors, unpublished PhD thesis,
  122. (2003). The implications of the National Minimum Wage for Training in Small Firms', doi
  123. (2003). The Labour Market: History,
  124. (2000). The Marketing ofMilk,
  125. (1998). The Modem Apprenticeship: new wine in old bottlesT,
  126. (2002). The New Political Economy of Postwar Britain'.
  127. (1985). The Peculiarities of the British Economy, LondonLawrence and Wishart.
  128. (2003). The Political Economy of Skill and the Limits of Education Policy', doi
  129. (1998). The Revival of Irish indigenous industry 1987-1997,
  130. (1998). The Role and Challenge of Case Study Design in Industrial Relations Research',
  131. (2001). The Specification and Quality of British Products',
  132. (1995). The Structure of the Labour Market',
  133. (1999). The TFelsh Dairy Sector: a strategic action plan, report prepared by the Welsh Dairy Industry Working Group, Aberystwyth- Welsh Development Agency. (Available
  134. (1989). The transformation of work? Skill, flexibility and tho labolir process, London: Unwin Hyman. 39 Wren, C (200 1): 'The Industrial Policy of Competitiveness: A Review of Recent Developments in the UK',
  135. (2004). The UK Productivity Gap: find out', ESRC Seminar Series, Council. what research tells us and what we need to Swindon: Economic and Social Research Euromonitor (2002): Retail Trade International - Ireland,
  136. (2002). The United Kingdom,
  137. (2002). The World We're In, doi
  138. (1995). Training and Development in Ireland: Context, Policy andPractice,
  139. (1990). Training Matters: Union Perspectives on Inclustrial Restructuring and Training,
  140. (2003). Training"'
  141. (2003). UK Competitiveness: moving to the next stage',
  142. (2002). UK Industrial Policy: Old Tunes on New Instruments? ', Oxford Review ofEconomic doi
  143. (1999). UK VET Policy and the 'Third Way'; following a high skills trajectory or running up a dead-end street? ". doi
  144. (1994). Varieties of Capitalism: the institutionalfoundations of comparative advantage,
  145. (2005). Varieties of Industrial Relations Research: Take-ovcr, Convergence or DivergenceT, doi
  146. (1992). Vocational training and British economic performance: a further instalment of the British labour problem, doi
  147. (1998). Was Ratner Right? Product Market and Competitive Strategies and links with Skills and Knowledge",
  148. (1998). What is Distinctive about Industrial Relations Research? ',
  149. (1996). Workforce Skills, Product Quality and Economic Performance' doi
  150. (2003). Workplace learning and the employment relationship in the Public sector'. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.