Location of Repository

Health sector reforms and human resources for health in Uganda and Bangladesh : mechanisms of effect

By Freddie Ssengooba, Syed Azizur Rahman, Charles Hongoro, Elizeus Rutebemberwa, Ahmed Mustafa, Tara Kielmann and Barbara McPake

Abstract

Background\ud Despite the expanding literature on how reforms may affect health workers and which reactions they may provoke, little research has been conducted on the mechanisms of effect through which health sector reforms either promote or discourage health worker performance. This paper seeks to trace these mechanisms and examines the contextual framework of reform objectives in Uganda and Bangladesh, and health workers' responses to the changes in their working environments by taking a 'realistic evaluation' approach.\ud \ud Methods\ud The study findings were generated by triangulating both qualitative and quantitative methods of data collection and analysis among policy technocrats, health managers and groups of health providers. Quantitative surveys were conducted with over 700 individual health workers in both Bangladesh and Uganda and supplemented with qualitative data obtained from focus group discussions and key interviews with professional cadres, health managers and key institutions involved in the design, implementation and evaluation of the reforms of interest.\ud \ud Results\ud The reforms in both countries affected the workforce through various mechanisms. In Bangladesh, the effects of the unification efforts resulted in a power struggle and general mistrust between the two former workforce tracts, family planning and health. However positive effects of the reforms were felt regarding the changes in payment schemes. Ugandan findings show how the workforce responded to a strong and rapidly implemented system of decentralisation where the power of new local authorities was influenced by resource constraints and nepotism in recruitment. On the other hand, closer ties to local authorities provided the opportunity to gain insight into the operational constraints originating from higher levels that health staff were dealing with.\ud \ud Conclusion\ud Findings from the study suggest that a) reform planners should use the proposed dynamic responses model to help design reform objectives that encourage positive responses among health workers b) the role of context has been underestimated and it is necessary to address broader systemic problems before initiating reform processes, c) reform programs need to incorporate active implementation research systems to learn the contextual dynamics and responses as well as have inbuilt program capacity for corrective measures d) health workers are key stakeholders in any reform process and should participate at all stages and e) some effects of reforms on the health workforce operate indirectly through levels of satisfaction voiced by communities utilising the services

Topics: RA
Publisher: BioMed Central
OAI identifier: oai:eresearch.qmu.ac.uk:337

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (2002). Assessment of the Effects of Unification on Health and Family Planning Services. Study Report.
  2. (2004). Civil Service Reform
  3. (1995). Civil Service Reform in the context of structural Adjustment Kampala: Ministry of Public Service;
  4. (1998). Decentralization and Human Resources: Implications and Impact. Human Resources for health Development Journal
  5. (2004). Development Report. doi
  6. (2001). Financial priorities under decentralization in Uganda. Health policy and Planning doi
  7. (1999). Health Briefing Paper DFID Health Systems Resource Centre: London;
  8. (2002). Health sector reform and public sector health work motivation: A conceptual framework. Social Science and Medicine doi
  9. (2002). Hornby P: The implications of health sector reform for human resources development. Bulletin of the World Health Organization
  10. (2000). Human resources and the success of health sector reform. doi
  11. (2002). Iftekhar MHM: Study on Enhancing Health System Performance using Procurement and Supply
  12. (2001). In Whose Interest Does the State Act? A Review of the User-fee Policy changes in Uganda. Uganda Health Bulletin
  13. (2001). Increased Utilization Reduced Quality: the Result of Abolition of Cost-Sharing in Busia. Uganda Health Bulletin
  14. Managing people in the health sector: Considering district team performance contracts
  15. Managing people in the health sector: Considering district team performance contracts in Cameroon. HPU, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
  16. Nganwa A: Progress Report on Decentralization
  17. Nganwa A: Progress Report on Decentralization of Health Services below the District Level in Uganda Ministry of Health.
  18. (1998). Okello D: User Fees in Government Health Units in Uganda: Implementation, Impact and Scope.
  19. (1999). Public service reforms and their impact on health sector personnel in Cameroon. In ILO/WHO Public service reforms and their impact on health sector personnel: Case studies on Cameroon Geneva: International Labour Organization/World Health Organization;
  20. (1998). Public service reforms and their impact on health sector personnel in Colombia. In ILO/WHO Public service reforms and their impact on health sector personnel: Case studies on Cameroon Geneva: International Labour Organization/World Health Organization;
  21. (1998). Rakhipbekov T: Reform of Primary Health Care in Kazakhstan and the Effects on Primary Health Care Worker Motivation: The Case of Zhezkazgan Region. Major Applied Research 5 Working Paper 3, Partnerships for Health Reform
  22. (2006). Recognising patterns: health systems research beyond controlled trials.
  23. (2003). sector Strategic Plan 2000/01 – 2004–05: Midterm Review Report Ministry of Health.
  24. (2000). Service Reforms and their impact on health sector personnel
  25. (2000). Service Reforms and their impact on health sector personnel in Uganda Geneva, ILO and WHO;
  26. (2004). Ssendyona GM: Payment of Lunch Allowance: A Case Study of the Uganda Health Service. Joint Learning Initiative working paper 4-2 Global Health Trust
  27. (1999). Sub-District in Uganda. Concept paper.
  28. The effects of reforms on the health workforce. Background paper to the World Health Report 2006; funded by DFID
  29. (1998). The Impact of Health Sector Reform on Public Sector Health Worker Motivation in Zimbabwe. doi
  30. (2003). The interface between health sector reform and human resources in health. Hum Resour Health doi
  31. (2003). The Study to Assess Implementation of HPSP using Essential Services Package
  32. (1996). The way forward. In Post Conflict Uganda: Towards an effective Civil Service Edited by: Langseth
  33. (1997). Thwin AA, Baqui AH: Developing Alternative Service Delivery Strategies for MCH-FP
  34. Thwin AA, Baqui AH: Developing Alternative Service Delivery Strategies for MCH-FP Services in Urban Areas: Findings From an Experi-
  35. Tilley N: Realistic Evaluation London: doi
  36. (1994). to the Budget Ministry of Finance, Planning and Economic Development.
  37. (2005). Ugalde A: Human resources: the Cinderella of health sector reform in Latin America. Human Resources for Health

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.