Location of Repository

The Adam Smith Problem Revisited: A Methodological Resolution

By Sigmund Wagner-Tsukamoto


The Adam Smith problem refers to a claimed inconsistency between the Theory of Moral Sentiments and the Wealth of Nations, regarding the portrayal of human nature in these two books. Previous research predominantly resolved the claimed inconsistency by uncovering virtuous, less selfish character traits in the Wealth of Nations. The present paper voices caution. I acknowledge – on methodological grounds – fundamental differences regarding the portrayal of human nature in Smith’s behavioural ethics, i.e. the Theory of Moral Sentiments, as compared with Smith’s economic research. The key argument is that Smith’s two books address different research problems and hence do not, need not and cannot adopt the same view of human nature – for methodological reasons, so my argument. Adam Smith scholarship overlooked that Smith himself in considerable degrees understood ‘economic man’ as a heuristic abstraction. I connect to the philosophies of science of Imre Lakatos and Karl Popper. Key words: Adam Smith problem; economic methodology; problem dependence; research heuristics; Popper; Lakatos. JEL classification Codes: B10 (History of Economic Thought through 1925 – General), B20 (History of Economic Thought since 1925 – General), B40 (Economic Methodology – General).University of Leiceste

Year: 2011
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/9976

Suggested articles



  1. (2003). [Review of] doi
  2. (1955). A behavioral model of rational choice‟, doi
  3. (1915). A History of Economic Doctrines: From the Time of the Physiocrats to the Present Day, doi
  4. (1993). A reconsideration of Das Adam Smith Problem‟,
  5. (1998). A study into Smith‟s conception of the human character: Das Adam Smith Problem revisited‟, doi
  6. (1979). A System of Social Science. Papers Relating to Adam Smith. doi
  7. (1991). Adam Smith and His Legacy for Modern Capitalism. doi
  8. (1927). Adam Smith and laissez faire‟, doi
  9. (1948). Adam Smith and the economic man‟, doi
  10. (1999). Adam Smith and the Virtues of Enlightenment. Cambridge: doi
  11. (1989). Adam Smith on business ethics‟, doi
  12. (1993). Adam Smith on the human foundation of a successful liberal society‟, doi
  13. (1997). Adam Smith on the virtues: A partial resolution of the Adam Smith problem‟, doi
  14. (1999). Adam Smith: Critical theorist?‟, doi
  15. (1927). Adam Smith: Moralist and philosopher‟, doi
  16. (1976). Adam Smith: The development of a system‟, doi
  17. (1979). Adam Smith: What kind of institutionalist was he?‟, doi
  18. (1994). Adam Smith‟s Discourse: Canonicity, Commerce and Conscience. doi
  19. (1986). Adam Smith‟s enduring particular result: A political and cosmopolitan perspective‟, in I. Hont doi
  20. (2005). Adam Smith‟s Moral Philosophy. Cambridge: doi
  21. (1959). Adam Smith‟s Moral Sentiments as foundation for his doi
  22. (1971). Adam Smith‟s Science of Morals. doi
  23. (1993). Altruism and economics‟, doi
  24. (1978). An Adam Smith renaissance Anno 1976? The bicentenary output – A reappraisal of his scholarship‟,
  25. (1776). An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations.
  26. (1990). Bounded rationality and behaviouralism: A classification and critique‟,
  27. (1978). Bounded rationality, ambiguity, and the engineering of choice‟, doi
  28. (1978). Conjectures and Refutations. The Growth of Scientific Knowledge. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. doi
  29. (1993). Contracts of Genesis‟, doi
  30. (2003). Das Adam Smith Problem: Its origins, the stages of the current debate, and one implication for our understanding of sympathy‟, doi
  31. (2006). Das Adam Smith Problem. A critical realist perspective‟, doi
  32. (1995). Das Rationalitätsprinzip„, in
  33. (1990). Deconstruction and the liberal order‟, doi
  34. (1993). Der Homo Oeconomicus als Heuristik‟, doi
  35. (1992). Der ökonomische Ansatz und das Problem der theoretischen Integration. Unpublished PhD Dissertation,
  36. (2005). Economic ethics, business ethics and the idea of mutual advantages‟, Business Ethics. doi
  37. (1995). Economic Evolution. An Enquiry into the Foundations of New Institutional Economics. doi
  38. (2001). Economic man vs. heterodox man: The concepts of human nature in schools of economic thought‟, doi
  39. (2001). Economic Sentiments. Adam Smith, Condorcet, and the Enlightenment. doi
  40. (1988). Economics and Institutions. A Manifesto for a Modern Institutional Economics. doi
  41. (1987). Economics Between Predictive Science and Moral Philosophy. College Station: Texas
  42. (1953). Essays in Positive Economics. doi
  43. (1869). Essays on Philosophical Subjects. doi
  44. (1993). Evolution and institutional change: On the nature of selection in biology and economics‟, doi
  45. (1970). Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes‟, in I. Lakatos doi
  46. (1990). Foundations of Social Theory. doi
  47. (1990). Further reflections on human-nature assumptions – part I: The „men‟ of Aristotle, Adam Smith et al. revisited‟, doi
  48. (1991). Further reflections on human-nature assumptions – part II: From Homo Oeconomicus Honorabilis to Homo Oeconomicus, the good steward‟, doi
  49. (1994). Homo oeconomicus und Dilemmastrukturen„,
  50. (1994). Homo socio-economicus: Foundational to social economics and the social economy‟, doi
  51. (1973). Homo Sociologicus. doi
  52. (1969). Human Nature and History: Vol.
  53. (2003). Human Nature and Organization Theory. On the Economic Approach to Institutional Organization. doi
  54. (1992). In Search of a Better World: Lectures and Essays from Thirty Year. doi
  55. (1949). Individualism and Economic Order. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. doi
  56. (1993). Institutions and credible commitment‟, doi
  57. (1994). Introduction: New directions in economic methodology‟, doi
  58. (1976). Introduction: Parallels and contrasts in structural inquiries‟,
  59. (2002). Introduction‟, in K. Haakonsen (Ed.), The Theory of Moral Sentiments [Adam Smith]. Cambridge: doi
  60. (2009). Is God an Economist? An Institutional Economic Reconstruction of the Old Testament. Basingstoke, UK et al.:
  61. (1999). Kritischer Rationalismus und die Methode der Sozialwissenschaften‟,
  62. (1974). Kuhn vs. Lakatos or paradigms vs. research programmes in the history of economics‟, doi
  63. (1762). Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres. doi
  64. (1978). Methodology of Economics and Other Social Sciences. doi
  65. (1998). Modeling Bounded Rationality. doi
  66. (1957). Models of Man. Social and Rational. doi
  67. (1972). Objective Knowledge. doi
  68. (2010). Out of a slave contract: The analysis of preHobbesian anarchists in the Old Testament‟, doi
  69. (1957). Polity and Economy: An Interpretation of the Principles of Adam Smith. The Hague: M Nijhoff. doi
  70. (1993). Popper and Lakatos in economic methodology‟, in doi
  71. (1993). Profits, Priests and Princes. Adam Smith‟s Emancipation of Economics From Politics and Religion. Stanford: doi
  72. (1976). Public goods and natural
  73. (1996). Rational choice, empirical research, and the Sociological tradition‟, doi
  74. (1990). Rational fools: A critique of the behavioral foundations of economic theory‟,
  75. (1995). Rationality and social choice‟, doi
  76. (1988). Regulating anew the moral and the political sentiments of mankind: Bernard Mandeville and the Scottish Enlightenment‟, doi
  77. (1981). Rethinking Das Adam Smith Problem‟, doi
  78. (1994). Scientific thinking without scientific method: Two views of Popper‟, doi
  79. (1986). Spheres of intimacy and the Adam Smith problem‟, doi
  80. (1998). The approach of institutional economics‟, doi
  81. (1976). The bicentenary of Adam Smith‟, doi
  82. (1897). The consistency of Adam Smith‟, doi
  83. (1987). The constitution of economic policy‟, doi
  84. (1990). The dehumanisation of economic science: In search of the appropriate methodology‟, doi
  85. (1976). The Economic Approach to Human Behavior, doi
  86. (1993). The economic way of looking at behavior‟, doi
  87. (1991). The Economics and the Ethics of Constitutional Order. Ann Arbor, Mich.: doi
  88. (1971). The Entropy Law and Economic Progress. doi
  89. (1994). The Lakatosian legacy in economic methodology‟, doi
  90. (1975). The Limits of Liberty. Between Anarchy and Leviathan. Chicago: doi
  91. (1977). The Logic of Scientific Discovery. doi
  92. (1978). The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes. Cambridge: doi
  93. (1988). The Moral Dimension. Towards a New Economics. doi
  94. (1994). The nature of man‟, doi
  95. (1995). The New Institutionalism and rational choice theory‟, doi
  96. (2009). The paradise story: A constitutional economic reconstruction‟, doi
  97. (1957). The Poverty of Historicism. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. doi
  98. (2000). The recurring “Adam Smith Problem‟, doi
  99. (1980). The selective interpretation of Adam Smith‟, doi
  100. (1982). The socialization of the individual in Adam Smith‟, doi
  101. (1759). The Theory of Moral Sentiments. doi
  102. (1987). The two voices of Adam Smith: Moral philosopher and social critic‟, doi
  103. (1967). Theories of the firm: doi
  104. (1994). Two proposals for the recovery of economic practice‟, doi
  105. (1994). Why I am not a constructivist: Confessions of an unrepentant Popperian‟, doi
  106. (2005). Wonder in the face of scientific revolutions: Adam Smith on Newton‟s “proof” doi
  107. (1966). Work and the Nature of Man. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.