Location of Repository

A Study on the Relationships among Stress, Coping Strategies and Job Burnout of Mainstream Secondary School Principals in Hong Kong

By Kitty Nim-yu Li

Abstract

This study investigates the relationships between the occupational stress, coping strategies and burnout amongst mainstream secondary school principals across government, aided and private sectors of Hong Kong. The study tests a modified version of Administrator Stress Cycle Model (Gmelch and Chan 1995) in terms of principals' perceived stressors, most frequently used coping strategies and level of burnout. Next, it investigates occupational stress, coping strategies, and burnout level in relation to nine demographic variables. Furthermore, it identifies the best predictors of burnout and the most effective coping moderators. All school principals from 450 mainstream secondary schools were invited to participate in the study with a return rate at 70%. They were asked to complete four questionnaires including demographic information, the modified Gmelch and Swent Administrative Stress Index, the modified Allison Coping Preference Scale and the modified Maslach Burnout Inventory. Results of the study show that Boundary-Spanning Stress emerged as the top stressor. The most preferred coping strategy was the use of Positive Attitude. Principals' burnout levels in Emotional Exhaustion, Depersonalization and Personal Accomplishment were moderate. Different types of significant relationship were found between the nine demographic variables and stress, coping strategies and burnout. Strong predictors of burnout in all three subscales were identified. Significant coping moderators buffering the effect of stress on burnout were found. The construct validity of the three modified instruments was established. The modified model on the Administrator Stress Cycle was statistically confirmed. The study concludes that the education reforms generated considerable stress on mainstream secondary school principals. Although the means of Emotional Exhaustion and Depersonalization were moderate, further analysis suggested that it might be reasonable to speculate that the burnout levels of Emotional Exhaustion and Depersonalization were high, which deserve our serious attention. Principals' work performance and well-being might be adversely affected if they have to continuously take on increasing tasks arising from the education reforms without substantial government support, policy changes and intervention programmes such as stress management

Publisher: University of Leicester
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:lra.le.ac.uk:2381/8990

Suggested articles

Preview

Citations

  1. (1996). 1 am the eye of the needle and everything passes through me: Primary Headteachers explain their retirement,
  2. (1977). A
  3. (2001). A comparison of the reported levels of Massachusetts secondary principals and their schools' scores on the
  4. (1988). A confirmation of the three-factor
  5. (1992). A consideration of the validity and meaning of self-report measures of job conditions,
  6. (1984). A data-based model of how teachers cope with work stress,
  7. (2000). A First Course in Structural Equation Modeling,
  8. (1983). A framework for planning stress interventions, Canadian Counselor.
  9. (1978). A model of teacher stress,
  10. (2000). A psychometric evaluation of the Occupational Stress Indicator,
  11. (1993). A review and an integration of research on job burnout,
  12. (1982). A social psychological grounded theory of teacher stress and burnout,
  13. (1988). A study of burnout, stress, and coping strategies among elementary principals, EdD dissertation,
  14. (1988). A Study of Job Stress of Secondary School Principals in Hong Kong, [in Chinese], Unpublished MEd thesis, the Chinese University of Hong Kong.
  15. (1992). A study of the levels of burnout as perceived by public school principals in the state of Maine, EdD dissertation,
  16. (1979). A study of the relationship between degree of stress and coping preferences among elementary school principals, EdD dissertation,
  17. (1996). A Wellness Prescription of Stress Levels by Secondary School Principals, Unpublished dissertation for the Doctor in Education,
  18. (1974). Adjustment as person-environment Fit, In
  19. (1992). Administrative burnout: a comparative study of the levels and perceptions of burnout of high school principals and superintendents. PhD dissertation,
  20. (1992). Administrative stress and burnout among public school administrators in Georgia,
  21. (1988). Administrator burnout: Findings and future directions,
  22. (1995). Administrator stress and Coping effectiveness: Implications for Administrator evaluation and development,
  23. (1990). An analysis of stress and coping skills among public school principals in North Carolina, EdD dissertation, South Carolina State College, Dissertation Abstracts International,
  24. (1994). An analysis of the extent to which school district superintendents experience burnout, EdD dissertation,
  25. (1982). An analysis of the relatioinship between stress and the public school principalship, EdD dissertation,
  26. (1996). An analysis of the relationship between stress and public school administrators,
  27. (1981). An approach to living: The third world escape form stress and burnout,
  28. (1995). An examination of the Transaction Approach in occupational stress research, In
  29. (1994). An Investigation into Burnout among Mississippi High School Principals, Paper presented at the
  30. (1992). An investigation of burnout as perceived by public high school principals,
  31. (1994). Anxiety and depresson among school principals -Warning, principalship can be hazardous to your health,
  32. (2002). Applied Multivariate Statistics for the Social Sciences 4th ed,
  33. (1986). Appraisal, Coping Health Status and Psychological Symptoms,
  34. (1990). April) Sex Roles and Perceived Job Stress of Washington Elementary Principals, Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association,
  35. (1991). April), Letting Go of Outlived Professional Identities: A Study of Role Transition for Principals in Restructured Schools, Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association,
  36. (1971). Are-evaluation of the concept of non-specificity in stress theory,
  37. (1976). Assertion Training: A Humanistic-Behavioral Guide to Self-Dignity,
  38. (1988). ATransactional Look at School Principal Stress. Paper presented at the annual meeting
  39. (1997). Basics of Structural Equation Modeling,
  40. (1979). Beating the 9-5 grind,
  41. (1982). Beyond burnout: Obstacles and prospects,
  42. (1977). Beyond Stress to Effective Management,
  43. (1976). Burned out,
  44. (1985). Burnout and the school principal,
  45. (1996). Burnout in heads of independent schools in South Carolina,
  46. (1993). Burnout in teachers: The concept and its unique core meaning,
  47. (1995). Burnout level stress of school-based administrators, EdD dissertation,
  48. (1983). Burnout Syndrome Among Hong Kong Secondary School Principals, Unpublished MEd thesis,
  49. (1982). Burnout: The Cost of Caring, Englewoord Cliffs,
  50. (1980). Burnout: The High Cost of High Achievement,
  51. (1988). Career Burnout: Causes and Cures,
  52. (1984). Case Study. In
  53. (1990). Chronic work stress and coping: A longitudinal study and suggested new directions,
  54. (1984). Communication climate and administrative burnout: A technique for relieving some of the pressures,
  55. (1994). Conducting and analysing interviews, In
  56. (1987). Controlling Work Stress,
  57. (1988). Coping Resources Inventory for Stress Manual, Atlanta: Health Prisms.
  58. (1986). Coping with job demands and avoiding stress: A gram of prevention,
  59. (1996). Coping with stress,
  60. (1990). Coping, negative affectivity, and the work environment: Additive 75, and interactive predictors of mental health,
  61. (1984). Coping, stress, and social resources among groups with unipolar depression,
  62. (2004). Could you ]dndly please check if the scales 1-6 of the Educator Survey mean the following? gov. hk> C(`: "kittyli" com> f E3 m: Thursday,
  63. (1991). Crisis in education: Stress and burnout: Assumptions, myths and issues,
  64. (1964). Demographic correlates of psychological strain,
  65. (1994). Designing single- and multiple-case studies, In
  66. (1992). Developing Expert Leadership for Future Schools London:
  67. (1996). Development and disenchantment in the professional life of headteachers,
  68. (1987). Doing your Research Project -A Guide for First-Time Researchers in Education and Social Science, Great Britain:
  69. (1981). edition.
  70. (1988). Educators' response to stress towards a coping taxonomy,
  71. (1991). Effects of the use of Management
  72. (1987). Exemplary principals and stress-How do they cope?
  73. (1996). Exploring causes of principal burnout,
  74. (1999). Factors of job-related stress as perceived by middle school principals in Virginia, EdD dissertation,
  75. (1979). Fate Control, Paper presented at the meeting of the California Association of School Psychologists and Psychiatrists,
  76. (1997). High school principal burnout: A study relating perceived levels of professional burnout to principal's reliance in social bases of power, EdD dissertation,
  77. (2004). Hong Kong Federation of Education Workers
  78. (2000). Identification of the level and perceived causes of stress and burnout among high school principals in South Carolina,
  79. (1997). Identifying factors that elementary principals perceived contributing to stress, EdD dissertation,
  80. (1992). Indiana female principals' perceptions of occupational stress and effective coping resources,
  81. (1989). Influential factors conducive to the occupational stress of female principals in Texas, EdD dissertation,
  82. (1985). Introduction to human stress and cognition in organizations, In
  83. (2003). Iowa School Superintendents' and Secondary School Principals' Perceived Stress in the Workplace, EdD dissertation,
  84. (1982). Job stress among school administrators: Factorial dimensions and different effects,
  85. (2003). Job Stress and Job Performance among employees in Hong Kong: The Role of Chinese Work Values and Organizational Commitment,
  86. (1988). Job-related stress factors and special educational administrative positions,
  87. (1975). Juvenile Theft: Causal Factors, London: Harper and Row.
  88. (1996). Life stress, personal control, and the risk of disease, In
  89. (1963). Man's Search for Meaning,
  90. (1984). Management team stressors and their impact on administrators' health,
  91. (1999). Managerial Stress in Hong Kong and Taiwan: a Comparative Study,
  92. (1984). Managing Communication Stress: The implications for communication administrators,
  93. (1991). Managing the Megaschool,
  94. (1993). Maslach Burnout Inventory Manual, Consulting
  95. (1996). Maslach Burnout Inventory Manual, Second Edition.
  96. (1991). Measurement of stress: Scaling the magnitudes of life changes,
  97. (1987). Method variance as an artifact in self-reported affect and perception at work: Myth or significance problem?
  98. (1976). Occupational sources of stress: a review of the literature relating to coronary heart disease and mental ill health,
  99. (1997). Occupational Stress Among Hong Kong Secondary School teachers, Unpublished Masters Thesis, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University.
  100. (1995). Occupational stress among school teachers: A review of research findings relevant to policy formation,
  101. (1993). Occupational stress and burnout in education administration, EdD dissertation,
  102. (1992). Occupational Stress and Burnout in Educational Administration, Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association,
  103. (2003). Occupational stress and coping strategies as perceived by secondary school principals in Kuala Lumpur,
  104. (1993). Occupational Stress as Perceived by Assistant Principals in Hong Kong Aided Secondary Schools Unpublished MEd thesis,
  105. (1988). Occupational stress factors as perceived by public school superintendents in Arkansas, EdD dissertation,
  106. (1979). Occupational stress profiles of male versus female administrators,
  107. (1983). Occupational Stressors and Administrative Role in Educational Organizations Paper presented at the annual meeting
  108. (2002). Occupational Stressors and Well-being among Chinese Employees: The Role of Organizational Commitment,
  109. (1984). Organizational stress and coping: A model and overview,
  110. (1984). Organizational Stress and Preventive Management,
  111. (1986). Perceived job-related stressors and coping strategies among high school principals in Pennsylvania, EdD dissertation,
  112. (1992). Perceived Stress of Secondary Public School Administrators
  113. (1994). Perceptions of occupational stress among public school principals in Tennessee, EdD dissertation,
  114. (1974). Person role fit, in McLean A. (Eds), Occupational Stress, Charles C. Thomas,
  115. (1998). Person-Environment Fit, In
  116. (1988). Polls and Surveys: Understanding What They Tell Us,
  117. (1997). Principal applicant drought oppresses districts nationwide,
  118. (1992). Principal burnout and personality type: Do relationships exist?
  119. (1992). Principal burnout in the public schools: A study comparing the perceived burnout levels of elementary, middle, and high school principals EdD dissertation,
  120. (1995). Principal burnout: Implications for professional development,
  121. (1994). Principal's leadership as a critical indicator of school performance: Evidence from multi-levels of primary schools,
  122. (1980). Professional Burnout in Human Service Organizations,
  123. (1979). Professional Burnout: A Personal Survival Kit,
  124. (1993). Professional Burnout: Recent Developments
  125. (2002). Professional Vitality and the Principalship: A Construct Validity Study, EdD dissertation,
  126. (1981). Psychological stress and coping techniques among selected elementary school principals, EdD dissertation,
  127. (1995). Psychological stress and the workplace: A brief comment on Lazarus' outlook, In
  128. (1995). Psychosocial stress in the workplace, In
  129. (2004). Re-thinking the Education Reform: People. Process, Priority and Professoionalism, Paper presented at the first Hong Kong Principals Conference,
  130. (1989). Reducing Stress in Schools: A School Administors' Guide to Managing Personal and Building-Level Stress,
  131. (2002). Reinventing the wheel: educational reform, In
  132. (1993). Relationships of burnout levels, coping preferences and selected demographic variables among Minnesota elementary principals,
  133. (2004). Reply from Consulting Psychologists Press (CPP) dated 1
  134. (1991). Research Methods in Education,
  135. (1993). Restructuring Schools: Learning from Ongoing Effects,
  136. (1986). School administrators and organizational stress: Matching theory, hunches and data,
  137. (1980). School administrators: Sources of stress and ways of coping with it, White Collar and Professional Stress,
  138. (1967). Somatic response patterning and stress: Some revisions of activation theory,
  139. (1989). Sources of burnout among educators,
  140. (1977). Sources of stress and burnout in professional child care work, Child Care Quarterly,
  141. (1996). Stress among high school principals in California high schools, EdD dissertation,
  142. (1995). Stress Among Primary School Teachers in Hong Kong, Unpublished Masters thesis,
  143. (1976). Stress and Behaviour in Organizations,
  144. (1984). Stress and burnout in suburban teachers,
  145. (1985). Stress and burnout: A comparison of principals in North Carolina school districts,
  146. (2003). Stress and coping preferences among female high school principals in California, EdD dissertation,
  147. (1996). Stress and Job Satisfaction Among Teachers in a Laissez-Faire Context where Carrots Are Already Out of Stock Unpublished Master thesis,
  148. (1986). Stress and Strategy, London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  149. (1980). Stress and teaching.
  150. (1982). Stress and the principalship: A comparative study of elementary and secondary principals in Virginia public schools, EdD dissertation,
  151. (1981). Stress and the principalship: strategies for self-improvement and growth,
  152. (1980). Stress and Work: A Managerial Perspective,
  153. (1977). Stress at the desk and how to creatively cope,
  154. (1984). Stress coping research: Methodological issues,
  155. (2002). Stress Faced by School Headteachers: A Study of Sources of Stress of Local Primary School Headteachers Unpublished MEd thesis,
  156. (1994). Stress in Academic Life: The Mental Assembly Line,
  157. (1987). Stress in the principalship: What causes it ?
  158. (1993). Stress Research and Stress Management: Putting Theory to Work
  159. (2000). Stress type and leadership style in the principalship.
  160. (1975). Stress Without Distress,
  161. (1978). Stress-related transaction between person and environment",
  162. (1984). Stress, Appraisal, and Coping,
  163. (1995). Stress, burnout and coping strategies among elementary school principals in Pennsylvania, EdD dissertation,
  164. (1999). Stress, burnout, and coping strategies among Washington State high school principals, EdD dissertation,
  165. (1998). Stress, coping strategies, and psychological distress among secondary school teachers in Hong Kong,
  166. (1983). Stress, health, and coping strategies of public school administrators,
  167. (2000). Stress, In
  168. (1987). Stress, time management, and selected demographic factors of elementary school principals in Connecticut,
  169. (1998). Stress: sources and coping strategies of secondary public school principals,
  170. (1993). Stressed? Who me?, Keynote Address to the Association of Catholic Secondary Schools Queensland.
  171. (1992). Surrey investigates job stress illuminated by deaths of school officials,
  172. (2002). Teacher Burnout in Hong Kong secondary schools, Unpublished Ph.
  173. (1996). Teacher stress and guidance work in Hong Kong secondary school teachers,
  174. (1996). Teachers Under Pressure: Stress in the Teaching Profession. London and
  175. (1982). The assessment of coping, defense, and stress,
  176. (1994). The association of role conflict and ambiguity with administrator stress and burnout,
  177. (1992). The changing principalship in Chicago,
  178. (1997). The Changing Role of the Principal in Washington State, Association of Washington School Principals,
  179. (1986). The current debate about the meaning of job stress,
  180. (1987). The dimensionalities of stress and their relationships to administrative characteristics,
  181. (1995). The impact of over-involvement on burnout and job satisfaction,
  182. (1998). The impact of personal professional, and organizational characteristics on administrator burnout,
  183. (1991). The New Meaning of Educational Change,
  184. (1989). The organizational framework for educational leadership,
  185. (1986). The perceived stress levels of primary and secondary principals,
  186. (1987). The perception of stress levels by secondary school principals in relation to age, experience in position, educational preparation and size of school student population, District of Columbia, EdD dissertation,
  187. (1990). The Person-Environment Fit Approach to Stress: Recurring problems and some suggested solutions,
  188. (2004). The Practice of Social Research,
  189. (1981). The reactive effects of self-monitoring anxiety,
  190. (1984). The relationship among elementary principals characteristics and job stress factors and perceived effectiveness and frequency of use of stress coping techniques, Doctoral dissertation,
  191. (2001). The Relationship between External Environments and Teacher Stress, Unpublished EdD thesis,
  192. (1991). The relationship between perceived sources of stress, coping preferences, and selected demographic variables exhibited by public elementary school principals of Texas, EdD dissertation, Texas A&M.
  193. (1999). The relationship between school principals' perceived levels of stress and selected demographic variables,
  194. (1984). The relationship of selected variables and perceived burnout among principals, EdD dissertation,
  195. (2002). The relationships among principals characteristics, school demographic variables, preventive coping resources, and stressors of public school principals in Florida,
  196. (1998). The relationships of personality type to perceived levels of job burnout among secondary principals, EdD dissertation,
  197. (1985). The role of the adrenals in the psychophysiology of stress,
  198. (1991). The secondary school principal's organizationally based stress: Sources and coping strategies, EdD dissertation,
  199. (1967). The Social Readjustment Rating Scale,
  200. (1975). The staff burnout syndrome in alternative institutions,
  201. (1983). The Stress Game: Administrative Roulette,
  202. (1956). The Stress of Life,
  203. (1976). The Stress of Life, 2 °a ed,
  204. (1981). The stress process,
  205. (1978). The structure of coping,
  206. (1999). The study of stress in principalship: Towards an improved methodology,
  207. (1997). The Truth About Burnout.
  208. (1991). The use of coping skills in the management of job-related stress among secondary public school principals in Mississippi,
  209. (1981). The Work Stress Connections: How to Cope with Job Burnout,
  210. (1994). Thinking on Stress for Success,
  211. (1989). Understanding and Conducting Research -Application
  212. (1982). Understanding burnout: Definitional issues in analyzing a complex phenomenon,
  213. (1981). Understanding burnout: problems, progress and promise,
  214. (1991). Understanding Stress: Psycholo ig cal Perspective for Health Professionals.
  215. (1990). Using uestionniares in Small-scale Research-A Teacher's Guide, Great Britain: The Scottish Council for Research in Education.
  216. (1986). Validity in Survey Research,
  217. (1999). What makes for effective research in a school or college? In
  218. (1982). Who are our burned out teachers?
  219. (1979). Why they leave and where they go?
  220. (1993). Work/family conflict among women and men managers in dual-career couples in Israel,
  221. (1995). Working your nerves: The toughest jobs,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.